Canada PR vs USA H1B visa. I am on H1B in USA with a good job and I have a Canada PR which I thought of using to get more stability in life but as I am running out of time on Canada PR it’s making me anxious if I should stay in the USA or move to Canada. Can someone share their experience if faced the similar issue?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Find a job in Canada, spend 3 years in Canada, figure out if you want to move back to USA - if you do, use a TN visa that does not require petitions or visa stamping to work in the USA.

I made the move to Canada with this idea, but I don't think we are moving back, wife is happy here, kids like it, pay sucks a little - but we don't really spend a lot and can coast to retirement. That said, we will move if we find an awesome opportunity in an awesome city.

likefunny

I was in a similar situation 7 years ago. Was working on H1B and my employer had started the GC process. Also was running out of time on my PR and we had to make a decision on whether to move to Canada for a certain status or stick around on an H1B and wait years for a GC. Found a job while in the US and made the move. We love it here. The work-life balance is great, public schools are good, very diverse with many immigrants from everywhere. My American kids love it too. Things are more expensive and you pay more taxes, but the free health care and other benefits are worth it for us.
We're now Canadian and so settled that we don't consider moving back to the US. We can visit whenever we want.
Depends on what matters to you and depending on your field, the job market in Toronto is pretty good. Like others said, you could always move back after citizenship.

likesmart

Thank you for sharing your experience. I am exactly on the same boat right now and have to make a decision soon.

like
Recent IconRecent

Move to Canada, get citizenship, come back to US. That’s what I had thought I would do but I never even applied for pr

likesmart

Canadain working in the U.S Under a TN -Sci Tech and I have recently realized my opportunities are limited with regards to moving up in any corporation while on a TN due to the single intent nature, Highly suggest looking into H1 or L1 categories to prevent the same issue.

like

If you’re single and in your 20s, stay in the US. If you’re in your 40s with a family, you may find Canada a better option to settle down.

like

In my case, I’m single and in my 20s but moved to Canada. Primarily because my company was dragging their feet about the greencard. So I went with what I felt was right for me.

likefunny

Made the move two years ago, agreed with above, once you stop comparing the salary between two counties, the life became much better

like

Stay with H1B. Not worth starting from zero (network, relationship, friends)

like

To the other commenters who say move for citizenship and after 3 years move back to the US on TN, it sounds much easier than implementing. First off, you need to complete 3 years of physical stay, so if you travelled outside the country in the preceding 3 years you need to add that amount before applying for citizenship. Secondly, the processing time is anywhere between 12 in best case to 24 months in worst case (18 months is the average). So when you move plan for a 5 year stay and hiatus from your US career/lifestyle. A lot of this will depend on your personal situation like age/spouse's career/kids/real estate investments etc. so this is not solution for everyone.
Lastly, the TN visa has several restrictions and it's not as easy to get one for a Software Engineer (any level) role. Although, assuming you have the I140 approved beyond 6 months, moving back on H1-B is not a bad deal, cause Canadian passports don't need a stamp.

like

I’ve never lived or worked in Canada but if I had the choice, I would choose Canada over the US. I’ve been here since 18. Many many years on student visa and then on H1B got my green card through my American husband a few days ago but overall I really regret being in America. I’m Asian and too old to go back to Asia but if I can choose between Canada and US I would pick Canada anytime

like

I made the the move to Canada this year and happy about it. Wish I had moved sooner 😊

like

I was in the same position and I ended up moving to Canada, very very recently.

like

One of my colleague is going through this process

like

In the same boat .. on TN as Canadian citizen .. the h1b lottery scares me .. is it really 30 percent?

like

Can you go L1, assuming you worked for Accenture Canada for a year?

Same position as OP. So confused lol

like

Work considering moving me back to Canada then come back on an L1 straight to EB1

Also tn—> cos to H-1b after establishing relationship with Corp. —> I-140 process

Find a job near the US-Canada border. Get best of both worlds. Taxes are complicated. You’d also need a nexus.

Depends on your level too.

Apart from healthcare, what are the other superior benefits in Canada?

Better work culture my rear end. WLB and culture depends on project / team / company.

For those who moved to Canada, why is it so much more appealing than the states?

Stability was a big factor for me. Plus the ability to switch jobs/pivot careers.

like

Related Posts

Do customer success roles get h1B sponsorship? Is that a rome aligned to strategy? Or operations?

like

Need your suggestions
I got offer from product based company and intiated notice period in TCS. Now manager is saying he'll intiate on site opportunity for Mexico. And asking to revoke notice only after official confirmation for Visa. What should I do now.
Offered CTC -9.3lpa
Cctc 3.6Lpa

like

Can I simply upgrade from Amex Blue Cash Preferred to Amex gold? Or would both just be open at the same time since one is technically a charge card?

like

My fried work in Infosys.
His manager asked for his interest for H1B visa nomination. What does that mean?
Will he get the opportunity to go outside India.?

Can anyone at Visa Inc refer me for an open position?. The job number is REF018545W.

@Visa inc

like

Does AmEx take codility test for hiring? Anyone who can share some insights?

Anybody knows how brexit will impact Tier 2 Visa

I signed my offer last week. How long until immigration contacts you for an H1b transfer?

Looking for some advice as I am considering relocating to US. How difficult is for HR professionals to get a work visa? I think from what I read I qualify under eb3 (no master yet) or h1b. How do for do about looking for positions that sponsor your visa? I'm in the defense sector and have previously healthcare and financial services experience. Also worked in global matrix organisations with US teams so know the culture quite well. Any help is greatly appreciated.

like
like

Any KPMG US AAS fishes here?
I can see lot of openings on the website but it says no visa sponsorship.
I’m in UK office but want to move to US for a change. Do you see any inbounds from other member firms generally? Is it possible if i apply?

like

I’m looking for a new every day cash rewards credit card. Do you know of any that is better than 2.6% cash back? Trying to find something better than the Bank of America® Unlimited Cash Rewards Credit Card.

like

Hello everyone. Any law firms hiring for international litigation, immigration or international arbitration? I have law degrees from both Paris and the United States and I will soon be sitting for the Paris and New York bar exams (fluent in French and English)

like

Hello Fishes,

I have got my L2 Dependent Visa stamped for the US through the Wife's organization and she has booked the tickets for the both of us in the next weekend. I am currently unallocated in TCS and seeking projects in the same US location as my Wife. Can I travel to the US just like that and then continue my search within TCS from there or do I need any approvals to even fly in the first place?

I am worried because of the time crunch and will be glad to hear some points on this.

like

McKinsey & Company What is McKinsey’s policy for Green Card applications? Do they initiate the process right away or is there a tenure requirement?

McKinsey & Company

like

Hi mates,

I am working as JAVA Full Stack Developer..
3 years experience in MNC (TCS)
I am living in India
Can anyone help me how can I get work/sponsorship visa.
Countries i think is better which might give good opportunities - USA, UK,Canada.
Or if they can help me by any help for getting into this country,it will be great.

like

Do you agree the US Immigration process needs to change Y/N only

like

Has anyone been able to switch (to industry ) on H1 visa? I am getting a lot of interest from recruiters but am not able to get past the initial screening because of visa.

More Posts

What’s your worst experience with a senior? (As an associate)

Have any of you started a PLLC for a solo practice? If so, what was the process for getting your firm to become a PLLC in Illinois. Did you file for an llc first then file a cert with the Supreme Court. PLLC filings for IL do not list attorneys as a professional group.

1st time going to Spain in May. Thoughts on the itinerary? Barcelona 4 days -> Seville 3 days -> Cordoba 1 days -> Grenada 2 days -> Madrid 3 days

like

Hilton 🐠 - what are your favorite properties to redeem points? What’s the best deal you’ve seen? Can be anywhere in the world. Interested in Waldorfs or Conrads that I can’t afford to pay in cash.

Hello Fishes,

I have got my L2 Dependent Visa stamped for the US through the Wife's organization and she has booked the tickets for the both of us in the next weekend. I am currently unallocated in TCS and seeking projects in the same US location as my Wife. Can I travel to the US just like that and then continue my search within TCS from there or do I need any approvals to even fly in the first place?

I am worried because of the time crunch and will be glad to hear some points on this.

like

Hello everyone. Any law firms hiring for international litigation, immigration or international arbitration? I have law degrees from both Paris and the United States and I will soon be sitting for the Paris and New York bar exams (fluent in French and English)

like

Does anyone know if PwC's prescription drug plan covers PrEP?

like

Hello everyone!! I have been interviewing with AlixPartners and have my case interview coming up in a week and a half.. any advice on prep, what to expect, anything else I need to know would be really helpful..

Thank you and cheers

like

I cannot find much of any Results on Fishbowl for ZipRecruiter. Is there anyone that can provide some first hand or even second hand information on working for them?

like

McKinsey & Company What is McKinsey’s policy for Green Card applications? Do they initiate the process right away or is there a tenure requirement?

McKinsey & Company

like

My fear of being ghosted has become a self fulfilling prophecy. Everytime I like someone, I have panic attacks when I don't hear from them for a few days. How do I stop this cycle?

like

Anyone have any experience with Veeva Business Consulting? Any success negotiating a base salary and TC?

like

What’s a reasonable salary for a supply chain analyst in MN?

like

Do we get product discounts on Google hardware that we want to buy for personal use?

like

People who work in any engineering capacity are usually very hardworking but it's not just because we have to be, it's also that we find this stuff really fascinating, kind of like a book you can't put down

like

Does KGS provide shuttle services in Bengaluru?

any suggestions on where to rent? preferably manhattan downtown or midtown. budget is ~2.1k or so. priorities are having a doorman, elevator, laundry in building at the very least

like

I think I have a drinking problem. I go big and I go hard when I drink. I want to throw in the towel and just be a sober person but happy hours and *do I like drinking with this person* are such a big part of our industry, especially internally. How do we balance? 😔

like

I need help finding a Christmas tree around midtown east. All I see are tiny ones or huge ones. Just looking for one ~5-7feet

like

I hope it comes into action soon...!

Post Photo
like

Additional Posts in Global immigration

Really over this job, but company just started my GC application. I hear it takes about 2 years. Is the GC worth the wait? Does the time go by fast? Lol I feel stuck here & just tired. Send help

like

Is the only way to find out your case tracking number through the physical receipt notice?

Has anyone requested for an experience letter from Deloitte for Canada PR? The automated letter doesn’t provide job responsibilities. I requested an exception and they want to know the reason for it.

Any company file GC on day 1 in NYC or NJ area or east coast. Maxing out in feb 2022 and on bench nothing is started. What I can do ? Please suggest. Skill set AWS/ DevOps/ Infra.

like

Got a new job and will start H-1B transfer. What’s the risk of giving my notice right before LCA is filed or right after? I know all lawyers advice to give notice once H-1B receipt is received but I need a break from my current role and want to have some free time before I start new role. I am fairly positive of the H-1B transfer at my new company as it’s a big tech firm

like

Does anyone know if ey will PP the I-140?

like

any recent stamping experience in Canada?

Looking for some advice as I am considering relocating to US. How difficult is for HR professionals to get a work visa? I think from what I read I qualify under eb3 (no master yet) or h1b. How do for do about looking for positions that sponsor your visa? I'm in the defense sector and have previously healthcare and financial services experience. Also worked in global matrix organisations with US teams so know the culture quite well. Any help is greatly appreciated.

like

Hello has anyone heard anything about the official date of lifting the travel ban from India?

like

Just got my I-140 approved. Do I see notifications when 485 case gets transferred to FO? Also, I see recommendations to call USCIS to request for expedited case handling - is this even a thing? Hoping to get 485 approval by end of September

like

McKinsey & Company What is McKinsey’s policy for Green Card applications? Do they initiate the process right away or is there a tenure requirement?

McKinsey & Company

like

How long does it normally take to get OPT STEM extension approved?

Apple GC policy for non-tech roles
Could someone share the experience of how to start the GC process asap? TIA

like

If my H1 is up for extension on July 2019, when should I initiate extension. Can I change my home city in that time period?

I’m a TPS holder and I have an EAD, I started my job with this and have been working for them for 4 months now. I work at a large nonprofit. TPS and EAD renewal application submitted, and with the new card I’ll be able to work until 2024. I haven’t asked my employer if H1B sponsorships is an option. Is it too early to ask? Should I wait until I build more credibility?

Anyone at @EY transferred h1b visa? How long did it take? JD will change from the previous employer.

like

Will we ever learn if our application was Denied because BAL made a mistake?

like

If I apply for 485 after receiving 140 approval (I.e., not concurrently) does the application always go to NBC? I’m ROW for reference. Thanks!

Anyone think the PERM processing time will fasten? I’d imagine with Covid there would have been less filing...

like

My gf is still waiting for her EAD and had to go on unpaid leave of absence which is coming to an end in March. Noting delays on current processing times, what are multinational companies offering on similar cases? Are they terminating their employment without any health insurance benefit until they can be rehired or are they offering any other support? I would appreciate you sharing your experiences to benchmark. TY

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal