How do you feel about the requirement to share a LinkedIn profile in many online applications? Personally, as someone who has almost entirely removed Google, Meta, and Microsoft from my life, I find it very irratating. It's not like it helps reduce fraud either, and LinkedIn posts are so vapid that it's a meme now. Why do hiring managers think this is a good idea? From my perspective it's just excluding people who pay the most attention to the technology landscape.

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

So then why not list a fake LinkedIn address like www.LinkedIn.com/in/OfflineOnPurpose

Or……

in/DoesNotUseLinkedIn.

in/NotOnThisPlatform

in/OfflineButQualified

in/IRelyOnExperienceNotApps

in/ThisIsARequiredField

Now the application can finally submit. You’ve satisfied the required field, and the URL makes it clear—politely—that you don’t use LinkedIn. Anyone paying attention will get the message

likefunnysmart

Yeah I mean I understand the appeal of the verification argument, but the fact of the matter is that fraud and impersonation is rampant on LinkedIn as well. Treating it as added security or verification is nothing more than false sense of safety. I'm not against having *some* public info, that's why I maintain a personal site and blog. But requiring it to be LinkedIn specifically just strikes me as lazy and missing out on the most talented hires. At least in software, of the people I know, level of Luddic behavior tends to scale proportionally to skill: The people who skip LinkedIn also tend to be the people who self host, who manage a fedi instance, who hoard 100TB of storage on their homelab made from reused server pieces, the people who have cobbled together on prem cloud environments in their own home that are more advanced than the systems their employers use. Again, just anecdotal, and obviously this isn't a universal rule. The good news is not all companies require LinkedIn, and those will be the ones who get access to the most qualified candidates who are overlooked by other companies.

Create a bare bones profile with your name and last initial and your title. Then list your skills and and any other unidentifiable information you want to add. You can also turn off public visibility so your profile isn't exposed outside of LinkedIn users. Seems like a pretty anonymous way of satisfying the request.

like

A very practical and realistic answer. I'd definitely do this if I was more desperate for a job. But on principal I don't like Microsoft holding the keys to deciding who does and does not get a job.

Because some positions like Recruiting use Linked In in their jobs so the Hiring Managers have to see if they have an active profile. Also, hiring managers look to see if your resume matches your profile because people have several resumes they are using targeting several position titles. There’s a business reason for companies to ask. If you don’t want to provide it or don’t have a LI profile, just write N/A.

like

Linkedin was at a time the place to have your online profile for jobs and business networking. Over the last several years it has gone downhill and is nothing more than a different flavor of Facebook. Its full of useless self serving posts and repetitive memes and fake job postings by offshore headhunters and scammers.

like

If there’s a chance that the hiring manager notices a common connection, or sees a company in the past that they are fond of, I’ll take it!

like

V a op
V

like

I have passed on companies looking for the LumpedIn requirement when applying. Even some CIO organizations require a profile just to sign up. LumpedIn is more like a dating profile, most of the time what you see is not what you get.

like

Its a violation or state labor laws & anti-trust laws & forced labor laws. Many state have "Social Media Privacy Laws in Employment" to prevent companies from requiring social media access to apply for a job, exspecially when most request come from a competitor called Dice. Because Dice & the recruiting companies, all compete with Linkdin, it violates anti-trust law by allowing Linkedin to control its competitors. Furthermore, since most recruiters work thru layers & may not know the end customer, Linkedin could be creating fake jobs to increase its membership base & increase sales, by exploiting unpaid labor, which can violate forced labor laws, as defined as serious harm thru reputational harm or psychological; harm, to get free labor, also know as anti-trafficking laws.

like

I can’t speak for whatever company this was, however I suspect it’s part of a) verifying you are who you say you are b) you’re less likely to have multiple jobs

I’m sure all of you commenting are decent and hard working people, but I’m also confident not many of you have the responsibly of putting food on the table every month for dozens of people and their families.

We have only 75 people but there have been numerous occasions over the last ten years where we have employed people who turned out to be working two jobs or borrowing peoples identity, threatening to expose our IP and general theft of equipment.

As an company founder I have a responsibility to all our team that we try our best to make good hiring decisions and hire people who are net contributors so that we can keep putting food on the table for our awesome people.

Linked-In visibility, jobs that match your CV, recommendation from people etc is just one tool in our toolbox to help us identify suspicious activity that just doesn’t look right.

like

I agree it’s frustrating but with the digital age so many people can apply for roles the more an employer can suss you out the better for them. They want to see if you’re engaged in company culture, have references, are knowledgeable and a thought leader. Many people are good at their job, what makes you the better choice aside from skill?

Companies want to see who will be as compliant as possible. With AI taking over the workplace, they want drones, not visionaries, for middle management and below.

I don’t like LinkedIn. It’s fake, and 99% of the time you just roll your eyes reading the nonsense. But ultimately, some companies just want to see who will roll with the punches. I have a LinkedIn, and never post. I’ll repost content from others once every couple months to appear active, but that’s all. I never update it with my current employer because it’s nobody’s business where I currently work.

Also, some companies just want to see what you look like before they even interview you. This is VERY common in public relations agencies where you’ll notice that almost all the employees are at minimum, moderately attractive. That’s not a coincidence - they 100% discriminated against applicants and judged their appearance before even offering them an interview. Pretty privilege.

like

I have noticed that as well. I don't normally post on LinkedIn so if they're looking for something, they won't really find it there.

Much of the time when this is required, it's because they are trying to filter out candidates who are Over Employed. I don't think anyone job hunting _likes_ LinkedIn, but for emloyers it is an easy way trick candidates into to stating whether they are currently employed publicly. I'm not saying that this is right or not—just a reality.

Related Posts

Any recent numbers for Salesforce TPM - Senior Manager position?

like

I am currently in negotiation with Agoda Bangkok for senior software engineer position. I am currently working in India. How much I should ask them during the negotiation? Also, if any Indian working at Agoda Bangkok can guide me with the kind of expenses in Bangkok as an expat?

likehelpful

Looking for a job change.. plz suggest if there are any openings..
Skillset: .Net Full Stack developer, YoE: 6 yrs.

Anyone hiring? I’m a PharmD looking to jump from consulting to the industry.

like

Anyone with recent experience recruiting for Boston Consulting Group? Got in touch with a recruiter through referral, was directed to submit an application and already finished my pymetrics. Anyone know when I would be able to hear back and what the hiring timeline looks like? Recruiter suggested to get back in a few weeks but isn’t it too slow? McKinsey sent me an invite for 1st interview in a few days after they received my referral.

like

Hi fellow 🐠, I recently moved to Vancouver from Europe, and I’m actively looking for a job. It’s been 3 months and over 200 applications with little luck :( Getting a bit desperate. I’m looking for Project Management/Business Analyst roles. I’ve have 4 years of experience in SaaS implementation and success management. If any of you know of any openings & would be able to refer me, I would be extremely grateful to talk with you. Thanks!

like

Any firms or companies hiring now that don’t take forever with their green card process? My H1B ends in September 2024 and EY is not making meaningful progress on my perm process. Looking for roles that require really strong financial modeling and analytics skills.

like

Hi Folks, I have submitted the documents in last week 8 days ago for Test automation position. But still I didn't hear for further steps of HR round. I called HR, she said my docs are under review, they will get back to me. My question is what time it takes to release the offer for Persistent. Also anyone knows how is Accleriote BU at persistent, would be helpful for me. Thanks

What are some good practices during the sales phase of a potential project to execute before the contract is signed? Seems obvious but would love some ideas on standard operating procedures that help with seamlessly handing over a signed contract to the account team. For example, speaking to the potential client explicitly about their role in staying on schedule, reviewing scope creep consequences, etc.

like

Anyone working for Oracle Cerner / Cerner Corporation and can provide a referral?

like
like

How to move into executive leadership? I’m a mid-40s former MBBer with, I think, an impressive and diverse resume. I think I’m suitable for an executive leadership role, but unsure about how to pursue one. Any suggestions? Career coach? Headhunters? Cold “calls”? Thanks!

like

I have an interview with Korn Ferry for an associate principal role and am curious about others’ experiences have been with work-life balance here. Also, I have an idea of what I should be compensated in this type of role, but any insights on how they pay compared to others would be helpful. Are you traveling during the pandemic or have client interactions been virtual? Lastly, if you are a consultant here, are you on billable hours? My current consulting role is not - so this would be new.

like

Hello fishes..How are pega developer openings for 2 year experienced lately @tcs @infosys @aaseya @coforge @capgemini @techmahindra @cts @verizon @virtusa @pegasystems any information will be of a great help

like

Hi everyone, have a final informal interview in a couple weeks with someone I’d be working with routinely. Was told that it’s the final step but have also read on here that there’s a hiring committee interview. Is this for everyone, or should I expect to be done after this upcoming one?

like

Need referral in siemens java developer. Java ,spring boot, microservices.

like

Hi guys need referral for ux designer.

Please let me know if someone has the requirement.

like
like

More Posts

Hi fishes, URGENT!!!
I've put down papers in TCS. My project management is ready to give me early release. How probable is the HR to accept my LWD prepone request?

like

What's the best way to prevent burn out in this line of work

like

Today no one came into our restaurant and my boss started crying. Do I... comfort them? Leave them be?

likefunnyupliftinghelpful

Does cisco India have their own PF trust or is it EPFO..govt's only

like

Dating in California! What’s your experience?any difference between NYC?

like

Can anyone share what are the usual components of a flexi benefits basket and to what max amount can you utilise them.
Eg. Communication fuel etc

like

Hi fishes, Need help!!!!! Is gratuity deduction mandatory in Infosys from salary, if yes if leave the organisation after 1 year, are we eligible to receive the paid amount? Or only after 4 years we will receive? How one can opt out of gratuity???? Please suggest!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Infosys Infosys Limited

like

Hi People,
I'm looking for opportunities in Investment Banking Analyst roles in Mumbai.
I have 5 year's work experience and a finance major.
Please ping me if there's an opening in your organization and I would like to know more.

like

Anyone working PwC India SAP Advisory??
How is the projects and perks?

I gave 6 yrs of exp in SAP HCM. Cctc is 10.4 how much i can expect?

I have 2 offers with 22.3 LPA. Any chance they will match it??

like

Hi Sharks, I have 2.5 years of work experience in ZS Associates in decision analytics, I have significant projects in data science but want to fully deep dive as a data scientist. Kindly refer in case of any openings. Thanks

like

Anyone go from a 1 bedroom to a studio? What was the transition like?

like

Is it just me or do 90% of the jobs being laid off by big tech sound made up? Many job descriptions with multiple bullet points that all kinda revolve around the same idea. One of my buddies works for a big IT company and literally just sits on meetings all day. No one really contributing to anything other than agreeing to whatever the speaker is saying. Are these kind of jobs finally being exposed? Six figure employees getting paid to sit and bounce ideas off each other?

like

Any one working in Emirates NBD in tech roles?

like

Once all the boomers are gone will there be a gult of homes? I have rentals here will they be worthless in the future?

funny

Any ideas on planning a quarterly retreat for a startup? Specifically for strategy day and culture. Never planned a quarterly retreat before and is not to sure what it entails. I’ve been told agendas for retreats are very subjective to company but would like some general ideas if anyone has any!

like

2 weeks in an my night and points are all fucked up.. come on Accenture get your data migration workstream together

likefunny

Additional Posts in Job Hunting in Tech

Anyone have any advice going into the mock/pitch portion of the interview?

like

Hey beautiful people,
I’m 27Y and work in tech. Unfortunately my carpal tunnel is getting worst slowly. I’m worry that I still have like 45 years more to be retired and can’t stop working because I have a f* mortgage to pay 😭 I have a super ergonomic workstation, but I know my hand needs a long rest, and I can’t do it… Does anyone relate? What do you recommend?

like

I am a QA lead looking to break into google Spotify or meta as a program manager or project manager . Can someone please guide me on what does it entail to be a PM at these companies?

like

Anyone have a couple of great recruiter that you could recommend for a SAAS sales position in Houston Texas?

like

Hello there. I have been interviewing with Okta and got through all 5 rounds of interviews. They say they want to offer me the job but there is a global freeze for all marketing roles at the company. They want to offer me a contractor role instead. Does anyone here know if that is the case? I haven't heard anything as they seem be on wellness week. Thanks for any guidance :)

like

I am a UX designer who has completed a Google certification program along with a resume and professional portfolio. However, I’ve struggled to find a job (remote). Any advice or resources I could use? Or are there any employers currently hiring and are interested? I’d be happy to hear from you.

like

Hi all,

I work as a membership manager in a tech-related, non-profit startup.Main tasks are taking care of members activities (newsletters, webinars, surveys, CRM - but not directly sales) and at the same time I am kind of a IT project manager without IT background, I design with an IT agency members experience with different tools (members platform, crm workflows etc). How could I boost my career towards the IT project manager role?

likesmart

Recently found out a hiring manager was bragging to a bunch of people at the company about getting me to accept an offer for a must cheaper rate than he expected. He was let go soon after. Justice? Not sure..

likeuplifting

Anyone know of IT Security jobs specializing in NIST and/or FISMA that are hiring?

There have been surprising news with layoffs lately. Has anyone here been affected by the layoffs at Twitter or META?

like

My current company is “taking me off payroll” but instead of laying me off or firing me, are fully expecting me to take up an hourly contractor position for $30/hour with no specified time or guarantee of hours. How do I respectfully tell them no?

like

Guys I am from Texas, USA. The last time I appeared for an interview was 10-11 years ago. I work in Java and related tech. I am also AWS certified (architect associate) but don't have much experience with it. I create small stuff on AWS for my personal learning. I am looking to switch jobs in the next 6 months so I want to use this time to prepare but not sure where to start? Any guidance on what to prepare etc? Like What skills are must have,
What skills are good to have, etc

Potential new job is flying me across the country….for a one hour interview. Red flag? Or just a formality since they want me to relocate so I can see what it’s about?

like

I’m looking to get my first job Online i need help please…

like

Has anyone taken ITIL 4 foundation test?

likeuplifting

Anyone from @Tide UK? I’m interviewing for a role and I’d need some help with the prep.

like

Looking for a fully remote PM role with US based teams. Any leads? Currently juggling 2 teams and one off shore. None of which was disclosed in the interview process.

like

Although Amazon has instituted a hiring freeze and layoffs are probably on their way, I went through the loop for a security engineer position at AWS. Before I attended the final interviews, Amazon placed the hiring freeze and called me to ask if I wanted to go ahead or cancel my application. I decided do go ahead Right now I'm waiting for their response and the position I applied to changed from "under consideration" to "no longer under consideration". Thoughts?

like

Tomorrow is my first day at my new job after being layoff... I enjoyed seen this post with stats so here is mine:)

2 months (pluss 2 weeks after accepting a offer, just waiting for paperwork etc)

273 application

10-20 recruiting condos (some pass on me, some I passed on because they were not fully remote, salary or long hiring process)

3 companies I when thrue the whole interviewing process

From the 3, 1 company just declined no feedback the other 2 send offer letters

170k base, tech.

likeuplifting

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal