Need suggestions: A newbie in ERP, Want to push for a cert to be specialized, but unsure which one to pursue that is worth the money and time:
Oracle, SAP, Salesforce, Workday

Please explain why whichever system suggested is the best choice!

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

SAP and Microsoft Dynamics continue to be industry favorites. I’ve been surprised how Dynamics has grown in popularity primarily given the growth in Azure and sticking with a common Microsoft stack.

like

ERP is so broad. You really need to decide first what module within the ERP you want to specialize in (i.e. supply chain, finance, HR, CRM, etc.)

Then you can choose the application.

Also note that certifications don’t have much value. When you’re first starting, they are useful for showing companies/managers that you have an interest and have committed to learning it, which can help you get in the door for working in that practice or project.

Once you’re working on those projects, your experiences counts more than any certification would for getting future project roles. But certifications do help in year-end evals or higher salary considerations.

SAP is the goat of ERPs, with Oracle in a far 2nd. Salesforce is the goat of CRM. Workday is the goat for HR capabilities. Ariba is the goat for sourcing and procurement.

SAP always has work, but it’s saturated market so you have to compete with a lot of people. Oracle and Microsoft are fighting for ERP marketshare. All the other niche softwares are growing quickly so it’s easier to hop in with little experience.

Again, the software comes secondary to the actual functional area you decide to specialize in.

likehelpfulsmart

M1 .. brilliant beginning answer : pick the functional area. Then drill.

like
Recent IconRecent

I was one of the earlier workday consultants for my module in my country. Demand was huge and as a result, fast tracked my promotion cycles at a Big 4. However soon realized that I will only be staffed on workday projects and nothing else since my rates as a workday consultant was far too high compared to being on a non-workday project. Recruiters reach out but only for workday related roles. For other roles being offered, I’d have to take a significant pay cut and just didn’t make sense. Essentially what I’m describing is the golden handcuffs phenomenon. I think it’s great for people who want stability, but as someone who went into consulting to try different projects and industries, workday was an inhibitor. For those who are young and growing, I would stay away from these erp systems. Personal take of course

likesmart

Golden handcuffs. Swore to myself I would only do one ERP project. 15 years later leading an ERP practice. What happened?

like

Salesforce is CRM. Not ERP. If looking at ERP, Workday is a no-brainer but your firm must have a partnership with Workday and send you for certification training.

likesmart

Workday is the future. Way faster processing and it’s capable of doing basically every business task and can be customized for specific industries

likesmart

As a former workday consultant, I’d say workday has the highest demand. However, I had to fight frantically to get out of the pidgeonhole. To each their own 🤷🏻‍♂️

like

SC1 - it gets boring. Every project starts to feel the same. And after your fourth or fifth project on one these packages, you can almost predict the potential issues before they start.

Certifications are a money scheme by these software companies to keep getting money off implementors “needing” to re-up their certification every 2 years. I’d much rather someone with five years experience with no cert, than someone coming in with any amount of cert. they even state on them you should be a full time practitioner of at least 3 years before taking them.

like

It depends on the cert. Some are geared towards actual implementation work and actually require hands on practice, getting this cert would not distinguish you (or anyone with <2 YOE). Some certs can be obtained by taking training courses for foundational work etc, id put weight into these since it is aligned to your actual knowledge and shows you’re interested. I would look for the latter type of certs as it will give you leg up and actually allow you to have an understanding of the work/software

like

Manhattan WMOS - warehouse management systems

E-commerce is exploding. Always needs distribution technology.

Requires extensive travel if that’s your thing.

likehelpful

Honestly I’d focus on AWS/GCP/Azure and if you’re looking for a new language to learn, definitely Python. No one is going to tell you that Oracle is dying and that you’d be pigeonholed if you make that you’re only focus. I agree Microsoft is a good investment of time but cloud enablement is really where a lot of the opportunities are.

like

Following this thread, similar to OP also wanting to break into implementation. From my understanding most certs require sponsorship by the partner firm. Trying to pivot into those roles now. Hoping to get into cloud WD for fin mgt.

Worth picking up basic AWS / Azure certs in the meantime, since I’m coming from a generalist non-tech background? Any coding languages that would be helpful besides SQL? I’m starting Python as my first since it seems to be so adaptable and useful

like

Hey SC, haha sounds like we’re doing the same exact thing. 👌🏼 best of luck to both of us 😂

like

I’m in the workday field. I think it is saturated. Can he or she try AWS ? That’s where the future is. All my clients are or plan on moving to AWS

like

I am an ex-ERP person (PeopleSoft, which was purchased by Oracle a while back).

If I had to choose between these four, I would choose Workday because Dave Duffield created PeopleSoft and was so annoyed that Oracle did a hostile takeover of PeopleSoft, he went out and created Workday. And he has been successful in growing market share.

like

Not any Oracle Financials Cloud ? 😢
I have been working on it for five years and find it way more user friendly than the old SAP I saw in college.

like

Definitely Workday. Specialize in FIN or PATT, get a few years under your belt. Go independent and make $300k a year and take as many days off as you want. That's a pretty nice life.

like

Salesforce - choose a sub-functional area within CRM. Hands On trainings are free for most of the modules with excellent material available on Salesforce’ site including free sandbox. Salesforce conducts a lot of 1/2 day free virtual trainings. Certification fee is $100 for most of the modules. Huge demand and great future - IMHO

like

What about Microsoft?

I’d say it’s pretty up and coming. Has been mainly for middle market and upper middle market companies but in my opinion it’s among the top preferred ERPs by customers due to user friendliness

like

S/4 Hana Essentials

On boarded into Oracle but never got certified and was able to work across different industries, processes, and technologies. Echoing some of what’s already been said, I’d recommend skilling up in delivery methodology early on rather than any particular technology. Gives you opportunity to explore since tech consulting groups/service lines aren’t incentivized to let you.

ERP Newb 2 here...are “Functional Consultant” the entry-level roles I should be hunting for to pivot into implementation? I have a finance background but no formal developer hard skills/cert. Looking to get into cloud financials (WD ideally). Don’t mind taking a step back in my current title/scope to learn from the ground up, coming from MC.

Yes, since no one can do workday unless they are certified, everyone starts as a “functional consultant” once they get certified

like

Related Posts

With regards to learning, future opportunities, and transferable skills, which one is a better next step? Solution Consultant or Project Manager?

like

Have cloud experience..so is the AWS SA cert worth it or should I just go for professional instead? Also, your thoughts on AWS certified security exam..Security in cloud next big thing? Thanks!

like

Hi fishes,

Got offer in Barclays 10.5 currently in Tcs as unix system administrator application support. Please suggest is Barclays good to move. 3.3 yoe

like

Hello - decade old question. ..

Medium fish in a medium pond.. or small fish in a big pond?

29M. Have had plenty of success within my current organisation. I feel like I'm over-staying in my organisation .. clocking close to 7 years under my belt.

But if I were to make a move .. it'd be ground zero all again


Help.

like
like

How did you decide what field of law enforcement you wanted to be in?

like

Any one has specflow dumps for CCA exam?

What do I do?
Just switched to a gud org with gud perk,pay,project work but My boss is the epitome of a**h*** reasons-
Onboarded me on a huge project (12 phase proj) with no KT, only gave docs to read from.
He was handling this proj till phase 4 but has completely withdrawn out without proper transition.
I cannot make decisions and my decisions are overridden by him.
I have 2 yrs experience and it's now my onus to negotiate with PPL in VP,EVP position and also handle testing & dev team.

like

I landed my first job in tech as an IT Analyst. I want to be a Project Manager, do you think it’ll be hard to make a transition to Project Management.

like

Howany competency parameters needs to be at next level to become consultant?? Is there any other criteria?

I have been working as an AC ~ 30 months

like

How did you decide your speciality in Cybersecurity? Did you naturally gravitate towards one area?

like

Hello, looking for supervisor positions in healthcare within NYC, I am looking to start ASAP. I have my Bachelors in Health Services Admin and Economics, 5 years of experience in the industry and I am currently working towards my PMP certification, as well as going for my MBA or MHA, depending on what program I can afford. I am currently located in Queens. Thank you!

Hi Fishes, I am a Consultant with approx 11 Yrs of exp being offered Senior Consultant II within IN3 and I want to understand if this is appropriate as per my exp. Can someone please explain how many levels exist within IN3 ?

likefunny

Those who went to consulting or advisory from audit as a manager: did you have to step down?

like

Does your undergrad school matter to MBA admissions? Does it make a difference if you have a great GPA from a state school or an average GPA from a highly selective school?

funny

Has anyone done the GARP Financial Risk and Regulation course? Was it educational? Did you do the FRM after?

Do you think you'll stay in public accounting for your entire career? What areas or roles do people typically exit to?

like

Is there a good spot/website I can look for a “checklist” of things to do before going freelance? Or can any of you fine people help me out? Would love to hear from creatives in particular.

like

If you accept a job offer from a T2 consulting firm then get MBB and decline after rejecting 1 can T2 legally hold you back from moving to mbb?

like

More Posts

For >20 YOE, multiple companies founded, highly technical, patents, academic papers, former F10 Director… even in a T3 city, $240k TC in consulting seems low, right? Not complaining at all just not sure what direction to go for higher comp.

like

I have got an offer from Cognizant and completed document submission then they are asking to do prejoining formality. What happened if i am not going to join this company afterwards.. do they black list me ?

like

How is the hiring market now , us it still bad or companies has started hiring?

like

Hi Fishes,

I have 1.6 years of experience in Java, Spring Boot, Angular, Microservices.

If I'm planning to switch how much CTC can I ask for?

Current CTC - 5.8LPA

like

How often do you conform in Flame? Hasn’t premier caught up at this point?

like

State of decay 2, Xbox?

like

Heard ICIMS let go of 5% of their workforce today. Also heard that last week they acquired SkillSurvey.. must have cost a pretty penny.. better to keep the acquisitions going over keeping people employed

Starting to think it’s all a scam. Everyone knew tomorrow would be a bad day for the market... and bam... Gilead announces. = rally tomorrow!!! Ride the waves, my friends 🤣 THOUGHTS???

like

I’m not certain about who will win the election, but unless it’s a landslide, I am concerned that it could take weeks and/or months to determine an outcome. In your opinions, is this a legitimate concern and if so, what would the impact be on the markets?

like

Is anyone else convinced we are headed for a correction in equities, and quickly? The market has been straight up for months, with the exception of a blip around GME week. Seems like everyone is day trading, too, which I take as a sign of froth. I know market timing is typically a bad idea, but talk me out of moving to cash for a few weeks until things get cheap(er).

like

Good Morning Guys . Can anyone tell me how much increment would an Analyst 3 get in the Indirect Tax profile in EY india ?

likesmart

Banana Boat sunscreen smells sooooooo f*kin GOOD. I look forward to rubbin some on me every 4 hours. I'm bout to get some right g*kin nooow before this zoom meeting.

funnylike

S&P Global I heard S&P Global recently fired so many people from Ahmedabad, Gujarat location.
Is it true?

like

Does anyone have any tips for Napa Valley? 🍷🍽🥗

like

Hey all, 4 YoE strategy consultant looking for some exit options. Looking to jump ship from consulting into something in the life sciences field, but not particularly interested in working for big pharma. Does anyone have any suggestions?

like

Any good PowerPoint SmartArt memes?

like

Trying to get an investment job in Toronto as a new immigrant. I have 4 yoe in consulting, investor searching and financial service (risk). Currently working at call center to get local experience (bilingual), opportunities for internal transfer, while preparing for CFA 3 next Feb. Any ideas what to prepare in extra?

like

For those that lateraled to another firm for FDD work - was your 2 week period paid out? Were you worked? Should I expect to have a 2 week paid vacation when I put in notice?

Receiving approx 30% pay bump to move firms. Stay schemin boys

like

I'm 6 months old at D! Planning early promotion next year.. counselor and pm both are backing me.. I need to go to India for at least 4 weeks in Dec ... most probably would be rolling off from current project by then .. would this vacation hurt my promotion chances coz of utilization etc?

like

Additional Posts in Technology/IT Consultants

Looking to specialize in privacy and was considering getting the CIPP/CIPM/CIPT. I already have my CISSP and CISA. Is it worth it?

like

The thing I struggle with the most on a project is being able to quickly understand the business process of the clients across different industries. Any tips or resources I can use to improve that?

like

Guys, have you gone through some traumatic experiences, or realized somethings that unnecessarily cause you to be too aware instead of living your best life? If so, how were you able to reconnect...

like
like

I’m in tech consulting right now & would be interested to explore areas that it intersects with law besides cybersecurity. Does anyone have any suggestions? Always been interested in law school.

like

Looking for referrals for PwC Australia ..

Want to start going back to leetcode for more exit opp. Getting stumped on very simple questions. Any resources to help with algorithm? My data structure funds should be good enough. TIA!

like

Making a switch form Android to iOS. Whats the best way to get my backup messages on to the new device ?

like

Anyone here that completed Udacity data analyst nano degree program? I feel that it would be a great way to get into the DataAnalytics practice or find exit opportunities in the industry? Thoughts? I am a first year Senior Consultant.

like

Is TOGAF worth it? Been coding for 13 years and want to stick to coding / design work. Is it worth taking the test now?

Currently in cybersecurity but looking for my long-term specialization. Not interested in doing the pen testing route. Not really sure what's out there and where to start...

Actively referring folks with ServiceNow and low code backgrounds looking to learn/move into cyber, should anyone be looking or interested.

like

What’s the salary range for client facing manager position in Consulting vs Tax?

like

Are there dedicated Linux security consulting teams? Maybe within IBM/RedHat, or some boutique? I really enjoy working with these systems.

like

Hi ZS folks, I have an offer for a Business Technology Solutions Associate role at ZS. I wanted to know if there's room for negotiation, considering I have another offer and also considering the cost of living and student loans. Can anyone share some insights about BTSA comp and negotiation? The principal did mention that I did well in the interview when they called me. My profile: BS in CS, MS in Business Analytics, Location: Princeton. Comp: Base: 85k, Sign on: 7k Relocation: 4k. Please help.

like

I work heavily in AWS and am looking to learn another cloud platform. I have zero knowledge of azure and gcp and would like input on which to learn. Azure would make sense since its the second largest in terms of market share, but GCP seems far more interesting and technically challenging with things like Kubernetes and BigQuery.

like

If you join pwc with an approved I140, do they start the green card transfer (perm, i140) immediately ? I was told by recruiter it will start immediately after H1 transfer . I Wanted to know how true this is if anyone been through this

like

Is it OK to ask the interviewer to split a 2.5 hour face to face interview into 2~3 sessions since I am 9 month pregnant? Should I mention that I am pregnant during the interview?

like

CohnReznick hiring for cyber/tech risk ... seniors and managers. Lmk if anyone interested.

like

Deloitte is looking for qualified candidates to join their Cyber & Strategic Risk practice immediately. All levels. Please reach out if you're looking for a change and I'll submit your resume!

likefunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal