Hi! I’m feeling super bummed out as I got rejected for a job over an internal candidate. The interviews went really well and I felt like I connected with the hiring manager but here we are. I can’t help but feel like a failure, this has happened a few times now. I feel like there’s a reason why I’m getting to the final stages but passed over.
I’m trying to dig and see what I can do better for next time. How are you all upgrading your skill set?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

You're not a failure! It sounds like you are doing the best you can, it's just the job market is so fierce right now. When one position has hundreds of candidates and apps, it's tough to set yourself apart. You'll get there, I know it's frustrating as hell, but you can't give up. Each one you don't get just leads you closer to the position you are meant to get. Good luck. I wish I had more you could do.

like

Some ideas: 1. when you first get in touch with the hiring manager, ask them if the position is open for internal candidates, if yes, ask specifically what they are looking from when sourcing external candidates. 2. as for the feedback, ask them after the interview. 3. it's ok to fall, that's how we learned to stand up and walk and finally get us to places.

like

If you were in direct competition with an internal candidate, then you shouldn't over analyze. Being a competition with someone from inside the company give the other candidate an immeasurable advantage. The match up was just not fair, nothing you could about it

like

Hey please message me I have something that might interest you.

like

Hi! I’m not sure how to direct message here. I don’t see an option for that

Sometimes we may not be the right fit. I can tell you for the longest I had my resume up on indeed and I would apply to so many different positions and I would never hear back from anything. I was to say in the last few months of looking for another position my resume has been on fire after I made a few tweaks. I’m back in school earning my bachelors, and immediately after I will go into my masters. Look at the positions that you’re applying to and see if there are any skills that you’re lacking. Sometimes when they promote within it simply because the company may not want to take the time to acclimate someone into the position. Stay positive, what’s meant for you will not pass you.

like

First of all, you are NOT a failure, why dont you think of it as they dont deserve you so your value is hidden from them for a reason and the right opportunity might miss u if you worked with them. Second of all, yes its a stupid tough market so just apply and learn as much as you can. Good luck!

Don't be too hard on yourself! You made it to the final stages which means you're doing something right. Sometimes internal candidates just have that edge, but it doesn't diminish your worth or abilities.

I’ve heard from others internal candidates being hired over externals are common. Businesses should do an internal search first before posting their openings on job boards but IDK why they don’t. But this means it wasn’t your fault! Keep doing what you’re doing and try to get a referral for your next application. That will give you an edge over candidates who don’t have one

happened to me before. and this one company I was the internal candidate and I beat out the external candidate luckily. they did this to keep it fair but i as the internal candidate had been doing the work for 2 months. later i came to find out if they really like you, they will make you apply thru the job board but they can advertise that it's for internal candidates only. i never got that respect. sucks

Related Posts

Is RPA a bubble and will soon fade away? How much valuable is it as a skill set?

Best way to get ahead in software engineering? Learning additional skills? Really curious if anyone here made a big income jump through making any particular kind of change

like

So, I landed a Customer Service Advisor job at Sitel in the UK. But I heard that they fire you without any prior notice or end their campaigns abruptly, leaving us with no job. Can’t be facing the risk of no livelihood, right? Can anyone who worked with Sitel give me the real truth? And does Sitel sponsor Tier 2 Visas as such? I am surely looking for stability, security and growth.

like

Hi there, I will be completing 1 yoe in May 2022 and looking to join MBB's. My key skills are Aletryx, SQL, Excel with VBA, R, Python, Tableau, and Power BI. I am looking for some guidance from people working in Analyst roles at MBBs.

like

Any help would be appreciated.

My current tech stack is Microsoft Powerapps, PowerBI, Powerautomate administration.
But when I search to switch jobs in the same, the options are very less. Why? Can anyone suggest? or, what exactly should I search for related jobs?

Should i change my domain? or, Should i study something else in the same domain to get jobs???

YOE:2 yrs

like

I am a ServiceNow Developer and want to switch the domain. Confused about which one to choose. Can any please suggest some good domains.

Hi all, what’s a good career path after consulting? Where would you all go as your next step?

like

Is TAG to M&A Tax a typical/feasible exit opp after experience?

likefunny

Hi Sharks, I have received the following offers from Infosys -13lpa ,@techmahindra-16lpa
No offers in hand but got selected in following compaies
@wonderbiz
@chubb
@valuelabs
@trianz

Can you suggest which company offers better career growth?

like

Hi 🐟 s,

is there a way for tech consultants to become partner ? i am sure there would be but what would be the fastest ? is the bowl reckon quick shifts or sticking to the way on top .
love to know if there are any experiences .

like

What is sales engineering? And how does one get into it?

like

Hi all,
I have been a practicing DPT (doctor of physical therapy) for 9 years and am a certified orthopedic specialist. I have worked in multiple environments including hospital based outpatient sports ortho and acute care. I am about to finish up my MBA with a focus on healthcare administration, and am worried that my current place of work may not have a place for me to grow into. I'm hoping that some of you may have suggestions of roles or positions to pursue? Thank you!

like

Hello Everyone!
Looking for inputs on ballpark compensation for a professional in Deloitte Netherlands.
Y.O.E - 5.5 yrs
Current Designation - Sr. Consultant
Service Line - Cybersecurity
Specialization - Cloud Security
Master's Degree (MBA)

Should I target Sr. Con. Or Junior Manager?

Currently with a Non-EU D member firm.
Any info is highly appreciated.
Thanks in advance.

like

Has anyone passed the Oracle GL 2021 exam yet ?

like

Is Wall Street prep worth it to help break into IB?

like

Is it a viable option to make a move from big4 audit to big4 corporate finance division?

like

How many of you have quit without another job. Did you regret that decision?

like

Not in my 30s or 40s but looking to network with people in industry. I am a fun person so you will not get bored :)

like

I am a field engineer II. I have 12 years of experience and I also have a master's degree. I am currently studying for a doctorate. Do you think I am up to the task of providing services as a consultant while I obtain my doctorate degree?

like

My dilemma… I am an injury adjuster at a carrier experiencing high inventory that’s barely manageable. A competitor offered a higher salary and manageable workload. BUT, I would like to get into underwriting. I applied for UW position w/ a different carrier and they’ve made an offer. It’s lower than my current salary and significantly lower than what I’d make by taking the first offer. Do I take the high salary and stay in claims or go for UW in hopes it will be best in long run?

like

More Posts

Why would a luxury watch brand make/sell connected or smart watches? What is the business reason for it? To me it just kills the brand value. For instance I was a big fan of Montblanc but after I see their smart watch line up I instantly devalued the brand in general. Same for Tag (tag is questionable anyways), or Breitling. What is your opinion on this topic?

like

New to this....best place to buy a Rolex submariner for under 9k online. Also, really like the look of the Rolex explorer II, but have always wanted a sub. Any thoughts or recommendations on submariner or explorer II?

funny

Alright, this is a different one. Anyone know what watch Greg from this season of the Bachelor is wearing? Shout out to everyone getting through this cringe fest of a show

Post Photo
like

2YOE life sciences consulting after mba as consultant with managerial duties and am given senior associate consultant role with lower comp. Would you pursue final interview with them or move on?

like

When I am looking at an email attachment in Outlook it shows the Google Chrome logo but when I open, it opens in Adobe which is what I want. Even though it is opening an Adobe, my boss would like it to show the Adobe icon instead of chrome next to the attachment… anyone know how to do this ?

like

Currently going through some negations on an internal role. I’m currently at 88k and they offered me 100k for a position that requires a lot more work. Do you guys think it’s easier to land a higher salary when applying externally rather than internally? Also this is for a territory sales management role. They stated 120k+ is extremely high for that role. What do you guys think? Playing the game?

like

What are good exit opportunities or things to move onto after becoming CRA?

like

Hi Fishes,

Is S&P planning to open offices?

like

Can we all agree that gender reveal parties are an annoying thing to subject your friends to?

likefunny

Transferring to the century city office of my firm. Would really appreciate neighborhood recs!

likesmart

Any insight into hours/culture at WilmerHale in LA? specifically in lit.

like

Marcus just cut their APY rate to 1.55%, down from 1.7%.

Post Photo
like

SO and I are debating contributing to 401k this year since the rate of return is around -11% on our portfolios this year. I believe it would be better off saving the cash in my account.

I'm thinking of contributing again when/if the market picks up next year. Thoughts?

funnylike

I broke through the wall in 2020 and feel like I blinked and it is 2022. I have been saving something close to 75% of my take home and dumping into ETFs. I feel like I want to branch out into real-estate but never lived anywhere more that 3 years. What would you do? I have cash to put a large down payment to avoid the high rates but am scared I have no roots and will move in another few years.

Post Photo
likeupliftingfunny
like

Do you still implement reference checks (on top of background checks)? I’m not convinced of the value add to the selection process and it takes a lot of time and resources

like

I am going to move in the next few month to a location with a higher cost of living due to personal circumstances. I love my current company but I’ve only been here a little over a month, how should I go about requesting if it’s possible to get a salary increase? Might be a stretch but thought it might be worth mentioning.

like

Best tips for studying/prepping for case interviews? I am overwhelmed.

like

Nagarro car rental
Hi Nagarrians, Can I give an account number of a different person and the bill/ RC of other?
I don't want to give the account number of same person of whose RC I have given..

Please help out a newbie here.
TIA

like

Hi All,

I have 7 years of experience in Frontemd (Angular,Vue) Development.. Have hands on Dotnet and NodeJS as well
Can anyone please refer me for
Mumbai location?

Additional Posts in Product Marketing

like

Trading Event Sponsorship for Party Rentals! Hey everyone - as a nonprofit we are having an upcoming event and having sponsors for it. We don’t have a huge budget so we are looking to ‘trade’ these sponsorships for table/chair rentals. Since we are a nonprofit are we able to give them the deduction value to claim on their taxes?

like

Any good books or articles worth reading on product marketing and analytics? I come from more of a technical and general product management background, so I personally feel like I lack on the marketing side. Like Search engine optimization, etc. Thank you.

like

I have an offer from TikTok and Microsoft. TikTok is higher pay but worried about work life balance. Both jobs are product marketing. Help!!! Should I go for the $$$$?

like

On Amazon, a role’s title is Sr. Manager but when reading the job description it says Senior Program Manager. Does that mean the salary will be that of a Senior Program Manager (L6)?
Amazon

like

I’m so new to product marketing- was hired as a subject matter expert. I feel like I’m winging it like 85% of the time. Can anyone recommend resources or somewhere I can look to learn more and get up to speed?

like

What should I pay a part time PMM at a Series A funded, Y Combinator-backed Fintech SaaS startup working 20 hours a week whose job it is to assist the CMO (me) with setting up and managing a product marketing function? This person will be the 7th hire, the second marketer, and will grow into a full time role (if they want it) as we scale. I myself just completed PMA's Product Marketing Core Cert, but I can't do it all myself and run Demand Gen and Mar Ops. Also HM experience should I require?

like

any insight into how a pmm skillset is different from a brand strategist one? of course the pmm applies insights to and influences the product, but it seems like a lot of the core elements - research, understanding the user, generating insights, developing messaging and angles to speak to them, etc are super similar. interested in transitioning and I want to understand where my gaps are!

like

Any suggestions on how to answer these interview questions? Thanks!

1. Tell me how you would hold the line and push back against leadership.
2. How would you increase your CLV, among e-commerce advertisers?
3. What are the biggest challenges marketers face today?

like

Looking for creative ways to generate demand for demos that don’t require big ad spend - any advice or tactics you’ve done to great success? (SaaS product in niche industry)

like

I just got an offer from a company that I have mixed feelings about. Team seems great but Glassdoor reviews, not so much. I’m currently interviewing with a couple of other companies that are amazing and would be my too choices. However, I’m very early in the process so it will probably take a month or so to get to the offer stage with them. I don’t want to fall between two chairs for not taking this offer and then not getting any from other companies. What should I do? Best strategy?

like

Who does the Director of Product Marketing typically report to (besides the CEO in tiny startups) ? VP of Marketing? I can't imagine it would be housed under Product/Engineering...

like

I’m interviewing for a Manager role at PayPal in the product management department and wondering how much of a salary I should ask. I am a woman and POC so I don’t want to fall into the trap of asking for/getting paid less than I’m worth. All insights welcome!!

like

Has anyone ever built a voice of the customer program? Want to hear about your experience: processes and tools put in place, stakeholders involved, how to socialize findings. Thanks!

like

Started a marketing company trying to figure out how to actually get my clients on the first page on Google. Any advice?

I have my first interview for a PMM role coming up on Tuesday at a tech startup. Would love some insight into a typical interview. What questions can I expect?

like

Hi everyone! In your experience, what is the one tool / must-have / methodology any of your companies use to bring about a cohesive and comprehensive go-to-market strategy in the launch of new products and services? As a company scales, coordinating cross-functionally and across time zones is becoming increasingly challenging so we have identified that we need frameworks or tools to help us go-to-market in a less clumsy, more coordinated fashion. Would love to get your ideas on this.

like

Should I take this role?
Pros: 50k bump, company is full remote, no time tracking software, unlimited PTO, 10k in quarterly bonuses, vertical move in responsibility and title, will set me up for future roles in different companies with the title I am looking for (so strategic move)

Cons: Its a startup, the solution they offer is adjacent to my desired industry, its a very small team so I wouldn’t grow my network as much, tech stipend for new laptop (but they don’t provide a work one)

like

I'm two thirds through the PMA Core Certification, and the info is great but the tests are a joke. They need to contract with an educator that specializes in testing and assessment to come in and develop exams that actually measure if you know the material. The bad test design devalues the certification. Not to zero, but I definitely will not be proud to have earned it. It just means I had $1300 and sat through 15 hours of video lectures.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal