Torn between continuing consulting and industry, curious to hear the opinion of this group:

3.5 years in consulting since undergrad and wanted to do SCM consulting with following goals:
1. Learn from experienced team members with industry and consulting experience
2. See best practices in action and implement them
3. Maintain variety in my career by working with various clients, industries, etc.

Thus far it hasn’t really panned out that way for a number of reasons. Some more details below 😊

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I was/am a supply chain specialist. @4 yrs in consulting I went to a client for 5 yrs and then returned back to my firm for another 20+ years. Having a “real job” for a while made me a better consultant

like

Great perspective, considering doing similar, thanks!

Here's a predictable consulting response - it depends. There's a possibility that a long term investment with your firm will pay off if that practice does grow, but it's anyone's guess if and when that will happen.

Same would apply to an industry job, except I'd argue you may have more role definition within industry than consulting (at many firms, you are staffed wherever they put you without your say, especially as a junior resource).

If you aren't happy, aren't growing at a pace you're happy with, and don't legitimately belive in the future of your firm or role, I'd say it would be a good time to test the waters elsewhere.

like

Yeah, I definitely think this firm’s mission to grow their SCM presence is going to be successful, but I don’t love some of the core operations of the firm and don’t necessarily see myself growing here. Maybe it’s joining in covid that has me more frustrated than normal, but personally don’t see myself staying long term.

Agree with you though that industry would likely lead to better role definition, and likely working with more experts, and as long as I like the role it could be fruitful. I worry I don’t have enough relevant experience to get an industry position that pays at least 80% of what I make now, looking for at least 110k…if you have any recommendations/thoughts

Probably going to try to get through a year at the current role and see if it turns around at all

like

I went from consulting to industry and now I’m back to consulting. Depending on where you are for industry you can learn a lot but you’ll only learn about the one role you’re in. Consulting gives your wider variety of learning opportunity. On the flip side, I understand my clients pain points a lot more since I’ve lived in the industry side. I would say it helps a lot to have that experience too. It’s personal preference.

like

For sure! Just look at the skills needed for the role and what you’d be able to learn on the job. Helps gauge which ones to apply to

like

Consulting 100% has been more enjoyable for me. Was VP in industry for a few years and it gets stale and politics frustrating. Plus with covid now travel isnt the issue it was before.

like

In school I loved my internship in global supply chain that was in industry and learned a lot about planning, supplier negotiation, etc. and had a wonderful manager to boot.

My first stint in consulting 2.5 years, I was working on an ERP system that was SCM related but ended up doing a lot of tech PM work. It was very transferable, but not 100% in line with the goals I had above.

My last half year+ have been with a smaller consulting firm that has a newer SCM space, my first project was really interesting but the organization wasn’t ready for it and there was some political drama above my head that didn’t make it the most enjoyable experience. Now I’m on the bench because it’s a newer SCM space and a few folks above me have left because it’s definitely a slow startup for the business. I definitely feel that the goals above aren’t being met.

Is meeting these goals a pipe dream? Is it possible in a consulting environment or better off trying to move in industry.

Are you me?

Haha same goals. Wanted to be SCM expert in consulting ended up doing tech work and feel like I'm hitting a wall after 4 years.

Pay is great but the circumstances haven't led me to where I wanted to be.

Hahah glad to know I’m not alone, I’m nervous to continue pursuing it because if I don’t like it then I don’t know what I’d go back to

Related Posts

Anyone is a tech role in healthcare ? If so what is your title so you enjoy it?

like

Has anyone successfully moved out of claims into underwriting? I have been doing worker’s compensation claims for about 9 years now as an adjuster. I would really like to get into underwriting but have not had any success so far. What are some other roles I can transition to?

likehelpful

Has anyone taken the CA brokers exam? Thinking about taking it as I enter my second year working in real estate.

like

Recently accepted a job in oracle/financial systems consulting. I have some experience in systems but mostly FP&A and operations. I have a few cloud certifications as well.

How tough will it be for me to get up to speed and are there any recommended trainings I should do? Please let me know!

like

I keep getting recruiters asking to apply for new roles, which is what I thought I wanted because I’m not growing at my agency. But I’m so fatigued I don’t even know if I want to stay in advertising. Have y’all left or took a break to do something different? What did you do?

like

Currently a staff in audit - 6 months in. Glad to be learning a lot, and have had a generally positive experience at the firm other than a few interactions, some tough busy season nights. Really been intrigued by TAS/M&A, however, and had a few convos with a senior in TAS i know at the firm. It’s closer to what I studied, but don’t know how to make the jump as it seems an internal transfer could take 6+months/senior rank and a lot of convincing. Is it better to jump firms/has anyone done this?

like

What monetary goal/target are you telling yourself to hit before quitting big law?

like

Hi sharks,
How is the career growth for a Salesforce developer in the market in near future.

like

Hello!

I'm about to start a new job with my main account being a big beer brand.
I want to study and prepare as much as I can before it starts, and influence myself as much stuff as possible... Both from advertising and outside of it.

Can you please share your tips and recommendations?
Specially Art Direction focused - I really want to arrive and be prepared to perform to the best level possible.

Thank you!!

like

Hello, I have 4.5 years of NYS WC authorizations for orthopedic. I also have experience as a front office supervisor at a hotel. Any suggestions on a career move? I feel really stagnant where I am right now and I feel very under paid for the amount of labor I have to put in. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Thank You

like

I'm the only employee with a background in finance in a tech startup growing at a 300%+ per year. But it's actually my first finance-related experience (interned and now part-time as I'm in my senior year of undergrad) and don't know really how to have an impact as my knowledge is "limited" and have no technical mentorship.

Any advice/mentorship would be wonderful!

I’ve been doing autocad design for 5 years now, and though it’s cool, it’s not what I want to do with my life. How can I break out of this and into game design? I find creating stories, monsters, characters, levels, maps, etc infinitely more interesting than utilities underground.

likeuplifting

Which would you rather? Internal at MBB or client-facing at Big 4/ACN?

like

Is 30k bump in pay worth the move from a large bank to a series D start up?

like

Find your why, your why will give you purpose? This is part of your self discovery journey.

Great for business development, career development, this is something I learned in business school (Why statement is a powerful tool) by Simon Sinek

Post Photo
like

Hello sharks,

Currently I have 4 years of experience in SAP CPI and Success Factors system.

I'm confused on what to learn next to progress my career. I'm fairly good at coding and so would like to work in modules which involves technical aspects.

Please advice what can i do to improve my knowledge and also compensation

like

I am a graduating senior with a CS degree about to start my job in IT (low code, mostly using data tools) at a biotech company. My goal is to be a solutions architect within the next few years. Besides sol. architect cert and other AWS certifications, what can I do to put myself on the path to becoming a Solutions Architect ASAP?

like

MBB folks, I’m a Product Manager (non-tech company) and interested in working at MBB.

Which level/role does MBB can offer me ?

like

Hi,I hv got a job in IAM project as a BA.Any feedbacks on the domain? How can I advance in my career and how can I go abroad

Pwc AC
I am an Software Engineer Analyst in my current organization yoe 2.8 years, and is offered an Associate L2 position in big4.
Is it correct position to go with according to my yoe or I should apply for senior associate?? Please suggest.

More Posts

What bump you got from the big resignation? Is you WLB better or worse? From where did you leave?

like

Anyone who’s moved from consulting to VC, what are some of the ways you’ve made your application stand out? How much of securing the role was down to networking?

like

Which agency does Jack Daniels TV?

like

Hello!

I'm about to start a new job with my main account being a big beer brand.
I want to study and prepare as much as I can before it starts, and influence myself as much stuff as possible... Both from advertising and outside of it.

Can you please share your tips and recommendations?
Specially Art Direction focused - I really want to arrive and be prepared to perform to the best level possible.

Thank you!!

like

I am new in oracle . Just wanted to know is there any yearly hikes in oracle idc and are hikes project dependent and manager dependent here?

like

Oracle India Hi Fishes,

Does anyone can suggest me what to do? I recently joined oracle as a staff Consultant supposed to work as a Java developer but working on their utility framework. I don't have any interest in this. I want to work on Java with springboot development projects.Oracle India

like

What are the promotion cycle and salary review cycle months?

like

Delta experts: Upgrade question. Just made Platinum and have been #1 on upgrade list since check-in at 6am. But open First seats went from 5 to 0 during the day. What's going on here?

Looking for book recommendations; any favorites? Interested in both fiction and educational/self-improvement (for example, investment / finance books, time management, etc). I feel my vocab is...

like

Best consulting firms for work-life balance? I know consulting is chaotic in nature, but just curious to see which ones are the best in dealing with this?

like

Hi folks,
I am working as a Business Analyst with 3.5 YOE and in total 4.9 YOE. I am getting 6.7CTC which felt totally low. If I switch then how much I can expect as a market standard currently. Thanks

like

My employer is going on a hiring blitz and is offering new hires of the same position a higher salary than I currently have, is this normal or should I demand a raise?

likesmart

Suggestions on how to improve at work? I feel like everyone knows more than me and feeling like I’ve been left behind. Where did all of this knowledge come from??

like

Just signed the outside employment form in KPMG onboarding system. I actually wanted to start dabbling in creative writing as a potentially monetizable hobby, but I'm guessing this may pose issues.

Definitely interested in the "exception from this policy may be requested if provision of non-professional services doesn't interfere with one's duties of causes conflict of interest" clause, though. Has anyone been able to get one of those before?

likesmart

“What do you guys see...a mouse or a blue screen”

12b6 always be tellin’ it like it is

Post Photo
likefunny
like

Dell vs SAP labs which is better in terms of work?

like

can we change office within the same city? in my offer letter it is mentioned rga but i want the nearest office.

Additional Posts in Supply Chain Consultants

Is CSCP worth it? 2 years out of school and know i want to be/stay in the supply chain field but torn between prioritizing that or GMAT right now. Feels like id be way more motivated in studying for this over GMAT rn too

like

Hi
I’m going to receive an offer from O9 as senior consultant, how is WLB, someone in the same role has some insights? The job will be based in Europe. Actually I’m working for a software boutique in supply chain and I’m looking fo an enhance in my career.
Thank you in advance for any advice

like

Hi all, has anyone in supply chain taken one of the certification exams? (CPSM, CPSD, CSCP)
Does it help in any way besides refreshing contents about supply chain? I was thinking might be a good way to strengthen my resume (most of my career in investment analysis) but not really sure if it really brings that much value. Any insights appreciated. #supplychain #cpsm #cpsd #cscp #education #certifications

like

Where are the main hubs for supply chain consulting in the US? Where is your firms largest SC team located? Or are most SC consultants spread out all over the country to serve local clients (similar to Europe)? I have been hinted by a partner for an opportunity to relocate and I am looking for tips regarding location.

like

Technology (ERP) consultant looking to make the switch to a supply chain transformation/tech strategy role. Any suggestions on how to make that transition? I have a CSCP credential and am starting an MS in supply chain soon.

like

Let’s get their together.

Post Photo
like

Anyone who joined from industry and went back to it? Is so, were you able to jump levels when you returned back and what factors helped you ?
Thanks !

Supply chain strategy work (design, transformation) versus implementation? What firms have the strongest practices for each?

likehelpful

Anyone has good resources on how companies set-up their logistic network in Africa? I found an article on Coca Cola but I am rather looking for heavy machinery companies

Network design exit opps? I love working on network design and optimisation project but I am a bit reluctant to specialise there because I am not sure what kind of exit opps exist.

like

Anybody did the apics certification in logistics ? I have the choose between the cslp and cscp but not sure which one I should be doing

any startups worth looking at? I think I'm done with consulting and would love to go to a SC startup that's using analytics and tech

like

Anyone hiring in planning process or transformation practices? Not really happy with my boutique. Experience would likely translate to experienced M level at bigger firms. Have experience leading process design projects, IBP and Anaplan implementation projects. Getting more involved w/ o9 too but no project lead experience

like

I’m currently in change management and have no experience in supply chain but I’m interested in getting into it. Realistic to transition in? Would CSCP be my best shot?

like

Anyone with connections to potential in-house scm opportunities in the NYC area?

At this point in my life, consulting is really burning me out, would love to be in house where I can learn and grow at a pace that is more sustainable.

like

Thoughts on GEP?

like

Can anyone refer to tier 1 or tier 2 consulting firm? I have 6 years experience is supply chain.

Thanks

like

Could anyone recommend a set of indices that are publicly available and is a good predictor for consumer spend in home renovations ?

like

Any tips when preparing for CSCP?

like

Cross post—- 🐠 need your help. Has anyone deployed Oracle iProcure or P2P can you share your experiences and what functionality the platform is missing compared to Ariba and Coupa. Thx so much

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal