Weighing two offers (one Big 4, one Industry). Wondering what others would do in the same position.
Role 1: SC at Deloitte: $150 base, 17% annual bonus, $20k signing bonus
Role 2: Manager at Large Tech Firm that went public last year. $130k base + 60k equity that vests after Y1 + refreshes additional 60k (+annual merit increase) starting Y2.
Total Comp is much better at Role 2 starting Y2, but the internal team in Role 2 seems very stressed. Anyone been in a similar position?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Deloitte has a way of putting their best spin during the recruiting process and then you are thrown to the wolves when you actually start. And if you ever slip up, well that’s on you. I would go Role #2 every day of the week.

Source: someone who has led many recruiting efforts at Deloitte.

like

Role 2. Tons of people at Deloitte are pretty stressed, but we’re just very good at hiding it. SC is a tough job and it only gets harder and more stressful- it’s not unusual to hear horror stories about SM level work, and because of the up or out culture you really do need to keep rising.

This is all for traditional model, specialist track may be different

likesmarthelpful

In practice, I dont see the difference betwen traditional and specialist tracks...I see Specialist Leaders driving sales and managing teams/ projects and vice versa with Senior Managers, the only upside for SMs is that they have a chance to make Partner and get some equity, but then I hear MDs are not badly compensated either so...

Recent IconRecent

That 17% bonus number is the top end of the possible range. I would probably factor a ~10% bonus into your calculations.

Also, are you sure that Role 2 is more stressed? Weekly hours at Deloitte can vary from 35-60+ depending on the project so it can end up being very stressful

likehelpful

In Deloitte, Yes those are.

like

I went with Role 2. It was surprising to see the comments so one-sided! Thanks nerds

likefunny

How stressed at #2 place? Worse than Deloitte?

likefunny

I know right!? Just seemed noticeable during interviews that the team was frazzled. I could be reading too much into it

Wow congrats on the offers OP. Didn’t know Deloitte SC went that high. Mind me asking how many YoE?

like

7 years total! My career path is a little weird. 5 years in industry straight out of college. Then last 2 years Consulting in Bay Area

likehelpful

#2. Equity is a god damned dream....

You will be very stressed and have very little free time at a big 4... take it from someone whose looking for an out... might just be a bad time at #2. I can guarantee a bad time at #1

like

Pick Number 2 ma lord!

likefunny

Go for Role 2, you can always exit and return to a Big4, even at a higher position, the other way around me is much more difficult

like

I would go with Role 2, also. Merit increases at Deloitte will be smaller, the stress is definitely there on some engagements, and rarely will you ever receive a max bonus.

like

17 years consulting and moved to industry, never done a timesheet since and don’t miss it for a second. Go for #2 and don’t believe the bonus BS in consulting. It will happen once in 4 years while the others you take “one for the team”

like

Agree wholeheartedly

Dont join Deloitte. You will regret after joining. These bonus numbers are just numbers on the paper. Actual numbers will be way low

like

Option #2. It’s a no brainer.

like

Role 2, no question

like

Role 2. You been in consulting, try something else.

like

17% annual bonus is top end. It’d be lower most years (I think) and could be 0 in a bad year (Covid)

I would 100% go tech and easier to bounce around once you’re in

like

Voting #2 as well. See where that company can take you. You can always go back to consulting if it doesn’t workout. Just keep those technical skills sharp.

Congrats!! 🎉🎈

like

Second role. I like the equity, investments generally go up.

like

Role 2

like

Role 2 for sure. The stress level and wlb in Deloitte is awful. Period!!!

like

Related Posts

Any AWS managers around? how's the compensation in large cities ?

I got notice everything at the new firm is good to go. Now to give notice. I’m dreading it. I really really like my boss but this opportunity is too good to pass up. How do you even start? I’ve been in this role 8 years. How to give notice?? Yikes! I’m giving about 2 1/2 weeks notice. 10/17 start date. Any help is appreciated!!!

like

What salary I can expect from advance auto parts and microfocus. Security Engineer, yoe 6

Hi Sharks,

Please let me know what is the current situation in cognizant related to the revise offer letter?

Already holding an offer from CTS and I am expecting one more offer from another organization, so CTS will match that offer or not?

CTS Offer :- 17 LPA
Offer from another organization :- 23 LPA

Please give your inputs.

like
like

Currently 1 YOE tech consulting at Deloitte looking to make a hop to more strategy type roles and came across the strategy analyst development program- 1. is this only for fresh undergrads from specific schools or would I be able to apply? 2. What’s the compensation at this level? (worried I might have to take a pay cut). Also would appreciate any remarks regarding the program in general. Thanks!

like

Looking for better and competitive compensation according to the industry standard in delhi NCR region either in core IT industry or IT Consulting.

Current CTC - 250000
Expected CTC - 400000

Suggest me please.

like

On a project (A) with a role that's a bad fit. Have been approached by a partner on another project (B) who wants me staffed on his engagement by April. How do I transition over from A to B knowing ..

like

I accepted an offer from Cognizant for a consultant position a little less than a month ago. My joining date is 5th September and I would need visa sponsorship. I have completed my pre joining formalities and background verification. The thing is I haven’t heard from HR in a while and no update as yet on visa sponsorship process. Should I be worried?

like

Bajaj finance is extending an offer to me for Pune location of 16 LPA fixed. My current fixed is 11 LPA. Is this offer good enough ?
Tech stack: Machine learning, Python, R, PowerBI, Basic SQL.
YoE - 3 years

Can someone suggest if fixed pay is fair or low or high according to current standards. If it's low, how high should I quote to HR

I just applied for a Delta flight attendant role and my page glitched right in the middle of my application and now it says I’ve applied even though I didn’t finish answering questions. Has anyone else had this happen? So scared it has completely ruined my chances.

like

Currently at Deloitte at looking to apply to Amazon. Know anyone who is ex-big 4 who would be open to giving advice on application&interviews?

like

Help me with the inhand salary.

Post Photo
like

What is the expected date for Promotion news in GDS Knowledge?

like

SL - TAX
YOE - 4
Joined q4 2021
Rank - 44
Rating : 5
Vpb - 34.5 %

like

Anyone have a couple of great recruiter that you could recommend for a SAAS sales position in Houston Texas?

like

Hi Fishes,

Can anyone tell what is the variable component percentage for D1/Senior Manager band in Capgemini? And also do Capgemini provide variable pay quarterly Or yearly once?
Please guide.

like

7.9 years of exp..
Barclays has offered 22 lpa, for BA4 role...Is this a fair offer.?...looking forward to hear your suggestions...
Thaks in advance

like

What's the typical performance bonus for new experienced hire? Joined in Feb. I'm MBA S&O SC2 if it helps.

like

More Posts

Which Kimpton do I choose in Portland?

like

Heyy there,

Some advice please on which is a better option

American Express
JP Morgan

Both are offering around same fixed salary.

Field - Java + Microservices
YOE - 8

like

Does EY supports higher education in any manner like loan,time-off without resigning..

like

Hey friends, I've been in sales for over ten years in retail/ hospitality.

I'm focusing my efforts to make a switch into tech sales and id like to work for AWS.

I completed a tech sales bootcamp and have purchased a couple books on sales methodology, more so enhancing sales + active listening skills.

If anybody would be willing to chat! I'd love more insight on roles Within AWS tech sales.

Care for a quick dm chat?

like

I was approached on LinkedIn for an early career recruiting role in DFW, TX. I don't have direct experience, but I have the university experience/connections from working in career services. This is the first time I've considered work outside of higher education. I said my salary expectations are minimum $90k and that didn't seem to be an issue. Am I asking too little, too much? How can I know I'm getting the best salary and not just settling at the low end of the range?

like

Let’s do another ASL 32FChi

like

Quality engineering VS software engineering. I am currently a quality engineer in medical device. I have 4.5 years of experience. I’m stuck between getting a degree and continuing in quality / manufacturing or switching to software where I know money is great. Thoughts?

likehelpful

What happens if you put in your two weeks right before your firm has firm wide holidays for 2 weeks?

like

Is it a bad idea to leave public after 2 years + senior title?

Currently on H1B and waiting for an offer from EY. Does EY kick start with green card process quickly in special cases. HR said normally it is 1 yr but he has to check with legal team. More inside..

like

This app is so therapeutic for me !

I enjoy the fact I can relate to people’s feeling’s and also see that I am not the only who has similar thoughts.

The one thing that stood out is the ability to share different perspectives and not necessarily know each other !

I love this app !

like

I have notice period of 80 days, Skills C#, WPF, UWP.

YOE - 8 , let me know any new opportunities

like

Just randomly browsing through Expedia. Check out hotel rates in Manhattan

Post Photo
like

Teaching has taken over so much. I’m a wife and mother and still have a home life, but there is nothing outside of work and home. I have no friends, no other activities, no escape. Covid restrictions do not help. I know it’s not healthy to only focus on everyone else, but I’m not sure what to do about it. I have only sporadic time opportunities and I don’t even know what I enjoy doing anymore. When trying to do other stuff I can’t turn off mom or teacher brain.

like

Hi All,
How's the Job security and WLB for JL 8 (AM) employees in Accenture?
I know it has got a lot to do with the project, I'm assigned to, but just wanted to get an idea. Any insights?

Skill ~ SAP
YoE ~ 9

What are you writing off on your taxes this year?

like

Trying to gauge what everyone is giving to their sales assistant for the holidays?

like

Last night I saw a couple getting busy (way too busyy) on the streets in bellandur area. Is this normal in blr? They looked from well to do households.

likefunny

Can someone share any openings for JPMC Bangalore related to freshers.
Tech stack is SQL and Tableau. I am a fresher with 10 months of experience in internships and 1 month of full time experience.

Thank you for your help!

Additional Posts in Technology/IT Consultants

A lot of my friends end up working as data scientist while I’m doing SAP consulting. What do they do? FYI all of us had the same major at school

like

Recommendations on developing a database that can pull public info from the internet for use in a web application

like

Anyone here on the tech side of PwC? Someone from PwC reached out to see if I'm interested in a QA Manager role. How good is the quality engineering practice in PwC? Also what's the range like for QA Managers?

like

Making a switch form Android to iOS. Whats the best way to get my backup messages on to the new device ?

like

UBS If I had to move within the company to a different location , how does it work? For example if I move from low cost of living area to high cost of living area does the company re-evaluate the base salary within USA? Or do they come back and mention its your family requirement since your partner is located and you are moving ?Suggestions or experiences any !

like

Anyone here that completed Udacity data analyst nano degree program? I feel that it would be a great way to get into the DataAnalytics practice or find exit opportunities in the industry? Thoughts? I am a first year Senior Consultant.

like

Any practical AI/ML learning resources for developers to go from zero to hero?

like

Looking for connects at Accenture, Deloitte, EY and KPMG, anyone willing to help out?

like

How much can you eventually make with long term career in cloud consulting? $180k-$250k?

like

Ideas please:

I’m inheriting a “team” of siloed strong individual developers who are on different work streams and are very jaded and struggling with motivation. Most are contractors. They have legit gripes about the client, but I won’t be able to solve those without getting cross-discussions going with knowledge-sharing across our “team“. Any suggestions for remote team-building that won’t just be shrugged off with cynicism, or worse, ignored?

like

As we know cyber security is hot hot hot, I’m currently earning 30k as a junior cyber security consultant in uk going to be asking raise soon and wondering what should I be aiming for?

likehelpful

Looking for 2 to 8 YOE for lateral hire in Technology consulting roles. Folks with red hat, open shift, RPA, BPM, Salesforce CRM, big data & Analytics experience and certification, DM me for referrals.

like

This might be embarrassing, but, is there any courses on writing technical proposals? I’m not horrible at it, but I’ve seen some colleagues finish technical proposals in half of the time and in better quality

like

Sorry is someone has asked this already. But masters vs certs which one gets you more money ?

like

What is your preferred enterprise file storage solution? I’ve been comparing all the features but I’m curious what everyone likes best.

like

Interviewing with Oracle for Senior Director role (Strategic Client group). 18+ yoe
How is the work culture and PIP at Oracle? I have a comp discussion planned this week, any insights into their salary structure will help - base, joining bonus, RSUs, etc...

like

Actively referring folks with ServiceNow and low code backgrounds looking to learn/move into cyber, should anyone be looking or interested.

like

Hi guys, I have a table with customer information. Some entries are invalid. Way to find them out is by invalid customer name like ‘dguychjki’.. no definite rule. More so like you get to know that it does seem right. How best to extract such entries for further review? What condition do I put in where clause of sql?

like

Hi AWS fishes. How bad are layoffs at Amazon? Hearing news of more than 10000 people getting laid off. Are they happening within AWS as well? I am about to join AWS in few weeks and getting bit worried considering the situation. Thanks.

like

Anyone familiar with Ephesoft Transact that would let me pick their brain?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal