McKinsey & Company Any thoughts on BCG vs. McKinsey, particularly in Canada? Major differences in culture, WLB, industry reach and type of work? Are there actually noticeable differences in brand / exit ops and is that worth it for a comp difference? Coming in as an experienced hire.

McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Here we go again

like

Which office? I have personally worked with the leader of the Toronto office and she is fantastic. It’s an overall great office with really strong MDPs

like

McK for sure

like

It’s harder in a virtual environment, but I found going through the process in person that BCG was a much better cultural fit for me (no brainer). For some they will fit better at McK. Probably harder to judge in these times.

like

I say this with a lot of jealousy, and with recent experience interviewing for a CXO role. The McKinsey brand is still superior to anyone else’s.

likehelpful

do you have both offers?

like

Yes to the both offers - trying to figure out what the best fit would be

I don't know about McK but I've worked at BCG's Toronto office and the culture is toxic. Obviously, this depends on who you work with but I saw multiple instances of it.

Also, I noticed that experienced hires from non MBB firms tend to leave within 2-3 years. It could be that each one of them were not a good fit but the firm also does not support and nurture experienced hires. There is a bias towards homegrown talent vs. Experienced hires and it shows in how you are treated and evaludated.

In terms of brand, McK still has a clear advantage.

Comp should be comparable.

like

This person clearly either sucked in role or never worked at BCG - as an EH myself at BCG. Very much untrue

like

It only comes down to culture and what you connect with. If you have spoken to enough people you know which firm you connect more with - just go with it
Everything else is pretty much balanced.

McKinseys is less diverse in Canada. Happy to share numbers on either firm, just DM me

Related Posts

Hi everyone ,this is a broad career related question:

I am currently working as solution advisor in advisory at Deloitte(recently joined).

I have 2.7years of experience and have a CTC of 10.5 L currently.

It's a widely known that product based companies (like MAANG pays handsomely), for software engineer roles and that is what a lot of CS grads strive for ,this is true for MAANG and also a lot of startups,unicorns and other tech companies.

(Continued in the comments)

like

Hi, can anyone provide some insight as to WLB for a Fund Accountant at Carta?

like

30 July was special.
Salary credited. Tax debited.
Both were equal.
Ab pura August daal-chawal khaake!

funnylike

I was offered a position at fidelity. Now when I trade on behalf of a client, will I get commissions for that trade?

like

Looking to make a change from Canada (Toronto) to Dubai. Any thoughts or Big4 Cloud Consulting roles in the ME? Deloitte is generally the global leader. Any thoughts on Digital/Cloud Transformation in MENA?

Hey guys… I’m a case worker in child safety and I’m someone who loves being outdoors/dies at a desk all day. I’m hoping to organise that at least once a week I can go to a cafe and catch up on all my case notes that need to go into the system.
So far the only reason I’ve been told no is that “if you do then everyone will want to and then no one will be in the office” … how can I convince them that I work better out of the office and get this freedom & mental break for myself?

like

Anyone from BCG DV that can provide insight and functions of the firm? Interested in learning more 🙏

likehelpful

I currently work in Healthcare as a respiratory therapist for 10 years. I have been at my job, currently, for a little over 5 years. Alongside my bachelors degree I also have a masters degree in healthcare administration. Although, I am happy with my current position as a respiratory therapist, there seems to be not a lot career growth with where the department I currently work in within my healthcare system. I am wondering what doors/opportunities I have if I were to utilize my masters degree?

like

I’m a newly graduate from a community college. My program of study was Health Information Technician. I passed my RHIT exam a month ago, and I’ve been applying to jobs in state, out of state, and remotely to only receive “sorry you were not selected email.”I don’t have experience and I know that’s the reason I’m not getting selected. I’ve applied for receptionist, medical biller/coordinator, and medical clerk. Even with inflation willing to work for minimum wage or less just to gain experience.

like

Has anyone actually gone through with accepting an offer from the Siegfried Group? I hear from a recruiter representing them probably once a week. How is it?

like

I’ve long disliked the term ethics. Definitions of ethics all refer to morals. Morals are very personal and vary a lot from person to person, culture to culture. Law is how we as a society express our preferences and impose rules and restrictions on ourselves. So the question should never be about whether companies can be ethical. What does that mean? One person thinks eating meat is unethical, another thinks it’s perfectly ethical. Companies should focus on complying with the law.

like

I currently work at a medium sized firm and have about two years experience in personal injury litigation. The billable hours and lack of work life balance are really getting to me and I am looking to switch to something else out of litigation, preferably in house. I am also looking to relocate to a different state. How do I go about properly marketing myself to companies that might not take my relocation and minimal experience seriously?

like

What are some questions to ask in an interview to assess culture and WLB without sounding like you don’t want to work hard or put in long hours when it’s needed? And what are some red flags?

like

Hii fishes, i am starting to interview at jpm, can anyone guide me on the process and what should be my salary expectations be for Software Engineer python, yoe 1.5+ at mumbai

like

Hi folks,
How much Wipro pays for Europe on-site role with B3 designation.

like

What should be expected CTC for UI developer (React/Redux) at Amdocs
YOE 2 yr 11 months
Full stack work experience

Does Amdocs renegotiate the offer ?

I have 20 LPA offer discussed with Amdocs (offer not released yet)
Other company giving 25 LPA Fix CTC

likehelpful

After nearly 20 years in the military serving in T&E and HR roles, I’m considering moving on and have been conducting lots of research into consulting. BS, MA, and SPHR cert - no MBA. I’m looking for suggestions or advise about transitioning. DC Metro area is likely landing spot.

like

Deloitte M2 advisory salary in SF?

like

More Posts

like

I am a current Agricultural Technology student, I have loads of hands in experience working with hemp used for CBD products in a farm setting, looking to move into controlled indoor ag, but I have definite interest in the cannabis industry. I can’t even access info on this app concerning that industry due to my age.

like
like

It's awfully quiet in here.... Let's get to matchmaking!

Post ASL and what you're looking for. 😀

like

What is the courtesy of withdrawing an offer you already accepted?

Do Cvent India provide any occasional goodies to the existing employees?

Cvent

Can anyone refer me to the Starz/Lionsgate Legal Affairs, Counsel role? I’d be happy to send you my resume first. Thanks!

likesmart

Should Dropbox be used as the main file system for a busy Litigation office? Help me prove that it shouldn’t and suggest a software that your firm uses.

like

I got a call from the Google recruiter about my L7 em interview Google She said I did overwhelmingly good on all interviews except one had mixed feedback on a system design. No surprise because it was not a good interview. The recruiter said i had a choice to go to hiring committee, give referrals they could call about my system design or take another system design interview. I’m not confident about the system design because of the bad experience I had with the previous interviewer. What should I do?

like

What is element require mitigation in a background check?

like

Looking for some advice on a couple of offers I have.

The first offer is for an Account Executive position at a smaller company with a base of $50k and another $20k in OTE.

The second offer is for a BDR position at a larger and faster growing company with a base of $60k and another $20k in OTE. Also some stock options but they aren’t public yet.

I have 2 YOE as a BDR and think I could succeed in either position. Both have hybrid work set ups. Any thoughts or advice is appreciated! Thanks.

like

Good morning!

Still trying to figure out this whole Fishbowl thing, so here goes my first post.

I would love to get into provider credentialing, but all employers I've looked at want at least 3 years of experience. So, I'm looking at Provider Network Coordinator roles, because I'm finding some of those roles don't need AS MUCH experience. I'm a RHIT, and have been working in healthcare for nearly 10 years.

Any input on employers is appreciated!

like

Did Deloitte disable Spark, the email app?

like

Anyone know how long it takes to get an offer or rejection from Accenture after the final interview? Interviewed for a consulting role.

like

If anyone is interested in forming a case chain or is already in one for McKinsey interviews, drop a comment

like

I am a Master’s Student who landed up with a Product Management internship. I am enjoying it and have done tasks that I thought were not my cup of tea. I want to continue with this role in future and would love to know experiences of other PMs. Also, any suggestions on how to prepare for PM full time opportunities?

First time cooking steak. Yay or nay!

Post Photo
likehelpful

I’m feeling anxiety about Coronavirus. Does anyone else think that the virus is being used by the government for population control? I don’t know if I’m paranoid.

like

What is the pay scale band for senior associate and manager level in M&A/private equity/project finance ptofile in PwC india?
Can anyone help on this?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Anyone ever get an out of cycle raise without having to get an offer from another firm?

like

Hot take. Is FAANG even a thing? Or was Cramer just worried about the acronym if he took out Netflix?

likefunnysmart

Is it recommended to get two full years of consulting experience before looking for a move elsewhere...for more comp (say to another Big 4, industry, attempt at MBB or FAANG)? Already have 8 yoe in the DoD space outside of consulting. And about 16 months of consulting exp

like

Any really impactful books that have helped you career-wise? Not necessarily consulting focused. In need of guidance and a new book so figured I'd kill two birds with one stone or whatever.

like

Question from a newbie consultant - What are some good online courses/ books to improve consulting skills?

like

What's the pay for a SC in Advisory after promotion? Just got the call :)

like

What do you recommend as Delta platinum choice benefit?

like

Top consulting firms in the aviation / urban air mobility space?

like

Will companies know that you got laid off if they do a background check?

like

How many snapshots you have? I only have five client snapshots so far

like

MBB peeps - what is your experience working with people that came from Big 4/Accenture (excluding those who came from strategy arms of B4)?

I am disappointed in the talent we have here at PwC and A) am looking to switch B) nervous that we don’t have a good reputation based on who I’ve worked with here

likefunny

Good nonfiction book recommendations? What are you all reading?

like

Just finished my last travel work week before the wedding vacay! This year has gone by so fast 🙈

like

Have any US 🐠 gone abroad for their MBA? Looking at LBS / HEC. Pros, cons? Not looking to exit into MBB, FAANG.

like

About to have annual comp discussion. What should I expect? Is there any room for negotiation

like

What are some of the best consulting firms for a software engineer? Is MBB still considered elite in this area too?

like

Woke up at 4am to get ready. Read the best message of my life "Your Delta flight has been cancelled" !!! Dreams do come true 😁

like

Starting to get more involved in the project sales process - any recommendations for books or resources to develop skills in this area?

like

Is anyone 1-2 segments shy of status with Delta and had to cancel trip due to ATL power outage? Delta says call back after Jan 1 and they will consider those segments but not 100% guaranteed.

like

How soon into joining a company can you gain paternal leave?

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal