Transitioning from Criminal to Civil

I’m at a crossroads in my legal career and could really use some guidance from those with experience in civil litigation. Here's my situation:

I've spent the last six years as a criminal attorney, with trial experience as both a prosecutor and a public defender, across two states. I’ve also had a brief stint in private defense work. However, I'm growing increasingly disillusioned with the day-to-day life…[Continued below]…>

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

With a growing family (three kids, the oldest not even 7), I’m now looking to transition into civil law for better work-life balance and compensation and I’ve interviewed with handful, few offers on the table but two offer on particular: stand out most:

1. **Plaintiff Personal Injury Firm**
- **Position:** Litigation Department
- **Offer:** $110,000 annual salary, standard benefits, *bonuses* paid out in the fourth quarter.
- **Pros:** Salary, potential for bonuses, and the opportunity to leverage my trial experience. Not necessarily sure what an associates job entails (day-to-day), partner said he does about 2-3 trials a year.

2. **Civil Defense Firm**
- **Position:** Civil defense work with a focus on hospitals, insurance companies, construction law, and some commercial litigation.
- **Offer:** $1850 billable hours, with bonuses tied to hours worked above the billables.
- **Pros:** Partners seem down to earth, the work involves more writing, motions, and depositions, which might mean fewer trials.

Both firms seem like good fits culturally, and the partners are approachable. My main dilemma is ensuring a smooth transition from criminal to civil while also considering long-term quality of life. While I have strong trial skills, I’m not looking to continue spending my entire career in court.

For those who’ve made a similar switch or are familiar with the civil side, particularly in personal injury or defense, which role might offer a more seamless transition? I’m looking for insights on day-to-day responsibilities, work-life balance, and long-term career/financial growth.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

like

Insurance defense work is a thankless job. The ceiling is much higher at a PI firm but finding a firm that can afford to be selective with their cases is key. If they’re taking anything that comes through the door, I’d go the defense route for the experience while looking for a third option.

like

100% plaintiff side.

like

PI, save yourself.

like

It sounds like you need to find a smaller PI firm that is particular about the cases they accept and are willing to file suit when they get low offers. I loved working at this type of firm. At a minimum, make sure you’re getting a salary, plus a percentage of the fee on cases you’re bringing in. Ideally you want a percentage of every case you work, but smaller firms may not offer this arrangement. The pay may be a little lower in this setting, but you’ll get mentorship, hands-on experience, and flexibility.

like

I was prosecutor for 10 years (kids 1, 2, & 3) then opened my own shop and practiced civil (with a tiny bit of criminal defense) for 7 years (and welcomed child #4). COVID and employees burned me out and I quit law.

Based on those experiences, I say 100% urge you to go Plaintiff PI. I did insurance defense once — I hated it. My friends doing it hated it too. Depositions are your trials. And you may find better resolutions for clients if you take PI cases to trial b/c opposing counsel may not have your trial skills. Just make certain you
1. watch a civil trial to see the differences in how the judge conducts themselves and
2. Make it part of your contract that a senior counsel will sit as second chair to help for your first civil trial.

You got this. Enjoy your professional evolution ~

plaintiff work. learn the business, the practice, save money, and open up your own shop at some point.

Plaintiffs side for sure — not having to worry about billable hours is amazing. And cases rarely go to trial; 2-3 a year may be an exaggeration.

Related Posts

Hi, please confirm what will be the work of Wealth Manager Band 1 and how much is this profile involved into core sales .. or is it a customer service profile? I am very new to banking sector so will they provide training after joining or not?

Rakuten / Rakuten India OR Morgan Stanley
which has more future scope ?

like

People talk about doing industry research as part of free Friday afternoons or other downtime, but I'm not sure where to even start. I'm a Project Manager.

like

I know this question is somewhat vague and broad but I’ll soon be joining a Banking & Finance team (in BigLaw) as a junior associate. I’d be grateful for any tips on how to thrive in this role. What characteristics make a good junior transactional lawyer?

like

What technical skill sets should I learn to go OE at over $100k for each? Follow up: how do I learn it and how long will it take?

like

Looking to pivot into healthcare consulting. I come from a MHA background with a two year Administrative Fellowship following it. Any experience breaking into one of the top consulting firms with this type of background?

I’ll be promoted next year to senior but I’m in a niche role where I don’t see myself long term. Should I make a job switch now or should I wait to get promoted to senior? I currently have 1.5 years of experience.

like

About to start my first PM job! Any tips to be prepared and ramp up quickly? Books to read, courses to take, etc.. any tips are appreciated! Currently in ops consulting. No tech background.

like

First post, not sure if this is the best bowl to use but here goes. I’m wondering if anyone can share a bit about their experience working at MongoDB. I have seen they are hiring for many roles and am curious to hear about their experience. In particular, I would like to hear about software engineer roles. Currently I work on database engine C++ code and have seen some roles that indicate continuing down this stream would be possible with my skillset.

like

I had recently attended the interview at IQVIA for sql developer position, but when I received the offer letter the designation mentioned there is "Software engineer- technical operations 130'.

Just wanted to know if this is some kind of a production support role.

Can anyone please help me understand this?

TIA !

like

Anyone from Amazon or Google with a non-tech background? Looking to learn for post MBA opportunities in Toronto.

like

YOE : 7.8 i have an offer from IBM and HCL.
IBM : 18 fixed + 1 JB HCL : 21 ( 18 fixed + 1lakh approx (monthly variable) + 2 lakh Annual variable ) . Now i have a discussion pending with Robert Bosch , What should i quote ! Which will be better for job security and work life and overall career growth .

like

Is principal consultant equivalent to senior manager in pwc? @pwc

like

Hello, I am looking to make a career change that starts at a minimum 75K salary. The economy is tough right now and I can no longer afford to stay in my current role. I have a bachelors degree in Sociology with experience in managed care, utilization management, & clinical admin.. Does anyone have any suggestions for a possible higher paying career that I would be qualified for based on my background?

Hi, I'm getting lot of interview calls for SAP SD Consultant but they want someone experienced 2 to 3 years of experience, 1 or 2 implementation done, support or rollout etc, Relevant experience of sap is zero I have, for BFSI industry is 3+ years I've, so what would u suggest??I'm not getting any work, 5 months gap already now in doing SAP course, hana certifications etc,any fresher in SAP, how u made it in SAP? I'll start working anywhere now, in SAP I'm not getting anything, tired or have i

like

Looking for advice: would you stay in partner pipeline at Big 4 or move to one of the MBBs as a principal? I am hearing that with Big 4 getting into strategy more, MBBs will be obsolete soon thoughts?

likefunny

Is Wall Street prep worth it to help break into IB?

like

I want to learn SQL with free certificate. Any one can suggest where ca in find it free. You response can change my life

like

Are online executive leadership programs helpful in getting a higher level role or getting noticed for Director and above jobs? Or does it not matter if you have a decent amount of experience? 10+ years?

More Posts

after receiving the portal link to accept the offer letter, what is the deadline to I accept it?

like

What is the notice period in Cognizant. I joined on JAN 2021 they didn't mentioned on the order letter as well Cognizant

like

Got an offer from syneo health gurgaon of 12 LPA for 2.5 yoe i don't know much about the slabs! If anyone can help with that??
And also the working environment of this CRO...

like

Can anyone please share the experience to allocate the project after joining. Experience in Java backend. Is there any tips to allocate project before joining or after joining. Thank you. @

like

Can some one refer me for finance transformation role at Deloitte?

like

Is there anybody out there 👀🗣

Need advice: do you tell your manager that you’re unhappy or do you just leave?

I’m being taken advantage of with being thrown so much work and really don’t see my salary increasing to be in line with my coworkers doing similar work. I’m a consistent high performer - management reviews tell me that much.

My coworker did mention to the manager that they’re not being paid well for the work they do, and our manager took it personally and told them they’re ungrateful 🥲

likehelpful

Hi,

I got an offer from Simieo solutions. What will be my in hand salary after deductions?

Also how about work life balance with Simieo.
Pls share your experience. @

Post Photo
like

Want to get your opinions on the best small agencies in LA in terms of work produced (media and creative)

like

Hi Fishes,

I Received Eclerx offer for Morgan Stanley client for Mainframe technology, Can someone suggest is it good decision to join eclerx? What is bench policy ? Are they having mainframe projects?

like

What is system integration senior specialist designation in NTT data?
Is it lead or like senior software Engineer?
I have filled the online application form and how long does it take for offer letter?

Hi fishes, How Risk Mitigation team is in Citi?? I will be working on Global CRM financial application. How is the work here? Is there WLB ?

like

Would anyone consider their senior colleagues to be their genuine friends?

like

FRM is has narrow focus, demands depth, quick to complete

like

Do you think people working in the pharma industry will gain more trust, respect, or positive vibes in 2021 after vaccines are widely distributed? Right now it’s the industry with one of the lowest perception scores

likefunny

The son of the owner where I work has been coming to work with a gun showing it off to people. He got into an arguement, put his hands on another employee and threatened to put a 9 bullet in his head. I suspended him and opened an investigation. The owner is mad and feels my case is biased and suspended me. He admitted guild and its not about what happened but why! I need to protect the business & secure the victim to lessen the chance of him reporting this to EEOC or DHL. He's being a dad

like

Has anyone transitioned from PA to a PhD in Accounting? What is the PhD like? And how did you know it was the right decision/time?

like

Would anyone think it’s weird if someone has a squat rack in their bedroom or office? The past couple days I have been thinking about getting one of those models that folds up against the wall so I can save time commuting to the gym, dealing with crowds, save money in the long run, etc., but I live in apartment so I don’t have a garage to put it in.

like

How does one decide to take risks and apply for news job when the state of the economy and the world is ever changing. We know salaries are going up, but employers struggle doling out the cash. Is it better to stick where you are or jump into something new?

like

Which branch of the military is the best?

like

Additional Posts in Personal Injury Lawyers

Thoughts on purchasing leads?

like

I give my cell phone to all clients routinely. However, there are always 1 to 2 clients who abuse this and it seems as soon as their cases are over I find a new one and it is making me rethink. I hate to do this because 98% do not abuse it and I like being connected to my people. Thoughts??

like

4th year at a mid size PI firm. Got pulled from litigating MVAs to help this solo we hired start a med Mal/nursing home practice. 1 year in and it looks like I’m two steps backwards in terms of getting paid because we’re a year or more out from a lot of the fees hitting. I respect the solo a lot, he’s a mentor, but I’ve got kids and I gotta get paid. Trying not to burn bridges, but I can’t wait years to get cut in. Advice?

like

What are good margins for PI associate attorneys; i.e., what should they make for the firm compared to what the firm would/ should pay them?

like

As a former Corporate Counsel, now mostly solo practitioner in Federal Court specialty practice is a mixture of Bankruptcy, Immigration, Business Transactions and Employment law.
My question is could I affiliate "of counsel" on part of my practice like say only Employment Law?

like

For Plaintiff's attorneys, how big is your caseload? What kind of cases are the majority of them and are they in suit? I am currently handling 150+ mostly MVAs and premise liability cases, just about all in suit, (on top of about 10 DUIs and other small traffic matters) and I feel like I'm drowning and looking to jump ship. What is normal/to be expected? In NYC area if that matters

like

What metrics do you think are most important to measure for success of a Plaintiff’s firm? Obviously revenue, but what else is at the top of the list for you?

like

What's your preference for plaintiff's side? Steady pay at approximately $120k with no bonuses, or a base salary of $70k plus a cut of what you close over a minimum threashold? Midwest-ish market. In both situations, you get a cut of what you bring in.

like

Plaintiffs PI attorneys, how many cases on average are you assigned to at any given time?

like

What kind of split does your firm give you for bringing in cases? Trying to negotiate with my firm for an increase. Currently, I get 15% plus my base salary.

like

Hello. Does anybody have a CA loss of consortium demand they are willing to share.

like

Hello all, I'm a very green attorney, never tried a single case or even was second or third chair, but managed to land a litigation associate position at a Plaintiff's firm. Does anyone remember their first trial? How did you feel and how did it turn out by comparison? Anything you wish you did differently?
I know in THEORY what the process of trials are but thanks to COVID I haven't been able to observe them in real life so I'm very nervous for the day I finally enter a courtroom.

like

I want to start my own PI firm. What should I know? What should I do? What should I read? Thanks!

like

Definitely going to be a noobie question!

My client's medical provider asked for his PIP ledger: how do I get that? Just send a LOR to the carrier and ask?

like

Has anyone ever dealt with Geico UM case where they insist that a release needs to be signed? Geico extended our client’s policy limits but wants him to sign a release. We offered to sign an acknowledgment of receipt of funds but Geico said without a release signed, they will not issue payment.

like

What does compensation look like for a second year associate at a personal injury law firm? Please comment if you practice in Los Angeles.

like

Plaintiff’s PI/Med-mal attorney, thanks to a good relationship with a former client who is in HR at a major health system I have an interview for an in-house associate’s position. Any advice on how I can market my skillset so I don’t blow this?

like

What’s a good LA or NY business litigation firm and salary to expect? I’m a 2yr with quite frankly a lot of experience across civ rights, PI, excessive force, wrongful death, employment defense, K dispute, corp. structure dispute, professional licensure. Write every kind of brief, appeals, argue motions, take depos. Am the only associate working directly under partner on all cases. In house or M&A/Real Estate Transactional are likely the end goal but want to get the litigation out of me first.

funny

What do you guys send as gifts to referral sources for attorneys and/or former client referral sources?

*Assume in my jurisdiction there are no ethical issues associated with this

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal