McKinsey & Company Is it normal for the IIT grads to simply reject other non-IIT candidates in the interview who are coming from some service based firm?

I feel like this is actually happening. I have faced it multiple times. Even after answering all the questions correctly, they simply reject the candidate without giving any reason.

Instances:
McKinsey & Company
Boston Consulting Group
Visa
Deloitte

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Personal bias can creep in hiring process. I feel training the interviewers on hiring process should be done by companies now. It won't eliminate such instances, but yes may reduce it to an extent.

like

I agree. Has happened with me as well. I interviewed for Udaan wherein they sent a 1 year exp ISB MBA grad to interview me, he himself wasn't sure about what he was asking and then trying to prove that my approach is wrong in case based interview. I never tried to interview for that company again.

like

Bloody personal insecurity.
When you observe this cut down the interview in shot and share the feedback to hr and post it review other platforms like Ambitionbox etc... Unsure of the results but it may help someone sometime.

like

Sure thing, buddy. I will write a review. It was for Visa though.

Oh yes, absolutely!! I dont care abt IIT, but that hot girl is definitely winning the interview race. Hands down.

like

Could be personal bias. But the most common reason is that the team might have found another candidate who's accepted the offer. It has happened with me in Bain & Amazon

like

Recruiter.

Biases exists everywhere but I would also suggest discuss your interview with friend/ mentor you trust and see if there are things you could improve upon. Sometimes it’s just coincidence!

like

I am quite confident about my answers. How do I know? My codes were able to pass all the test cases. He asked me to design a DB model and I did. I think may be he was a bit insecure or they just found someone else.

Academics can be looked for resume screening but you are in interview, its based on your experience and role fitment. You can ask Hr for detailed feedback

like

McK3: In McK, I got interviewed by 2 guys. 1 was an IIT grad and the other one was not. They asked me Spark, Kafka and DSA related questions which I was able to answer. I still don’t know why did they reject me.

Related Posts

Hey Fishbowl friends, Last Thursday I got laid off from my job. I am on h1b and now I have 57 days to find a job or I will be out of status. If you or anybody in your contacts is hiring for TPM, It project manager or similar roles please forward them to me.
Any other suggestion and help is really appreciated.

like

I just completed the interview process at CGI, the HR called thereafter saying that I've cleared all the rounds and they'd like to give me an offer. They also sent a couple of mails for required documents. But I am yet to receive the offer letter, is this usual?

like

I am hearing that MBB is pausing majority of the interviews - should I be worried about my offer getting rescinded? I luckily got my offer a few months ago and received my signing bonus already.

like
like

I’m a consultant with 3.5 years of experience at a fintech firm working in a professional services role. Looking to jump ship and pivot into a blockchain focused role/company ASAP however I haven’t got any blockchain experience unfortunately (started a course on coursera to become more familiar with it). Any suggestions on how to become yourself more marketable to a blockchain focused company when you don’t have blockchain experience? Or how to go about applying for such roles?

like

Does Chase Mortgage offer better mortgage and service? Just submitted an application, I think they're going to hit my credit report - wanted to be sure they're good enough and it's not for waste

I had very positive feedback on my interviews for a S&O role but the team hired someone internally. If I interview again for a differenr role, would I have to do all the interviews again or can I use some of the scores from previous interviews. I understand doing RRK again makes sense but what about GCA, googlyness or leadership . Thank you

like

Hi! I have been seriously applying for weeks upon weeks for a scrum master position/agile coach. But it’s hard getting an offer 😢

Folks , need help. Have 1 week this month for vacation and don’t know where to go, Hawaii is super expensive, any international spots with quick visa turnaround ?

Hi Fishes

I have 11 years of experience in PeopleSoft finance and I am looking for a switch in workday finance. May I kindly ask what learnings are must to get the workday interviews cleared?
Also Please let me know in case if there is any opening for workday where they are looking for any candidate from other ERP experience and ready to cross train on workday.

like

Hi Fisher ,
Can anyone guide me or provide the link for how to get job visa for UK or Europe from India, as I am getting job opportunities in UK but they are asking work visa for UK as the company where I am applying are not eager to sponsor my visa?

like

Starting soon in Boston but the the WFH situation was still TBD when I interviewed. Are there any updates on when everyone would need to go back to office full time in the U.S.?

like

Hi All,
I got an offer from a different vendor to join morgan stanley. I leveraged to offer to directly join morgan stanley. Will this cause an issue? Can the vendor complain about me? I have not joined the vendor. I had only given interview with morgan for 2 different profiles.

like

Hi guys, I am currently interviewing with Putnam Associates. I have a background in clinical studies for vaccines from a big pharmaco. Would love to have some tips for the case study interviews. Also, is it possible to get any referrals during the process? Thank you! Putnam Associates

like

Need advice on a specific question!
Interviewed with Chicago court 2 weeks ago; they decide mid-August. Interviewed with DC judge last week; hear from him by this Friday. Chicago said if I need an answer before August, they'd try to make a decision about me sooner.
Should I ask Chicago for an answer? Or should I wait until there's an offer from DC judge? Maybe seems better to withdraw before an offer is made rather than ask for time to think about it/turn down DC? What's proper etiquette?

like

Interviews with a private credit / direct lending / distressed real estate group have been going on for 6 weeks and now I’m waiting for the the final decision. They said that they’ll review the case studies and make a decision soon but does anyone know how soon :((( I’m so tired and exhausted and I really want the job so much. Technical was last week and last interview was yesterday. It’s a reputable American company - how likely is it that they’ll make a decision in 2 days?

like

Has anyone taken the SHRM-SCP? Any study suggestions and impressions of the test?

like

I just had a first round interview with BCG, I did ok in one of the interview and did great in the other one. What are my chances of moving to the next round? More info: Based in Canada, there are two 45 mins interview for first round.

likefunny
like

What’s the best way to format consulting experience on your resume? Project bullets with sub-bullets or one bullet per project? Trying to update and I’ve seen both, appreciate any help! (visual below)

Post Photo
like

More Posts

Pos wordle 4/21/2022 - 5/6
⬛️⬛️⬛️⬛️⬛️
⬛️🟨⬛️⬛️⬛️
⬛️⬛️⬛️🟨⬛️
⬛️⬛️🟩⬛️🟩
🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩

likefunny
like
like

CFA or CPA ? Anyone has both? Any benefits of having both instead of just focusing on one ?

Dear Microsoft Fishes,

How is work pressure in Level 58 support engineer roles.

Please put some light on the culture and work life balance.

My wife is a Software engineer - QA with 2 Yoe, now we are thinking to move to Canada, can someone please guide us on which 2 year course can she pick (for student visa), is data science related course a wise decision? Or how to find a QA related PG program.
Preferably in Victoria, British Columbia

For anyone who has run focus groups for an employer branding exercise, what questions did you find most impactful?

like

How much should be the salary for an events manager in FL? I handle global events

like

Hi fishes can you help with perks and benefits of joining maersk at Pune office.
Are there any reimbursement or work from home option available.

Hi,

If total CTC offered is 9LPA in TCS, what will be in hand salary ?

like
like

Does anyone recommend working in high pressure better salary(WFH IC Engineer role in a relatively big Financial services firm, but working hands of on many things that builds pressure) vs

job 2 or atleast offer (Senior Manager 3 days a months in office( Banking firm) minimum, people manager for 24/7 infra operations teams and new project)taking a salary cut of 8k in base and with better WLb( hr) says so in interview. I am too confused. On job security we all know we can't guarantee anything.

like

I’m a new consultant (8 months in) I’m working with a partner who is unresponsive but has high expectations (ex: it’s just the two of us and he wants an entire deck/analysis end-to-end). What to do?

like

JPMorgan Chase folks, how long does it take after accepting the offer/contract to getting contacted by the premployment screening team ? I have been waiting for a week now but I was told it is triggered automatically after 24hrs to 48 business hours after the acceptance. I have called my recruiter and they said I should check my spam folder which had nothing. Any indications here ?

like

Is it irrational for me to get an “ick” for this?

I went on a “date” recently. I paid for the tab as they were going to the bathroom. As we were leaving they said “thanks for lunch” — I was hoping they’d at least ask to Venmo me half as a kind gesture. Following lunch we grabbed dessert. I was hoping they’d offer to cover dessert since I covered lunch but it didn’t happen.

I am fine w/ paying but I was hoping the gesture would at least be presented… am I crazy?

like

Best part about being single: Not having to hold in my gas ! What is the best part of it for you??

likefunny

Do recruiters actually look at your education and early work life when you've reached a certain level of experience in the industry?

Is it even worth it to try and dispel the notion that ACAB?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting India

Hi guys, i have just joined Infosys and they have mapped me to work on Infosys Migration Platform but my interview was on JAVA and Springboot with REST. Should i talk to my HR regarding this or should I continue with whats given to me?

Is it advisable to switch from Support role to a Developer role after 6 years( This is a devloper role for a niche skill for which not much data will be available on Internet)
I have 2 offers from which I need to decide, 1 is for support role (shifts) and other is for Development role which I don't have hands on but managed to crack the interview somehow.

Hello, everyone. Why are only IT jobs discussed in FishBowl/LinkedIn/zigup/Naukri? Core waale sab kaha hai? Mechanical/chemical/aerospace etc?

like

Does IBM Consulting have on-site opportunities?

WHAT DO YOU SUPPORT?

Post Photo
helpfulfunnylikeupliftingsmart

Does Infosys confirm probation period employee if they are pregnant or terminate them after probation period?

like

Hi all,

I have offers from Ofss and Gainsight. Can anyone suggest which is good to join considering learning growth??
Please answer for both the scenarios below-
(i) CTC for both are same.
(ii) CTC of Gainsight>>Ofss

#JobSwitch
#OFSS
#ORACLE
#Gainsight

like

Hi Fishes,
What are the perks one can expect at
Deloitte India and salary for Azure Data Engineer having 4 yoe

like

What would you prefer and why between IT project management role or ERP consultant (SAP/Oracle) role ?

Awaiting your responses 😁

like

Hey fishes 🐟🐠🦈🐡
Hows the work culture in IBM GBS (work load, wfh, etc) ?
Got an offer in Apps support role, Bangalore.
Band 8, Business Manager, 26.80 LPA, yoe 10.5

like

I am a Salesforce Developer with 4+ years of experience, my current CTC is around 9.5lpa.

I have 3 offers in hand from KPMG, IBM and PWC .. All are providing compensation in the same range.. around 50% hike on fixed part!

1. Should I be expecting more for a 4+ years experienced Salesforce developer?

2. And which one should I be joining based on factors like good work culture and appraisals ?

like

Hi, Can I get 11 likes for DM?

likefunny

I have usually seen people taking sick leaves when workload is more and there is more responsibility coming in team. But I always hesitate to ask for leaves, I feel I'm doing something wrong. At the same time I'm exhausted with work and feel like I should be taking 1-2 leaves per month. Even in new organization it's been 4 months, I have not taken even a single leave.

How to deal with these thoughts? It looks like job is taking control over my mind and health.

like

Epam
Before : work from anywhere
Now : work from nowhere

funnylike

I'm working as a UX designer in Accenture, I like to shift to a product based company. Can anyone help me you here?

like

Few days ago many cmpnies were calling for interview. But now suddenly no calls from past 6-7 days.
Also i m serving notice then also
Has the hiring slowed down?
Will it gather speed like earlier in coming days?

like

Bain & Company Can one growth in the Indian IB or Management consulting with an MBA but with a BBA(Finance) from one of the premier institutes if one works consistently on up-skilling and delivering better? Deloitte PwC EY KPMG KPMG India Goldman Sachs JPMorgan Chase Bain & Company Boston Consulting Group

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal