my s.o. and i have a total salary of 210k and we’re 28/25 respectively. her parents ordered a tesla y for 70k and paid off 45k so far. we live in chicago and they are in iowa so they figured it’ll be better use for us to have the car. we’ll pay off the current loan and pay them back the amount they paid throughout the next 8 years interest free. is this even a good deal for us or are we able to get too much car for our age?

likeuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Ah yes. Paying 80k+ for a used Tesla (probably worth max 50k) makes total sense.

likefunnyhelpfuluplifting

OP, also bear in mind:

1) You could buy a brand new Model Y for $70k today - why would you buy their used one?

2A) Tax credits. If you bought a new one, you could qualify for tax credits making your net cost $60k instead of $70k

2B) As a corollary of 2A, <they want you to pay them $70k for something they paid $60k for>.


There are a couple of possibilities here and none of them are good. If it was me, even bringing up this preposterous idea would be a serious red flag for my relationship with them, and could risk spilling over into my relationship with my spouse. I’m not exaggerating.

Either:

A) they’re legitimately this clueless about money. I would be seriously concerned about their financial position and ask your spouse to have some hard conversations about elder care. Are they going to move in with you in ten years? Start asking you for loans? Help paying off their debts?

or

B) they know this is a preposterous idea, but hope that YOU DON’T. I.e. they are intentionally taking advantage of you *and their own child* to enrich themselves. As bad as the first option is, I think this is worse.

likehelpful

There are no current tax credits for Tesla (this was wound down over 2020 as Tesla hit its sales threshold for the credit) - there are some states that still currently offer sales tax incentives, none of them come close to $10k in value.

like
Recent IconRecent

The “family special”

Post Photo
likefunnysmart

VCA, as your cousin, I will sell you this only partially-chewed apple core for the low, low price of $3.00. Just for you.

likefunnyuplifting

Damn, I thought you were getting it just for the $25k left on the loan, which would probably be a good deal.

Re-reading this, they also want you to pay back the principal they *already* paid?

Are these people on drugs? Serious question. They want you to pay the price of a brand new car, for a used car? 😂

likefunny

Probably principal + interest

That makes no sense. In Chicago you can get around without a car using public transport, in Iowa you cannot. Also, you really gonna keep the car 8 years?

like

It's mind boggling to me how willing family members are of screwing over other family members for their own benefit. This is such a shit deal it's shocking.

likesmart

The above points are good; plus: don’t forget the opportunity cost. That’s a LOT of car—at least 50k more than you actually need to get from A to B.

So the real question is then — assuming you do need a new car — do you want to put this extra 50k into a car? Or into retirement, student loans? Maybe throw in a nice vacation?

I personally would not touch a 70k car until you have at least 500k in net worth. IMO that extra $50k is much better spent on VOO over the next few years

likesmart

A 70k car seem like misplaced priority for you at this point in time. It would make more sense it it's going into an appreciating asset.

How old is the car? Are you sharing a car? Don’t pay that much for a used car. Maybe if they offer you the car and just pay the rest of the loan (25k) but don’t pay back the rest of the 45k. Cars depreciate and they’re taking advantage of you if you need to pay them back for the car over 8 years.

like

Get a cheaper car if/when you need one. You’re looking a 700+ monthly payment over 8 years if the whole 70k were interest free? Or are they only giving the 45k interest free and you need a loan for the 25k which would make it every more expensive.

likehelpful

Personally, I wouldn’t pay more than the current loan principle plus whatever amount would get to market value if they resold it.

Sounds like they are rethinking their decision and trying to offload it on you while making a 45k interest free loan sound like a good deal.

like

It would be cheaper for you to buy a new Tesla than to go through with this deal. I don’t understand why they’re asking you to pay back the amount they’ve paid already. That’s sunk cost. It’s not as if they bought the car for you guys.

likehelpful

Boomers screwing over millennials. Name a more iconic duo, I'll wait.

likefunny

What is the car worth now? that is what you should pay them, if you want the car

like

They are scamming you guys lol

like

Fellas y’all ever been scammed by your in laws??

likefunny

Wish I could say no.

likefunny

Personally as a technician in both gas and diesel, you would be better off owning a diesel vehicle. You can find both cars and trucks that run on it, but the longevity you will see out of one is far superior to that of an ev. Also the main batteries in an EV aren't completely fool proof and have a history of going bad at random times. And if one ever catches fire, it can take 40k gallons of water to put one out completely, sometimes the vehicle has to get submerged in water for a few days because the fire will reignite multiple times

likehelpful

Diesel in Chicago? Good luck with their winters.

You are about to get screwed. Don’t take the deal.

Always be wary when someone figures something will be good for you. 😂

likefunny

Is the car still new? Why are you paying off the remaining loan AND paying them back everything they paid? Sounds like they decided they don’t want this car and so they are dropping it on you at full price.

likeupliftinghelpful

1) Just avoid financial transactions with family. 2) That’s way too much $ into a used car, especially at your age, get a nice car for $30k and put the extra $50 into the market and when you’re old it’ll be worth a lot and the car will be 🥜

like

I believe the author mentioned that it’s a brand new car, so many comments talking about a used car, like can y’all even read😅 Author please realize that you are asking in a group where people are frugal and will save every penny they have and drive a 20+ year old car just to save more for retirement. Nothing wrong with that but it really depends on your lifestyle and goals. I personally think it’s great that you don’t have to stress about paying interest because it’s being passed on through family, plus, you will save SO much money on charging it and it’s great for the environment. The price on the car will not go down so you can essentially sell it at any point if the payments get too expensive or if you want to switch to something else. I know that people on here will say: “your car worth decreases right after you drive it off the lot” but that’s not true. I bought my car almost 3 years ago, it’s a Honda Hybrid and the MSRP went up so if I sell it, I will actually make a profit. With Tesla, same thing, I have a friend who bought it in 2020 and sold it for at least $7k more. So the way I see it: you are able to enjoy a great quality car, without paying for gas, no interest rate and you can sell it at any time. Of course you need a car for the family and especially in a place like Chicago, but at the end of the day, go with your gut feeling, it’s usually right!

likesmartfunny

Pretty much every new luxury car offers 0% interest , it’s not that special.

They sounds sleazy and they’re trying to scam you. For 80k by two brand new Honda’s and have 7k leftover

like

Honestly this doesn’t make any good sense

like

Related Posts

Any bonus and payrise at Visa Inc have been communicated yet?

like

What’s the average project delivery specialist compensation in GPS like?

like

Thoughts on potential business ideas or investment opportunities where I can live the life I deserve now and not in retirement? I’m always trying to think of potential business ideas and come up with nothing. As far as interests, it doesn’t matter what it is. As long as it makes money I’m interested.

like
like

Hi everyone!
Does anyone know how much is the start-up salary range out of college for forensics/criminalist in California? And where to apply?

like
like

I am close to receiving an offer for an EA position. Would like a signing bonus. When/how do I ask? I don’t want to lose the job opportunity. It’s a great job.

like

Hii! Looking for compensation range for a mid level researcher in San Diego, California!
Do all companies provide a sign in bonus? What’s that like?

like

Dear EY folks, what's the difference between EY GDS and EY India?

I have been selected for EY GDS as PM. What kind of projects I can expect?

Also, how is yearly appraisal and bonus in EY GDS?

like

What salary range should I give for Avascent analyst role?

like

What do you think Verizon India's plans are to keep up with market inflation and rising job salary slabs? Attrition has been high, and understandably so. If you again get the same routine ~10% hike at year end, would you leave?

Hi All,

Kindly suggest which option to opt for

HCL 27LPA with 15% VP
TCS 22LPA with 2.5L VP

I know there are more difference with Salary in HCL but I am worried about Job Security and Work as I have already reached 12 plus of experience as .Net Developer. I am planning to settle down for few years. Kindly suggest which option to opt for.

like

When does HCL pay annual bonus? Which month?

like
like

Salary for a CA fresher in TIAA India as an internal control analyst

What would you say it's the average salary for a consultant with 4 YOE in London?

like

Anyone know the base or starting salary for someone in compliance department at Grant Thornton in the Charlotte office?

Can anyone tell me what the salary range is for a QA lead in the metropolitan area at Salesforce is?

like

Hi Fishes

Please please please help me with the following:

What are the perks or benefits provided by SCB?
How is associate manager placed in the hierarchy?
What is the avg salary for associate manager?

TIA

like

More Posts

Just had my interview with Deloitte. Overcome with happiness. I was told my skills and experience are perfect Deloitte.After months of being unemployed I have hope that I will find a job. God is Great

like

What are the realistic exit options for a consultant less than 1 YOE ? (Is FAANG too ambitious?)

like

Anyone have any insights on the Goldman Sachs early careers program?

like
like

In search of the LV Accesoires from By The Pool Collection. Anyone selling?

like

Is anyone else tired of how car-centric downtown Denver is? I feel like more housing density, better public transportation, and more walkable spaces would really benefit the community.

like

Who does like a strong espresso?

like

Does anyone know what the NOC would be for an SAP consultant? Is it 2171 - Information systems analysts and consultants?

Also does anyone know what the job title would be in the letter given by Deloitte for a Consultant? Will it be Consultant or will it be technology consultant or will it be something else?

like
like

What would be the hike percentage for a new joinee who has been in Fidelity for 6 months? Grade : 4

Are you or did you make any 2022 resolutions? If so, please share!

like

Hello fishes, can someone tell me if HSBC EDP provides, work phone to it's employees? Like a seperate mobile device for work? Or can it be requested?

like

I have cleared all the round in pwc interview now hr is telling we cant hire you are bca graduate and have completed mca as distance. iam having 4 yrs exp. Is it like this type of norms in pwc?
#pwc @PWC @PWCKOLKATA @PWCSDC

like

Partners with kids and a working spouse, how do you manage? Is it realistic for both people in the relationship to work full time long term? How do you keep marriage going and career progressing?

likesmart

Do you continue to see in-flight interview processes through once you’ve received and accepted an offer? It feels premature to cut the chord on the others, but also the decision between the companies becomes harder. Also afraid of the possibility to go back on the acceptance of the one role in favor of another.

like

Can Amazon please do a stock split 😭

like

Will the market continue with its usual bloody day?

like

Advice appreciated: I want to sublease my apartment so that I can rent elsewhere and pay less. I had to move in a short amount of time and it was during the period where there was a high demand for housing, & leases everywhere were expensive so I signed what I thought was fairly cheap in comparison to what was out there. However I found something this month that will cut costs by 30%. How do I go about finding someone to sublease my place?

like

Additional Posts in Personal Investment Chatter

Is stock market surging tomorrow?

like

I’d like some independent views please, on a financial decision my wife and I are about to make. We’re looking to buy our first/dream home and the property is valued at $1.25m. We have savings of $250k and our HHI is c$350k, with no debt. We will probably exhaust our savings on the deposit and closing costs. A $1m with mortgage at 6% with property taxes is c$8k/month. We net about $14k, we think it’s just about manageable, however keen to get your views please? More context in comment below.

likeupliftinghelpful

What is the best way to get euros out without fees and at the actual exchange rate? Is it best to use an ATM at the destination or is there a better alternative?

like

What would you recommend doing with extra cash after max 401k and IRA? Open a brokerage account and continue to invest in the market or diversify into real estate/small business? Total noob btw...

like

Starting to think it’s all a scam. Everyone knew tomorrow would be a bad day for the market... and bam... Gilead announces. = rally tomorrow!!! Ride the waves, my friends 🤣 THOUGHTS???

like

Can Amazon please do a stock split 😭

like

Will the market continue with its usual bloody day?

like

Advice appreciated: I want to sublease my apartment so that I can rent elsewhere and pay less. I had to move in a short amount of time and it was during the period where there was a high demand for housing, & leases everywhere were expensive so I signed what I thought was fairly cheap in comparison to what was out there. However I found something this month that will cut costs by 30%. How do I go about finding someone to sublease my place?

like

House flip question

Hey all newbie here. My husband and I are living that Double Income No Kid life wanting to (Financial Independence) Retire Early.

Both in tech in the Bay Area. I’m in Arizona visiting family and am thinking of an investment property. Does anyone have a book/course/video that they personally have used and recommend for flipping houses? I want to do some research there’s a lot of content out there.
Thanks a bunch!

like

Is sending kids to private school worth it? Talking about 25k-30k per year. Living inside city where public school are average. Thinking of sending kid to international school with bilingual program (family speaks multiple languages)…. The money adds up a lot over a lifetime. Especially if we have more than 1 kid.

like

Advice & resources? My spouse and I are starting to make good money (ages 28 & 31, $105k & $70k) with $10k in savings (we were hit hard financially this year) and 2 car payments.

We live in a cheap apartment ($1.3k) that is sh*tty. Don’t quite have a down payment (especially not in ATX). Is it dumb to rent a house for a year at $3k/month while we save up again?

We both didn’t come from $ and are figuring out how to not be idiots 🙃 tbh we would prefer to rent forever but that feels dumb???

Book suggestions for new-ish investor - PLEASE. Need to learn the fundamentals

like

I have a 401k still in the Deloitte plan. What are your thoughts of rolling it into my current 401k or leaving it where it is?

like

Can someone explain to me how it monetarily helps me to split my home mortgage into half and pay half on 1st and half on the 15th? So if my payment is 4K, I pay 2k July 1 and 2k July 15

like

31, $155 base, expenses 2300mo, 30k investment, only debt is 500k house. Is it too late? How far behind am I? If I throw all of my cash moving forward at investments and mortgage can I recover?

like

Finally have built up an emergency fund after 2 years of working! I’m looking to move most of it to a high yield savings account (and then start investing, woohoo) but not sure which is the best one or if certain ones have better services etc. I’m looking at Marcus just because it seems to have the best rates right now but any info helps! TIA

like

Can someone point me to some material where I can read about profit sharing vs 401k. I get the concept, but I am trying to understand is 10% profit sharing vested over 5 years better than an employee 401k match of 6%?

From my understanding 10% PS is better because it’s just a standard 10% on top of whatever I contribute though it takes 5 years to vest. Does this mean if I leave before 5 years I don’t get any of it?

like

I’m finally hitting a stride (now in my mid-30s) and have some cash to play around with/invest. Any suggestions or recommendations on good, long-term strategies (and/or things I should absolutely be doing) for people not familiar with having a tiny cushion of wealth? Also open to “you should hire a financial advisor, etc..”

What should I do with my cash in this environment? Have quite a bit sitting in savings which is obviously not ideal with inflation running high. Are ETFs still the play?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal