Would you be okay being the first non-white hire at a small agency? Like they are making their first effort to bring diversity in (making it clear that you are not just a diversity hire), but you are going to be alone in a sea of white faces. I personally don’t know how to feel about it but I’d love to hear other opinions.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

lmao no at the least my black ass needs to see shonda in hr or something

But that IS one of the issues of diversifying workplaces I think about. It's a tough thing being the pioneer. Blazing the trail for others to follow is easier if I know I'm getting help and know the whole company is aware, also doing the work to bring in people who aren't white. Do you feel like that's the case here, OP?

Also do you WANT to be the trail blazer?

likefunny

I think I’m with you, I’d probably rather be at least the second or third. I don’t really want to be the trailblazer but this job might be a good step up for my career. I haven’t had the chance to ask the hard questions yet, so I don’t know if the whole agency would be up to doing the work, but it’s a good reminder to make sure I find out!

uplifting

Update: I had more interviews and thanks to your advice, I asked some hard questions about DEI efforts, etc. One person seemed almost offended that I was asking so 🚩🚩🚩, I otherwise wasn’t impressed with their answers (they talked about monthly seminars where everyone talks about their lived experiences with discrimination, but everyone is white, so…?). Anyways, shortly after that happened they let me know they decided I wasn’t a good fit anymore. I couldn’t agree more.

I lost out on another really amazing opportunity because I gave this one a real shot, so I am honestly pretty annoyed, mostly with myself, but I guess I learned my lesson.

like

Yeah I’d be fine with it. But I get why others would not.

like

If it’s a good opportunity and will help your career, take it (as long as you feel comfortable and they haven’t shown any negative attitudes towards POC). I’ve been in that situation before working at companies or teams where I’m the only poc, but made the best out of it. I do prefer more diverse teams and have always made it a point to hire diverse talent for my teams. The reality is that there’s still a lot more work to be done and from time to time we may encounter all white teams/companies.

like

I also feel so much more comfortable in diverse teams, especially working with another BIPOC creative partner, but that’s so rare. I would be totally remote so I’m thinking the disparity wouldn’t be as glaring, I don’t really have to be involved in day to day office culture. But yes, definitely have come across this kind of situation more than once, so appreciate the insight.

like

It depends on how things feel there. Some companies are alright but in a lot that would feel so uncomfortable. I don't need to be the test subject for diversity.

like

This is definitely my fear. Planning to get more of a feel for the vibe, try to get a microaggression check.

I spent the 90’s being the first (or one of the first) POC creatives at the ad agencies I’ve worked in. Tom Burrell once told me I was doing more good here than working for him right now. It was an inspiring you-didn’t-get-the-job speech.

Now I’m one of the first POC in UX design. Recruiters flood my mailbox like I’m the UX unicorn. I still hear how difficult it is to find candidates like me. I don’t like the situation, but I gladly accept it, because I help open doors and I’m in positions to hire, making sure it doesn’t remain that way.

like

Hi! Let’s talk. If you want.

I was the only for many years and I have some perspective. Namely look at the possibilities rather than the drawbacks and, more importantly, you are building a career so think big picture.

DM me if possible.

like

Nope - I specifically ask about numbers/percentages in the department I am interviewing for, and the company as a whole. I'm already dealing with express anti-blackness at my current place, but at least it's the devil I know, they pay me well and they are smart enough to leave my black ass alone because they know I have receipts. To have to go through it all again at a new place just feels too exhausting. I'd certainly take a pay cut to work at a more diverse and more supportive employer, but those places are so few and far between in our industry...

It’s tricky. If they are being open about it I think that’s great, because you are going in with your eyes wide open. I personally find it a little bit of a turn off (but I’m older and have fought a lot of battles during different times) however I think the points that it needs to start somewhere, and that it could be a good thing, are valid ones. Are you going to have an opportunity to contribute to other non-white people being hired? Will your feedback be heard on its merits, not only as a non white person? Unless there’s some thing that really shows 🚩🚩🚩, It’s worth having the conversation and evaluating it on merits of the agency and what you will get out of it from your career overall, not just about being the first person who isn’t white.

And I know I said I’m tired from fighting a lot of fights but I also have a lot of change/impact I’ve contributed to that has made me really happy. It’s just that change takes time…

helllllllll nah

Related Posts

Best neighborhoods to live for a young adult in San Diego budget of 3k ish for a 2 bedroom

Without warning it looks like we'll be switching from consultant teaching to inclusion...what do I need to know. Never co-taught or done inclusion except for years and years ago and it was very informal. Best ways to build a solid relationship with the classroom teacher you're paired with? Pitfalls to watch out for? Thanks!

like

Has anyone bought/ done the HRCI Certificate in Diversity and Inclusion in HR Management? I already have my PHR, but I’m looking to gain more knowledge/skills and beef up my resume. Is it worth doing? The course is $239 and you get 12 Recert credits with it.

like
helpful

What’s an average S2 salary in FDD for high COL’s like NYC, SF, LAX and Chicago?

Looking for a dog friendly 2BD or 2BD+Den apt/condo/rental in the Reston/Tysons/Arlington corridor with min 1300 sq ft. For context, we’re moving to the area from a house out of state and need a bit of extra space to store furniture/boxes while we house hunt. I’m open to recommendations as well as any other creative ideas 😌

like

Has anyone changed your project after being selected in Jan. DCA?

like

Hi all,
I'll be moving out to San Diego for a few months and wont have a car, can I get around downtown without one? Also, what areas within downtown are safe?

like

Really want to attend a diversity conference on Monday but have a client meeting Tuesday. Think I could do it? Both are super important to me so trying to figure out what I can do

likehelpful

Has anyone here actually won the diversity visa lottery? I've been playing for 7 years with no luck...

like

What are GOOD agencies in Boston? I'm a media planner/strategist handling $15mil in budgets, looking for a new home in Boston. Moving from MIA.

What is a good OTE for a customer success manager located in SLC exiting Salesforce with three years of experience in strategic customer success. I am seeing initial offers ranging from $100k OTE to $160k. Salesforce Adobe Microsoft Qualtrics Celonis Inc

I have been working in SEA region last 4 years. I feel burned out. I have 10yoe, I have try to move to other country but I pretty much suck in LeetCode. I want to take some time off to unwind, finish some personal business, and really prepare for interviews. I would like to hear from you. Should I quit to my current manager(5th so far) or wait after mid year performance review, when a new boss will take over my team? I'm thinking on giving them 2 months notice period. By contract is 1.

Thanks

like

Now that it’s officially peach season. Best peach things (fresh peaches, peach drinks, etc.) and where to find them in ATL?

like

Anyone have a Soho House (cities without houses) membership here in ATL?

like

Hey DFW, TX folks. We're going through comp and merit raises, I suspect you all are too. This is the first year we're using pay ranges from payscale. I am completely surprised of how low compensation is in TX. For any of you that have visibility to pay ranges what is your experience with pay ranges for your company?

like

Best sushi places in San Diego county/city?

like

GSP San Fran or Leo Chicago?

like

Was at an event recently. Seems like advertising really only cares about diversity as it applies to white women. I think this industry wants to stay white.

like

Best Luxury Apartments in Buckhead or near Chastain? Looking for 24/hr concierge, security, and under $2500. Open to other areas as well (just not DT ATL).

funnylike

More Posts

Hi everyone!

Can anyone provide a referral for a senior technical program management role at
Disney Streaming Services?

I’m currently the head of operations for a start-up and have over 6 years of experience in technical program management.

Any help is greatly appreciated. Thank you!

like

Hi,
I got an offer from
Wipro for an HRO Lead Programmer analyst(B3 band) Alight account. Can I have any suggestions regarding this account and position?
Wipro

like

I have 5 YOE and currently live in a HCOL city - I was just offered another Associate Editor position that I really want to take as I can build my resume and network and open tons of doors. Is 90k a lowball in this case?

helpful

Being a male and Asian really sucks.

Need 11 likes for enable DM.

like

Question from a newbie consultant - What are some good online courses/ books to improve consulting skills?

like

Question for some of the senior partners on this bowl: do you mind sharing what does the the top end of partner comp look like? Is it like 2-3M annually? And how many years it took you to get there after becoming partner?

like

Kindly requesting likes for this post to enable pvt chats

like

So much baggage brought into the relationship. 2 years in and just discovered a whole lot more. Its been mentally extremely difficult and it’s changed me as a person. Just venting but feel hopeless and I know my SO is suffering. Wish there was a solution but I’m losing hope

like

Gift ideas for GF dad? We have been dating a year and a half, I get along with him super well. He is dealing with some medical complications so isn’t to active at the moment but loves cooking and golfing. He is one of those guys who already has everything he needs, and they are super wealthy so I feel bad getting him any clothing or accessories knowing it wouldn’t be as nice as the things he wears, although I know he doesn’t expect anything and would genuinely appreciate anything I got him

like

Hello!! Does anyone know if there are any open positions @ mediavest/spark? I'm a temp & was told they don't know when I'll be hired on. So I thought I should apply online instead of waiting. Thanks!!

like

Who's got the most fishbowl points?

like

The socks I like are left and right footed and indicated as such on the bottom. Honestly, some mornings it takes two tries.

like

On the job hunt in London and considering a portfolio website. Thoughts on how to manage that with NDAs?

like

“have fun with this brief” they say before telling you the client is pretty conservative and needs to have safer options.

i know we don’t always work on stuff we’re thrilled about but i’ve never dreaded reviews for a client before until now

like

What's going on this weekend? Any fun holiday shops or pop-up bars I could check out?

like

How Income tax deduction is calculated in Mphasis payslip?

Is there any specific % or threshold values?

like

Which big law firm in Dallas has the “better” work life balance?

like

How do you appease the client when they call and ask when their tax returns are done and they want them done now but they are further down the queue of returns because they submitted their PBCs later than other clients who submitted their source docs on time?

like

Additional Posts in Minorities in Marketing

I’m working with a manager who likes to prioritize his ideas over strategic research, I want to be helpful because it’s very distressing to watch ideas being presented without the appropriate research, any advice?

African American 🐟 - why do I feel so annoyed when I hear “black” ads on the radio? With the sassy female leads and the urban slang and such. Feels so forced and wack. Just me?

like

We might be receiving stipends for professional development, I would like to use it towards a conference, which are some good ones to consider?

like

Hey, so I’m going to my first 3% conference. I heard it’s usually white feminism x 100. But I was wondering what I should expect? Has anyone been.

like

What’s an appropriate rate to charge per word for a publication like VentureBeat or TechCrunch?

like

I have non closet supporters at my job. They just leave the room when the conversation turns to politics

A good friend is looking for a Hispanic multicultural strategy/ planning director- based in NYC.

Let's get Meta with it here for a second. Since it's Monday, and I'm relatively jr. I'm interested to hear your experience breaking into the industry as a minority. What was it like.

Is it a bad idea to have a mentor or advisor who isn't a minority? Would it be better to get one that is? There's a woman I would consider asking to be my mentor but she's white and I'm mixed Korean and African American. I feel like there might be stuff I want to ask her or get help with that she doesn't understand.

like

Anybody struggle with imposter syndrome as a minority? How and why? Need some coping strategies man.

like

What's the most natural next step for a marketing coordinator?

like

Happy Black History Everyone, let's make this a truly historic month!!

likeuplifting

Just found out I got laid off. Cheers to the weekend 🍺

like

Anyone good marketing books recommendations or online certifications?

like

Is there any industry recognition for poc creatives the way adage and others recognize creatives?

like

Dear Nappily Ever After,
No one has an office, much less an assistant. Creative and account are different jobs with their own dress codes. But dumb, off brief ideas by white creatives do win.

like

So, it's super obvious not to use "Police" in ads and activations, right? Like, we all know not to dress actors as police and have them "bust" people who have the wrong product, right?

likefunny

Any advice on how to actually FIND a mentor? I’m a first-gen black girl trying to navigate this whole ~career~ thing by myself. I would love to meet someone that’s actually done this before to help 😩

likehelpful

How do you deal with a team who only takes action when they have gotten the cosign from white counterpart? I.e. Maybe place a tag ...no action. White counterpart, I agree we should place a tag 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal