When you are handed the news that you’ll be getting a raise or promoted, do you still negotiate your salary?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

No, you need to negotiate before, self-promote before, advocate for yourself before. By the time the org has gone through the process of figuring out what to give you, their salary budget is already allocated across the whole team.

likehelpful

exactly. before, not after. very little room after. too late for you.

I'm shocked at the answers. Yes you should always negotiate your pay if it involves change in responsibilities. Getting a raise for doing a good job isn't the same as being promoted to a higher position which automatically means you should inquire and try to negotiate the pay increase. I've always negotiated my salary increase for a promotion. It's not smart not to at least try.

likehelpful

@CD1 yeah that specific example is pretty bad - I've seen a spectrum as well because humans but outside of that, always know and negotiate your worth.

Also, read Never Split the Difference and listen to all of Chris Voss' talks online!

Recent IconRecent

Can’t relate.

likefunny

Same. I was just curious in case it happens. Keyword: in case.

I was promoted and given a raise a few months ago, however both the title and salary were far lower than I was expecting based on my new job responsibilities. I thanked them and told them that I appreciated their confidence in me, but that I didn't think that title or compensation was adequate for the responsibilities I was taking on. I told them that based on my research, I should be making 20-30k more than they were offering, and that I wanted to negotiate for more. I also told them that I would be more okay with the salary if there was at least a guarantee that there would be another review within 6 months where I could negotiate for another raise, but that I didn't feel that it was fair to ask me to take on a much more significant role with only a tiny increase in pay, (especially since, given the nature of the business, if I were to be laid off due to losing the client within the next year, that I'd essentially done that work and gotten nothing in return to show for it). they were understanding and came back with an additional 10k, with a promise of another review in 6 months where I could again negotiate for more money.

like

I showed them proof, but also pointed out that the level they hired me at was two full levels lower than the work and responsibilities I was doing, and that I had also taken the job at a pay cut from my previous job. the raise they had initially offered would have put me at the same pay I'd been at previously, but I'd be doing way more work. when I was hired, I'd just gotten laid off and didn't know how long another offer would take to come through. I told them that as much as I loved working there, I wouldn't have accepted how low my starting pay was if I'd have known how much I'd actually be doing, and so I didn't think it was fair to base my raise off of my starting salary given that the starting salary was for a job with far fewer responsibilities than I'd actually been performing. I also knew they couldn't find someone to do the job for less than what I was asking.

like

The proper response is thank you.

like

u must be male

like

The times I have gotten that news, it’s been with an apology. Something like you are getting a raise but it’s tiny, some people aren’t getting a raise, so you should be grateful. Blah. Blah. Blah. No room for discussion. Best way to get the big raise is to move to another agency.

likesmart

Yes, why not? If the organization can hire someone outside and negotiate their salary, why not yours? If you’re considered for a promotion you already know they value your work. Know what you’re worth and ask for it!

likeupliftinghelpful

Only if you are prepared to resign and leave

like

Always negotiate. Worst they can say is no. I just had the same scenario and negotiated a 100% increase on the pay-rise. Never take the first offer. My mind is blown by the responses on this thread

likehelpful

Nope

funny

I guess it’s why you haven’t called me in your office yet

likefunny

People do it all the time. It’s common to say what you were hoping for in an increase.

like

Say thank you. Set your goals. And negotiate for a bonus.Incentive based income is possible. They may not buy it but at least they know you are willing to commit and it is more likely they will invest in you.

like

OP I just went through the same thing. Already got a promotion but was waitlisted on pay raise. Never discussed with the powers at be what that number was gonna be. Had no idea. Found out via email that it was approved and ready to take affect. Felt really happy with the number but also a little bit of ‘why that number?’ It’s definitely fair but also probably mid market value if I were to be accepting a new job. So many articles said you’re expected to try and negotiate so my partner and I planted the seed but I’m pretty sure it’s just gonna be a “that’s the cap budget” which is fine. Still not sure if asking was the right thing to do but the worst that can happen is hearing “No.” I hope 🤞

Also- are youuuh my partner, lol?

like

Hey partner, i mean CW1. So how did it go for you? Any updates when you and your partner did ask for some more? How did you justify it?

I was promoted and given an a raise. I didn’t think the raise was enough and negotiated an additional $15k in my salary and $10k additional annual bonus.

like

How did you justify that additional 15 and 10? Is it based on the responsibilities you had in previous months? As a mid-level creative in startup, I couldn’t think of anything besides that would actually justify negotiating for more.

If you feel the number you’re shown doesn’t match to the value you bring, I think it’s totally fair to negotiate with strong rationale in reasonable relation to market factors. Don’t just push for a number arbitrarily - it should be correlated. That way, if the answer is no, you can be clear on where you stand.

likeuplifting

If anyone wants an update. Just want to say thanks for all the insights. Boss took notice of my hard work and is appreciative of the value I bring. Will get an increase that is far more money that I would get had I said the number first. I did it. It’s taking effect next month. You can do this kids. Keep dreaming. Sksksksks and I oop!

like

Thank you! That is so true. It was my first experience to undergo an intense performance review and it was enlightening. I think your instinct should probably be your lower limit, at least! Yes, go get it women!

I’m fortunate my boss explained to me why this and that and what my pay could get moving forward. And I was taken aback on how big it could get. Of course YMMV. It all depends on where you are and the agency but yes, believe in your ability and the value you bring to the agency. I wish you folks the best.

like

No

like

I actually am shocked people are saying no. Negotiate. They have not given you the highest raise possible - it’s still a business. It’s never too late. Those who don’t negotiate will lose major money over the course of their career.

like

My boss mentioned it to me few months ago but I was so anxious I never said any figure or what have you. But the fact that we had a conversation around it, I guess it doesn’t hurt to ask for more should the time come?

Just wanna jump on here a little late: Currently up for a promotion and should be hearing about it soon but haven't even remotely discussed any $ numbers yet. I have a number in my head that I get the feeling will be higher than what I'm offered. Do I bring it up before the actual update/news or do I wait until the promotion actually comes.

like

CD: We’d like to give you a raise and promotion!
AD: I’d like more money
CD: Here is a box for your things.

😂😂😂

Related Posts

Hi,
I have got offers from Sabre travel technology and LG soft India, both are offering almost same package.
Please suggest the best one to join?
YOE: 2.8 years
Techs: Software development, .Net, C#

like

Hi! How’s the growth in the tech department of the company? How are increments and bonuses?

How easy is it to make manager in 4 years in a large metro B4 tax group? How does an early promo manager salary compare to a non early promo manager?

like

Any Group Life & Disability Underwriters out there? Wondering what the salary range is for those with 5-10 years experience in the US. In your response could you please include what segment size you work with?

like

H1B visa stamped.

While applying for visa my company quoted 80K as compensation. Now they want to reduce it to 75K.

This feels like unfair practice. Is it common? What should be my approach?

Hi All, I'm a retail banking business analyst holding an offer with Virtusa IBM NTT DATA On the compensation part IBM has matched an the counter offer with NTT DATA (They were providing me the highest in the fixed) Virtusa fixed component is nearly 2 lakh lesser than ibm and NTT data . Could you please help me to understand which organisation to choose with regards to career growth, work life balance, and other factors This will help me to clarify which organisation to choose among both. YOE 5.5

like

Persistent Systems Limited Hello fishes, Please suggest which one is best in terms of WLB, Job security and carrier growth. 1. Hitachi Vantara 2. Rakuten India 3. Persistent systems limited 4.Neudesic LLC 5. Thoughtworks
6.Publicis Sapient

Not received offer so far. All the above in pipeline please suggest me how much can expect.

Tech stack: Dot. Net Full stack developer, 7+ exp Please provide some insight about the company suggest by you.

CTC: 15 LPA fixed

like

What kind of salary range can I expect in industry in a tier 2 city if I leave consulting after 3-5 years of SAP experience?

I am a proposal manager for federal consulting company. My base is low (112000) but I make up upto 50-70% of my base income with win bonuses. But I get the bonus only after the completion of one year of the base period of the contract. My question is -is this arrangement good or should I negotiate for higher base instead ?

like

People who are joining Nagarro, Make sure you are aware of the project details before joining...lot of projects in Nagarro are sub contract projects..
Make sure your skills are matching. Don't just see package only...

like

Salary of clinical research managers in the Bay Area ?
Thank you

like

Quality engineering VS software engineering. I am currently a quality engineer in medical device. I have 4.5 years of experience. I’m stuck between getting a degree and continuing in quality / manufacturing or switching to software where I know money is great. Thoughts?

likehelpful

Hi guys,

How's ZS Risk and IT compliance team ? How is the work life balance and work culture?

How much can I ask for ?

Currently working in a Big 4 having 2.5 years of work experience.

Current CTC : 6LPA

Any update on this front is highly appreciated.

I have got an offer from Deloitte for 14LPA as a consultant. But my current organisation is trying to retain me by giving me a raise and promoting me to SSE with 11 LPA they have also promised to give me more interesting work according to my will. For now I have said yes to my current organisation. What should I do? Was this a correct decision?

like

Hi All,
Need an help!

Help me choose :
Apexon 22 fixed client : Paypal
Virtusa 23.5 fixed
Which one should I join?


Virtusa Apexon

like

Hey fishes,

Need referral for data scientist 2 role at mastered

It would be great if anyone can comment on ctc part.

Thanks in advance😊

like

Hi Fishes, I'm about attend Hr discussion in few days for Freshworks Inc. What is the salary slab for lead software engineer? How much I can ask for? Current CTC : 20lpa. I dont hold any offer so far.. Please help me with your insights

like

Hello, what is working in retail banking like at JPMorgan Chase ? Specially the branch manager role. I’m looking in the Columbus area. How is pay, culture, benefits, sales environment, meetings, etc. How easy is it to transition from retail banking to corporate. I hear the Polaris campus has great opportunities, I was thinking about getting my foot in the door through retail then transferring to corporate ?

like

Anyone have a gauge on salary of a supply chain professional with 12 years experience?

like

What is fixed CTC at Amazon/Microsoft for SDE2

like

More Posts

Guys how on an average much does a sr analyst (ENO) pulls in cs?

How many locations does Tiger Analytics have?

like

Finally got the call! 🙌🏼🙌🏼 First day on the job.

Post Photo
likeupliftingfunny

Does Barclays give Diwali gifts?

likefunny

Anyone heard about LSC?

like

Hi everyone,

I have received an online assessment from Accenture for selenium Automation Testing.
Any one has any idea what sort of questions are asked. It will be really helpful.

Thanks in advance

like

On interview days, do you take adderall / concerta? I’m nervous that it can make me seem more robotic / less personable during cases etc.

like

Who needs a day between Saturday and Sunday?

like

How often do men get a haircut?

like

Anyone from Amazon's finance division. Require an employee referral for a role.

like

Hi
I am working in Amazon from June 2020 as L3 HR Generalist. My current CTC is 5.2 LPA. I have a post graduation degree in English.
I was wondering if doing an MBA distance course from Symbiosis would help me get a better position and salary?
Can anyone please suggest? If not symbiosis then can I choose any other University for doing the MBA?

Hi, Are there any video to help with case studies for power day at capital one . Really appreciate if anyone who went through it provides their materiel . I am new to consulting cases . Thank you

It’s feeling impossible to find a long lasting mentor-mentee relationship, especially when agencies are understaffed, timelines are ridiculously short and the best in the biz jump ship every two-ish years…

Does anyone have tips on how to become a better writer when you don’t have consistent senior writers around to share your with with?

like

Hi Fishes !!!

I'm looking for a job referral for an entry level project management and market research job profile. I have 10 months of experience and available for immediate joining.

like

Mercedes-Benz Research & Development India Hello fishes. Can someone please refer me to job id MER0001M1A in Mercedes-Benz Research and Development India Mercedes-Benz Research & Development India

like

Dear fishes, Can someone please refer me for SAP SD. YOE- 3.9 years. Please drop a comment, will share details with you.

like

Anyone know of or use a good pitch strategy guide/template that helps focus and structure the final deck? Any best practices you could share would be appreciated. Thanks!

Suggestions required ::
YOE : 4.5
Skills : Native HANA , SAC

Offer 1: Accenture: 12.7fixed +21%var
Skills tht will be working on :Primary Sac Secondary BW or HANA

Offer 2:Bristlecone: 15fixed +10%var
skills tht will be working on Native HANA Modelling and they will train on HANA XSA2.0

Focus is on choosing a tech which would still be in demand after 2-3 years

like

Reorgs are just a part of the corporate world. If you haven’t been a part of one in your career yet, then you most likely haven’t been in the corporate workforce for very long. If you have been a part of a reorg, however, how do you personally approach it? There are many factors at play, but in general do you try to establish relationships with the individuals you know will be key contributors and/or decision makers going forward? Or do you lay low and let what ever happens be/hope for the best?

like

In your opinion - What type of property is the easiest to sell?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Today my boss told me I need to work on showing my frustration directly to people. She mentioned a meeting THREE weeks ago where, during a meeting, I said one single thing that showed I was unhappy with not being included in a particular meeting (for a project I was leading), and my tone made it clear I was unhappy about it. She said the person I “called out” didn’t even bring it up to her; it was what she “noticed.” Cont’d...

like

New State Farm commercial- who is covering "Don't forget about me"? I can't find it anywhere.

like

What is the difference between an account executive and a project manager? When I look at the job descriptions there is not a lot of clarification. Could you enlighten me?

like

Do you feel it’s appropriate for a non-Latinx/Hispanic Producer to ideate or create a Spanish US/Domestic ad for the Latinx audience?
(ie Spanish spot running on Univison for Walmart) **Not referring to LATAM ads**

like

How does one proceed if/when receiving job offers from two shops within the same holding company? Asking for a friend.....

like

What do y'all know about Konrad NY?

like

How do you politely tell a recruiter that you do not offer “holds”

funnylike

Which agencies are going through layoffs

like

Dumb question.. what’s the proper etiquette for when you get a job through a recruiter who reached out to you first? A simple thank you email, a Starbucks gift card, etc?

like

I think I’m finally burnt out on agency life. What’s a logical next step? Freelance? In-house? A new career all together?

like

Had my review (it was good) and manager says that they’ve put me up for promotion/raise saying that there’s no guarantee / not sure if it will get approved — wondering what that means? 🤔 (I’ve been at the company ~2 yrs without any raise/bonuses)

like

Kudos to the man on the train next to me who has his ticket around his neck, his glasses in his hand and a full sleeping mask on. 😴

like

Which portable standing desk converters do people have and recommend. I live in a tiny NYC apartment so use my dining table as the office during the day but need to put it away at night.

like

Is there any tv work worse than the State Farm Chris Paul and his agent unfunny turds? It’s like the creatives watched the Footlocker basketball work and tried to do that. WTF agency does this?

like

Nice Ronald McDonald spot, Subway. Enjoy your cease and desist letter tomorrow morning!

like

I've never worked on anything for TikTok and hope I never have to. TikTok is from hell. I was on it one time for about 10 minutes and could feel myself becoming mentally unwell in just those 10 minutes. The human brain is not designed to deal with the sheer amount of sensory overload that app gives you. I'm pretty sure TikTok is one of the main reasons we are constantly hearing about how much Gen Z struggles with mental health.

likefunny

Coworker (we’re the same level) has a tendency to use “I” statements and then proceeds to present the entire deck that we both contributed to equally…. So annoyed. How to get across to our bosses that I worked on it too?

like

For those who have worked at W+K Portland, what has been your experience? Obviously it is regarded as a unicorn in the industry, but curious to know what peoples experience has been?

like

We’re in such a vicious business. You give your heart & soul to an agency, a client, a brand. Then the wind changes & you’re laid off, reassigned, chewed up, spit out, on to the next. I’m tired.

like

Hi all! Moving from TX to NY and have an offer for 80K. Is this reasonable for someone with ~3 years of experience or am I being lowballed here?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal