Anyone buck the traditional advice to Max out 401k? I've been making out but see little value in it for me. Who knows what my health will be like when I'm 65

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

What are you proposing to do in place of your 401k that could possibly have even remotely close to an advantage?

like

Why do you see little value you eventual multiple millions of dollars?

like

If you put money into a 401k, your gains grow on a pretax basis and you are only taxed on your gains when you withdraw. 401k means you are only taxed once.

If you invest outside of your 401k, you are putting in money that has already been taxed once as income, and you will be taxed again when you sell your gains. You are taxed twice.

This is why people advise you to max your 401k, because it is a tax advantaged way of investing. As "payment" for this tax advantaged status, there are limits in place on when you can withdraw to ensure that you really are saving for retirement.

So if you want to rationalize not putting money into your 401k because you think you can make better returns elsewhere, you need to be sure that not only can you beat your returns in a 401k, but that you beat it even if you are taxed twice on your investment.

like

Personally, I do not follow the ‘max 401k advice.’ I don’t believe in parking money when it can be used for higher yield businesses / investments. For example, I was able to recently acquire a couple rental units that cash flow $5k per month. By the time I’m in my 50s, all of the rent will be profit (exc occasional repairs). This year, I am planning on acquiring additional units rather than maxing out a 401k.

like

Another upside for maxing 401k is that it reduces your AGI which is used to calculate phase outs for other tax benefits... so by contributing to my 401k, I reduce my agi and am therefore eligible to use the depreciation loss on my rentals to offset my active w2 income.

like

Don’t withdrawals without penalties start at 59 1/2? There are certain conditions that one can withdraw at 55 without penalty as well

like

There are strategies to access 401k money without penalty before 59.5.

BCG1 fair response. But real estate is way too hard for the masses to do *successfully* compared to simply diverting x% of your salary to an investment account. If you can do it right more power to you. I'm into real estate as well, btw.

like

Not hard... I have 16 units and spend minimal time each month managing it... usually just time in the cab to and from the airport

Company only matches 25% of the first 6% of salary. But it is pre tax so that increases the benefit.

It will take a while for it to get into the millions given the max and that it's on a Target fund. I could put it in higher earning investments

Also I can only use it starting at 65!

OP, with the pace of advancement in medical technology, if you’re in your 20s or 30s, you’re going to live to be 100. Gonna need those ends!

Planning to pay for grad school soon so want more liquidity in my money

Related Posts

Is there anyone from Canada here? I’m looking for some information on working out of the country, but selling insurance.
Thanks

like

I have got an offer from S&P Global I want to know about following things

How much of Variable Pay is Paid ?? I got 15% of Base salary but how much will be paid like the usual norm i want to know

And what are the deductions from Base salary apart from PF ?
There are lot of allowances like internet reimbursement etc etc
Are they mandatorily credited or you need to claim ?

For those who work 100% remote with their company, what health insurance provider does your company offer? (ie. UHC, Aetna, BCBS, etc)

like

How old were you when you bought your first house?

like

Lot of fear in the market right now (understandably so). The situation in Ukraine is awful and the potential consequences are scary to think about.

There are some who want to sell in fear of their investments falling further. Do not do this. Hold and continue to buy more. Continue your 401k contributions, and add whatever you can afford after every paycheck into your brokerage. Those who sold the covid crash were often late buying back in.

This is the dip you're worried about.

Post Photo
likehelpful

Hey beautiful people,
I’m 27Y and work in tech. Unfortunately my carpal tunnel is getting worst slowly. I’m worry that I still have like 45 years more to be retired and can’t stop working because I have a f* mortgage to pay 😭 I have a super ergonomic workstation, but I know my hand needs a long rest, and I can’t do it… Does anyone relate? What do you recommend?

like

Anyone out there who left their previous job for a new one have any advice or life experience to share? I’ve been thinking about it for months but currently feel comfortable in my job/the products I work on. I’d say I have a great work/life balance but I do know that I could be making 20-30% more and have better benefits if I left. I also feel a bit stagnant in my job but the job security has kept me put. Would love to hear if leaving a comfortable job for more money is always worth it.

like

List the college you went to. When you graduated. How much you pay monthly on student loans and when you think you will be done.

like

Bonus is out for EY GDS steps to see. Goto gdsindiapayroll.greythr.com, click on IT Declaration on left. Then click on My Tax Planner at the top right. Then click create my plan then click view it calculation on bottom right then expand income here under adhoc income you should see variable performance bonus amout.

like

Planning to file tax return in India. What are the considerations? I used to upload firm 16, add investments and file it until last year before I moved here. Anything else I need to think about?

Looking to buy an 💍. Might make a trip to India in 6 months. Any advice on helping me make the decision to buy in US vs India?

like

Looking for a great realtor with knowledge of East Austin. Any recs?

like

Anyone know if you can cancel your Chase Sapphire Preferred after 3 years and get Chase Reserve and still be eligible for the signup bonus points?

like

Currently 25 years old.
Goals:
* Own a home in a HCOL
* 2 kids (eventually)
* Retire at 50 on $125k/year.

Envelope math:
* $125k/year would require an investment portfolio of ~$3M.
* Targeting a $2M home (split with partner)
* 2 kids - $1M to raise both (including college fund, split with partner)
* $500K buffer for unexpected expenses
* 33% tax

Therefore, 6.5-7M retirement savings needed. To hit this (assuming 6% return after inflation), I’d need to save ~$110k/year.

How does this sound?

like

Hi, I am currently a Sr. Radiation Therapist experiencing burnout. I am currently looking into other positions within healthcare that does not involve direct patient care. Any suggestions of routes I should take?

like

IPOB is up 133% on the year. Would you buy IPOC right now as it’s only up 5%?

like

Currently interviewing for a remote account manager position with USI Insurance in NC. I have over 20 years experience in personal lines as an agent. Can anyone provide insight as to the average pay for this position?

like

Recently received notice from landlord rent is going up ~20%. For reference, it is privately owned condo and did not sign at a COVID discounted rate. Super frustrated. What are others seeing for rent increases?

like

Is it financially irresponsible to buy a home that requires you to divert what you’re currently saving / investing monthly to pay the mortgage?

like

More Posts

Anyone working off Wacker in Chicago have any apartment suggestions? Or any general advice for the area?

like

Can anyone provide insight on the Salesforce Program/Project Management team in Atlanta?
Found a role and am curious to learn more

like

Any recommendations for learning Mulesoft? I used it a bit a few years ago, but I don't remember much. How much has it changed since being bought by SF?

like

Looking for a salesforce referral, highly qualified, passionate product manager seeking something new! Will DM the role(s)!

like

To all AEs in the fishbowl, if I am a consultant in sfdc space what is some advice on how I can get time w an AE or get on some preferred list of consultants that an AE might use to help their clients? New in consulting space at the moment but years in SFDC space

Any job openings? Lol

funny

What’re the advantages to contributing to my 401k vs. just investing on my own? I understand it doesn’t get taxed on the way in, but after I withdrawal, isn’t it the same?

Looking to sale majority of my holdings in next bear market rally. Does folks who do tech analysis think we have started one from Friday. Want to sale as much before we get another brutal sale-off before mid terms.

like

I'm looking for a scenario planning framework or template. Something that essentially says if this happens then do that. Any help much appreciated.

like

Hi Fishes, I immediately need to switch my role related to Data science/ML/AI with good hike. Suggest some companies and ways. I'm willing to learn new things after deployment.

YOE : 1.5 years as Python developer

Skills : C, Python, Excel in writing SQL queries, Swagger, Microservices, PostgreSql Aws(Lambda, Api gateway, SNS, SQS), Angularjs, PHP.

I've taken all the exams twice and only passed BEC... got a 71 on REG and 66 on FAR. I really feel like giving up. What are some tips to stay motivated?

How much is the average Emergency Medicine physician making out of residency? (Name your city)

like

Where do y'all get your lumber?

I recently moved to a different district and am starting to plan ahead for next year. What novels and plays do you think are worthwhile and essential for 10th, 11th and Pre-AP? I have many in mind that I have used before but am really looking for some fresh ideas!

like

Best strip clubs in town? Is it weird to hit ‘em alone? Asking for a friend..

like

Hi
I will be joining cisco bangalore soon
Can anyone share with me the holiday list for oct 2022
I need it to plan my travel
Just need to know if there's diwali holiday or not

Thanks

like

Is verizon service based or product based company?

Anyone willing to do a resume review? Getting a lot of rejections (before interviews) and wondering if it has to do with my resume.

like

Hands on Skills in COBOL,DB2,JCL,VSAM

I have been looking for job change and when I speak to HR's with the expectations of around 25 LPA fixed( my current salary is 15 LPA)... Most of the companies are directly rejecting my profile saying budget issue...

But is it really more that i am asking for or is it because of the my skill set?

like

Is it fair game to report someone’s particularly polarizing IG posts to HR? Was friendly with this person but now I wouldn’t ever want to work with them after some of the things they’ve posted.

Additional Posts in Personal Investment Chatter

Is it unwise to be investing for my future mortgage down payment? I hear to keep it in savings, but this isn't exactly short-term. It will take me at least 5 years to accrue what I need, and even longer if I have to just save up for it in cash.

like

A very privileged question, but do any of you expect significant inheritance? And if so, how has that affected your retirement planning?

like
like

My rent is increasing about 10% and the parking is going up even higher. Lease is up in October. Is it too late to look into condos or coops? It’d be right around the same price

like

Fidelity, who asked for this?

Post Photo
likefunny

Here we go again.

Post Photo
likefunny

Looks like stocks are back on sale

like

I had a baby almost a year ago. I should start a 529 account for my child but I am originally from France which also makes her a French citizen and she could easily go to college in France for not much money. It’s pretty much free there, I have 0 Student loan debt. With that in mind, a 529 would not be super helpful if we go that route. Should I consider other options? Do you have suggestions? Thanks so much!

like

How are you all determining the future cost of college and target levels of investment for 529 accounts? Having a hard time seeing how 100k for college in 15 years is realistic. Also don't know the right level of savings to target (50%? More?).

like

I currently have both of my retirement IRAs in SPY (Roth & Traditional). I rarely ever see anyone here invested in SPY, it's usually a vanguard fund like VOO, VTI, VXX etc. What's you're reasoning behind that, and alternatively if you're in SPY, why?

like

Accidentally sold all my VOO stocks when I was trying to put in a trailing stop loss. 🥲 Feeling real crap.

like

180k base in CA: Is 1500/month net saving goal too aggressive?

likesmart

I have 200k in HYS. Currently have 1k in BTC. Id like to start DCA to diversify my investments. How do you recommend this? Should I buy a bunch outright and then start investing 5-10% of each paycheck?

like

Want to buy a house in bay area? Is this a good time? Thoughts?

like

31, $155 base, expenses 2300mo, 30k investment, only debt is 500k house. Is it too late? How far behind am I? If I throw all of my cash moving forward at investments and mortgage can I recover?

like

Where do you buy dogecoin?

like

I’m originally from Brazil and most of my investments are allocated there.

Brazilian fixed income products are paying 13.25% returns and I’m wondering if it’s a good idea to secure this return in Brazil or if now it’s a good time to build a portfolio with US equities?

(90% of my money is on my Brazilian portfolio)

like

Looking to put $5K in the market. Which ones would you buy? Lululemon, delta airlines, Peleton, docusign, Zoom, etsy. Any that I’ve missed and should consider? Already have MSFT, BRKB, NVDA, BABA and multiple broad ETFs

like

Will there be any tax implications from Venmo transactions in FY21 given the new fees they introduced earlier this year? Neither I nor any people I have transacted with this past year have noted that anything was for goods/services regardless if that was actually the case so am wondering if there will be any changes as to how things are accounted for or if any new forms are being issued.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal