Would it make more sense for public accounting to follow more of a big law / IB type of salary/bonus structure for junior staff? And bonuses make up a bigger portion of total comp e.g. all 1st yrs make X and bonuses range from Y-Z based on performance. All 2nd years make N and bonuses range etc

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

PwC with the cohort model has effectively done this. All within a cohort get the same base. Performance drives bonuses.

like

I think this is out of necessity more than on purpose. So much of IB fees in particular are contingent on deals closing, so it’s safer to have a smaller base and then blow out bonuses when they know how they did for the year. PA work is much more recurring or at least more estimable at the beginning of a project but with less variable upside, so a higher portion of comp can be safely “guaranteed” through the salary component (keeping in mind the comparison is only for salary and bonus percentage portions of total comp. obviously the actual total comp is wildly different)

like

Ah very good point. Thank you

like

Because bill rates are lower so they’d have to lower partner profits

Assuming the same total comp? I'm not sure why I'd want that. It would just make my per paycheck significantly lower in favor of getting a single fat paycheck at year end. I guess that disincentives people leaving before bonus, but then everyone leaves right after. Also as someone else said, public accounting is much more fixed fees I feel instead of say returns on IB portfolios or deals

I think you’d also have to reduce the number of people coming into PA and have the remaining work longer and take on more of the work to offset. I think audit is just too crowded to do this effectively. Also, I don’t think you’d be able to lower pay to offset the increase in bonus as starting salaries aren’t the highest to begin with. You’d still need to provide enough of a salary for the person to make it through the year to collect their bonus. So, IMO to have this sort of pay structure, you’d have to increase starting pay, reduce employee count, and raise work expectations. There’s a reason why IB teams pay one starting associate 100k -120k + bonus instead of two people at 60k + bonus.

Bonus in public isn’t high enough.

Related Posts

Hello Fishes, I have 7 days for joining. please help me decide below

UST Global - 19 Fixed + 1 Variable + 1 Joining bonus

NTT Data - 16 Fixed + 2.2 variable

i can ask NTT to match the offer, if they match which is good to join??

Techstack - Backend engineer with Python, Django, DRF, SQL

YOE - 5 years

like

Hi Folks, Have been offered Lead consultant role at Thoughtworks.
Years of exp - 10
What should be my ctc ask?

like

Hi Fishes, Please share your suggestions for the below. Schneider electrical (or) Comcast (or) CTS (or) SCB Which one will be preferable considering market recession - job security - WLB - benefits. All offered decent CTC. TIA. Schneider Electric Tata Consultancy CTS Comcast Standard Chartered

Guys please suggest which company should i join
Optum(uhg) - 22 Lpa
IBM - 22 Lpa
Epam Anywhere - 24 lpa
YOE : 6.2yrs
~TIA

Fishes..pls help...s there any change in the salary structure...where our in hand salary s less now n pf amount contribution will be more...

like

Any idea how much increment and bonus one can expect this year in KGS? And how much it will be if I had joined in march.

Hi there - anyone aware of FTI director salary range for Dubai office? Not enough data on Glassdoor to verify..

like

Guys.. Please help..
- Jpmc(28 fixed + 8-10% Variable bonus) bangalore
- Deloitte India (28 fixed + 1.5 joining bonus) Gurgaon
- Current company (bofa) retaining with 45% now and 20% in end year (total ~28 fixed only).

CC: bofa
Yoe: 6
Current location: Dehradun/Gurgaon

Should I accept ans retain in the same company??
Please help

like

Alston & Bird LLP Does anyone have any insight into associate pay, bonuses, min billable hours, and general work/life balance at Alston & Bird LLP? (DC Office)

like

Any Scimitar 🐠 or folks familiar with Scimitar? A colleague at EY just accepted a role there and claims the total comp is 40% more than his total comp at EY and he was at the very top of the senior consultant pay band as an MBA hire. The folks on LinkedIn look like a bunch of former PwCers.

like

I am working as a product designer.
Having 5 YOE.
Knowledge about photoshop, blender, uv mapping, textures, illustration, AutoCAD, Corel draw.
What would be the salary bar for a designer in a company? How to get a better growth in the design industry.
Could anyone suggest me?

Hello Everyone!

Can anyone help me calculating the in hand salary after pf and tax deduction?
Thanks in advance!

Post Photo
like

Is $100K good for a supervising senior at a mid sized firm?

like

Hello fishes,
I have 5 years of experience. I have received offer letter for IN3 role (java developer) with 22LPA(fixed)+variable(4)+joining bonus(2)..Is this good package or are they lowballing me..?? Should i try for counter offer… will they increment in case of counter offer??

like

Hi Fishes, Please advise ASAP
YOE - 9y
How much can be expected from JPMC on existing offer from other company of 28 LPA Fixed + 2.8 Bonus ?
Planning to ask 35 Fixed , will JP give this much ?

like

Hi, I am going to have interview at wipro for Android Developer for Lucknow location. I have 8 yr of experience and my current ctc is 6 Lac. What salary should i ask them.

like

Hey fishes! I’ve recently been promoted to lead position however the compensation remains the same. I’m planning to not accept the offer stating the expectation for the lead role is higher than my current role. What do you think? Let me know your thoughts :)

like

Looking for an entry level remote tech position. Honestly not picky, current TC is 111k anything close to that would be appreciated.

Currently having 12.36lacs CTC, YOE 8, Business analyst skill, other skills power Bi, SQl, SAP Hana, before 1st round informed recruiter expected CTC as 20lacs not aware BOnus included in IQVIA.

Now that i have submitted all the docs, waiting for HR discussion. My expectation is now 25lacs fixed. Can i say this now to HR when they call?

Ps no idea about grade. What is the scope for negotiation?

More Posts

I am a registered sales assistant which means I have my series 7. I also have the 63 and my Life & Health license. I was a financial advisor but the role is commission only so I decided to take a role as an assistant for some time to learn etc. I really like my role, but I only make 32k a year and after taxes I only take home about 25k. I have a gut feeling that I’m not being paid market value but it’s tough to find comparable salaries. Do you think $15.38/hr is a fair wage in this case?

HR: I still didn’t get approval from finance on the freelance req. not answering email.
Me: FL’r already in the building. you sit in next office can you just talk to them?
HR: ok. I guess.

funnylike

Hi can we check PMR in workday ?

like

On the topic of intimacy with partners… I’ve been with my boyfriend for 2 years and the past year his libido has dropped to zero. Mostly due to work stress (he says). Whenever I try to initiate, he always shuts me down and says he’s not in the mood. I even touch him and he gets hard but stops me as soon as I try to unzip him. We went from once a week to maybe once a quarter.

I’ve talked to him about it and he says I should take care of myself. So frustrated. 😭😭

like

What are "paper pushers" called nowadays?

like

I don't know if it was only me, but I felt I couldn't truly trust any of my mates on deployment. Am I the only one?

like

Hey does anyone have any air purifier recommendations? Perferrably ones with low EMF radiation.

like

I've noticed that the engineers keep their mouths shut whenever they're asked for feedback, but when they're alone, they talk about how much they wish they could change management.

Why is that?

like
like

Republicans annoy me because Biden is fumbling the bag right now and wrecking everything and republicans decide that RIGHT NOW is the time to die on the hill of a social issue. We have a litany of economic and energy and strategic issues and they decide to just randomly do this for no reason

like
like

The mid-level associate who directly supervises me isn’t being responsive. I am worried about missing a deadline. Should I keep pinging him? Figure it out on my own? Reach out to someone above him?

like
like
likefunny

Hi Fisher...

I am looking for job change in technical support.

Please let me know if there is any openings for this.

like

How long it take from senior2 to Asst. Manager?
Joined in May this year as S2.

like

Hello all, anyone know people who are seeking Azure, AWS, or web design professionals? Always looking to help people in these areas. Thanks in advance ;)

like

Does anyone still have an active Becker account that I could borrow for 2 months to study for my REG exam? Please! Thanks!

like

Hello machlion

My bgv is going in halt state for one reason or another.
Today i got mail to upload salary slips april to june.. I have already uploaded slips of april,may. Still i got this mail. Is it normal in bgv process of oracle.

like

As variable pay tenure in #EY is from July to June so if we are in notice period and my last working day is last day of August, so will i will be able to get the VPB for this year?

like

Additional Posts in Accounting

What makes you really happy?

like

What is the best time to go into industry tax if you have no intent on staying long term (SM/Partner)?

like

Tips on how to start an upward feedback conversation? The SM on our job is making the team miserable. Not a bad guy, but I think we will all benefit from him being made aware of the team's concerns

like

Team is already talking about eating hours. My utilization is down cause I was in unassigned for a month in Dec/Jan. What's worse pissing off the partner or having a low utilization? -staff 1

like

Please I need some insight... If I forgot everything I learned in college but have 10 months to focus just on the CPA is it doable?

likefunny

If a train is delayed, how much is timeliness worth, for you? A $20 uber? More or less?

like

Had 2 hours of billable work today 💀

likeupliftinghelpfulfunny

Poll: do you bill time spent dreaming about a client/tax return/audit or not?

likefunny

No action in my job search.... Been applying, but no takers. Too seasoned?? Do I need a recruiter??? What's helped others?

like

If you leave the firm, does your Becker software (provided by the firm) expire or continue to stay active?

likehelpful

When do we find out about raises?

like

Nice cup of flavia at the office on a Sunday. Name a better feeling... I’ll wait

likefunny

has anyone had any luck leveraging an offer from another Big 4 to have your current firm match/transfer the new offer? specifically switching service lines

like

What y'all dressing up as for Halloween?

like

Do partners cheat on their significant others while traveling? Stories please.

like

Thinking about putting a dead fish in the vents before I peace out next week. Anyone else pull a senior prank before leaving? 🐟🐟

likefunny

Has anyone lost motivation and just stopped studying for the CPA? How Did you get back into studying? I became depressed while studying and I just gave up.

like

Does getting a mst brand u as a tax-only person? I'm applying for both tax and advisory internships, but my current big 4 intern experience is tax. My resume has leadership experience & meets GPA req.

likesmart

My utilization is 90% but all of my clients are small jobs. Does that look worse than someone who works on the larger, higher revenue generating jobs with all else equal (utilization/performance)?

like

So...bonus was abysmal and I whined...but I had no idea that the profit sharing would be even more pathetic. Fuck this shit.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal