Would you rather be a manager of individual contributors or a director who manages a group of senior managers and why? Looking for pros/ cons of each role.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I am much happier managing managers and not directly managing ICs.

like

Eh, it depends. I was thinking of this recently actually. If you lead a function that has commonality amongst all the roles under it (sales is a good example of this), leading the senior staff is better as they'll genetally be higher quality and it's steering the ship and setting tone (missing/vision/core strategy).

If you're over an area with a lot of variety in the roles of functional staff thst you lead, leading the senior staff is hard to make changes. It becomes more about finding the right key people to take accountability for those functional areas... the problem with this is its very easy to get dragged into minutiae, especially if you're in a high visibility part of the organization.

I think generally the former is better, but it's more cutthroat as it's live or die by the results and there's usually others doing the same function also at a senior level that you'll be compared to.

Most are limited in wherever they get to choose one or another by their career path specialties to whether they get to pick one or another until very late career. IMO growth through the second path makes more versatile leaders though too so uts a but of a coin flip really

like

Actually. I realize I didn't really answer your question
I would pick leading the leaders, but know that you'll almost always have one or more of them that thought they should've got your job and be ready for that turnover (and general drama) whenl it comes

like

I once took a job as a VP managing a bunch of directors. As I was introducing myself to them, one of them said to me, “I should have gotten your job.” My response, “but you didn’t.” He didn’t know what to say and we got along pretty well after that.

funny

Related Posts

Anybody have strategies for combating narcissistic bully principals when the teacher is already mentally broken and completely vulnerable to their tactics?

like

Looking for a roommate for a Navy Yard apartment this summer. Let me know if you (or anyone you know) is interested!

Hello Fishes,

Got an email today to close Tata Mutual Funds as it's restricted entity. Basically I am from Advisory team and not from Audit or Tax department.

Do i really need to close the Tata Mutual fund?

like

Has anyone joined the new "Women of PM" community?

Wondering how it might be different from the Bureau of Digital or DPM communities an if it's worth the fees.

like

Thoughts on 3-page resume?
I come from a very varied background and can't fit it all on 1 page

like

Why provide redlines against the original draft instead of the last turn when sending drafts to opposite counsel?! This profession makes no sense.

like

SIL and BIL told us excitedly last weekend that she was pregnant (had literally just found out, so barely four weeks). This week she tells us she’s not pregnant anymore :(. They did not seem super torn up about it and were very practical about it. We said how sorry we were, etc etc. should I do anything else? Should I not mention it again unless they do?

like

I was accosted last night at the bar when some guy overheard me telling my date I worked at Apple. Lots of expletives and "go back to where you're from" rhetoric. Do people really feel this way? So far, everyone I've met has been so welcoming.

likehelpfulfunny

Anyone know how working for the IRS would compare to Big 4?

Looking to make the move from big4 to law firm. I am a JD/LLM and a new manager. Any suggestions on networking with COVID, recruiters, etc.? Also interested in hearing experiences of others that have made the move.

like

In your opinion, which biglaw firms have the best tax groups?

like

Do the BB's ask for SAR reports for lateral moves ?

like

Does Credera promotes agile promotions, and generally how much is the percentage increase in overall compensation from one level to another??

“Frankly, my dear, I don’t give a mindset”

likefunny

Tell me if im crazy but: Berkshire Hathaway been sitting on their hands forever waiting on an acquisition target where multiples weren’t so out of control. Well this might be it, so calls on targets?

like

Dear Men - Need your perspective.

like

Does your PhD define your research for your career?

like

Get on a CDM already...

Post Photo
like

Any opportunities for dynamics functional consultant in Canada??

like

Additional Posts in Senior Leaders and Executives Only

What are your biggest frustrations with the wellbeing/burnout prevention initiatives that you’ve seen?

like

I’m currently considering an offer and am finding that all online compensation benchmarking is falling flat in terms of understanding how I should be looking at comp for this role. I’d value your advice on how to access cleaner comp data and/or how you might look at comp for this role: Chief People Officer for a $2.5BIL revenue ($150MIL net income) global organization. 50,000 employees. USA based. Looking for Total Comp and cash targets/benchmarks.

like

Working my way up the corporate ladder. I have so many thoughts on leadership and want to initiate changes in the departments I work with. But at this level it's so difficult. Ppl are so resistant to change.

My key learning thus far in my career: Noone gives a shit about your ideas unless you're a head honcho. Real change is brought about from a position of authority.

like

Anyone have success using JobScan or ResumeWorded to pass ATS scanners and land more interviews? Looking to refresh my resume after 10 years.

like

I’m a new manager to a newly created team. The team has extremely low morale and in two weeks I’ve had to have 4 difficult conversations about performance. Any ideas to help boost morale quickly?

like

Looking for guidance. I’ve been in people manager roles (in director/senior leader capacity) for the last 5 years now, and prior to that I was a “rockstar” Project Manager. I’ve worked really hard to get to the position I’m in today, but I’ve been recently asked to move from my current role to a senior IC role to take on a highly visible Program for the company, with some very senior stakeholders. I feel conflicted as it does feel like I would be backtracking in many ways. Thoughts?

like

I set up a call today with an even more senior leader (I am an EVP) and asked him for advice on navigating the political waters of our global workplace. He was so honest and helpful it was .....amazing. I don't think I expected it to be so genuinely helpful. I highly suggest you reach above for advice if needed. Sometimes it works!

like

Does anyone have experience sitting on boards? I’m interested in doing this at some point in my career, but am not sure how to get started and what’s typically required (both qualifications and work involved)

like

How much of your gig is spent interviewing candidates? I feel like that’s a solid 30% of my role these days.

like

Help me understand why executives lie and gaslight so often. I’m new to this and don’t feel comfortable doing it.

likehelpful

What's your opinion on restricted stock?

Do you miss anything about the non-executive portion of your career journey?

like

I work at a Financial Institution and have recently been approached about a Director role with my prior company. It’s a great opportunity but I have 2 young kids (Preschool/Elementary ages) and I don’t want to sacrifice time with them for career advancement. I would love to hear from working moms in senior leadership roles to understand if it’s possible to balance both, or is it best to wait a few more years? Not happy currently and looking to move, but unsure of pursuing lateral vs. a promotion

Look at the Future of work , how are you planning to be relevant !

like

When did you know you were ready for a senior leadership or an executive role?

like

Looking for guidance. I’ve been passively applying to Director roles since January, and actively for 2 weeks now. I’ve gotten one call for a position I didn’t apply to and no other response. Is there something I should be doing to get more traction?

For context, I was hired as a site GM. Then 8 months later made a regional. In January I was placed in a Director capacity pending position approval. The position has been postponed a year tentatively but I’ve been asked to continue in unofficial

like

Thoughts? What could be going on here?

Post Photo
like

Hello! I started at a company that is well a hot mess. I’m starting with building and organizing all departments SOPs. Any suggestions on platforms that specifically track and organize SOPs and Playbooks? (Besides sharepoint or google drive) Thank you!

like

At what level do companies begin to entertain golden parachutes?

like

What are everyone's thoughts on resume services/coaching? I am a leader/exec that was laid off (first time) and have spent over 15 years in various roles such SVP Operations, Senior Director Product, VP Solutions, etc. at different companies.

I am struggling with putting my experience/qualifications on paper...

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal