I’m so tired of the incompetent recruiters out there that don’t even pick up the phone, only communicate through email, let you go through three rounds of interviews without asking you how any of them went so together you could call out any ways to insure it’s a lock. It’s like they are just flipping houses. So frustrating. Why do we need them again? The bad ones I mean at most large firms. My indy recruiters are the best. Ugh.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Recruiters are one of the least prioritized jobs by agencies in terms of competence. At the end of the day, they'll find someone management is satisfied with.

Most of them have no idea how advertising works, they wouldn't know a good campaign if it took a dump on their doorstep. Since they're dealing with people who are neither employees or clients, they can be terrible at communicating, ghost you, waste your time, and never get reprimanded (or even known) for doing it. Agencies hire young, cheap recruiters with low experience to keep salary costs down.

I worked at a shop where the recruiters had "cheat-sheets" that was just a list of agency names in one column and awards in the other. They'd match-up resume details with the sheet, and if there were no connecting dots, your resume went in the trash.

Indy recruiters are far better because they have to know what they're doing to be placing people in ad-industry jobs. General recruiters hired at the McCanns or Ogilvys of the industry just need to know how to open an email.

This is also why so many agencies get bad talent, you can't judge a person solely on those minor details.

Look at places like W+K, most of their recruiters are old as hell, have a history in the industry in one form or another, and know exactly what to look for. That's how W+K manages to consistently hire "no-names" with mediocre-looking resumes who end up doing absolutely fantastic work. The recruiters know what they need to look for in good talent, and the resume isn't the holy grail

WK call me plz 🥺

like

Creative Circle and Robert Half are scams. Don't bother

WK doesn't *only* hire nobody's. But I know a few folks who came from some small local shop or mediocre agency who got in and shined, and they have colleagues who are in the same boat. I've rarely worked with folks in those same backgrounds at my half-decent Y&Rs and Publicis' of the world.

Nobody who would be good at recruiting chooses to be a recruiter for a career.

like

Related Posts

Hey guys, I have the first short 15-minutes call with a product guy from Hugging Face today wherein he is likely going to take a guess at what roles I could be suitable for. I had applied for Post-Sale Machine Learning solutions Engineer. Is there anyone who’s gone through the process for a similar role at similar organisations or best case scenario would be if anyone has gone through the process with HF.
I have been working for a year and am doubtful if I’m mature enough for the role. Help lol

like

How to tackle gap periods in IT interviews?

like

Any tips on how to approach a life story interview at Shopify? I heard it's a one hour long conversation that touches upon personal and professional experience.

like

Hi Everyone,
Is it only me or are you guys not getting enough calls from recruiters nowadays?
I mean it used to be a good rate during May/ early June but it has reduced drastically.
Any ideas? Is it due to economic slowdown? Or something else?

like
like

Hi Guyz,

I went through the entire recruitment process and got selected for IBM ISL. Now I am being told by the HR that they are unable to release offer as there is a hiring freeze.

Can any one please tell me if its correct or just an excuse not to give me offer. If its true, when will this freeze be removed?

like

If you are in an interview, please take time off for the interview and not do your work in parallel with your interview

like

Hi, fishes.
A quick query here.

I'm going to move from non IT profile to IT profile. Basically I'll be applying as front end engineer in new company. Previously I was working in a BPO profile.
Just wanted to ask if I'll be provided training in my initial months as a front end engineer or am I expected to work from the very first day.
Your comments will be really helpful.

Thank you.

What does it mean when you still see a job link being re-posted, after you’ve had several rounds of seemingly positive interviews for that specific job?

like
like

Need to put down references for an interview but don’t really want to disclose that I’m searching for a new job. Any advice?

like

Hi guys in Accenture, myCompetency, for Primary Skill assessment is there any proctor checking or it's just an assessment without any proctor or supervision?

like

Can we refer someone in Optum if they are unknown to us and reach out to us on linked in ?
Mostly are freshers who are reaching.
Also is there any limit for number of referrals which we can make

like

Guys.. just a headup.. dnt join epam anywhere .. they dnt have projects.. they are re-evaluating people again .. same technical interview of 1.5 hours ... Not sure wat is the outcome of the technical interview after geeting offer letter n joining epam.

like

How do you politely tell a recruiter that you do not offer “holds”

funnylike

I have a friend who was let go a few months into his first job after college (reason: the manager felt like he wasn't grasping the training content to the level that was expected). He's worried about if he should put the experience on his resume anyway, if he does will recruiters ask why he had such a short time at this place, and what will recruiters think if he explains he was let go. What are some things recruiters expect from candidates in this situation to continue considering them?

How many days does it take to receive the offer letter?
Last Thursday HR confirmed my selection.

like

Guys, I interviewed at amex gurgaon 10days ago and was told by VP that I will hear from HR very soon. But when I checked on HR yesterday, she said interviews are still in progress and it will take a week more to finalize.
I want to know do they take this long to close a position? This opening was posted on 30th Sep.. It's already been 1.5 months. This is when they said the position was urgent!! 🙄

like

How does the project/client interview goes for frontend developers in EPAM Anywhere ?

Are these difficult to crack? What sort of questions do they generally ask?

like

Can anyone please share the interview process for Epam ? What questions are asked? What topics to cover?

like

More Posts

Anyone know if the wellness subsidy would cover an office chair? Or does D cover office supplies or nah? Looking to upgrade my home office. Thx!

like

What is loan staffing project and non loan staffe project? Pros n cons for both?

like

Can someone explain how billable hours work? At a new agency and although I had to fill timesheets at my previous agencies, they were mainly used to ensure we weren’t over servicing a client/for setting the appropriate retainer for contract renewals. I asked ppl at my agency but haven’t gotten a proper explanation. I get the impression that billing to the agency admin code isn’t recommended, and my manager said he bills everything to client codes, but that doesn’t make sense to me .

like

Kingdly share your view fishes

Post Photo
like

I’m worried that my voice, communication style, and body language comes across as too effeminate for our straight clients and peers. I’m transitioning to sales now and am insecure that my personality and appearance may hinder sales gen? Client industry is very old school. Can LGBT partners//Ds/MDs chime in how they managed the same transition?

like

How tough is online test for azure data engineer profile for kpmg?

Any tips?

like

I want to get my masters in HR, but I also want to get my phr.. is it better to get one over the other? Or should I do both. Are there any masters hr program someone can recommend?

like

Hi Fishies,

How much can i demand for having 3.5 Yr in Java, Springboot, Microservices knowledge. Current ctc is 11 LPA.

like

So I’m charging jobs due to unforeseen situations to another company as a assistant manager and I wanted to know is it unprofessional to turn down a job after you already accepted the offer to take another companies offer if the pay is better by $5000-?

likesmarthelpful

Anyone at BBDO willing to help push my resume / app along? Project Management role!

like

I have recently given interview at Microsoft.
HR provided the feedback as I am not rejected bit not fit for the role so they have put me in talent plus pool. What should I expect next and does this mean that I may get the offer ?

like

I have been working the same position for 5 years. But our job title has changed a few time I went from a pre registration rep to a verification specialist during my time there I want to branch out but not sure where to go from here. I have a bachelors in Health Science. 5 years experience dealing with patients, insurance, referral, data entry, etc.

like

Hi ,

Looking for a job change and interested to join and explore your career in Qualcomm with below jobs, please DM me.

Post Photo

Hi fishes I need your help. I joined a company 3 days back. Onboarding is completed. Now I have got offer from an organisation that is near my home town and ctc is also more. I want to join there. What should I do. FYI I checked service history in uan portal my pf account is not created yet for new organization. Need your humble opinion.

like

Random question, has the govt shutdown affected anyone’s work/business?

like

Why don't I have access to PwC managers group anymore?

Tomorrow i quit.
Gg wp.

like

Has anyone seen firing in Deloitte India? Is there any process or employees are fired directly like few companies?

like

Looking for insight on avg total comp for registered middle management with big bank. Considering making the jump from a branch advisor to managing a team of branch advisors. I’m newly 9/10 licensed. I’ve been building book in a bank branch but the consumer bank side of the job is draining. I’m making $155k total, $75k of that is salary. Anticipating a $130k salary offer if I go management route, with small annual bonus. Any others with experience that can speak to this?

like

Hey do SAP eliminate candidates in managerial round?
SAP

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Looking for agencies in the Bay Area and I'm not super familiar with the names at play. Places to check out? Places to avoid?

like

Anybody working with a client that is looking for content or has everyone just decided to rerun old work?

like

Remember this: you can only do one thing at a time. Make one decision at a time. Be in one meeting at a time. So for everyone overwhelmed about what they’ve got to do today, go out there and gettem!

likeuplifting

Any one else ever truly ruin your family’s holiday? Just me? Ok

like

Most beautiful places to escape within three hours' driving of NYC? Forests, lakes, ocean, camping.

like

Just found out there’s an ECD in a big NYC agency who claims to have won awards, but the name doesn’t pop up in any of the archives.

How do they get away with it?

like

How do you politely tell a recruiter that you do not offer “holds”

funnylike

Funny to see how men are trying to post shit about DMA...

like

Anyone have any good job searching strategies/tips? I'm losing motivation

like

How do you find joy in a business where you’re told “no” 100 times a day?

like

Any agencies that have a good reputation, but suck when you actually work there? Wonder why that happens?

like

Love when you get passed over for the client side job and subsequently get served their banner ads for months.

likefunny

Can someone explain how billable hours work? At a new agency and although I had to fill timesheets at my previous agencies, they were mainly used to ensure we weren’t over servicing a client/for setting the appropriate retainer for contract renewals. I asked ppl at my agency but haven’t gotten a proper explanation. I get the impression that billing to the agency admin code isn’t recommended, and my manager said he bills everything to client codes, but that doesn’t make sense to me .

like

We’re in such a vicious business. You give your heart & soul to an agency, a client, a brand. Then the wind changes & you’re laid off, reassigned, chewed up, spit out, on to the next. I’m tired.

like

Not to be an asshole BUT... why hire juniors if you are at a high level creative agency? (Stealing culture/ platform insights not withstanding )

like

The people behind Diet Madison Ave IG account are heroes

likeupliftinghelpful

The new Volvo commercials are 🔥🔥🔥

like

Which portable standing desk converters do people have and recommend. I live in a tiny NYC apartment so use my dining table as the office during the day but need to put it away at night.

like

Any word on Swift in Portland?

like

Hey is there anyone interested in starting an agency in NYC?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal