Has anyone left Big 4 to a mid tier Accounting firm (GT, BDO, etc.)? If so, how was the change?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Not from a big 4 accounting firm but I was at Accenture before. I would say the culture was the biggest change. Accenture (and I imagine the big 4 is similar, if not the same) had a cutthroat culture, management was very snooty, and I definitely felt like a number. I came into a culture where (not saying there aren’t politics) people weren’t cutthroat, management cares and is helpful and you know people at all levels because they know you exist. The other major difference was the resources and processes. Accenture had very streamlined and strict processes that work. From the technology, to the staffing, to the templates for deliverables. Everything was consistent and you knew where to find what you needed and when you found it, there wasn’t a doubt that it’s right. The change was difficult at first but not terrible and I was able to quickly adapt.

Btw, I speak in past tense of Accenture because I really don’t know what it’s like now. It’s been years since I left so things might have changed

like

I had a hard time. There were a lot of things I hadn’t seen at B4 that they expect you to know at mid-tier, coming in as a senior was pretty rough. Big learning curve but it evened out quickly!

like

This is actually really nice to hear. One of the biggest issues I had was that the learning curve was incredibly slow at big 4 (9/10, not the staff’s fault). I find that this is often the case when regardless of the client mix in general tax.

This is going to be a huge issue as the firm pushes technology and offshoring more and more. The staff simply don’t have the steep learning curve they need and feel like they are drowning (speaking from experience). Leadership has known its an issue for the past few years so it’ll be interesting to see how they address.

likehelpful

Yes. It was fantastic. As a Sr Associate, I made more than an M2 at PwC in my market and I only worked later than 8:30 once. I also didn’t work a single Sunday all year

like

To add, you’re going to hear it’s better from some, and worse from others. It’s on you to do your homework and pick the right firm. It’s not really possible to lump mid tiers together. Some will pay far better and have great quality of life and others could have you worse off than B4

This. I’ve worked at three firms: a regional, PwC, then a second regional.

Regional 1 was just ok. Pay was bad.
PwC had great training. The teams ranged from great to soul destroying and pay was so-so.
Regional 2 has been amazing. Excellent culture, pay, and work life balance. Some things frustrate me for sure, but the pros far outweigh the cons.

Anything outside the Big 4 and you really have to do your homework before you sign on. I’d imagine next tier firms (GT, RSM, BDO, etc.) are going to be somewhat consistent, but more variable than B4 from market to market

Related Posts

Leaving Big 4 for Academia - I do not enjoy it. I know I don’t fit in. The idea of being told what to do, right or wrong, etc. I am a problem solver (research-wise), not a doer.

Thoughts?

likehelpful

What is the salary base for Internal IT Audit Manager within 8 YOE in NYC? Looking for both Big 4 & industry for comparison. TIA

like

Anyone able to refer for a good company as for internal audit or risk advisory? Looking for Richmond, VA area or fully remote. Target base is $125k and above. I have my CPA and 6-7 years of experience (1.5 at big 4, 3 in mgmt consulting, 1.5 corporate)

likehelpful

From a big 4 Management consulting. Have been invited to apply for Accenture strategy, same level. What is the reputation of the strategy group of Accenture?

like

What’s a comparable position at big tech firms for a tech M in Big 4? Senior Program Manager?

likefunny

is partner at a big-4 better than a equivalent role at accenture? is there a comparable role? in pay and prestige? as i understand there is no equity concept at accenture but may be pay wise they can meet big-4 partner packages?

like

Anyone know of a consultant company that sponsors H-1B transfer for a non-tech job - banking risk. Probably about to lose current big 4 job

like

Considering making a switch from Big 4. Comments to share on bonus this year and in a normal year? Culture?

McKinsey & Company Bain & Company Oliver Wyman McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company MBB, Big 4 ANZ fishes, is the public sector work significant in the region? Who are some of the key spenders? What kind of work should I expect?

like

Quick scenario:
If I have a consulting offer from a different Big 4 that has a start date post-10/15, so that in theory I would not have to submit a 2 weeks notice until post-10/1 (bonus payout date) but I sign the offer pre-9/30, am I obligated (looking for both legal & professional standpoint) to tell PwC because it is with a competitor? This is essentially the exact same group at the other big 4

like

How does the new rule impact on amendment? Big 4 has promotion typically every year and which require amendments. Do you think this will effect current H1 holder?

like

How can certain Big 4 companies pay less than the other Big 4 companies? Wouldn't there just be a mass exodus to the higher paying Big 4 companies for the same work?

like

What’s the best way to determine whether or not any of the Deal/FDD service lines are offered in specific big 4 office location? Trying to search in the Portland market if anyone has any insight.

like
like

Looks like B4 partners makes the most $$ in the long run, even tech/FAANG or industry level senior roles doesn’t pay more then $600-700k, except a few roles like ceo/IB/PE/other financial roles/startup rsu (of u r lucky). Came to the conclusion after reading all the posts in this and other bowls. May be MBB, but if u add pensions, I think B4 is better. Thoughts?

like

Big 4 M1 tax salary in the Minneapolis office? Am I underpaid at 110k currently? Not able to leverage big4 transparency data. Appreciate if anyone could share their thoughts.

like

hi everyone ,

I currently work as intern in one of the big 4, now I got an opportunity In deloitte with a package of 7.6l lpa (6l fixed, 1l joining ,bonus & 60k variable) for the same job role. it is through cmpus placement & recruiting us as freshers. I do have another 3 yrs of experience but it was for other role. considering the experience that i have ,is there any chance for me to negotiate in the salary?
please advise

Anyone willing to share ballpark salary expectations (signing, base, bonus) for KPMG M&A Strategy Manager entering with 8 YOE (5 in B4 Strategy, 3 in PE Ops; Market: HCOL Coastal; M7 MBA)

like

My growth is really being stunted at my current firm, how do I switch big 4's as a senior. I don't have my cpa FYI

like

More Posts

Any companies hiring for Director level+ in Information Security / GRC? I have 8+ YOE - a mix of Big 4, smaller advisory/consulting firm, and industry experience. Industry has been focused on FinTech/Startup space, but focused on mid-size/larger clients when at the Big 4 & smaller advisory/consulting firm.

like

Hi All,

Need referrals in Application Security domain.
Skillset: Web Application Security Testing(SAST and DAST), Penetration Testing
Yoe:2.5

Help appreciated:)

like

I am a seasoned Executive Assistant looking for a n 100% remote opportunity.
Please share what you have.

like

What are some easy to make, low stress holiday meals for a school holiday staff party? I was "volunteered" by our principal to set it up this year (🙄). I'm making decorated sugar cookies but kind of drawing a blank when it comes to savory dishes. Bonus points if you have any adult holiday themed games or fun drinks to suggest! It's off school property and there will be a bar (thank god), for context.

like

Planning a trip to Santa Fe. Probably flying to ABQ due to costs, any tips on transit logistics (rental vs Uber vs public transit) or any recommendations?

like

Hi Fishes,

Please tell me how much would be my in-hand salary for below CTC breakup in HCL?

Post Photo
like

Will any company create an entry in EPFO if we complete their onboarding process but don't join the company and inform HR prior to DOJ? Mindtree

I mean, by the onboarding process , we fill our personal, education, and employment details right after the offer letter is released.

like

Transitioning from junior in house at a very small company where I only did small easy contract review to a large multinational corporation in a few weeks, and have those weeks off. Does anyone have any book recommendations I can read until then that actually offer good insight and helpful tips?!

I didn’t learn that much on the business side and I love reading, so seems like a good idea to relax while also preparing a bit.

like

NGGM a success or failure in UKI? Anyone still missing digital?

like

If wanting to move up in the HR Realm, which would be the better certificate? PHR or SHRM?
I am wanting to advance in Talent Acquisition and program management. I am looking for insight as to which would be the better path.

like

Y’all were so helpful with my last question I’m coming back to the well! Who does cross platform brand lift between linear TV and Connected TV?

like

Does anyone else have strong alcohol cravings / triggers in Airports, Airplanes, Hotels/hotel bars, travel in general? I can be fine at home but then go on a bender starring the minute I enter an airport all the way through returning home.

like

Morale is low rn on my team. Superstar team members have left the firm, and more members are trying to leave before busy season because we’ve had to pick up the slack. How to still stay motivated?

like

These kids are really getting out of hand. Just in case you haven’t heard. These are the TikTok challenges by the month.

Post Photo
likehelpful

Anyone willing to provide a Kearney referral please?

like

How's Ramamurthy nagar as an area to live and commute?

like

After how many days the Date of exit gets updated in the UAN portal after the LWD in TCS.
I have received my final payment after 10 days of my last working day.
Because after Date of exit is updated only we can start the PF transfer process right?

like

I'm a selling agent, and I'm having difficulty with one of my clients. She's asking way too much money for her house and she won't believe me when I say it's not going to sell. How long do I keep trying when I know it's basically a lost cause?

like

Anyone know the manager (analytics if it matters) compensation package at DoorDash

like

Back in the day:
Guy: “Wanna go out Saturday night?”
Gal: “Sorry, I have to wash my hair.”

Now:
Guy: “Wanna go out Saturday night?”
Gal: “Sorry, I have to wash my hands.”

likefunny

Additional Posts in Accounting

Kenneth bone for president #BoneZone2016

like

I feel like I have no actual friends in my home office. I only go out after work with the team that I'm on. I'm in no groupchats or anything. Will this hurt me in the long run?

like

What’s the best way to go about getting off a team you don’t want to be on due to them forcing you into huge assignments you don’t have enough availability for? Like being scheduled 3 hours a week but actual is 30+ hours and they don’t change your assignments or scheduled hours

like

Dear psychopaths who highlight the entire sheet white,

Please remove the gridlines instead.

Sincerely,
Your victims

likefunny

Questions to tax manager during a potential switch to another firm?

like

How do people get away with filing HOH when they have no dependents?

like

What are some exit opportunities for an experienced associate in IT audit?

likefunny

Anyone here thinks about changing career path to Software Development Engineer? Being a CPA and have spent 4 yrs at PA, I feel that I want to try another career path. I understand the transition is not easy, and I’d like to get some advice from the group.

like

Any Desert Trippers alive out there?

like

What's the most ridiculous expense you got away with while traveling?

like

Mid-size firms in the NYC area, have they announced when ppl can start going back yet?

like

Where can I find my employee ID number after I’ve left PWC?

like

New Tax Head in NE from KPMG with his side kick. Went from AA to KPMG. Can it get any worse?

like

I was told not to take off during summer & busy season if I wanted a promotion. My overall utilization was high but took a month off during non busy season. How would you approach this? I wanna quit!

like

Pros and cons to the different consulting/advisory groups within the B4? Looking to make a switch from assurance to advisory, not necessarily within EY.

like

If you're on the bench when you give notice, will they pay you the two weeks or ask you to leave?

like

Has anyone left employment at their firm prior to passing all four parts of the CPA exam, and had to reimburse the firm for the cost of the Becker study materials?

like

Anybody know how to download a spreadsheet from the big4transparency website after you put your stuff in? There used to be an option to download a CSV but now I don’t see one and it merely gives you a screenshot of roughly 15 other salaries which isn’t really helpful for comparison purposes since it’s such a small sample size and not the easiest to see the data, filter things, etc. Any ideas? Maybe I’m missing something.

like

Men: if you were to receive a small “thinking of you” gift for busy season from your SO, what would you like it to be?

like

How do you handle bonus money? I recently received ~5k which I worked hard for and looked forward to the last few months and feel pretty lame stashing it all into savings.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.