Greetings! Seeking advice on a move from a holding company media agency to consulting. Currently interviewing w/ KPMG Advisory but not just interested in ‘big’ firms.
- Primary interest & expertise is data strategy & analytics. Have a technical foundation but not interested in coding all day. Want to translate technical capabilities, challenges & industry changes for non technical people
- 3 YOE in data specifically, 5 in media more broadly

(Continued in comments)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

- Hoping to leverage current experience while gaining exposure to more functions & industry verticals beyond media planning & buying. Is this a realistic expectation or will I get silo’d?
- In terms of media & marketing specifically, curious to know about the quality & impact of firms with bespoke agencies (Accenture, Deloitte etc) vs those without (KPMG, Slalom)
- Definitely interested in a masters degree in the next couple years (maybe MBA but more likely a 1 yr specialized program), what’s the likelihood of a firm sponsoring that/what’s that process like?
- Anything else I should know and consider?

Appreciate y’all!

Hey @OP, we've discussed this topic before and I feel like what you're asking is a bit all over the place, so I'm going to try and simplify things a bit since I've straddled both worlds:

1) Your media planning/buying experience will be minimally applicable to strategy/management consulting, and only relevant in the following--either within a specialized group that advises on media strategy with clients, or your technical foundations are strong enough such that you can be plugged in as a data scientists/analytics specialist consultant. If you want to jump into a generalist role, you're going to have to start from the bottom in nearly any scenario.

2) Based off #1 - you should decide if you want to pursue a generalist management consulting track vs a specialized data/analytics consulting track VS marcomm/media specialist consulting track.

3) You mention having expertise in data strategy and analytics, but is that narrowly defined within the marcomm space, or do you have enough skills to handle different types of applications (eg data model and strategy for business analytics in various industries that are more B2B oriented, or is it really around data-driven customer segmentation/marketing applications or supply chain/logistics optimization etc)?

4) Your point about bespoke agencies is a bit confusing, but I think what you're trying to say is that some major firms have agency/studio arms that GTM separately, while others seem more integrated. So that's for you to answer--do you want to work in an agency that is part of a consultancy or do you want to work within a consultancy that can touch some of the work an agency-esque outfit would do? Accenture Song/Deloitte Digital/IBM iX can do far more than a KPMG or Slalom ever could - - but it comes down to the environment / type of people you want to work with / problem space / outputs

All the firms you mentioned are fine, but it depends on what you actually want to do.

To be brutally honest, if you haven't worked with "real consultants" extensively, it's very different from working with most agency folks--it's something you should keep in mind.

5) The only firm that would meaningfully sponsor a masters degree is MBB, and that's for MBA IF you are a top 5% performer. Since you said you'd rather do a 1 year degree, expect minimal levels of sponsorship (eg maybe $10K max at a firm). You didn't specify what type of specialized program you were seeking - is it in data science and analytics?


Here's a meta question for you - - why do you want to transition out of the agency world? What do you want to do in consulting (be more specific than what you wrote above. If you can't be, then maybe we can start there)? Do you want to shift away from working with marketing-side clients or tackle business problems that extend deeper that marketing concerns?

Love the perspective here. Will hit you up on the side to continue discussing my specific case but I guarantee you this will help a ton for anyone in a similar situation. Cheers!

Related Posts

I'll switch to a startup as the only data engineer and will closely work with all the Head ofs + the CTO.

Any advice/books/... on stakeholder management at that level? Especially when things fail/discussing budgets/new hires etc.

like

Hi Guys I have joined Publicis Sapient with interview on .Net Core and Cloud but now doing support legeacy job any suggestions what to do? anyone else in similar boat Publicis Sapient

like

I'm not sure if I have the willpower to become "successful" in this industry.

like

Any advice on breaking into international arbitration? For background, I’m a 6th year litigation associate (general commercial) and I’m feeling bored with my work. I really took an interest in international arbitration during law school (participated in Vis moot, etc.) but didn’t actively pursue it after graduating. Am I being completely unrealistic by wanting to switch?

like

What are actionable items one should strive for when trying to grow as a designer after landing their first role? I hear a lot about ways to grow to land the first job but very little about how to improve after you know the basics.

like

How is risk management as a career? Is it lucrative like typical consulting? How are salaries when compared to technology ( as this is peak) nowadays?? And does risk management comes understand niche skills??

I work in field sales as an IC. My aspirational career path is to end up in people leadership. Recently, an Inside management position opened up that’s been brought to my attention by the hiring director. Question is, is going back Inside the right move to get into started in leadership? Or should I continue down the field path and wait until those field management slots open up?

like

GCA Questions Help

Hi everyone!
I've had 2 rounds of interviews at Google (UK) for a non-tech role in Platforms & Ecosystems (L4/L5). Recruiter told me that I've been selected for the final rounds (GCA + Leadership Interview). From his feedback, one thing they wanted me to improve on was the GCA Questions. Would anyone have any tips on how to prepare for these? I've checked some of Jeff Sipe videos online but would appreciate any support! I find GCA quite stressful...
Thx
Thanks in advance!

like

Looking for a casing buddy! Fairly new to casing and come from a science background not business. 2nd round BCG interview coming up. :)

like

Hi all 👋 does anyone have any recommendations for career switchers trying to land entry-level digital marketing or social media coordinator roles?

The biggest challenge I’m finding right now is that I don’t have many of the hard skills required (photoshop, illustrator, Google analytics) 📊📈.

I would really prefer a smaller marketing agency where I can wear many hats and learn the ropes from scratch. Thanks in advance 😁

like

Currently controller at a smaller company reporting to the cfo. What are some next career moves back to larger companies or how easy would it be to jump to the consulting side?

like

Beginner video editing advice wanted - I’m working on a personal side gig project. As part of that, I’m recording short interviews with people currently using a camera and/or iPhone .. (cont)

Anyone have any worst interview stories? 100% bombed one yesterday, essentially just because I wasn't well prepared enough and I was super nervous. Knew what I wanted to say and said none of it, pretty sure I blacked out for at least some of it. Tell me I'm not the only one, (!!) or tips for self confidence are also welcome.

like

Fishes, any suggestions as to how to move into the VC role with a non-finance background (PS - exp. of working in founders office of a startup, management consulting in past and do understand corp. finance, financial statement analysis etc.)

like

I’ve been thinking about law school for far too long and want to take the plunge. Where do I start? Any recommendations for studying for the LSAT?

like

Is anyone a member of the Product Marketing Alliance? I want to join in hopes of being able to make a transition into the career.

like

Currently I have an offer on my hand and my current employer has nominated me for H1B

If I resign what will be the consequences?
Is it good to stay in the company or resign as I have a better offer in hand

like

Anyone here broken into real estate private equity from big 4 consulting? What steps did you take to jump into RE PE? What gaps in knowledge did you have and how did you fill them? Outside of the knowledge gaps what other things do you think you needed in order to get into RE PE?

like

Hi sales engineers, I’m currently a cloud security engineer with a cybersecurity background. I am pretty recent graduate and am passionate about sales engineering but have struggled to get my foot in the door in this field. Seems like every job out there is like 5+ years experience. Any advice for how to get in this field with little experience?

Hello! I’m going to BSchool in August. Any recommendations on books / websites / videos to be more prepared for management consulting interviews?

More Posts

Mutual funds you have your eye on right now?

like

Canadian 🐠 Which ETFs are you buying right now?

like

What did you do with your RSU’s after it vested? Did you keep it or was it sold and reinvest to another stock/fund/etf?

Is DC a competitive office to get into for McKinsey?

like

What’s the best sign off party/event for a big-ish team with a large budget (about $150-$200 per person limit)?

like

Hey Fishes,

Can anyone tell me how to identify someone's FJ level in
Fujitsu?

I checked ZinZai and Employee directory but didn't find the FJ level.

FUJITSU LIMITED , Fujitsu

Thanks in advance

like

Currently living in the museum district but the rent is getting out of hand. Considering moving out to Katy, The Woodlands, or Friendswood. Any suggestions on pet friendly elevator buildings in those areas?

like

How are you all voting on the fair tax amendment? I am voting no because I do not want to continue giving our government money until they fix the pension situation too. But curious to hear your thoughts.

like

CVID.
Caption: “You need 2x5 Euro 💶. The first that lets the bill fall loses and the winner picks up the winnings, resulting in hours of peace. You can thank me later...”

Post Photo
likehelpfulfunny

Right-wing Republican moving family from deep blue progressive city. Looking for excellent schools, low property taxes. reasonable housing prices, and a high percentage of Republican voters. Any suburb recommendations?

likefunnyuplifting

What does the pay range look like for a UX/UI Design Intern?
Background: Master’s in CS student based in NYC/NJ.

like
like

Who believes the whole 300 hours of study rule of thumb?

like

What's it like working with BCG in Dubai? Which service lines have the best people and which should be avoided?

like

Has anyone interviewed or accepted a position with Teneo Strategy? Interested in hearing your experiences.

For folks who’ve done R1/R2 interviews at BCG… how useful did you find the CaseCoach courses? I’m a week out before my R1 and I’m wondering if it’s going to be time we’ll-spent. Would love to hear “ignore this, definitely do that” sorts of advice if possible. (For background: I’m familiar with Victor Cheng, I’m using RocketBlocks, practicing live cases, consumed a bunch of YouTube videos, etc.)

like

So the feeling that you’re forgetting something important because you have so much on your plate…that never goes away right?

like

I’m trying to make the jump from legal services to corporate IP. I’ve only been in practice for 2 years and I have 0 experience in corporate. Do I have a chance?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting and Advertising worlds collide 🌎💥

I know of the top-tier agencies (BBDO, DDB, Ogilvy, etc) but I don’t know who the top-tier marketing consultancies are. Is there a real list somewhere, that isn’t filled with design/logo shops?

likehelpful

Just got an offer from traditional agency and one from Accenture and frankly I was disappointed by Accenture offer. Not that money is everything but wow. I guess advertising isn’t that bad

Post Photo
like

How can a media planner break into media consulting?

like

Any folks in this bowl have an Adobe Experience Manager certification? Worthwhile?

I have my intro call with Deloitte Digital next Monday. Any tips or advice? Also what’s the salary for an SEO Lead?

like

Anyone made a successful switch from the Ad Agency world to consulting early on in their career? What drove you to it, was it worth it? Did you get the professional growth opportunities you were looking for?

like

Hi all - I am looking to move into the world of brand strategy consulting (KPMG has customer consulting division but brand and marketing aren't that strong. Also KPMG UK is the only one of big 4 that has not bought an agency!!). Wanted to hear some advice on the options: go to a boutique (like Lippincott, Prophet) or brand agency? The salary cut for agency is huge though. Are there other options?

like

What are the best consulting/brand agencies for recent college grads to go to? I understand that now isn’t the best time to apply but I’d like to start researching!

like

I am interested in pivoting from an agency into a traditional business consultancy role. I have start-up tech experience and four years of Strategy experience for media clients. Are there any projects folks in consulting would recommend I take on to add to build on to a resume? From the outside looking in, it seems like there is an overlap in the core competencies of a strong strategist at an agency and a consultant.

like

Anyone at Ogilvy Consulting? Can we chat?

like

Looking to leave my AAE role (almost 2 year YOE) to move into consulting. Anyone here made the leap? Any advice?

like

For those consultants out there ... have you found it valuable to have a formal certification for Digital Transformation Change mgmt? What do you feel is the most valuable/marketable certification?

Does anyone have any recommendations on consulting firms that have a marketing or media practice outside of Accenture and BCG?

like

C-suite consulting leaders: why are you buying creative agencies?

I’d like to better understand if it’s better to stay in consulting with a well-defined career path or to move to Google/Facebook/Amazon with a good level and having the consciousness of being promoted is really hard.

like

Cold emailing consultant HR reps for jobs, yay or nay ?

like

Looking for info on how Accenture comp packages are structured at Managing Director level? insight into base, bonus, signing bonus, and equity- would be great! Thx!

like

Does anyone from agency world to “cagency” world have tips on learning the consulting side? I’m finding as an experienced hire, I lack in some skills such as economics and budgeting.

like

Need an expert in Salesforce (Marketing Cloud x data onboarding). Our agency ♥️s LiveRamp, but have a client needing some Advertising Studio expertise. Freelance/contract opportunity here!
DM me please!

like

What % do you guys charge a partner to advertise on social using your handle/ad account? Is a 100% markup fee plus an "agency" like fee for maintenance of 15% too aggressive?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal