Currently a 3rd year Manager at K. Got an offer to join Oliver Wyman as an Associate. Interviewing at another Big 4 for Senior Manager. Thoughts appreciated on OW Associate vs Big 4 SM

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Although I don't know about the culture or career progression at OW. I would not make that mistake again of leaving a senior position to start from the scratch.

like

OW offers similar pay to MBB, comparable talent, just less breadth of industry. If you know what industry you want to work in, we do a handful of them extremely well. MBB is better branding if you’re looking to exit, but the differences in the day-to-day are likely to be negligible.

like

I see people make moves like this all the time and it never turns out well. Take the SM job somewhere else.

like

Thanks OW1. That’s good to know. Recruiter said usually they try to fast track experienced hires to EM. Also, I was told salaries are not that negotiable and most Associates come in around the same band. I am coming in at mid 100s.

like

Not sure how far you’ve progressed interviewing for SM roles at the other big4, but I know that we often advise 3rd year managers to make a lateral move to Deloitte... SM is a really hard level when you just join a firm: need to rebuild your network, build a pipeline, have significant sales targets off the bat... not that it can’t be done, but I would expect a manager role for at least a year (at Deloitte)

helpful

I wouldn't come here as an experienced hire. They don't fare well.

like

I moved from big 4 as SM to OW associate, and was promised all the fast track stuff as well by the recruiter.
But the truth is it’s really hard to come is an EH and perform well so easy to get stuck. But also the quality of work is far superior at ow so it’s understandable to be dropped from big 4 levels.

like

Tried for EM at OW, but they apparently bring people usually a level below. Care more about quality of work and eventual trajectory than intermediate salary

Are you coming in aligned to a practice? I would hope it’s at a higher Associate level, as the step down isn’t immaterial, especially when compared to your other SM option. What do the manager positions pay? Associates here make mid to high 100’s depending on level, I believe. You can make EM after 1 year as an Associate here if you’re good.

Yeah although I will say that we work pretty hard. I don’t know how old you are, but since you’re up for SM roles you might have family commitments or other priorities. Associates here can have it rough. Long term upside is probably higher here, but the SM role doesn’t sound bad at all, especially if you want out of the meatgrinder phase. I don’t mean to say it’s that bad, I still love it here and have done some sweet strategy work with some of the smartest people I know. The positives vastly outweigh the negatives.

Totally confused. What practice? Senior manager is two levels up compared to associate. Not even sure how to compare.

Digital Tech Ops and Analytics. I am equally confused. Working for OW was sort of a long term wish for me. But going from 3rd year M to an Associate is a bit bizarre.

Trade-off is quality, long term upside vs salary, work-life balance (not really that much work - life balance as a SM tbh)

SM is only two steps away from Partner if that is your goal. Also plenty of exit opps from SM at Big4.

Recruiter sold me the same shit "we promote experienced hires faster" and left a Manager position at a Big 4.

Why a dream to work for OW? I can understand for MBB. But OW? Great firm but not sure about the dream part. So as an associate are they paying more than 3Y KPMG manager?

I think the recruiter is blowing smoke

Seems like a step down if you're going from manager to associate even if its OW. Lateral to another big four firm to increase pay? Senior manager may be tough for the reasons listed above.

You should take the SM role. Why on earth would you want to go back to being a pleb? I don’t care how awesome whatever group you’re interviewing with at OW is, there is no way it’s worth it

No comparison! SM role

I vote tough it out as M a while longer and look for an M or SM role somewhere else as prestigious as OW.

Related Posts

I have a consulting/PE interview on Friday, please recommend consulting books or sites to read. Need to speak consulting language

like
like

Vodafone offered me 7 lpa for 3 yoe java , can I go for it or I will get better offer ?
How is work life balance Vodafone

like

Hello folks,

Just landed as a PR in Canada a month back.
Been interviewing for front end dev - 5YOE. Had been with Deloitte USI as a Consultant back in India. Applying for big 4's and tech firms but seems like they have been taking forever to review the applications (2-3 weeks now for few since applied!)

Have one offer from CGI as Sr.Con for 105k. Does anyone know how good/not good is CGI in terms of work, culture, WLB, perks?

Would appreciate any help in getting referred as well! Thank you

like

Anyone know the Deloitte GPS S&A bands for C and SC? Specifically for experienced hires, non-MBA masters, tech background.

like

Although Amazon has instituted a hiring freeze and layoffs are probably on their way, I went through the loop for a security engineer position at AWS. Before I attended the final interviews, Amazon placed the hiring freeze and called me to ask if I wanted to go ahead or cancel my application. I decided do go ahead Right now I'm waiting for their response and the position I applied to changed from "under consideration" to "no longer under consideration". Thoughts?

like

Why is HCL delaying the offer letter?

like

What aspects would you look at when interviewing a person for a Manager position?

like

Dell vs SAP labs which is better in terms of work?

like

Anyone work at Nvidia that I may be able to ask a few questions to about the company and it’s solutions / products just high level prior to my second round interview ?

What is the eligibility or time period needed to move from 6B to 7A in IBM? I have 4.7 years of experience and joined IBM recently in JL 6B.

Thanks in advance.

My final round with Deloitte for UK Tech Consulting Manager position soon. Strangely it’s not a PMD round as it usually is for other Big4/tech consulting firms.
1. Can anyone tell me if they’ve been through the whole process without speaking to PMD? (First round Sr Manager, second Case Interview by a manager and third again by a manager) 2. What is a typical salary to expect? I was asked in screening but kept it vague (e.g can discuss later bla bla). I was hoping 75-80 (ridiculous?)

like

Any idea what Deloitte and Accenture Strategy pay in Singapore at the Manager level (post MBA)?? Thanks!

like

How much in hand if 12 lpa package in TTL

like

I am joining IBM 7A Band as senior Application developer.How much time it takes to get band 7B. I wanted to know about band progression and % increment they give in that.IBM

like

I’m currently working in Citi as an AVP in Mumbai for the past 9 months.. due to personal reasons I wanted to move back to Pune (I have worked in Pune for last 8 years before coming to Citi) so I landed up with an offer from HSBC into Wholesale IT (GCB5).

My current Fixed CTC in Citi is 26.5 excluding PF and Retrials and HSBC IT has offered me 30.5 for the same and said they cannot increase further as am moving jobs in after 9 months which is too early..

Questions -
Have I been low balled?

like

Hello,

If I joined HCl and will have to leave within probation period, do I have to pay anything to HCL? Anyone has any idea. (There was no buyout of NP by HCL)

Thanks

like

More Posts

Would it be wild if I added my preferred gender pronouns to my signature? (He/his)

like

Does anyone have good book recommendations which talk about varying leadership styles?

like

Do you get notified when your computer ships?

like

Got an offer within Product Ops (Mt View) for L4, 145k base, 15% bonus, 185k equity (33/33/22/12), 15 sign on. One competing offer (that is lower) and only MBB promotion to Engagement manager in a few months as leverage point. Any fish guidance on how the offer fares up / how to proceed / what comp I should push for?

like

I am a 30yr old with a masters in finance and bachelor in Econ but I feel like I am not doing what I can to continue my education. I barely read but know I need to. Any page turning book recs that can get me start reading more?

Does anyone ever feel morally or ethically conflicted working in this space? Serious question.

like

Hi all, asking on behalf of my SO. He’s currently in a backend engineer security role and wants to move into an infra related one. He’s in talks with his manager about moving internally in his current company but that is still in discussion. He just got an offer from another company for an infra role but they need an answer in the next week. How do you guys suggest he push for a decision from his manager about the internal move. Should he tell his manager he has another offer?

like

Anyone familiar with SAG-AFTRA rules? If we’re on distant location, and it’s a 6-day work week. Is the 6th day paid at a premium rate?

like

What are the director level salaries of Product Manager in SF/Bay area?

like
like

Awkward question incoming! - What is the average salary for a mid-weight art director at an agency in the north of the UK? (Specifically keen to hear from anyone Leeds based!)

Hi Folks,
Few days back,I have received BGV mail from Oracle India, Can I expect the offer letter soon (or) it will be released post completion of BGV?

likehelpful

Does oracle has a office at Kolkata ? My current location is banglore , can I change my base location to Kolkata ?

If yes , what's the process ?

like

As a person who used to struggle with guilt I found this scripture to be so powerful and awesome. Have a blessed day! You matter!

Post Photo

We get our self worth from God. Blessings friends!

Post Photo
like

How to be an exceptional buddy to my intern?

like

From a UX Director... “Design is everything. You’re nothing without design.” Excuse me?

funny

Apparently I drunk ordered 4 Blanton's Golds last weekend. Just got the shipping notification 😂🤦🏼‍♂️

likefunny
like

Additional Posts in Consulting

How will the US come out of covid19? As an outsider they seem at greater risk then others: expensive healthcare, no sick days, homeless people, people who wont stay home... Thoughts?

likehelpful

Anyone work in PwC Strategy& ‘s Healthcare Tech Strategy or HIA Advocacy Transformation areas? Would love to get more insights on the culture!

like

Any good business/consulting books on amazon kindle that y’all have read that has helped you in your job?

like

Is anyone running a small nonprofit on the side in addition to consulting? I am planning to start one to carry out some of my passion work. (Any books, courses, places to start?)

like

Best consulting firms for PE work (CDD,Value Creation)? Looking for the best firm for exit ops to PE ops eventually. Thanks!

like

Best consulting firms for the retail and CPG industries?

like

Do you guys have Any good books on business? Not those self help books

like

If you know you’re leaving in 5 months for new job, can you slowly do less work to get severance?

funnylike

What does a manager have to demonstrate in order to get promoted to the next level?

likesmart

What's a good salary in CH for a Big4 for a Manager position? What benefits can be included?

like

Are alcoholic beverages free for those in delta comfort? Newbie to the status game. Help!

like

What’s the average age for making partner at the top consulting firms?

like

Do you make post tax contribution to your 401k account? In addition do you also do backdoor IRA. What are the limits?

like

@slalom
Whats the health insurance like? How much does Slalom pay towards the premium for individual/ do they pay for family?

like

Salesforce 🐟 : do you need to be at Salesforce a year before mat leave benefits kick in? Salesforce

like

Not sure if I am getting laid off. What are some key signs. Thanks in advance for your help?

like

What do you guys get your parents for gifts when they've said they don't need or want anything? My mom doesn't really have any hobbies... Or interests...

like

Is anyone from Nashville or know downtown Nashville well? If u had to stay at the sheraton grand or ac hotel which would u stay at and why? For location and for the property?

like

Starting a new job in industry tomorrow! Any last minute advice?

like

Got hired as a digital strategy consultant. I have over 10 years of industry experience but I’m new to consulting. What courses, workshops or books would you recommend to build a solid toolkit?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal