Change my mind: I have about $300k in Roth IRA that I want to take out and invest in rental properties. I can withdraw my contributions without penalty (though not the earnings). I don’t want to work a 9-5 for 30 years to sit on a pile of money that may or may not even be enough. Has anyone else opted for skipping 401k contributions for real estate?

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

You can set up a self directed IRA to keep the favorable tax treatment, and then invest in RE. The down side to this approach is your earnings would be reinvested in your fund until retirement age. Not a bad idea though.

like

For those asking about a real estate crash - why would it? Unemployment rates are at historic lows. Supply is far below where it needs to be and that will take years to fix, if municipalities are so inclined to rezone even. The market is basically frozen because of low supply and high interest rates. It will be a slow thaw over many years, not a crash. Meanwhile, people will continue to rent and hopefully continue to save for a down payment when really ready to buy. I’m in that boat myself.

like

Just don’t go in thinking real estate is a passive investment. I have 2 properties and they have sucked so much of my time over the last 2 years. If I could go back - I’d keep the money in S&P 500 etfs.

likehelpful

Curious: You using property managers?

I have a condo in a downtown luxury high rise in a MCOL city, 2010 build, and my neighbor 10 floors higher flooded because of a burst water pipe and I’ve had to manage that renovation from 1,000 miles away.

You cannot for the life of you ever guarantee a passive managing of an investment property.

helpful

Thanks for sharing that experience. What a nightmare. I would definitely only buy where I’m within driving distance.

Sure, lots of real estate tiktokers will tell you this is the only way to live.

IMO, you should be diversified but, you can do whatever you want.

You also get tax benefits like depreciation that doesn’t help you in an IRA

That’s an incredible ROTH IRA balance! I would absolutely not give up *tax free* compounding growth. Depending on your tax bracket you can think of this as an additional 25% return on your growth! I would however also build real estate assets. It doesn’t have to be an either or. I am not a financial advisor but can help you with potential numbers for your real estate purchases and straightforward ways to build a portfolio without using up all of your assets.

You don’t get annual depreciation if you sell the property. And 1031 deferment is only when you sell. It all depends on your timeline and goals. And I’m what part of the country you’re planning to buy. I just would personally keep the funds in your ROTH IRA and start your real estate portfolio with other funds. This way you’re leveraging all options for your maximum benefit. There are financial advisors who are real estate friendly advisors and can identify what percentage of your funds make sense for you. Again, I’m not a financial advisor. I’m a lender.

Related Posts

Please suggest me best SIP to invest

like

1M net worth, 450k total comp, age 35, just paid off tons of student loans TONS, want to retire at 50. What’s the move?

like

Right now sitting at 40% cash in brokerage account. Want to decrease the cash reserve to 15% to 20% but not sure if I should just buy more stocks now or wait for the next market correction. I know never time the market but still.....

like

All my investment is in real estate - 1 primary and 2 rental. Total 3.7 M value and 1.7 mortgage pending. About 400k in cash. I’ve 0 RRSP. Is my investment strategy terrible?

like

Newbie here, can anyone here pls share their trading journey?

like

I'm a Canadian on the TN visa working in the US and planning on maxing my Roth IRA (6k) and will have enough left to max my 401k this year, but am not sure if I should just use a taxable account over 401k due to tax considerations when I move back to Canada (likely 1-2 years from now). Any thoughts here? I don't think I'll have enough RRSP room to move 401k>IRA>RRSP and I would prefer to not have to file US taxes every year in retirement for withdrawls if I left the 401k in the US.

like

I am planning to invest in REITs. What is better VNQ or XLRE? Is XLRE a mutual fund and tax wise slightly less beneficial than VNQ?

I was just checking my salary slip on new payroll tool and found some interesting things.
There is some ex-gratia 3 amount ( less then rs. 500) and income tax deducted is more then last months (which is unusual as I have declared my fbp and IT declaration in oct only). Upon checking in IT statement found I got gift perk of around rs 4500 but it eas not added to my salary in account. Did anyone know where is this gift perk and how can I use this ?

like

What would you do?: trying to maximize points. Have CSR, Amex Gold, Chase freedom unlimited. Will be receiving CORP Amex from new firm. Background:

My son will be turning 1 soon and I would like to present a gift and thinking of investing on a watch so that it will hold its value 25 years down the lane, any suggestions would be very much appreciated. Budget is around $7k.

like

Realtor fishes, let's play a game: I share some details of some listings that we have available at my office and you let me know if we should keep them in our portfolio or make room for better properties.

like

Is it too late in our lives to jump into a mortgage?

So my fiancée and I are relatively late in terms of finally landing well paying jobs and being able to save money instead of living paycheck to paycheck. We’re both 36 and currently rent a 2 bedroom in NY and have a combined savings of $35,000 which she wants to use as a down payment on a condo. I kinda just wanna continue saving while renting. I also literally just started contributing to my 401K so I’m also late in the game for that too.

helpful

Is now a good time to buy a house?

like

Is this the official Amex Fishbowl?

Base: 5 lakh
HRA: 2 lakh
Max how much I can exempt with HRA while filing ITR?
I live in my own house. I can pay to my parents in the name of rent.
What are the documents I need to produce?

Mid year check in! Jan 1, 2021 someone posted asking what everyone’s net worth goals are. How’s everyone doing? My goal was 75k and it looks like at this rate I won’t reach it by EOY and I’m ok with that!

like

Dallas attorneys - where would you live if you were working downtown but your spouse worked in Fort Worth? Looking at Irving (Las Colinas) but not sure if the commute is unreasonable

like

Got a loan rate for 3.375% for an appt. This seems a little to high. Thoughts?

like

For those of you who got out at 10, do you wish that you rode it out to 20? I’m at a crossroad and I’m not sure what to do. Have some active/reserve time, wrapping up graduate school, and am now considering either a) come back to the business world or b) go active and retire before 50 and live off a nice pension. Obviously there are draws to both. I’m an officer for what it’s worth so I can realistically retire at O-5, MAYBE O-6.

likesmarthelpful

More Posts

Anyone working or worked in past with WIPRO, just need one information when will we receive form 16.

like

Question on UK visa-
My partner will be traveling often to London, once a month for an year starting September. He is getting his visa through work (10 years, multiple entry, 6 months max stay, cost some $1000).

I have applied for standard tourist visa in the past and they are usually short term. It could be max 6 months, but they see your itinerary and allocate you few months around the itinerary

Is there a way to get 6 months multiple entry visa, if I were to join him once in a while.

like

Hi
Can anyone help me how should i explain my project on which i worked in my current company to the interviewer.would be very helpful if someone can help with the basic format from start to end or else can give example of their own project.

Thanks in advance

like

Hi fishes
How.much percentage of hike is infosys and TCS offering to retain their employees.?
If anyone has any idea please let me know.

like

Hi all,
Does anyone have any availability to case prep today? Based in ET and looking for someone relatively experienced. I’ve done/given around 20 cases

like

Hi , my base location is kolkata in ibm . And i just shifted to kolkata with my family. However i am tagged to a project Barclays client which is in pune and bangalore. Is there any chance of my base location getting changed any day in future in IBM.

Infosys Tata Consultancy IBM Accenture Cognizant Capgemini

Comments will help very much

like

LTI is Hiring for below Cloud - BU Positions!!

Immediate to 30 days joiners will be preferred.
Interested plz DM with job codes to apply

Post Photo

Where can I get f&f settlement doc ? On the former employee portal i only see status as completed.

Hi team, thanks for joining lets grow together.

like

Sometimes I feel like I am a drone that just works all the time and I have no friends.

likefunny

Given the current downturn in US markets and specially Cypto, what's your strategy?

like

How about the scope/ demand of mobile application testing.

like

Off the topic.. being in IT field and living in Bangalore, what do you think is best renting a house or opting for a home loan and paying similar emi for 20 years?

like

Pretty new to the game. What do you do with trees in your pocket? You can't store them. Should I go ahead and sell them? Or should I go plan them some place on the edge of my island.

like

Multiple positions open in IBM. DM me

Post Photo
like

Tips on dealing with imposter syndromes? Building skills at a small firm? Feel like I can’t do research well in my niche field …

Additional Posts in The Real Estate Bowl

Any one knows what’s the easiest way to order a radon test for new construction?

like

I would like to learn more about development and real estate. Can anyone recommend any books or courses that you think are informative. Eventually I would like to own a few apartment buildings, but I know there is a lot I need to learn 1st. Any advice appreciated. 

like

How big is to big for an initial investment property. Theres a 20 SFH portfolio for sale by me for about a mil. Is this to big to start with initially? I'm less worried about the Financials (feel comfortable on that end) and more worried about the managerial aspect.

like

I am looking into buying a multi unit (dullex,triplex,quad) in Chicago ideally in Lakeview East/West, Lincoln Park, Wicker Park, Logan Square, Bucktown areas.

This will be my first property and planning on living in one of the units. Downpayment will come from what I have in stock market but wondering if anyone has any models to how to analyze if it would be a good investment property. Would appreciate any help? First in family to get into something like this.

like

I am considering putting down an offer for a TH in a community that has Mello Roos. It gets added to the property tax. I am looking at paying an additional 5-6k for that.

Online videos say it’s all good because the money gets invested in building the community .

any potential downsides? In terms of future sales and demand ? What am I missing?

like

Planning on buying a house with MIL. She would lend us half the price of home interest free in return for being able to live in it rent free. We’d have 100% ownership. Repayment only required if we sell the home.

She would maintain the place 100%. We would cover races and insurance.
Relationship aside, does it sound like a fair deal?

28 year old with ~125k in cash/brokerage. Have been wanting to begin purchasing rentals but anxious to use a good bit of my liquid savings. Thoughts on biting the bullet vs. investing in stocks. In Houston if that is a factor

like

Does anyone have experience managing an out of state property yourself? Are there any tips/services you use?

like

Having trouble selling my (retired) dad's house. It needs a lot of work, but has great character. What if I buy it myself for a low, low price? Then I would be able to get a FHA 203k loan to do the updates. Rent it out or put it back on the market in the spring.

like

Commercial real estate question. When a residential property will likely zone commercial in the coming years, do we, the owner, wait for a buyer/developer to contact us?

like

How did you decide where to live? Have a young family, working remote, and currently living in a city. Looking to move to the suburbs but a bit overwhelmed with the number of options. Also struggling since we don’t live close to family and don’t like the areas family members currently live in.

like

First time home buyer and I have no idea what I can afford. Excellent credit. I know to get a preauthorization before looking but want to skim homes the meantime. Any good rule of thumb when searching?

like

Has anyone used Loan Cabin to refinance? They seem to have the best rates.

like

Anyone in CA dealing with increased insurance costs on rental properties. AllState just increased my rates by 46% from last year. I had no claims what so ever. I am reading online that several other companies have raised their costs as well and wondering what others are seeing and if there is a preferred insurance provider for you.

like

I joined a real estate team & I was expected to show up at 9:00am sharp every single day. Is this a common team policy?

funnylike

I am moving to Charlotte, NC for a new job. I currently live in Portland, OR and have a single family home here. With my income, and current mortgage, I can afford a 350k house I’m Charlotte with about 10% down. What are the pros and cons of buying a new place in Charlotte and then sell my house in Portland?

like

For any of you real estate investors, what tools or sources did you learn from when getting started. Can’t find a mentor currently so want to find some highly recommended books or videos. If focused on the tri-state area (NY, NJ, Long Island mainly) that would be even better. My hope is to buy and rent out a apartment while also owning a house and house hacking that by renting part of it out. Trying to understand all the steps, traps, and how to find if it’s a good investment.

like

What's the best city in UK to buy a buy to let property, with best returns?

like

How might I start to evaluate whether or not it’s worth it to keep my current primary residence and turn it into a rental, instead of selling and using the cash to roll into the next down payment for our next home? Currently in our “starter home” and thinking to upgrade in a few years. Some figures to consider for current house - 299k purchase price, 240k left on mortgage, could prob rent for 2250-2500/month, or sell for 375k. It’s in a desired school district, but in the “city” tax district.

like

What rates are people getting for condos? I’m thinking about selling my condo (I had 3.25%) but my realtor said that the rates are so high now that if I were to buy a similarly priced place, the monthly payment would be like $800 more. I’m bad at math, so I wanted to ask here to confirm this is accurate. Mortgage is around $700k

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal