WWYD: Atlanta for $115k/year or Philly for $135k? Assuming you like both jobs equally. Quality of life in ATL for me would be better but is it worth $20k?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I would be on the next plane to Philly.

likefunny

Philly is a much better city. Very underrated in my opinion.

likefunny

M1 is feeling some sort of way. DC is absolutely not a shit hole. Every big city has its issues; but DC is clean and safe in the most populated areas. Philly is neither of those things

Signed,
Someone from neither place who has spent significant time in both and can be partial

like
Recent IconRecent

Tell ATL about the Philly offer and see if they can meet you halfway - get another $10k out of them

likefunny

I i already squeezed that peach dry

likefunny

20k worth it for a brutal winter?

likesmart

Yep- would be working downtown and living in midtown

$20k in year one isn’t how I’d base a relocation decision

like

@OP, first and foremost, where do you want to live and work? What’s the social and family scene like in each place and what do you prefer? What’s the nature of the work in each place? Is the COL such that a $20K pre-tax difference is negligible after considerations like housing cost, commute cost, etc?

You might end up living wherever you choose for the next 5, 10, or 50 years, and you’ll spend and earn multiples of whatever you’re considering during any of those timeframes.

Philly real estate is more expensive than Atlanta, so if you associate quality of life with the quality/size of your house, then go with Atlanta. Also, snow sucks, and you only get an inch of it per year in Atlanta.

like

Yeah I thought housing prices would be equal. I’d pay a bit more in philly for a not as nice place. But some parts of philly have historical charm.

Snow Vs no snow. Atlanta is an underrated city, mainly by those who've never been there.

likesmart

Hotlanta!

likesmart

Atlanta!

smart

Philly .... you can live in south jersey ( cherry hill or maple shade ) . As you don’t need to travel much to office you can work mostly from home . Airport is like 40 mins .

like

Don’t do NJ. Taxes are terrible

Atlanta resident who grew up in Pennsylvania here. Feel free to DM if you have any questions! P.S. Atlanta all the way

like

did you consider phili city tax? I woukd say go with ATL.

like

But yes good point

Atlanta resident here. Your $$$ for sure goes further here. Would you buy a house in Midtown or Condo? Or rent? You’ll have access to tons of stuff in midtown if you’re late 20s / early 30s. Your commute will be nice. From a safety perspective, this city can be sketch at times. I live in east Atlanta and I wouldn’t walk around at night outside the confines of my tiny neighborhood. 20k seems insignificant for real happiness and it sounds like you’d enjoy Atlanta more. I hear the food in philly is killer, but it’s pretty good here too. Summer is oppressively hot, but I might take that over a winter. Good luck.

like

I live in Highlands and love it!

like

OP created a thread to trash talk Philly for seemingly no reason. For someone who claims to have been in Philly so often you seem to have failed to experience it.

like

I was thinking the same thing.

like

I’d begrudgingly choose Philly in this situation. I grew up just outside the city in a nice suburb, went to school in DC, and now been back in Philly for almost four years and planning my escape.

While I’ve never really felt unsafe here, parts of the downtown area are gross and it never seems to get better. Also, a lot of people (especially in industry) are quite provincial. The ground transportation infrastructure is terrible by northeast standards but the airport is ok. On the upside, as someone else already mentioned, the proximity to NY/DC (and cheap flights to Europe from NYC airports) is awesome and should be considered. Also, I just generally don’t click with the south so I can’t see myself taking a job in Atlanta.

like

for those cities, $$$ is king.

For context: In Philly I’d have an hour commute each way (bc I’m sure af not living in Delaware). Have family and friends in Atlanta. Know nobody in Philly but i make friends easily. Have a dog, so it’s not like I’m gonna hop on a plane every weekend. Really leaning towards Atlanta but that’s a big $ diff.

Why would you have a commute if you lived in philly ? You mean you have a job in Delaware ? How old are you ?

like

If you decide on ATL DM me. Landed on a West Coast project til March. My 1BR will be empty starting mid NOV. Got fam in LAX and PHX. And yes, utilities are included

Join us in Philly.

In the grand scheme, that does not seem like that big of a difference money-wise. You just listed a lot of things that matter far more IMO than 20k. If you are looking to buy a home, then you’ll get far more in philly. But that that out of the equation and COL is about the same

Related Posts

like

What is ideal ctc for 8.5 yoe Dotnet lead developer? I have worked in cognizant and EY. Now looking for change.

Hi fishes, I joined Tavant technologies few months ago. I wanted to know more about appraisal process in this company like when will the appraisal meeting happen, what's the usual rating and hikes one gets there. Also from when will this reflect in payroll.
PS - I really have lot of commitments going forward, so these details will help me plan accordingly.
Thanks in advance. @tavant

like
like

Joined at 502 in JPMC in mid July (in Operational Risk). 6 YOE (4 in audit, 2 in BPO). Haven't really started working in the true sense yet. Objective setting discussion just began for this year. Wondering what to expect from performance appraisal considering these facts in terms of hike and bonus. LOB - Corporate.

like

I was offered a associate manager job in quality in HCL technologies which is in sector 126.... Can someone confirm how much should I expect... My current package is 6.55 lpa and I have total 7+ yr exp and 5.5 relevant exp in quality auditing.

How is Nuveen tiaa? How much package I can expect for 7.5 YOE QA Automation with current CTC 10LPA?

Have 8.5 YOE with CCTC8.5 LPA with 10% VP. Tech stack - java, spring boot, microservices. #FirstSwitch
Offers-
1. TCS 19.4 LPA includes 10% VP (Associate Consultant) Delhi 2. WIPRO-25 LPA - includes 10% VP (B3 band team lead) considering it. (Pune) My queries
1.l initially didn't ask for JB from any. Can do that in anyway now as they are offering it to others.
2. What should be considered as good range of package for my yrs of exp. 3. Tech stack should upgrade to be competitive in Market.

likeuplifting

I have total 4.5 years of experience in pentesting
Certs: CEH, OSCP and CRTP

What should be my expected CTC? My current is 12.5L

like
like

How much is the salary for EY - manager - business consulting for mba tier 1 bschool graduate with 6,7 yrs of experience.

Is salary credited for KGS today or will it be tomorw

like

BofA Vs Hsbc

Which one to choose if BofA is paying 2 lac more than hsbc ? Is Hsbc worth to consider at a lesser pay?

like

How much of a pay increase do you try to get from another firm when looking for exit opps? Trying to jump from 80k to 115k within the next two years

like

Do PEs offer singing bonus or relocation fee?

like

When would Nokia credit salary this month😁?

How much salary does jp pay to promoted associates in India? Which are not in tech

like

Does an EY FSO make the same as a non-FSO counterpart?

like

Are the google salaries listed on levels.fyi show yearly stock of is the stock part split across multiple years?

like

Hey guys! What is the standard CTC for a non-qualified in Big 4 currently with 5 years of experience?

like

More Posts

Someone should get fired for this

Post Photo
funnylike

Hey Fishes,
Looking for a change,
Any reference will help to make a first jump successful.

YOE: 2.9
Technology Stack: NodeJs , MySQL/Mongodb, JavaScript jQuery.
Secondary Stack :- Angular, VueJs, Kafka, Docker and Kubernetes using ISTIO.

like

Hi,
Joining SAP labs, Bengaluru on 8th of August.
Looking for a share of accommodation. Female preferred.
Thank you..

like

Compliance question here, I have always thought of the SALT deduction on the fed return as a perm item & have treated as such in such sch M-3. I see that some people put it as a temp on sch M-3. What is the justification for treating it as a temp on the M-3. You don’t set up a deferred on the def RF for the state tax deduct & it is also a rate impacting item (I know that some temps can be rate impacting). But this all leaves me to side with perm. Does anyone know the logic behind temp treatment?

like

Europe!
What is reasonable salary growth coefficient when going from FTE to consultant?
My current reasoning is 2x as
* We get 100% parental leave for 6 months in current company
* Risk mitigation

I have never been a consultant before, what other factors should one consider?

like

How is the Managing Consultant role at Mastercard? Is it anywhere similar to Big3 consulting or something different? Anyone who could refer me?

SC to M, promotion in CBO.

I was promoted to SC in Aug 2020, and milestone year shows 2024 (4 years).

Is this normal I thought SC-M was 3 years and 2 for an early promo.

Can anyone suggest if it's even possible to try to get promoted in 2 years? Just don't want to put in extra effort and getting disappointed later.

like

Anyone up for chat😔😔 Feeling low...

like

This is how outsiders think when they think of NYC.

Post Photo
funnylike

Hello Members,

What would be my in hand hand for the following ctc. Considering all the deductions

Post Photo
like

Hi everyone! I'm looking for a freelance or home office job as a paid media analyst or any jobs in the Digital marketing environment.
I have experience working with big clients and manage significant amount of budgets. I've knowledge of Meta business, Twitter ads, Google ADS and analytics, about WordPress and Seo strategies.
I really appreciate any help!
Thank you very much!!

like

Are BAs comparatively safer than Dev’s when it comes to layoffs?

like

S&P Global Is it wise to join S&P Global during recession time? Can we consider this company as recession proof. Any history on layoffs in the past ..

S&P Global

Anyone on H1B here at Wells?

like

We are up to a massive 22 members! I know there are more Wagon Wheel Fish out there. Reel them in all!

I have to stop imagining how great it will be to sell my script until it actually sells.

like

BCG fish, have you received a salary bump across levels in the UK as well? Hearing something has been announced in NA?

like

Freelancers be like

Post Photo
likefunny

I’m looking into cyro banks to bank my eggs for long term storage. Has anyone had any experience with California Cyrobank, Reprotech, or Fairfax Cyrobank?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

After a year using my home office setup, especially the 27 inch monitor, how can I ever go back to the traveling life with tiny laptop screen? 😔

likesmart

CAIA vs CFA?

like

Any recommendations for items to shop for this holiday season? Thinking great gifts, quality of life improvements, that sort of thing.

Currently building my Thanksgiving week shopping list 🦃🦃

like

Anyone at BCG Digital Ventures? Would love to learn more about the practice

like

Any book recommendations on handling office politics?

like

any others having issues with delta showing up as a result in trips?

like

What are the best Sales books y’all read?

like

I am plat exec on AA and wife wants to purchase ticket to Europe (traveling alone). Any benefits of booking it through my account (and assigning her FF#) or none?

like

Any book recommendations for learning about investing smart in your 20s?

like

If interviewing at an organization that has different locations (with different MDs/Partners) for the same position do you apply to only one or should you apply to each office you have interest in? Interviewing for a director level position in one location but there is a senior director level position that fits my skill set in another office location.

like

What's the closest non US place to go to for vacation other than Canada

like

What's a good salary in CH for a Big4 for a Manager position? What benefits can be included?

like

Poll: What dress code do you follow at your home office?

When you find out your peers are compensated more even though your rating and utilization is higher :(

like

Planning to do a PRM or FRM qual. How useful is it to move from Big 4 Risk and reg consulting to industry? Finding it hard to get anything other than non-PM roles

like
like

Anyone have any recommendations for home office ergonomic desk chairs?

like

Looking for recommendations for good consulting / problem solving books and possibly LinkedIn courses if anyone has taken something worthwhile. Thanks Fam!

like

What are the top consulting firms in the retail/CPG space?

like

3 questions for fish with CFA designation.

1. Was it worth your time?
2. Do you feel it has helped you in your current/past work?
3. Do you feel clients value you more having this on your resume? (If so, is this sector specific? E.g Financial services clients)

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal