Mckinsey Fishes: I got an interview with the firm and I have to choose between a generalist role vs a specialized BA in marketing and sales. What are some of the pros and cons in regards to specializing early? I am interested in supply chain, retail, strategy, and dd

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

If you like M&S topics, would actually recommend going for it. They don’t meaningfully restrict you in any of the practices (M&S, Digital, etc.), really. You can still do any studies you want for the most part—you just need to do some portion of your studies in the practice

Pros: m&s BAs get special mentorship/coaching and perks (budget to attend certain types of conferences, retreats, etc.), can still largely get staffed on whatever you want
Cons: usually need to do like 30ish% of your studies, if I’m not mistaken, with the m&s practice (though these are usually the “sexiest” studies anyway such as GTM strategy and stuff, so it doesn’t matter)

like

Thanks M2! I dmed you for another follow up question

IMO, go generalist. You can still de-facto specialize by continuing to work in marketing / sales across industries, but you won’t be limited in exploring other functions.

smart

Thanks! Are the interviews going to be different between the two tracks?

Do marketing & sales, they tend to have some of the most interesting studies. If you do generalist you're likely to get stuck on a lot of very boring org/ops/finance

They will suggest ones in your area most likely, but you can just look at the M&S staffing log and message the people staffing other ones around the country.

I guess another follow up question would be - what would the primary reason be for hiring someone from undergrad directly into specialty practice - is it that they don’t want to consider me for the general BA or that they are actually in need of someone in MS?

There’s no special reason for it. They just probably want more M&S BAs. Plenty of BAs from all schools recruit for specialties as well as generalist roles out of undergrad. They are likely offering you the option because they thought your background might be a good fit and thought you might be interested

Related Posts

Hi Fishes ,

I have recently accepted offer for Epam , but when i saw some glassdoor reviews .it mostly about job security . Do epam really fire employees if didn't select for client interviews.can i reject my offer once i accept it..?

like
like

My company is hiring! Reach out if you are interested in working for an early stage Real Estate Tech Startup. Looking for Software Engineers and an Acquisitions Analyst (Private Equity MF). Based in Boston.

like

The new company I’m at now sent me an email from an email address that was HR@companyName.careers saying I was accepted for the position. They gave me paperwork to fill out and sign to accept the position

I fill out the paperwork and send it back to them and it goes through… then a few days later I go back to the email to say something else and I get this…?
Then today I got a check from the company In the mail to setup my home office, and it’s signed by someone I’ve never met before or heard of…?

What…..

Post Photo
like

Hi guys, hcl offered me E3 band , consultant position for its GCP practice. How’s is the project ? Any idea ? My joining is next week.

Getting ready to study for the CAMS exam. Do I need anything extra besides just studying the study guide and practice exam over and over. I’ve read online about people using AML assassin; is it worth it?

like

For the CFE, did you do anything in addition to the ACFE prep course? The course is just practice questions, so I’m wondering where I can actually learn the information first before that.

If anyone is looking for a referral as an experienced hire to the PwC DAT (Digital Assurance & Transparency - formerly Risk Assurance) practice let me know and would be happy to refer you. We are actively looking to hire.

like

I have an interview coming up for internal audit manager. Currently in external audit. When asked about my experience in ERM - what would you say Is transferable skills that I can leverage in my answer?

like

What exit ops are there outside of testing controls all day? Getting tired of this. Resume is ready

likefunny

If anyone is looking for Senior Associate or Manager roles in Risk Assurance, PwC’s Digital Assurance and Transprency practice (legacy Risk Assurance) is hiring and I would love to connect and refer you. DMs are open!

like

Hello everyone! I would like to apply to MBB as an experienced hire from big 4 for a post MBA position. Do you think this is a good time to apply or I should wait given the economic situation? Thank you for your answer :)

Is there anyone that works as a Mainframe Data Analyst at Bank of America ? I see an opening and would like to learn more about the day-to-day and projects. TYIA.

like

Hi i am working in TMB bank as an officer. Now I am planning to switch to IT since my qualification is MSc IT. What are the certifications that i have to do and is to possible to switch my sector to IT

Hi Guys,

I have offers from Amadeus Labs, and Powerschool similar roles, same package. Any recommendations based on work culture, growth, salary hike?
Thanks in advance.

like

Hoping to unlock dms with this post- my 17 year old buddy! I’m a director of UX strategy with a speciality in l&d, if you love your company I’d love a referral!

Post Photo
like

Is it possible for a school teacher with a masters in education and very good Microsoft office schools to become a resource manager/associate? Asking for a friend

Can some one share if KPMG employees can apply to Citi as when applying they ask that "have you ever worked for KPMG" . Is there any restriction??

like

Anyone from Strategy& Deals Strategy open to chatting?

I saw that your group is hiring again for entry-level (I'm currently a college senior - made fb account during internship). I really enjoyed my past CDD work and would love to learn more about the team. Thanks!

like

More Posts

How high does L6 range typically go for Sr Program Manager roles? I am currently at ~250k TC and the position they were interviewing me for hand a max range of 200k TC. Is >300k TC possible?

like
like

I made it through the first 2 interviews and I think it went well. How long does it usually take to find out if you move on to the final interview round?

like

I just left my job where I managed a community of 20-somethings and am about to start managing a community of people in their 40s. How different will it be?

like

How is the ViSa nyc office ? Any perks for employees ?

like

My family members have an F3 visa approved since 2012. Visa bulletin is now sometime in 2008. Iam confused if after the uscis approval they needed to have received the welcome letter from NVC or if that will only come when their case is current. Thank you all

Does anyone know the starting salary for Jackson Lewis in the firm's Connecticut office, as well as the billable hours requirement?

like

Hi! Looking for PM roles at later stage startups or big tech if anyone could help 🙏🏻. Trying to leave a toxic workplace ASAP

like
like

Do MBB firms usually give temporary accommodation to look for a place for people relocating from outside?

smart

can anyone please share @CitiusTech MR round general questions? today i hvae MR round.

like

Hello, How many public holidays in MasterCard? Is it same like other banking firms ?

like

Hi all,

What is the notice period and probation
period for new joiner in Ltimindtree?

like

Does running actually ruin your knees or is that just a myth?

like

Hi folks, i have recently joined tcs and now i had received a RnD kind of story and i have prepared the demo and also given the code to client as it was split between me and one client side developer. There are bugs in project but none of them are assigned to me. I had attended all the bug review meetings. Will it be a wise move to ask manager to assign me some bugs? Or should i just wait

like

Infosys vs tcs for job Security?

like

I am currently working as analytics professional. Some of the work included but not limited to are Insights generation, root cause analysis, creation and maintenance of data pipeline for owned charters and projects.

Regularly used tools are SQL (Hive, Trino, MSSQL), python, dashboarding tool.

Currently looking out for opportunities. If you have something into data science and analytics then please let me know. Will share my resume with you.

Regards,

like

Currently interviewing with Humana wondering how many vacation/pto days they give in total? I currently get 28 days and trying to compare

like

LTI is Hiring for below Oracle - BU Positions
Immediate to 30 days joiners will be preferred

Interested plz DM with job codes and email id to apply

Post Photo
like

Anyone having sfcc materials or videos session pls ping me.

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Best rotational programs for medium tier UG

like

How soon did you hear back about offer from PwC after partner round interview? Or did you receive any call/mail in case of rejection?PwC

likefunny

Ugh! Got 2 hours left in a 14 hour drive with younger sis. Both of us getting on each other's nerves and I hate road trips. Help fbfam! Anything entertaining? 😔

like

.. responsibilities: cooking, cleaning, Kia, meal prep, etc. i understand managing the family is a full- time gig bug I can’t work and take that on. What to do!?

like

We get it Netflix, twilight is great! Now please remove that sh*t from US top 10 list 😂🙏

likefunny

Shots fired. Your move Deloitte.

Post Photo
funnylike

Any 🐠 at Protiviti willing to chat/refer. Looking at a M&A role.

like

Best business-oriented, but novel-style books with good writing, style, & interesting characters? Not really self-help/advise focused, more of actual literature with business themes/plots. Any recs?

like

Looking to learn more about Strategy& and if possible, a referral. If anyone is available, I will DM!

like

Bain & Company Any fishes from Bain & Company’s LA office willing to connect? Interested in applying as experienced hire and wanted to know more about the projects/culture there. Thanks!

like

40% off tech stock sale today? GOOG proving again to be the master chess player.

like

Headed to bschool and considering Brand Management at a CPG company. The thing is, I already make ~$100k and with Brand Management salaries starting around $105k, it seems like a horrible ROI. Thinking I should just stay in consulting. How would you look at it?

like

Lot has changed in one year! 😂

Post Photo
likefunny

BCG folks, I hear rumors of layoffs happening given the slow pipeline. Is it true?

like

Since we’ve all been working from home for months now, what’s the best office chair out that y’all are using for our long work from home hours? Looking to invest in a better one than my ~$150 one from Amazon.

like

For all you major savers + investors, how would you suggest to get started investing in assets other than a 401K and ROTH IRA?

like

After a year using my home office setup, especially the 27 inch monitor, how can I ever go back to the traveling life with tiny laptop screen? 😔

likesmart

Looking to improve general communication skills (especially around structuring narrative/ key messages), any books/courses that you would recommend?

like

I’m moving from east to west coast. I can’t decide if I should just throw away all my stuff or not. Has anyone had to make this decision before? What did you end up doing?

like

New joiner. What should I get with my $250 wfh stipend? I already have standing desk, dual monitor, portable monitor, and good headset, not too sure what else I need, but it’s free money. Thanks.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal