Recently interviewed for a senior UI design job and was tasked to do a skills test - to look into their product and find areas of improvement.

The more I do the task, the more I feel that I’m doing a free design audit. Furthermore, they reposted the ad.

In my task, must I proposed a new design or would it be just a list of areas of improvements? How many is a good number of finds? Currently, each area is coupled with a write up and what competitors are doing.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

To me, it seems like nothing good comes from these type of “tests”.

But also, I wouldn’t do free work. But more so a quick diagnosis and ask questions of, what’s going on in the business right now and what was the original function of x, y, s? Were those goals met? And etc etc. otherwise all problematic findings could just be speculative right?

like

I’ll tweak my document to fit around that narrative. Thank you the tip!

Make the logo bigger

likefunny

Add more visual interest and make things pop so the user takes action

funny

When we ask for these types of tests we usually pay them for the day. But that's also because I'm very vocal about how we should not do these types of tests. We have their portfolio.

like

When people apply be an accountant, do they say “Here are last months books, do a quick audit on them”. What about lawyers? “Draft up divorce papers”. What about a photographer, “go to my daughter’s wedding and take a few photos”

like

Don’t. Do. It. It’s an insult to our profession. Say you’re worth it and explain your experience like a normal interview.

like

funny cause Accenture still does take home tests

If you really want the job, I suggest doing the test, but audit one of their competitors product instead of their product. This way you'll prove them that you're not skipping research and in the same time they'll have something they can't use. Also, if done right, you'll be considered a potential threat if you'll be hired by their competitor.

like

Excellent!

like

Could you do some rough wireframes of 2-3 examples and include a plan for what you’d do over the next few months to improve things?

Every single developer is asked to do a coding test these days. In that context this is a perfectly reasonable ask. I would absolutely want to see someone's work output as the best gauge of their skill. It is too easy to talk a good game in an interview, risking that when you are hired, your work turns out to be not that great.

The only area for pushback or resentment IMHO is in the scope and time commitment required to do the test. If it's more than a couple hours I would just calculate risk/reward and double check internally how badly do you want this job.

If it's for any kind of sizeable or reputable company, this test is definitely not free work and it's probably based on a client project they've already completed and want to see your approach to the same.

If the test is for some tiny shop and you have strong suspicions there are actually trying to get you to work for free...I would think there should be other warning signs besides this test, that you shouldn't want to work there.

Eh. I’ve been in the creative industry a long time. I can see the BSers from a mile away. This is why we (designers) spend so long on our books. The work and the stories should speak for themselves. Spec work (even for an interview) is not ok. I don’t know about you, but I don’t need to be spending my precious time solving problems I’m not getting paid for. If your recruiters aren’t trained well to see / know / hear talent, hire new ones.

Related Posts

Beginning to consider going in house (4th, corp) - I really haven’t thought about what I want, partly because I’m not sure what’s out there/attainable. Is it a bad idea to start by applying to a couple positions that interest me and seeing where that gets me? I’ll of course prep for the interviews but am afraid to burn potential bridges if I ultimately decline because I’m still figuring things out.

like

Thoughts on Steptoe & Johnson? Particularly DC office. Considering applying. Thanks!

like

Hi fishes,
I had interviewed for Cognizant and I was asked to submit my documents for offer letter release. This happened on the same day as my interview(Friday 6th May). I submitted my documents and I am trying to contact the HR who scheduled my interview, but she is not picking up my call. My question is how soon can I expect the offer letter to be released? And is there a possibility that they can reject my profile at this stage?

like

Has anyone gotten feedback on attention to detail? They say sometimes show if sometimes no.
Am I a POS who is incompetent? Tbh I think it’s cuz I’m working on projects that aren’t in my skill set since my last role was eliminated… so the role I’m doing is them squeezing a square into circle, and I know it. Yes, I’m applying elsewhere.

like

Is it a bad sign if the company that typically moves fast (as said by former interviewees) is taking a long time to tell you whether or not you move forward to the next round in an interview?

like

Good questions to ask at the end of a PE Interview?

like

Had a detailed an hour interview (just one) without job description being provided by HR
Received mail saying that you have cleared MR and will go ahead with HR interview. Request you to upload docs in "My documents" portal.

I could not login to ibegin portal and have to create a new profile... Toll free no on tcs portal does not help? It seems confusing

like

Any recommendations on when I should follow up with a recruiter? Interviewed last Tuesday, sent a thank you note Wednesday. She said she’d get back to me “Friday, or early next week”

likehelpful

Hello LTItes, i joined LTI a month back.
I attended a client interview last week and was selected for the same. Now they are asking to join within a day or two. I'm having my mom's surgery this week. How to safely refuse to join this client project for at least 10 days. I can't take leave for 10 days.
Can anyone please help me with this? I'm confused and scared.

Thanks

like

I have cleared technical interview at @EXL and have also given another round of interview with VP.

Q1. How long does the VP round feedback take normally?
Q2. What are the next rounds/discussion to expect if I clear this round?
Q3. What is the level and salary that I should expect for a BI developer role at 6 years experience?

Anything else that I should keep in mind during the interview process that helps me land better role/salary? TIA.

like

Had applied to Deloitte and got an email saying they are inviting me for an interview. I tried reaching out to the recruiter in the email but haven't heard back despite following up several times.

like

Hello,
If anyone can answer ,
On how time it will take normally for HR discussion and final release of offer after clearing the interview?

like

Hello recruiters, happy Monday!

I want to know why recruiters ask me in an interview if I am looking at other opportunities, or if I am interviewing at other companies. If I say yes they will ask at what stage I am.

I just want to know the reason behind it and if there is a right answer to this question!

like
like

Interview tips for a role in E-Commerce at a CPG? Currently in Sales at a CPG and have an interview for an e-commerce role at a beverage company. What kind of things should I research and be ready to discuss beforehand?

like

Does anyone have any experience with Draper Laboratory in Cambridge? just got a nice offer pending an interview. Feels to good to be true or it won't last long.

like

I am interviewing with Accenture UK for AWS Architect role. Total exp is 12 years. What base pay should I be looking at? I am moving from another country. So, no idea about UK pay-scales.

like

What level should I apply to if I’m a manager at B4? Considering applying

like

Hi fishes
I was supposed to have my
Amazon Round 3 interview in the first week of May but the interviewer didn't join. My recruiter didn't reply for a few days and then rescheduled it.
Even in this rescheduled interview, my interviewer didn't join. This time my recruiter joined and said she'll reschedule my interview.
She still hasn't done that even after a follow up.
Is this common? Is this some kind of patience test?
I have no clue but I'm really frustrated at this point.
Please suggest

like

Hello fishes,
I have been recently cleared technical discussion round one for Accolite Digital. And my next round is supposed to be Client interview round. What type of questions can I expect? Will it also be a technical round or managerial?

Yoe 3years
Tech stack- Java, MySQL

like

More Posts

Starting in 10 days with D. When will i get orientation details and welcome emails? Do my manager reach out before I join?

like

Can anyone refer me?i have 3years of experience in US insurance domain.. please

like

Hello fishes,
Help me to choose
Infosys
Cognizant
Prodapt
Valuelabs

like

Congrats everyone! This week was terrible with omicron, schools closed, backlogged work from the holidays, general malaise from two years of a pandemic, etc. It might have been the most difficult week of my career so far. But, we made it. Kudos to everyone. Here’s hoping that next week is better.

like

What’s harder, networking or dating?

1YOE as a strategy consulting generalist, interested in breaking into PM. Would love to know which books / courses will get me in the best shape for PM, and if it’s worth looking into with my currently level of experience. Thank you!

like

Is PR dead? Seems like s struggle and really few and far between to execute something that drives a ton of earned anymore. Seeing it across the board...

like
like

Offtopic: Please suggest some good noise cancellation earbuds.
Budget around 3k can go up and down if it's a good deal.

like

Has this ever happened to you that each time you meet your bf/gf , there is extreme nervousness from both sides ? It’s a good kind of nervousness (shyness , awkwardness) and almost feels like meeting someone you have known forever for the first time?

like

Is it safe to order from flipkart ?

like

I tried out a career and I'm currently miserable in it and want to figure out how to use the degrees I have to find something I find fulfilling. I don't want to go back to school and start over with that process. If anyone has any advice on what websites or resources to explore to figure out what careers and jobs are comparable with my degrees or if anyone has any information or experience with this please hit me up. I have a degree in biology and teaching credential

like

What's the range for L10 Tech/London. Pretty disappointed with the perf discussion result and being told that I am already at the higher side of range☹️.

like

Hello Fisher's Infosys is offering senior consultant roal 5a but offering salary is very low when I ask as usual their reason benchmark etc.. What should I demand and what is your thaught any hint appricate Infosys

like

3rd year associate. Former fed law clerk. Working at ID firm. Doing slip and falls and wrecks. Recently received big law offer to do products. Really want to go. Gave notice to current firm. Current firm really wants me to stay, counters that it will try to get me salary as close to big law offer and give me complex work. Stay at ID firm or accept big law offer?

like

Thoughts on recording meetings. In Texas and have ADHD. I’ve been recording internal meetings for the past couple of weeks and my work product has improved exponentially. I’m able to go back and listen to the directions over again. In law school I had a note that gave me permission to do this. Is this taboo in a firm?

likesmart

If you do billable work on a given PTO/vacation day, do you still count that day as vacation? Or do you get that vacation day "back"? Or do you only get the part that you billed "back"? (Or some other option.)

likefunny

What fee percentage are you paying your Union talent payroll service, aside from P/W?

Hi fishes, Dm me with the job id for referral in Cognizant.

like

Any recommendations for Harrisburg? Starting a new engagement there

like

Additional Posts in Designers

I started a new job just 7 weeks ago, but an opportunity for a dream job just suddenly and unexpectedly fell into my lap! It’s a lot more money, more aligned with my career goals, and will have better work life balance. I’d be an idiot to not take this great new opportunity! That being said… I’m going to feel bad leaving this new job so soon. I’m sure they’ll be disappointed and maybe even angry… is there any way to NOT burn bridges on my way out of this current job?

like

Hi all
I started out as a graphic designer. Worked for about 4yrs in different roles. Then i started a digital design role for 2 yrs and then made my transition into ux. i have been in a ux role for 5 years. But i want to steer my career towards something more creative. Like in 5-10 years I wouldn’t want to be a specialist or a ux director. I d like to be an art director or creative director. I love branding & marketing but also product. Would love something that allows me to do both?

like

I’ve been interviewing with Google since July. Passed the first interview but the team I was matched with ended up hiring someone else. Recruiter told me that she will let me know if any other opportunities arise as I’m still in the running and haven’t been rejected. I know that interviewing with google is a long process but I’m worried the longer I wait the more likely I will be rejected or just never hear back. Anyone else in this situation? How long until you got an offer?

like

Hi! What's the entry level UX designer job pay range realistically? Just trying to gauge a general range (I understand factors such as location play into it big time)

like

Anyone know any places hiring designers in PDX? 🙂

like

Someone talk to me about Isobar and/or IA Collaborative. 👍👎❓

like

What is it like working as a full-time graphic designer for a company (not an agency/firm)?

like

Looking for recommendations for high-quality, high-volume print vendors? (120,000+ direct mailers) Any help would be appreciated.

I had technical and behavioral interview today at Deloitte Canada for visual analytics and information design position.
In technical round there was a case study to create visual data sheet and present it to technical round.

It went good they asked couple of questions and showed that at some point it lacks of continuity and rest thing is good. I have been told we will discuss and send details to HR and you will get update within few days. What are the chances that they can hire me ?

like

Anyone at Nike? What’s the vibe?

like

How do you handle revisions at a company?

like

Hello friends,
I wanted to share that I am in my first job as ui/ux expert and I am the only ux/ui person in the team. I am expected to take care of entire research and design of the product. It becomes very overwhelming as the product that I am working on is in a early phase and I am expected to think about ui as well as ux and also design entire app on my own.There is no user interview or user testing happening as my project manager thinks it can be done after product is launched. Please help!

like

Thinking about applying to grad school in Europe for graphic design / branding / visual identity stuff. 1. Anyone know of good schools/programs? 2. How do tuition loans work with international schools? 3. Any tips on applying to a European school as an American? Lemme know!!!!

like

Is anybody using WACOM CINTIQ Pro 24"? I am contemplating getting one but wondering if I will be able to use a mouse/tablet along with it. I heavily use InDesign and wonder if I can use a mouse/tablet when I need to without unplugging it. Thanks in advance!

like

Hi Folks - agency vs in-house - pros and cons - go!

What are actionable items one should strive for when trying to grow as a designer after landing their first role? I hear a lot about ways to grow to land the first job but very little about how to improve after you know the basics.

like

Sr Design Manager vs Sr Art Director? I’ve always worked in an design studio where SR Design Manager is above manager and principal but moving to in house type agency for big tech and the titles are art director, creative director etc. Currently, titles above me are director > sr director > VP/CDO. What is the equivalent at an agency?

like

Maybe here maybe help; ive been looking for a job for the last two years ive been on hundreds of interviews. But nothing back ive updated my resume but nothing works ive started a small business clientele is super slow. Is there anyone here willing to pitch in to help me find out what’s wrong with my resume and business strategy?

like

Do product designers deserve to make as much as software engineers? Why or why not?

like

Anyone out there who left their previous job for a new one have any advice or life experience to share? I’ve been thinking about it for months but currently feel comfortable in my job/the products I work on. I’d say I have a great work/life balance but I do know that I could be making 20-30% more and have better benefits if I left. I also feel a bit stagnant in my job but the job security has kept me put. Would love to hear if leaving a comfortable job for more money is always worth it.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal