Looking for advice: would you stay in partner pipeline at Big 4 or move to one of the MBBs as a principal? I am hearing that with Big 4 getting into strategy more, MBBs will be obsolete soon thoughts?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

1) the idea that because Big 4s are doing strategy, MBBs will be obsolete soon is laughable. And I say that as an MBB alum that came to Big 4 to do strategy.

2) being a lateral principal/AP at MBB is tough. Not impossible at all of course, but tough. You’re competing to make equity partner with a bunch of people who are already embedded in teams/pyramids. You have to work pretty hard and have good luck to find the right seat to get promoted — basically you need to luck your way into a commercially successful team that doesn’t have a principal for a reason that isn’t “this team isn’t a viable path for promotion”. And as a lateral it’s hard to know the full story. You don’t have the institutional knowledge someone who grew up at the firm does.

3) on the other hand, making partner at Big 4 can be tough as well. Especially in these times, it can be easy for firms to tell you “next year” more times than you’re willing to wait.

So the way I’d look at it is: if you want to be a partner at a consulting firm, don’t take either of the paths you mentioned — look for a direct admit partner opportunity at another big 4. If you think you want to do something else eventually, go to MBB and get the brand on your resume.

likehelpfulfunny

The suspense is killing me

like

MBB but only if you have time bandwidth and a lot of physical stamina and networking ability.

like

First time hearing that MBBs will get disrupted by Big 4 consulting. If anything it’s the other way around - MBBs doing more implementation work eating into Big 4

like

Clearly you all have yet to read Clay Christensen ... not that it’s gospel, but it does support the thesis of the original question.

If anything, I think the small boutique shops are more of a threat to MBB than the B4. I can't even begin to count the number of clients that I have seen move their strategy work from MBB to smaller shops. Don't know if it's just a matter of pricing or clients developing a preference for smaller niche providers or unique expertise or simply MBB fatigue but from my vantage point its definitely been a noticeable trend.

Perhaps consider partnership at a tier 2 or boutique shop. You may have an ability to stand out and build a book of business that makes an impact on the company vs. just being partner #978 at a large firm.

like

I wonder how much of this is due to the increasingly technical nature of businesses. There are plenty of people who understand general business strategy, but to be successful requires more specialist knowledge than before.

But I don't think this means boutiques will disrupt big firms. Big firms will just need to get better at being a house of specialists vs an army of generalists.

likefunny

Been hearing that for a while - don’t see any signs yet so you’re hearing wrong. Also assume you meant as a Partner at MBB - Principals (at some firms like OW) is a level below Partner

like

If someone isn’t yet an equity partner at Big 4, the chances that they can get a direct admin equity partner seat at MBB are pretty slim. Almost everyone goes down a level when they move that direction.

likehelpful

It's really more of a convergence than either group disrupting the other.

"MBB" is mostly only a thing for consultants. I can't tell you the number of times I've hear Bain uttered in the same sentence as B4 when listening to clients choose a consultancy.

I've heard things like, "CEO is ex-McKinsey, so this will be tough," but other than that, many clients don't see a big difference.

likehelpful

My old 'boss' (Director Level at KPMG for 10 years) went to Bain as Principal.

The quality difference will always be there. I think MbB business is still safe, but Big 4 business might get disrupted due to automation.

How does automation disrupt B4 consulting?

Things have to be integrated to be automated. How close are we to automating integration?

We are a VERY long way away from automating market entry decisions.

Not sure what you think B4 consulting firms do, but it's a lot of things that are very hard to automate.

If you have a good thing why move? There’s your answer.

At the end of the career, does the compensations tend to become equal? Since MBB equity partners don’t earn pension but B4 partners do?

Depends on how high you go in either situation. I know bankrupt ex-PMDs from both back stories (or just living with a lot less luxury than they had expected). I think the NPV is probably about the same. B4 are, however, much larger consultancies than MBB, in general, so there are more Ps to be made.

Related Posts

How does health insurance at MBB & T2 strategy consulting firms compare to Tricare Reserve Select for a family? I’m 99% getting out of the Reserve within the next year and, assuming things go well with recruiting, would switch to the firm insurance as my primary once I start. Just want to confirm that there’s no reason for me to stay

currently debating if i should work on the hill or accept an IB role. i feel like working on the hill is invaluable experience that could get me into IB but maybe i’m wrong? Which opportunity gives me best resume experience?

like

If you could work at an agency for the rest of your career, would you do it? Or do you see being a professional creative as a means to another career altogether?

like

Boston Consulting Group , is GAMMA Solution Track a good role ? I got Offer Solution Lead , but not sure about that track. I have not been able to find anything and it seems pretty new// PLEASE HELP! I dont want to make the wrong decision...

@Boston Consulting Group

like

How many years did it take you to get promoted to senior software engineer?

like

1. What are some recommended readings to get smart for the Investment banking role? 2. Would you recommend getting experience before going to MBA? Do banks offer offcycle internships 4 nonstudents?

like

Anyone have any luck getting an interview at another Big 4 in advisory by directly applying to their website?

like

How big does an agency have to be to justify a CCO title?

like

Looking for some advice on how to branch off into a job in tech. I’m a Mechanical engineer interested in working in a big tech company. I have some programming experience but excel mostly in mechanical and product design as well as 3D CAD. Was wondering if any other mechanical engineers have managed to make the shift from a traditional mech job to a tech job and if you could give me advice on the best path that worked for you. Thanks!

like

Hello everyone,

Need your help to choose which is a better path to switch from Non IT to Core domain.
Confused on what to learn software testing or AWs devops or front end development etc.

Thanks in advance for your suggestions.

like

Would switching from S& to LEK boost, hurt, or not change exit ops to PE/ PE ops/Corp dev & strat roles? Also looking at benefits of not having independence and utilization requirements. Thanks!

like

Hey guys,

Currently in Saas sales for MDM and AV, but I'm getting tired of the sales side and constant budget chase. Probably also because we get few leads and I have to do a lot of building pipeline from scratch. I'm thinking about taking some online courses to try to move over to cyber security, what would be the easiest step that way career wise- preferably also away fro sales?

like

Is it the smart move to take a pay cut and clerk for a judge?

Little context: I was an ED student, full time paralegal/clerk throughout my law school experience, and a single mother. I did not take advantage of the law school extracurriculars and missed out on clerk application deadlines my final year (2020). Would it benefit me to take a pay cut as a transactional clerk by about $20k to work as a clerk for a year then re-enter firm life? I’m transactional and enjoy that line of work.

like

What is the job grade for sr specialist in nokia

like

Any one ever used a career counselor service before? If so what was your experience with them? Did you find it beneficial to your own career transition? And which companies would you recommend? Or if you hated it or think it was a waste of time I'd like to hear that too and why🙂.

Just looking for some tips and advice, any help is appreciated 🙂.

like

Hi, Are there people here who have switched from being a doctor or dentist and went on and got an International healthcare management MBA (or just a standard MBA) and also have experiences from surgery/clinical side, pharmaceuticals, and bit of consulting? If yes, how was your transition? What were your starting roles and salaries? Thank you :)

like

WNS Global Services Can anyone please help me understand the organization hierarchy and if possible minimum years of experience & salary brackets associated with each level? SalaryBox WNS Global Services

Facebook (Meta) Product Management (IC5) or Google Cloud Marketing S&O/ Annual Planning (L6) role if I want to eventually be working on Product Strategy for consumer tech?
Heard it hard to pivot from Google S&O to Product Strategy even with 20% projects internally…

Facebook (Meta) | Google

like

I'm a PhD student (graduating next year) looking to pursue consulting (ideally at MBB or Big 4). I would love to learn about full-time opportunities in New York starting 2023

So I work as an assistant manager at a restaurant for the past 9 months. I've worked in restaurants for the past 6 years science I was 16. Now I'm 22. I went to a trade school for media and film. I got a dream opportunity to work in the field making about the same or 10% more. I told myself the only reason I'd leave this company is for this type of job. Should I take the chance at this job and leave the restaurant that is on the rise and growing?

like

More Posts

Has anyone made a move from audit to consulting as a senior and could you speak a bit about the process??

like

Let’s share with each other how we are making or planning on making that income .
It is a strange time we live in but it’s time to hustle up .

like

How do I cancel my New York Sports Club membership?

likefunny

Can anyone please let me know what would be in-hand salary for 13.7LPA with old regime and investment declaration?

like

Hiring for a Senior Analyst position, and looking for someone who likes to use data to inform UX. We have someone to pull and organize data, need someone who can put that data into actionable website optimization recommendations. You will see your work in action for a large, global brand. DM me with any interest.

like

Anyone successfully pivot to education? Any advice is appreciated. I applied for Director of Student Services role that seems really interesting.

like

Hi all! Can anyone share recordings of successful McK PEI stories?

likefunny

Any IICS certified professional here ?

Hello. Everyone.

Due to family and other personal reasons. I am actively looking forward to join a Corporate to perform all such activities and roles as it is required from a Company Secretary. I have 5 yrs Post Qualification Experience.

This is an urgent requirement and request my readers to connect me with someone in known.

Here is my resume attached.

Thanks.
Nikhil Arora

like

Hey - Book club post again incase anybody didn’t see who happens to be interested. DM me and I can add you to our group chat!! Hoping to get together this week 📚

like

Any good yoga studios in Denver/Boulder for beginners?

What does everyone think of proposition 122 on this year's ballot? Do you think it'll pass?

like

Joining a group that specializes in incident response. Any recommendations on things I can do this summer to prepare on fundamentals/certs?

like

What are the easiest practices within S&C to go from A to C? Or does this not really matter? Anywhere I can objectively see the performance of each practice?

like

Are Uber/Lyft drivers reluctant to drive from DC (Logan) to BWI?

1) Hypothetically if you were looking to sabotage a colleague, can you code an excel document to throw off their numbers or calculations, (if you send them that document and they download it for use)?

like

Where is VMware Pune office located? Showing different address on Google and on website.

Also please suggest some locality to search for flats/pg near by.

Hi guys, what's the standard salary range for a digital strategist?

like
like

Additional Posts in Partner One

At what point you start coming on radar if you have been on beach for significant amount of time? Like Since thanksgiving . Is there a schedule to let go?

like

Is it true new partners at PwC are making 550-600k? Are there big differences in Partner Comp between Big Four?

like

Has anyone used Gideon Strategic Partner for investing? What was your experience?

like

Tips to build my brand and network as a junior practitioner navigates their career to the next level at the firm?

like

Hey PPMDs: do you prefer talkers or walkers? I see way too many talkers with no substance

like

Accenture MDs - what’s the expected L4 bonus structure look like for a TC L4?
I am SM4 should know in a month if I made L4 - getting close to getting an offer from a tier 2 strat firm .....contd...

like

Going through personally traumatic phase where the partner has some personal axe to grind. Client, others are happy but the partner is just out to humiliate me.

likehelpful

If an employee files a complaint about workplace behavior, do you treat them differently? I'm faced with reporting an SM for bullying and finding it near imposible to believe that it won't (cont'd)

Do Big 4 partners need to maintain any level of independence in retirement?

like

How is a Partner’s sales bonus at your firm calculated? Also, what if multiple Partners have connections at the same client when a sale is made? How is the bonus fairly distributed?

like

Partners, what are signs/examples that a project’s leadership is prioritizing the clients needs over the team beyond the normal ‘nature of client service’? Is a convo is worth it?

like

Would you say being a partner is more demanding than being an industry exec?

Hey Partners! I accepted a position at another firm and was bumped from manager to Senior consultant level. Could you give me some advice on 3 key things I can focus on to help me re-advance quickly?

like

IBM New partners - Both new joiner Partners(within last 2 years) as well as promoted in the last 2 years. Can you share your signings ,base/yr and RSU’s. If recently promoted from within , how has the % increase?

likefunny

Do partners know each other’s compensation? I see partners selling engagements for vastly different numbers b/w shorter ‘interesting’ strategy work and longer ‘boring’ transformations. Thoughts?

like

I've always wondered this ... How do PPMD's find new opportunities.. like is it mostly through networking / grapevine.. or something more structured?

like

What is base pay range for L5 at Accenture?

like

What has been more beneficial to your career and why: specializing in a service offering or an industry?

like

Just got promoted, still not satisfied with the comps - will it be received poorly if I ask for my compensation to be readjusted based on competing offers ? I have 3 that are at least 30% higher...CNT

likehelpful

Partner is pissed at me & judging everything because we disagreed on a deliverable. I was at fault at not giving what was needed even though we disagreed. I respect them, how to fix the relationship?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal