Had an interview VP/hiring manager loved me and wants me, 2 directors who are my peers likes me too but the third director also my peer tore me apart. What could be my chances in a hypothetical scenario be? Hired or fail? Opinions from experience please

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Where you’re interviewing is important. I had similar experience with FAANG and still got the offer. For other companies or industry, this could be a deal breaker.

like

Hard to say! If the Director who tore you apart was tasked with evaluating some type of competency and they report you didn’t pass it’s not good. If it was a personality issue, who knows...

Good luck!

I think one sour apple in the basket of interviewers is expected, no? I had one recently who was so weird - completely unfriendly and only asked me questions related to a tiny part of my profile and tore me apart on that - but I ended up getting the offer bc all other interviews went really well.

Related Posts

Is it easy or difficult to get confirmation in IBM after the probation period of 6 months. I have 14yrs of experience and have been provided a Business Manager role in Band 8.
What are the criteria to get the confirmation?

Hey I am a Presales/Bid manager with 8 years of experience and 15. 5Ctc. Is this the prevailing pay in the market for this role? Any leads to similar openings?

like

LTI-Larsen & Toubro Infotech is Hiring
*DM your EMAILID with JOBID to Apply*
All LTI Location!!

Post Photo
like

Is it okay if I ask my interviewer from the first round tips for the next round of interview/format of interviews? They’re a school alumni.

Hi Everyone, I have almost 1 year of experience as Business Analyst in telecom domain ( AI poduct specialist/QA) Total experience of 3.5 years in Retail and Trlecom domain. Any referral for Business analyst role

What is the work that an Associate Consultant does in the Deal Advisory team? I have an interview for the same role.

like

Interviewing for Sr Partner at Korn Ferry from experienced SM at Accenture… want to make sure I get clarity on all the right things (sales targets, charge-ability, client assignments, offerings, growth goals/ strategy… etc.). Please share your key questions I must ask. Thank you!

like
like
like

I’m any effort to get my application noticed, albeit LinkedIn easy apply, does it look bad to reapply to the same position through a second post for that same role?

like
like
like

I am in the final steps of the interview process for an in-house position. I mentioned to the recruiter that I had unvested equity I would be leaving on the table. She said the company would take this into account and make me whole. She later asked for proof of the equity in the form of my account statement and balance, which I provided. I have not yet received an offer. Is it typical for companies to ask for this documentation if they don't intend to make the candidate an offer?

like

I have an offer for $130k for a senior attorney position in a boutique L&E firm. Also have a recruiter who thinks she can get me into another for $150-170k. Both are more than I’ve ever made (Denver, 17 yrs of experience but completely different practice areas). Any tips for countering the $130k offer for more using the other potential offer while not risking a complete withdrawal of the current offer? I’ve never been in a position to bargain my starting salary so this is all very new to me.

like

Hi folks! Looking for an entry level accounts position for a friend. If you have any leads or anything that could be helpful, please lmk!

like

Considering applying for an entry level business analyst (consulting) position at a competitor Big 4 firm. I just completed my first year in audit, so I’m wondering if it’s still appropriate for me to apply as entry level instead of experienced hire?

like

What's the salary FIS can offer..I am currently at 55..This is for a PM role at FIS

like

saw this on portal, had asked for 30% hike on current fixed.

We regret to inform you that currently we do not have an open position that matches your expected compensation.
We have kept your profile on hold for the time being and hope to reconsider your profile for a suitable opening.

Do you think they will contact me again?

Current human capital consultant looking for a role in the Pittsburgh area. Let me know :)

like

More Posts

Of all the job pitches that I have received, this is the most incomprehensible so far.

Post Photo
like

How’s your work-life balance? New job at a new company and wondering how to clarify standards on this

like

What engineering fields have the most opportunity for someone who wants to travel as part of their job?

like

What is a current engineering field that might become outdated in the near future?

like

Hey Industrial Engineers, do you know of a free simulation program I can use to simulate the material flow where I can input cycle times and OE% data to calculate supermarkets or inventory between processes?

like

Potentially moving to Charlotte next June! Never been. Anyone have apartment rev commendations? Looking for 1 bed in a nice area!

I’m currently Working in Healthcare IT as a Project Manager. Thinking of transitioning into healthcare consulting. What are your tips on this with regards to companies, options and challenges

like

Struggling with ADHD, anxiety and depression and my therapist suggested I might benefit from medication. Anyone with Blue Cross Blue Shield in nyc recommend their psychiatrist?

like

Best way to develop your leadership skills for the healthcare field? Or books/resources you would recommend?

like

Anyone who works for Encompass/ Enhabit home health-PRN willing to share their hourly pay?

like

Any .NET developers in the big4? What’s your level, region and salary ?

like

Starting wage for a Radiology informatics application analyst? I live in Ohio. Thank you!

like

I have an interview tomorrow at Walmart for product designer position. I received design challenge 24hrs before the interview time and just now, 12hrs before the interview, received an automated email saying “I am no longer under consideration”??? Idk if I should continue working on the challenge... wtf any advice?

like

BCG fish: onboarding question: do you usually keep separate work / personal phones, or one?

like

Average hours/week in comparable practice areas at McK vs BCG? Wondering what everyone’s experience was hours-wise, and if there was any real disparity between M and B. Thanks!

like

What was the signing bonus for MBA hires that just received offers this fall?

like

How is the culture at quantumblack?

like

4YOE @Amazon & trying to lateral to a similar role @FAANG. Have my undergrad GPA (3.8/4) on resume from top 15 school but colleague says to take it off (looks silly). If it’s a good school & high GPA, why ever take it off your resume? Even if 10 YOE...can’t hurt?

like

Hi all I have 7 years of experience in Banking operations Internal audit and internal control, risk and control framework, Thematic review. AML/KYC aspects review, transaction monitoring, compliance reviews, CDD and STR reporting. Please refer me eagerly looking for a change. Preferable location hennai and Bengaluru.

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Tfw the client asks you to stop by his desk in 10 min and you're actually off site all week.

like

Strategies for work/life balance? Especially while traveling? Thanks!

like

How much does utilization matter for year end once you've met the target? E.g. if target utilization is 85% but I'm at 105%, will this 20% additionally help? If so, how much does it differentiate you?

like

Any good books recommendation on effective client communication/business writing?

like

Any audio book recommendations to listen to when backpacking / vacationing?

like

what does the bonus range look like for a new band 4 at bank of america?

like

Deebo got rocked

likeupliftinghelpful

Books you would recommend for consulting or personal development?

likesmarthelpful

Any book recommendations about human psychology / thought processes?

like

How is it living in Research Triangle Park area in NC? Been there couple of times for work but looking for some suggestions

like

Planning to do a PRM or FRM qual. How useful is it to move from Big 4 Risk and reg consulting to industry? Finding it hard to get anything other than non-PM roles

like

Are any top consulting firms hiring for experienced analysts currently? I know ACN and some others are cyclical for resources 2-3 years out of college, but I’m looking to make a move sooner than fall

like

Looking for good rental places in Detroit downtown.Any recommendations? Looking for studio apt

Bain & Company I will be heading to MBB in a few months. Any advice for how to best prepare for my new role? Any advice on books to read / skills to sharpen before I officially start? Thank you!

McKinsey & Company, Boston Consulting Group, Bain & Company.

likesmart

Bain & Company What are the best consulting firms and practice areas for Energy/Utilities advisory?

Additionally which companies and roles offer the best exit?

McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company Oliver Wyman EY-Parthenon Accenture Deloitte EY

like

I just connected some dots and got a colleague off the bench and on some billable work. What a great feeling! 🤓

like

Can someone please help me calculate my Utilization? The Client Service Hours on ToD seems to be confusing. When does the utilisation for the year start? April or June?

like

Is there anyone within EY public sector able to let me know what I should negotiate for salary wise? Senior associate position. I have two years consulting plus an MBA and six years in industry. Ty!

Best consulting companies with exposure to the blockchain / digital assets space?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal