Harvard MBA re-application. Is it better to apply this year with what feels like 80% of my best or next year with 100%? I am getting old and prefer this year but started my app and gmat learning late)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

ive been told by many - always when you feel your app is 100 ready

like

You need to apply this year. You’re about to age out for a consultant.

like

To understand the situation: Are you a re-applicant to HBS or a first-time applicant? Are you in the ‘HBS or bust’ camp? Why do you want an MBA?

The application is probably due in less than a month. If your application is done, just submit.
If you’re starting now or have a lot to do on your app, I might not bother unless you can definitely put together an app with more confidence. If you are set on an MBA, maybe add other short/later deadline apps for schools you’d also attend. Unless you’re international or military, you’re getting kind of old for an MBA. Waiting to apply next year means matriculating as a 31 year-old.

like

I mean “Harvard MBA” means something. Frankly even I don’t know the gravitas of “Harvard Extension”

Not trying to say C1 or M1 is wrong but OP's question was 80/100 now vs 100/100 next year. I do agree that age bias exists and is a main factor in app process and if OP is at 95 or 98 ready now then this year will be a better choice, albeit a marginal advantage. But if it is at 80/100, no question you wait and make it better esp. if it is HBS or bust.

Remember, it is already tough enough to get into HBS and you see posts from all these top talents getting dinged yesterday so make it unique and more competitive, if you can. You won't go from 50% chance of getting in to 5% just because you waited 1 year. Can it be 50% to 40% or 35%? Sure. But you can also make it up by making your app stronger and more competitive.

like

I’m assuming 80% is just a not fully polished application.

If the core of the essays/story isn’t there or the GMAT isn’t there, that’s a whole different story. that application would not be ready at all.

Honestly it’s surprising that OP has left this all to the last moment since it sounds like this has been THE plan for a long time. So you’re probably right haha.

How bad is the age discrimination in consulting can anyone explain? I’m 31 and plan to go for an top MBA at the age of 33

like

You’re fine if you look young enough to fit in with everyone else. Otherwise you’ll stick out in recruiting.

Ok. But assuming you get rejected this year. Chances of success reapplying the next year is what? I.e. what specific mechanisms or criteria will there be to limit success on next year re app?

Next year - too late this year

Related Posts

like

Any other round 1 Kellogg fish reading too much into this email from FinAid to apply for a scholarship? I know it says app still being reviewed but I want it to mean “you’re in, apply 4 scholarship”

like

Need some guidance. Here is my situation:
1. Just transferred to big 4 FDD as snr from big4 audit (~a month ago, with no deal yet under my belt)
2. Studying for fmva certification
3. 1+ year plan is to take the GMAT & apply to ivy league mba program. Planning to break into IB and then PE later.
4. Got approach recently by a recruiter from Houlihan Lokey (HL) for an associate position in the Midwest. Comp range 120k -130k. I make about 100k now.
- Is the move going to be worth it? what'd you do

like

Hello, licensed architect & NCIDQ-certified ID here. Curious what you all have done (beyond licensure & certification) to boost your salary most effectively? Currently bringing in $67k with 6 years of postgrad experience which feels…….low. Are my expectations too high??

like

I’m a defense-side employment attorney with 5-7 years of mid- to large firm experience. What would it take to pivot to an employee relations-type position? MBA? MHRM? Come as I am?

like

Which resume line would provide better signaling of talent to employers?

MBB? Or a mid cap VC ($500 AUM, not a name brand like Sequoia). Post MBA level at both, no promotions assumed. Not necessarily focused on future VC path over the long term, but interested in experimenting.

like

Georgia Tech Cybersecurity masters or the analytics masters? Currently in a cyber role at Deloitte. I was thinking it might be better to do the analytics master and get a CISSP. I feel like there is more value in the cissp than a MS cybersecurity

like

Book recommendations for 6th grade?

Hi fishes,

Needed suggestions from you guys. Currently I am working in TCS,having 1.2 years of experience with CTC 7.5 lpa. I am confused if I need to do M.tech or MBA or just do company switch after some time periods. Which will be more efficient in salary perspective?

Whether I should do m.tech in cs or mba in HR or just keep on switching?

like

To keep it general across tier 1 consulting firms...what would be the typical pay band for a practitioner with ~6 years experience and a MBA

like
like

Hello, I am a junior business administrator working in advisory operations. I have been with the company for 6 months, and was employed along with 2 other colleagues. I have picked the job up really fast and am even doing some “extra curricula’s” I really love my job. However I have recently found out I am being paid the same as an apprentice on my team, I usually do at 3 x the work he does whilst also doing my Cert CII. It has really disheartened me and I feel I should be earning more money

like

Hi fishes,
I am currently working as a Data Science Analyst in Amex and would like to make a switch to Fraud detection/Credit risk modelling in future.(not in a hurry but would like to start preparing for the same)
How should I go about preparing for it? Is MBA the only course?
My current tech stack is Python, Pyspark, Hive, SQL, ML, DL(specifically NLP based). I have already done MS in CS from IIT Kgp.
I am confused mainly cause the tech stack requirement is similar to my role in the company.

like

Are there any roles for non technical people at companies like Mastercard and Visa?

Currently I am working at a Fintech product company.
MBA with current package of 11.5 lpa
And my skill sets include SQL, ms office, data analysis, data mining, SAS, Hive, Power BI
Mastercard

Hello, I’m a Physical Therapist (DPT) and am considering going back to school for my MBA. I’m hoping to pivot out of patient care and into a more corporate/leadership role. Is there anyone here with a similar background? Any insights as far as opportunities an MBA could afford for someone like myself? Thank you

likeuplifting

Do you have to have an MBA to get a job at Big4? I'm trying to get into Deloitte.

like

Just looked up a firm a recruiter told me about. I would be the only Latino on the roster and among the few that didn’t go to an Ivy League or top 20 law school. I don’t even know if I should bother applying...

like
like

Hey hub, I just exited a web 3 startup after monetizing them while overseeing business systems and revenue operations and GTM I am looking for my next major gig. If anyone wants my skills I’m solo now. Message me. I have 15 years in high tech and 10 years industrial with backgrounds in military and an mba. it could be gig work, contract, or a temp role, I can help you hire and build your roadmap to making money. Thx!

Can you typically negotiate post MBA consulting offers?

likehelpful

More Posts

Does Deloitte Canada do the collective disconnect over Christmas like the US?

like

Folks who use dog walkers - how much do you pay & what’s your city? What’s a fair price?

like

I've been a government attorney for nearly three years now and have worked in the same office/division since I passed the bar. I've yet to receive a promotion other than two cost of living increases (in sum, a pay increase of 6k over 3 years). I know this is meager, but I'm mostly ok with it, I just want to see some recognition. On the other hand, it's hard for me to imagine negotiating because (given my inexperience), I don't feel I'd be able to do better anywhere else. Any advice?

like

What goes though you mind when thinking about quitting consulting ? Considering a move to industry

like

Hi all,
I need your favour here.
Do anyone has job referral for Business Analyst profile?

About me: 3.4yrs of workex-
Worked as a Sales Manager and across sales-Ops. 75% Team management+ 25% Data analysis and interpretation
Want to shift towards more data driven role.
I know advance Excel and SQL fundamentals.
Last drawn Ctc: 14lpa fixed

Any leads/suggestions would be helpful.

Thankyou :-)

like

Anyone know of any stores in Chicago that buy used furniture? I have a massive and heavy executive desk I want to sell that will require movers to transfer, so I feel like I can’t go the usual routes of Facebook and Craigslist with much success. Any recs would be SO appreciated!

Post Photo
like

Share your worst client experience? New hire here, just led a bad meeting. 🥵

like

How is stay at home going to be enforced? Can I drive and pick up takeout and curb side shopping?

like

Hi Members, 

I am a supply chain professional with 10 years of experience in supply chain operations and program management in e-commerce, telecom, and 3PL distribution companies. 

I immigrated to Canada 2 years ago and worked with Amazon Canada for last 1.5 years. I recently lost my job and looking for a new job opportunity. 

I have completed my CSCP and PMP certification 

I would appreciate any leads or referrals.

Is Accenture canada expected to do layoffs?

like

Just want to say this is such a thoughtful bowl. Great responses, lots of questions on self improvement, sharing of resources. Love UX guys #empathy

like

Is anyone else having doubts about starting their side hustle business? I’m struggling with taking that leap! I’m def not quitting my job though lol

like

What do when you’ve already accepted a job offer but then received a better offer? Does it look bad on you to decline the first offer?

like

Q. What did Jesus mean by “ He said to them, “This is what I told you while I was still with you:Everything must be fulfilled that is written about me in the Law of Moses, the Prophets and the Psalms.” Luke 24:44? I know the prophets shared about Jesus but what exactly was written about him in the law of Moses and Psalms?

like

Hi folks! If I quit this week, will I still get my bonus? (My LWD will be around September 26-27)

like

Thoughts on HOL? Seems like an interesting space play and I’m sure will be targeted by ARKX

What are the latest SPACs to buy? Why has there been no activity in this bowl for six months?

Do you tell corporate industry recruiter how much you currently making if asked (and stressed on knowing). I told them the number then also said I want at least 10-15% bump from that #, sounds like...

What do leadership development or management development programs pay out of MBA. Thinking of leaving consulting and want to see how my current exits compare with what MBA grads get in typical F500 gigs.

like

Any director’s currently traveling 100% right now? If yes, how often?

like

Additional Posts in MBA Applicants

do schools even consider the IR and AWA sections if they dont factor into score?

like

Started as consultant, then promoted to SC. But my responsibilities were pretty much the same. Should I break these out in my resume as two separate roles with separate descriptions?

like

Chin up to all my fellow HBS dings out there. It was a tough year. Congrats to all who were invited! 🍻

likeuplifting

I know that people say it’s all about story, but with a certain gpa/gmat score is there a “floor” that you’re safe on? For example would someone with 4.0/780 (not me) be pretty much assured at least 1 M7? Or is there a reasonable chance that all M7s will reject them? Or is their floor just lower (T15 for example)?

like

TTP Properties of Numbers is kicking my ass. Any helpful tips/tricks to remembering all the rules?

like

Do I need to submit transcripts from my study abroad institution?

like

M7 part time vs top 25-30 full time for career pivots and network?

like

Anyone selling magoosh access? Both math and verbal

like

Anyone heard of/done the PowerMBA? How was it? Was it worth it? Should I just go to proper b school, overpricing & all...?

like

In one month is my mid term review.. Should I let my mentor know I'm applying for mba this year now or should I wait till after the review session? I'm afraid mentioning going to b school would hurt my "fast promotion". What's your guy's experience? :)

like

Opinions on the INSEAD-Wharton Alliance?

like

How useful is sponsorship as a negotiating lever for full-time roles? I realistically do not see myself going back to consulting after B school. I have to stay for 3-4 more months to keep my sponsorship but starting to seriously consider quitting ASAP

like

What is your plan B if you don’t get into any of the schools you have applied to? I don’t have one

likehelpful

Enrolled in Stern for a few weeks.
The number of the alumni and current students that go to top consulting firms FT& summer intern are countless even for a small class size.
Stern is way more than a finance school. Given its location, do you want to spend your 2 years in a rural area or heart of Manhattan? Location is almost everything for business school. (I have a friend in Cornell that frequently travels about 5 hours to NYC for events.)

like

Anyone felt their Wharton TBD went poorly (or average)? Hope I am not the only one who felt that way.

like

Anyone here have experience / know anyone who did the Luxury & Fashion Retail MBA @ NYU Stern?

like

Does anyone have a helpful recommenders guide I could give to my recommenders?

like

Got a 690 gmat, should I retake? Plan to apply for part-time HaaS next year.

like

Any advice on where to find the best “profile guides” for the top MBA programs? I find that the school descriptions on poets and quants are a bit outdated.

like

Did you use admissions consultants? Who was it and was he/she worth it? Advice on selecting one?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal