Do creative strategies for applying for a job ever work? I’m talking about the fearless girl in front of McCann, or any similar strategy.

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

If you have a cool idea, you have a cool idea. But yeah...the other 99% of us just put our books out there and hustle when it comes to networking.

No need for a tap dance routine to get yourself into our 80-hour per week industry.

like

If you have an idea you think is cool, go for it. All of this is super subjective. Everyone thought that idea of imitating fearless girl was horrific and pandering, except the CD at McCann...so really if you impress one person, it’s a success. That being said, if you go the crazy route, your book better be solid

like

Senior Copywriter 1: that idea didn't impress the CD. It put the whole agency in a position where they couldn't say no. They offered her a 60-day freelance spot for PR.

OP: creative stunts are hard. Most of them fail or leave a bad taste in everyone's mouth. Focus your energy on building a good book, building good relationships, and if you still think you need more, building a good side project that you can pimp to the trade pubs and CDs.

likesmarthelpful

When I was taking classes at SVA a copywriter came in and talked with us about the business. He and his art director partner created their books together; he did the writing, she took care of the art direction. He sent out a promotional piece, she did not. Within a week he had two offers. A year later she was still looking for a job. So if you have something that’s great and relevant send it out and follow up with a phone call or email. I followed his lead and it has worked for me. Good luck.

like

Probably, but I wouldn't recommend it. A lot of people are going to feel like you cheated and there are other ways to get CDs to look at your book.

like

They say that nothing kills a bad product faster than good advertising. The same is true with stunts. Sure they’re a great way to stand out, but if your book is not up to snuff it’s going to do you more harm than good.

Think of the stunt as the cherry on top of your solid portfolio. The thing that pushes them over the edge to say yes. My partner and I created a stunt tailored so specifically to the agency that we wanted to work at, that it actually gave us a head start on better projects when we got hired.

It’s a way to make yourself heard but you absolutely have to be able to back it up with solid work.

like

You should make a rap video, I heard that works wonders

likefunny

as long as your work backs up the gimmick, it’s fine

like

We only hear about the successes. Which are very rare.

like

Great! Thank you for the advice

Spend your time working on your book, not your gimmick. That’s what’s going to get you the job.

I don’t understand why you guys are shitting on the Sprite rap video. I think it was great and certainly did it’s job. Far more work and creativity went into that than the Fearless girl stunt.

Related Posts

Anyone interviewed for DoorDash strategy/ops senior associate positions? What’s their salary band? Asked about it and the hiring team person who reached out to me refused to share info, saying that a recruiter will share this info later in the process. LOL. I heard some lowballing offers from DoorDash and other bad recruiting practices too.

like

I work in ERP consulting on the technical side. Wanting to move into product. Would anybody be willing to give my resume a once-over?

like

Anyone know how the Master's in Financial Analytics is at Santa Clara University? I was thinking of applying there for a chance to break into senior finance roles in Silicon Valley/Bay Area.

like

Any idea fishes on what's the last client round in EY Parthenon for Deals Strategy - is it a experience discussion/fitment or a proper technical round.

YOE: 8 years
Poaition: Associate Manager

And what's the salary one can demand??

like

Campus visit (non interview) says to wear business casual. Jeans and dress shirt tucked ok?

like

Hi guys,
I am working since a year in my first job and I don't feel like I'm getting to learn much here or see any opportunities for growth. I am thinking about learning Salesforce development and applying for specific Salesforce jobs.
Either that or I will join another company as java developer.
Which of the two has better scope in the future, java development or Salesforce?
Any advice is appreciated.

like

Just interviewed for a job. Saw an old work friend in the lobby, and he shot me a message after we said hi, saying it’d be great to work in the same building again, "plus this new one has a bar.” 😣

like

McKinsey & Company McKinsey & Company
I applied to the consulting role after getting a referral. But seems like HR is taking too long ( Over 1.5 months now) to respond or reach out.
Any suggestions how can I expedite the application in the vetting process?

like

Interviewing with a recruiting firm. What is an “normal” base salary? TIA

like

Fishes, Anyone in recent days interviewed for Cisco Front end role on React ? Could you brief the technical round ? @cisco

like

What companies in India only take about 2-3 rounds of interview? Which companies have the quickest interviewing process in India?

(Especially for Data analyst / Data science roles)

like
like

Does anyone have Organization Design case study experience?? I’m hoping to get some insight to help prep for my Consultant interview in some days with Deloitte.

like

Hi all, Are JPMorgan interviews in person now or online? I applied for a post in Hyderabad.

like

I have an interview with an MBB for an knowledge management/specialist role. I currently work as a technology consultant for the advisory arm of a sub big 4 accounting firm. Cont.

like

I have a meeting with a CEO of a start-up IB. She is meeting to help guide me in the industry (not just a job interview). What questions would you ask?

like

Considering leaving my agency after just a couple months in pharma - feeling underutilized and stuck.

My question: do I leave this stint off my resume entirely? List the parent agency instead of the wellness arm? Pass it off as freelance? Not trying to be dishonest I just know this experience probably isn’t relevant when going out for non-pharma jobs.

like

How is interview process at Nvidia ? How many rounds for 11 yoe , sr. system s/w engineer role.

How much time nvidia takes to finish all interviews and if everything goes well how much time to release offer ?

I am done with 1st technical interview. 2 more technical round schedule. Which kind of questions to expect in 2nd & 3rd round ?

like

I have an experience of 8.3Yrs, current ctc 14lpa and i have an offer of 21.5lpa from tcs. My profile is python, django, docker and kubernetes. My technical rounds have been cleared in Capgemini. How much compensation should I ask for in my HR round?

More Posts

like

I am a Master’s Student who landed up with a Product Management internship. I am enjoying it and have done tasks that I thought were not my cup of tea. I want to continue with this role in future and would love to know experiences of other PMs. Also, any suggestions on how to prepare for PM full time opportunities?

I joined Accenture few days back as level 9. Till now didn't get any project. I have one more offer from another company and have not told them that I joined Accenture.
Should I wait for Accenture to allot me project or shall I abscond?
I am worried since I joined Accenture as level 9 team lead and what if they fire me? Or map to some irrelevant project?

like

Anyone relocated from Toronto to London recently (within the last 2 years or so)? My partner and I are contemplating the move...we want more diversity in our lives and want to work to live, not live to work as we do here in our respective consulting jobs. Folks who have made the switch, would you be open to sharing your experience? TIA

like

Guys please help me with 11 love on my profile to enable DM.

like

Looking for a accommodation (1 Person) in bangalore, near prestige tech park area..
Might be moving on or before 1 Aug..
Please let me know if anything has it???

like

What type of case studies are people getting when interviewing for Strategy roles? How about Finance? Are they the same style/depth as consulting case studies? Are the examples from as "Case in Point" or "Hacking the Case" a good representation? Going to start applying in the next month or two and want to brush up on my skills.

like

Organization Transformation / Change Management consultants who exited consulting, what roles have you taken on in the industry? I want to know what other options are out there.

like
like

Anyone joining Deloitte India on 19th September

like

Off topic - please suggest gift ideas to carry to India from UK?

like

What is CBO TTH drive recruitment in TCS?

like

I have an interview Bloomberg for sales and analytics, can anyone give insight to what to expect at the super day?

like

Hi everyone ,this is a broad career related question:

I am currently working as solution advisor in advisory at Deloitte(recently joined).

I have 2.7years of experience and have a CTC of 10.5 L currently.

It's a widely known that product based companies (like MAANG pays handsomely), for software engineer roles and that is what a lot of CS grads strive for ,this is true for MAANG and also a lot of startups,unicorns and other tech companies.

(Continued in the comments)

like

Fixed offered as 36 lpa. What shall be the inhand in CBA. TIA

like

Any ideas for teaching ESL students (especially those with very limited English and formal schooling skills, computer skills) virtually bc of the corona virus?

like

Is it a fail of character leaving biglaw? I want to leave, but despite the constant stress and suffering, I can’t avoid feeling like it’s my fault or that maybe I’m over exaggerating how I feel. All my colleagues feel ridiculously happy, I’m the grinch one that’s never enjoying the grind (but the grind is hard and competitive, very competitive) :( any thoughts? Is there future after quitting biglaw so young?

like

My firm’s holiday party is on a weekday after work. I can just wear what I’d normally wear to work for that day, right?

likefunny

So took FAR today, felt good about it. For the most part I felt questions were from stuff i ready and felt was easy. Now am not sure if I got everything of it but I also know1/2

like

I got 10lpa excluding gratuity and pf. What will be my in hand salary?

Additional Posts in Creatives

Ever see your rejected ideas win Grand Prix by other creatives? Seen it more than twice?

like

I do a lot of freelance that deals with collage incorporated into my design.
Is there any good sites to get free photos from?

I know about pixabay and unsplash but looking for random items!

like

I’m getting sick of getting a brief and asked to create a cool new campaign with amazing designs in less than a day. My best work isn’t turned around in less than 24 hours. And for background, I have pushed back literally every time. Nothing seems to be getting better.

like

What is your first great advertising memory?

like

How do you deal with a management that doesn't seem to have a concrete process in doing campaigns? (Continued)

How early is too early to ask about salary when interviewing? First meeting w HR? With the CDs/ECDs? Or do you have to wait all the way till the end? Just went through a long interview process only to find out they never had enough to hire me without me taking a pay cut 😭

like

I made an entire ad campaign against a green screen for a protective hand chalk company. Would love some feedback if you're curious.

like

Any book recos for creative leadership? I’m new to overseeing other creatives and would love to be good at it.

like

How much does a CCO in nyc make? I’ve got big plans once the world sees my creativity and need to know if it makes more sense to try to be a CCO or start my own company.

like

Feel like I wasted a year learning UX.
I'm a graphic designer with 8 years of experience in brand design and visual comm
Finished 2 certifications in ux design


But now if I apply to UX or UI design roles obviously I am not that experienced.
Which means I need to take a pay cut starting as a junior ux.

Are there any designers in the middle who add skills while they work like UX?

Which roles should I apply to now?
My expectations are atleast something between $90-110k 🇨🇦

Please advise.

like

Benefits of being a creative in house? Better hours? Is the pay the same?

likehelpful

Any Deutsch LA CDs out there who wouldn't mind perusing my portfolio? I hear you have some cw openings and I'd absolutely love to work with you and for Karen Costello. DM if so and thank you!

like

Pre and post production routines/tips/etc? Ive always worked with my CD on productions, but going into my first solo. Any tips? Thank you!

like

Are account people still trained to be a creative ally or has the entire industry pivoted to merely kissing client a**?

likefunny

Hey! Anybody have experience working on the Brand Innovation Lab at Amazon? Would love to hear your thoughts positive or negative

like

I love Instagram, I really do! But sometimes I feel that as a creative the thought of "sticking" to an aesthetic makes me cringe! I feel that art & inspo should be free flowing - not confined to a box

like

My coworker, who was my friend for a long time, has been lying to me, throwing me under the bus, and taking credit for my work and ideas. I have done more and worked harder than him but he was promoted. He failed a new client big time and I was asked to step in and save the relationship which I did in a big way. Why do I have to work so hard every day while he gets away with scraping by and plagiarizing? How do you deal with a coworker like that?

like

I'm redesigning my site and I'm sick of Squarepace. What are your favorite web designing platforms?

like

My ECD keeps changing our work before it goes to client and it's cost us making good work. Our books are suffering because he can't get his hands off the tools. Our books are only full of spec now.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal