Hey guys! I'm someone with a BA in finance.

I am really conflicted rn. I would like to hear experience from people who have done masters, or all the way to PhD.

Did you regret doing lengthy studying and should have focus on practical work etc? Let me know your thoughts!

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I will say that a Masters is something you should absolutely achieve if you want to be promoted in most companies. As for a PhD? Well I have one. But I didn’t get it for career growth. In fact I had a very difficult time finding a job after I graduated because I was under qualified for teaching positions and overqualified for the private sector. I stumbled into my current career and had to really prove to them that having a PhD was equal to others who had years of experience. It does bring a level of immediate respect with clients. However, PhDs are incredibly difficult to achieve and you should really only go for one if you truly love researching and can give it your full attention - they are not for the faint of heart.


Speaking personally, I didn't think about things in that way. I did a PhD because I liked researching and I didn't know what else I wanted to do. When I finished, I realized I didn't want to be a professor, and so stumbled into industry, and am now going into consulting. In retrospect, getting a PhD was certainly not the most efficient way to reach the professional position that I did, but it also helped me develop skills that while under-valued in much of the professional world, are, I think, of use. Are they as useful as what I would have gotten had I avoided academia? Probably not, but I'm reasonably glad with the path I took.


A long time ago, I thought maybe a PhD would be of interest. Since that time, my household has seen two completions and it felt more achievable after watching their experiences. My daughter did it first because that is entry level in her field of microbiology. My wife did it to move into teaching teachers. For me, I want to bring something to tech consulting that my peers don’t. It’s a grind, but that’s why there are so few. It probably won’t change my pay much, but it will make me more attractive in my field. Three years in, I can see the light at the end of the tunnel.

I would suggest you think about how a PhD fits into your long term career goals and passions. I enjoyed my MSc research, fancied a career in academia, loved my professor and was fortunate to be offered a PhD scholarship so it was a natural yes. After my phd though I left academia because I didn’t fancy the bureaucracy of it all (publish or perish etc). So I moved into industry research and was fortunate to work on cutting edge energy transition technologies. If you do move into a client facing role, Guidehouse 1 is right, it definitely brings an immediate level of respect of clients, colleagues and seniors too.

Related Posts

Hi everybody,

Looking for some insight/curious to hear how others would handle this situation:

I have an offer I want to accept; I was trying to negotiate for a signing bonus… but they’re not budging.

The issue is, the start date is in a month and I’m up for a promotion in a week at my current company. I would like to leave before I get promoted, I think it would be pretty low of me to accept and promptly quit.

Not the new employer’s problem? Or can/should I try to leverage this?


Hi ,
I got an offer from KPMG India, I accepted it earlier but I am now planning to reject it. Will KPMG India blacklist me even from future opportunities? And also if there is any cool off period?


Microsoft started recruitment for Kolkata region for data scientists.
Great news for Kolkata.


I’m working with an art director who is unable to like ideas from someone else. She never said one nice word on my ideas (on the contrary) while both the ECD and the CCO consistently love them. This happened on multiple briefs.

There’s just never a positive reaction when I tell an idea. I’ve been telling myself it’s probably a communication thing but it’s really weighing on me to work in such a negative environment.

Should I move on?


Fucking axcess is doing maintenance 🙄 WHY!


Hi Fishes,
Can anyone please refer me
UBS for analyst position. The job id is 255789BR

Can anyone here from IBM HR can help? Waiting for a revised offer But did not get any update yet(phn is off) otherwise have to move on to next Org. To join @Ibm IBM


We’re hiring at Havas. Looking for Administrative Assistants in New York, San Diego, Los Angeles and Chicago. Let me know if you’re interested in learning more!


Has anyone been looking for/bought a house in the last couple years?

What kind of down payment / interest rate did you find?


Anyone looking for an [assistant / junior - creative producer/manager] part time?

I’m a college student looking for a part time job! I’m currently a junior creative producer full time but my school responsibilities are getting heavier and now looking for part time work. Please let me know! Looking for a remote job or hybrid!


What is the most useful technical or soft skills for any mechanical engineer to have where you work? I’m curious to know what really matters for everyone and what makes a big impact on the team and business.

Specifics if you can; CAD tools, simulation, CAD speed or proficiency, industry or standards knowledge, GD&T, certifications, Microsoft Excel, presentation skills, technical writing, project management, self organization, great communication, teaching ability, relationship building, etc.

are any firms giving the day off friday for juneteenth?


Celebrate azadi ka amrit mahotsav and reach your financial freedom when India will be celebrating 100 years of independence. 🇮🇳🇮🇳
DM me on 7019194829 for more details!!

Post Photo

What’s the salary being offered for tech Senior Consultant at Deloitte?Also what is the sign on amount?


San Fran ✨

Post Photo

Been in big 4 data analytics for 4 years now. All my team does is remediation. I don't feel like this is progressing my career as I'm not expanding my technical skillset on these projects.

Do all big 4 data teams do remediation? Is it worth going to a boutique consulting firm to pursue more technical challenges or is this best achieved in the industry?


Canary in the coal mine might be the most insufferable phrase that just doesn’t seem to die


I currently have an offer from HCL Bangalore location. I wanted to know if there's a way to get it changed to Mumbai location. Is that feasible?


I am tired of men catcalling me and following me at night - with less people in the city I feel less safe. I feel so exhausted for just walking to my apartment and having to fear rape or assault


Hotel GMs: What is your salary and size of your hotel?


Additional Posts in PhD, JD, MD Consultants

At a M7 (or top 10), whatever floats your boat. Have successfully finished my qualifiers. I know my goal is industry and I’m starting dissertation proposal stuff now (will take around 1.5-2 years to complete), should I opt for a Master’s and start working now? Should I get the PhD? Let’s look at this from a strictly career perspective. My goal is to come back to consulting.


I’m working on my PhD while working full time ... any tips?


Have a friend who is at an engineering PhD program. I'm trying to help shape her resume, but would love a second look from those that understand the differences in grad school recruiting.

has anyone created a research plan? applying for faculty roles at a university and a recent PhD, with only a published dissertation to my name


Hi everyone - MD Consultant here. Would love to network with other consultants in this group and learn why you decided to come into Consulting. Thank you.


Any MDs willing to talk to a MD with significant clinical experience who is interested in consulting?

What do you do and how much you made in 2021?


How to respond to stakeholders and team mates when they say, "your approach is to academic". For context, conducted stakeholder interviews to theme data, and used initial codes, axial, emergent codes


Has McK join the hiring spree yet? Any chances for APD to lateral?


JD for strategy consulting? I have JD, and I am currently doing risk consulting (regulatory/compliance/legal oriented engagements). Considering applying for a few strategy consulting roles. Any skill sets I am missing (e.g., financial modeling, SWOT analysis, etc.) that I should learn first?


What type of exit opportunities have you seen come across? Any issues exiting without an MBA?

Which machine learning conferences are FAANG companies recruiting at ?


Hey there -

Off the cuff -

My kidlet is a frosh in HS - she has wanted to be a surgeon since she was 3 - the last year or so, she's started specifying trauma surgery.

So... what's a good med school to track into a strong trauma residency? My second dad talks about Presbyterian in NYC as awesome.. but am trying to get an understanding of options to help degap her own research.

What matters?

Thanks a bunch!


I have a PhD, but damn does an MBA not seem fun and useful for networking. Has anyone gone after PhD and a few years of consulting?

Any advice on how to push through the last step of the dissertation? I work full time and only have that left for my PHD, but it has been very challenging to make real progress.


Hi! Sitting on offers from Harvard and Cambridge for PhD. I was hired out of undergrad into Strategy, worked two years. Trying to decide if I want to 100% pivot to academia...any advice/suggestions?


Hi. This is probably a basic question, but I'm wondering which consulting firms prefer people with a PhD background in science? Thanks


anyone here an entrepreneur? I have a PhD in org psych and 20+ years in Big 4 human cap... starting up my own firm and wondering about billing rates. what hourly rate do you charge for your services?


Any other MDs here? Are you preparing for industry exits or the long haul in consulting? I genuinely love this industry so far an am curious how much of my background will actually be useful after SA.


Interested in pursuing a PhD in Econ (don’t have research experience or the math classes yet) what can I do to strengthen my app? Should I apply for a masters before phd? Graduated from a T20 undergrad with a finance major and good gpa, been working at D as an analyst for a year now


New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone


Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or