Been interviewing new FAs and noticing most candidates want base salary. Question is, Why? To me, an advisor is an entrepreneur, every $ in base decreases upside earning potential. What am I missing?

likesmarthelpfulfunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

What you're missing is that most people have bills to pay: rent, student loans, food, cell phone, gas/parking/monthly train pass. And it takes time to make enough on commission to pay these. So if you don't have a parent or spouse footing the bill, as much as you'd like to be able to be commission-only, many times it is not realistic

likesmart

These kind of questions really get me pissed. First, and Advisor is not an entrepreneur. At least not if you are interviewing them. Also, you don’t want an entrepreneur there, you want an employee. Hence why you are interviewing.

Also, base only decreases earnings if you some how call it a draw and they have to pay it back.

Set it up this way, what split do you want to make? I assume you are a 24 or manager, so what ever their cut is, say 60% (lower than our office but higher than a wire house). Then give them a “base” of 50k forgivable draw. So, until they are bringing in 85k in revenue, they are getting 50k. Your overhead is deceased (the base) with every new client that rep brings in.

Now you two are on the same team. You are motivated to train them to be successful, to get off your draw. They are motivated to do better because as soon as they bring in 85k, the sky is the limit. It’s a win/win!

likesmart
Recent IconRecent

I think candidates are getting smarter, to be honest. 100% roles can be lucrative but it’s a grind and people can smell hunger and desperation for the next bonus check. I work for a decent size wirehouse and I make 50k flat plus what they call a discretionary bonus. Last year I made close to 100k after bonuses. I think the entrepreneur trend is dying and people want stability

likesmart

Times have changed. Straight commission out of the gate just leads to high turnover numbers. Make an investment in a solid employee via salary and give them time to succeed. They will contribute much more to the bottom line over time than what you have to pay them in salary to buy them time. Plus they can help with other office work, like research, financial plans, etc.

likesmarthelpful

Being an "entrepreneur" is a luxury reserved for those who can get financial support and living expenses paid by a parent or spouse. For the rest of us, we are burdened with the responsibility of paying these bills and if the commission doesn't hit in time we can be homeless or have or cars repo'd by the dealer and then not even be able to come to work! And health insurance and car insurance aren't free.

likesmart

There is no place in our industry for someone feeling "hungry”. We should all be fiduciaries and if you “need” a paycheck it causes an inherent conflict of interest. The advisor own interest over their client.

This isn’t Glengarry Glen Ross. Putting young advisors in that position is the exact reason why the DOL rule was invented and NEEDs to be implemented.

like

FA3, I get that. I agree that there are clients that need all of those things. I’m suggesting that someone new in the business, say the first 2 years, might not have the knowledge to know when they are needed and when they aren’t. What they will know is how they get paid. And while they don’t mean any harm, they could end up doing something “wrong” just because they need money. Thats what I’ve been address was Pru’s question about hiring and interviewing.

I’m of the mind that if I’m hiring someone, I’m making a commitment to that person that I will do everything in my power to help them succeed. That’s why you can’t get fired for lack of production at my firm. You could stay on our draw forever if you wanted. But if you aren’t making what you would like, I don’t want you out there knocking on doors or dialing the phone. I want you finding something to be passionate about in our industry! Maybe you feel you want to help teachers with their TIAA CREF account, then you better spend every free minute you have studying it. Because when our firm gets a retiring teacher, guess who’s door we are knocking on.

As managers and people who are “leaders” in our industry, we have a responsibility to usher in the next generation. I believe that we should never teach what we don’t know, and never lead where we won’t go. If I am asking a new hire to dial the phone 100 times a day, I better be prepared to dial 101 times. Just my view, I could be completely wrong but that’s the kind of place I wanted to work at and the manger I wanted to work for. So I built the place and I’m trying to be the manager. Nothing wrong with other places.

likeupliftinghelpful

New FAs gotsta eat, too!!

likesmart

Not to mention, do you really want someone working for you that NEEDS to pay their bills this month. He could suggest a diversified portfolio after assessing the risk of the client and get paid 1% annually on it or say F it, I need to eat! Here is a VA!

like

FA3, this is how I look at it. I was an idiot my first 3 years as an advisor even after several years as a trader. I just didn’t know what I know now. If I am hiring someone, I want them to be like me now, not the idiot. If that takes money out of my pocket to get them there faster, I’m ok with that. But those decreasing salaries (like at a wire house where I worked) don’t work for the majority.

Take Merrill right now. 3 year decreasing from 36,24,12 a year. You are 23 y/o, new to the business. Let’s hope by year 3 you have your feet under you. That final year you make 50k (12k base and 38 payout). Your payout is made up of clients that are friends of friends or friends of family because that’s all the people a Now 26 year old knows that has money. Now, year four you lose the base and the high payout %, plus Now you don’t get paid for accounts less than 250k. You could easily see you income go from 50k to 25k. You quit because you can’t eat and Merrill gives those accounts to another rep.

So Merrill used you to prospect (the hardest part of our job) and then you leave and some rep (who probably thinks you were just lazy and didn’t make enough dials) gets your 3.8MM of new assets.

To me, that is a shame!

likesmart

If someone can generate their own book of business, why pay a company 60% or more of the fees. Why not pay a base salary or a percentage of the fees generated from the clients they are responsible for and a higher percentage of the first year fee if they are responsible for bringing them.in

likehelpful

I actually have a selfish reason... I’m going to retire in 20 years, if I can build a firm of like minded advisors, when I retire, I know my clients will be taken care of the same way I took care of them.

Once we get to the point where we are “comfortable” with income, it’s not hard to make an extra 10% a year more. With the time that we now have that isn’t out prospecting, we could spend it training a mentee (which has by far been the most rewarding part of my career). So it’s selfish that I get to do what I love. But I’m at peace with that! Have a great day all, heading out in a few for date night with the wife!

like

Not to mention that today’s commissions have been stripped out compared to the “old timers” comp grids. It’s a lot more difficult to get up and running these days.

like

You don’t want to be desperate in this business. It stressful enough as it is.

like

Hence why they are seeking employment

likesmart

The industry wants us to change to fee based and away from commission. Feels like 60%+ of the people on here say "go indy RIA". I don't disagree with it, but as has been said, it's difficult to start as a young advisor.

likesmart

Managing partner 1, I like that, thank you. I appreciate all the feedback on here!

like

@Managed Partner 1 I couldn’t agree more. I can always tell when my competitors are commission only because you can smell the grimy desperation from them. I would NEVER want someone desperate for their next check to manage my money. Quality advisors won’t settle for shitty pay structure!!!!

like

MP1, thanks for the post. Good structure of pay vs incentive

likehelpful

Just so we are clear, I have no problem with commission only advisors. My comments are directed to the topic of new FAs looking for a salary.

There is nothing wrong with Commission only and if I was still with a BD only, I would probably be commission only because using their RIA is ridiculous cost (it was around 30 bp). We are actually a hybrid and leave it up to the advisors which side they would like to use.

likeuplifting

Related Posts

Chicago FDD associate 2 salary at big 4?

like

What are some of the salaries for Willis towers Watson client manager ? Just trying to figure what I should be okay with

I am about to hand in my notice at a job I am pretty secure in, to go to a job for a relatively new company (with a significant salary increase). Any tips for:

1. Getting over the nerves that are as a result of taking a risk (I am late 30's)
2. The guilt of leaving a role where I have an amazing working relationship with all my colleagues and my boss

Any tips would be appreciated as I am a mess of nerves!!

like

I’m an HR Manager for a small (41 employee) company in Chicago. I make $70,000 a year no bonuses. I’m SHRM-CP and PHR certified with four years experience and a masters in HR. Am I underpaid?

like
like

Comp structure question. How much of an average partner’s comp at your firm comes from: a) fixed base, b) variable comp based on individual performance, c) ‘dividends’ on accumulated equity, d) any other major components?

like

How do you invest your bonus? For context have ~40k in student loans (~4.8% rate), not interested in a house/apt purchase anytime soon, just want to save up for ~major life events~, have a little bit of money for fun and invest most of it. Any tips on percentages etc?

like

Hi recruiters! I am hoping a few people can share the salary range you’re seeing for a Director of Product Training position in a large software company. I’m seeing between $135k and $180k depending on YOE, scope of responsibilities, etc. I am negotiating a promotion opportunity and want to get more accurate data.

like

About to join BNY Mellon this month pune location as a Technical Lead. I am eligible for bonus in Jan 2023 or not ?

Have a final round interview with one of the MBBs next Friday and looking for case partners. I’m on EST and available in the afternoons and evenings during the week.

like

I’m being recruited back to a bank I left 6 months ago. Was contacted by a recruiter this week because I had indicated in my exit interview that I would consider a return to the firm in the future. When I left this bank for my current employer… I received a $30k bump. I’ve never been recruited before and am curious what questions I should ask? Is this a good sign? Would it be wrong to ask for an additional $25k to go back?

like

Hey all! So I got a job offer for 95k for a Sr. Regulatory Relations Specialist. Is this the average salary or a lowball offer? Personally, I am having a hard time finding the average role salary posted anywhere.

like

22 yrs experience and a new grad is being hired for $3 more than I make. I am doing double work because of short staffed. How do I get a raise without letting them know I know the difference?? I am due for my review soon. Thx

likehelpful
like

If gross salary is 129418, what will be CTC to be quoted to the new recruiter ?

like

What's the Senior 2 (D USI) role equivalent in P SDC. What's the current CTC post the recent appraisals. (Audit)

likehelpful

Anyone have any information on the New York office of Fox? Also would be interested in knowing 3rd year salary. Thanks!

like

I have an initial interview with partners at Thompson Hine in the Real Estate practice group. Can anyone shed some light on what I should prepare for?

likehelpful

Do pay ranges for Colorado job listings indicate base salary or total compensation?

like

Hi Fishes,
Can anyone please help me in calculating in-hand salary?
I have 1.5lac investment under 80C
and 96k for house rent

Post Photo
like

More Posts

Does anyone here work as a care manager 1 for Centene? I recently got hired and I’m becoming discourage from all the posts I read about CM being hard and making nurses anxious

likehelpful

How much do technology managers at hedge funds make? Specifically in portfolio management/trading?

like

Thoughts on Trump talking about wind?

Post Photo
likefunny

I had applied for two job openings in Deloitte USI for ServiceNow Developer role and they rejected the application within 4 hrs of applying stating “Unfortunately, after careful consideration, we have determined that our current position is not ideally suited to your talents, experience, and qualifications.” Can anyone shed some light on this. Are there any other eligibility criteria which I may be failing to meet? My 10th, 12th and Graduation is above 70 Deloitte Deloitte USI Deloitte India

I have students that need to make up a missing test. I want to keep the integrity and validity of a test.
Any suggestions??

likesmart

Anyone have any experience with DoorDash s&o final round cases? Have a “problem solving” interview, “operational excellence” interview and a “critical thinking” case. Any tips?

like

For buy side analysts, are there logical career moves one can make after having a couple of years of working experience?

like

Dear Fishes,

I am Java developer, I have cleared L1 interview round of 
Valuelabs and another round L2 is there which technical + hr. Can anyone please help me how to clear L2.

Infosys Tata Consultancy Accenture Amazon Deloitte Genpact

Earliest time after joining a startup to negotiate additional refresher RSUs? Performing well (IMO lol) and got very good feedback and it was discussed when I started that a bump in RSUs was absolutely possible in that case. No specific timeline was discussed however.

like

Can someone become a data analyst, data scientist if Current working as Business Analyst and how? Your opinion please.

like

Advice on how to transition from agency to brand side?

like

At $GNT event

Post Photo
like

Ever since moving to hybrid work, my coworkers are always complaining about how much they hate their jobs, how much of a hassle it is to travel or work from home. How can you be expected to do your job when you're just so far away from everything?

like

Hi,
Can there be a case when you are hired for a specific role and later on you are aligned to a different project ?
Thanks

like

What is the easiest way to change a project in CTS?
Been in a project for 2 months now. Not much learning. Want to move to a better project.
Suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

like

Can someone tell about annual bonus for new hires in Jpmc?

like

What unexpected specialities have you all picked up along the way as a junior? Somehow I became the go-to guy on tax assessment appeals because the other guy went in-house.

like

Am wrking TCS. For am medical emergency I have applied for salary advance today and it is approved.Buy amount is not credited. Ould any one let me know when will I get that money. I need that money for an medical emergency.

Is that possible will I get today?

Tata Consultancy

like
like

Additional Posts in Financial Advisors

Does anyone else dream about running away to live in a small cabin in the woods by themselves or is it just me?

like

Do you all find time to read books for pleasure with jobs like ours?

like

Taking book recommendations :) What have you all been reading?

like

It's March, and I have done a lot of seminars in Jan and Feb. I've gotten a few clients but would like to increase AUM drastically! Any books, sites or advice on what I can do for marketing?

like

How much travel would you consider to be reasonable on a daily basis for a client?

likesmart

Has anybody come up with a way to purge the words “like”and “you know” out of somebody’s speech patterns? I don’t want to be insulting, I truly want to help. It’s not a young person either

like

What does a mental health day look like for you? Took one today & it was the best thing I’ve done for myself. Bonus Q: did you own up to it being a mental health day or did you go to “the dentist"

like

For those of you who have had to increase soft skills as a means to grow and expand client relationships, how did you go about this?

like

Anyone have any experience as a franchise owner? Looking to diversify....

like

How would you handle a person at your job that makes inappropriate jokes in public? Just curious ...

likehelpful

What are one to three personal attributes you pride yourself on and work constantly to maintain, improve, or acquire? I will start: (1) Confidence (2) Composure (3) Humility.

like

Anyone using short term structured notes in an advisory account?

like

Things I miss about my 20�s: waking up without heartburn.

like

Have a bud who was a FX trader and now unemployed. Saw him yesterday and he wants to roll over his 401k at abt 800k. Now he has some bad habits so I ignored him but now need to give him an answer.

like

When you guys are making luke-warm calls. Do you leave voicemails? I've always been against it because, in my mind it puts the responsibility of the connection on the other person

like

Anyone have any suggestions on a RIA-Friendly custodian for 529 Plans? TD Ameritrade has an affiliation w the Nebraska Educational Savings Plan Trust (NEST). Has anyone had any experience with them?

like

What's the most effective way for a small RIA to recruit FAs who have a few years experience, want to break away from large/corporate firms? I'm a $70M fee-only (commissions for insurance) independent RIA with a generous comp schedule that enables FAs to own their own book while they grow. As the owner, my focus is to help FAs succeed; as a firm, our focus is on client service and helping them succeed. I can afford a small salary, but not benefits. I'm especially interested in female FAs.

like

How do you sign your emails? Close with �Best�? �regards�, etc.?

like

Anyone with US Trust as a PCA? Looking for additional details in terms of the culture, day to day type of things and how you’re doing there vs. what the recruiter stated was the average?

like

I feel like I can't do anything efficiently. My managers give me really simple tasks and it takes me 16+ hours to complete them. No one has made a comment but I feel SO SLOW. Any advice?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal