Can anyone give me a gut check on decision to buy an apartment? It’s a 2bd coop in Park Slope, zoned for best school (we have a baby), and it’s well maintained and washer dryer in unit. Bedrooms next to each other but big (relatively). 800ish sq feet. Previously sold for 800 in 2016, offered 975 asking off market. Feel like I should have low balled and it’s a bit overpriced but got caught up in the moment. I can afford it fine but not a lot more. Getting cold feet before signing next week…

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

If you live in it for 5 years or so, it will pay back in appreciation. We bought for $425k in 2001 and is now appraised at $2 million. Yours feels just a bit overpriced if that but quite reasonable for PS321(?). Supply in PS will always lag demand for 2/3br. All buyers tend to have buyer’s remorse for a little bit. Key is to make it a fun home and enjoy the Slope

like

The real value in real estate is the leverage. That’s about a 7% CAGR for the home, and assuming 80% LTV, increases it to 14%. It’s a higher return once you consider annualized principal pay down.

In contrast the markets would’ve given you a 9% CAGR.

What it went for almost a decade ago is irrelevant. The market value is probably >1M. That is a decent price for a 2 bedroom in NYC…Perhaps I should take it if you back out. I’ve made impulsive “felt right” gut decisions before on real estate and it’s worked out well. Of course you should make sure you can afford it before buying.

like
Recent IconRecent

800 sq ft for 2 br?!

like

800 is 60% > 500, 60% is not marginally larger, imagine a 60% base salary increase

You would’ve never gotten it if you low balled. Brooklyn market is on fire. Don’t have any doubts, the value will double in time.

like

Agree. Don’t second guess the price

like

800 square feet with a kid is going to feel very small, very quickly. That said the apartment will likely appreciate pretty quickly over the next few years, and if you’re planning on renting something comparable, might as well go for it..

likefunny

For example: 2.5MM place in Greenwich village we considered. They bought it for that amount in like 2017 or so that means a decent loss. There were multiple from people that bought in 2015-17, especially for people that bought the place as new construction.

More expensive condos might be a bit like new cars as well where the first owner just loses a bit (unless the market overall appreciates a lot).

like

Isn’t coop supposed to be cheaper than condo? 975 sounds like a condo price. Feels a little expensive, depending how new the apartment is.

like

$975k gets you a studio condo in the outer boroughs, not a 2 br.

like

Could wait 6-12 months and save more but won’t get comfortable much over 1m for a while. Most much bigger/better layouts start at 1.2. Some comps have gone closer to 900, some over 1m. Who knows what market will do in meantime…

Why are you buying an apt in that range? You work at McK and your comp will grow significantly in the next few years. Get something for 1.2-1.5M then. You’ll have way better options and find something worth living in for 10 years (which is needed to compensate for the 10% selling costs of a coop when you move).

FWIW I have lived in BK Heights, Park Slope and Cobble Hill for the last 6 years and you sound like me in 2021. I’m probably buying something for 2-2.5M next year.

I’m internal, won’t accelerate like that. so a few years would help but worry we’d still be in first tier 2bd 1 bath

SOME SOUGHT OV BIG GIRL MAMA

What’s the benefit of buying over renting?

GS1 reminds me of a story I heard about a GS Partner who rented and had outdoor plastic furniture in his rental. 🤣

You might very well be right that the math edges out towards renting (the discussion above completely misses closing costs for example and plenty of people that bought around 2016-17 actually took a loss…) but renting some random “luxury” apartment in a rental with 500 other people is not what I’d consider a home. Most rentals are trash. Luxury apartments that don’t have the space for a proper dining table are all too common.

Related Posts

I have got Gurgaon as base location in offer letter. But since I lost a parent(my father) and relocating is kind of not possible for me at this moment can I ask them to relocate me to Kolkata?

PS - I am a campus hire so a fresher - Analyst

like

Has anyone started a new job while expecting a child? I'm thinking about it but could use some input from people with experience.

like

Currently have a 5th grade girl who is struggling with classroom behaviors and choices. When questioned, she says she wants to be a boy, but her parents won’t allow it. Obviously, she is struggling with more than making good choices at school. Her parents are very kind and appreciative of all we do for their child, but they are also clearly struggling with this. Anyone ever been in a similar situation or have some advice on how we can best support the student?

Any superb restaurant recommendations in vail? My wife and I will be celebrating our 10 year anniversary and we just had our first child. Since most dinners these days entail standing over our kitchen island, want to go all out on the food. We already have Matsuhisa and Mt. Standard lined up, curious to hear about any others!

Best self-care tips for dealing with loneliness/sadness this time of year? This is my first Christmas without my mom and it just feels like nothing will ever be the same again 😭. If you’ve lost a parent can you give me advice on getting through the holidays? Being a parentalish figure to my students is both healing and heartbreaking.

like

Just got a $125 gap gift card in the mail from EY for having a child. Though QR code doesn't work.

Anyone else receive this from EY?

like

How many of you had a first transfer success? Curious to hear what issues prevent it from happening

like

Hi! I have some questions about the Child Status Protection Act and a case that was denied for age out at Cuidad Juarez. What’s the correct process to try and “appeal” or “reopen”?

Please give me some hope. Are there any agencies where PMs are partnered with and respected and not treated like creative assistants/baby sitters?

likefunny

Should you gift your GF who has kids but not with you something for Mother’s Day? 👀 if yes what’s a good gift that’s not over involved ? (Not flowers or chocolates 🙄).

like

I have $100K liquid cash over and above maxing out 401K, HSA, College fund, investments in Index funds and emergency fund. I plan to leave $25K for contingency. Of the $75K is it wise if I purchase I bonds worth $30K (myself, spouse, kid)? Current combined rate is 9.62 Does anyone foresee the interest rate drastically reducing? I don’t intend to cash them out before 5 years.

Man, "What? I'm in a meeting?"
Woman, "Did you leave the refrigerator door open again?"
Man, "I can't right now I'm in a meeting, can you close it"
Woman, "Please, make sure it's shut, how many times do I have to tell you. My breast milk is in there, I'm already taking care of one child I don't need another. I'm not your mother!"
Planner,"Hey man, we wanted to tell you but I guess you couldn't hear us. Your camera was off but you weren't on mute.'

funnylike

A parent of one of my students told admin she thinks it's irresponsible that I won't be grading over Christmas break. I let the students know to get any work they need graded in before the break and I'll get it to it during our workdays in January. Apparently that's not fast enough for her 🙄. Is it wrong that I'm sort of pissed off by this? Should I say something?

likehelpfulfunnyupliftingsmart

529 Plan VERSUS Prepaid

We live in Florida and currently have a Freshman in High School and a 16 month old. We hear from our friends and family with college bound children "I wish we would have done Florida PrePaid." After obviously ignoring this for years, we are finally trying to do it before "it's too late" for both children.

Does anyone have recommendations on which plan to go with for each child? I once did the pros and cons on a whiteboard and it seemed like 529 was better.

like

House flip question

Hey all newbie here. My husband and I are living that Double Income No Kid life wanting to (Financial Independence) Retire Early.

Both in tech in the Bay Area. I’m in Arizona visiting family and am thinking of an investment property. Does anyone have a book/course/video that they personally have used and recommend for flipping houses? I want to do some research there’s a lot of content out there.
Thanks a bunch!

like

How long do fed agencies give for maternity leave? does it matter if you take leave within your first year? does it vary from agency to agency? Specifically interested in SEC/CFTC.

like

I used to be really bad about not prioritizing my prayer life. But now I pray & talk to God all the time. I’ve seen what prayer does-it can change the trajectory of your life. God tells us to make our prayers & petitions known to Him & to pray without ceasing. What happens when we pray is absolutely incredible.The Holy Spirit within us interprets our groans & our prayers to our advocate Jesus Christ who petitions God the Father on our behalf. The perfect triune God hears my prayers and yours!

Post Photo
like

PwC India Hi Folks, I left my stable job at Deloitte USI and moved to Germany for a better job. But my mom had a major health issue and I'm planning to travel back to India to support her as I'm a single child. I'm working in one of the top organisation in Germany with a base of 90k euro and looking for good opportunities in India. Availability: immediately Tech stack: SAP BASIS/Hana with azure/GCP Exp: 8.8 EY PwC India Pwc AC Accenture Deloitte HCL Technologies

like

Has anyone here used the "Read Scripture" app? It goes through the entire Bible and includes accompanying summary videos from "The Bible Project" (whose videos can also be found on YouTube). I love how it groups portions of Scripture and the videos are helpful for making meaningful connections with the text. I love these for myself, but they're super kid-friendly, too. Excellent support for your daily study. Enjoy!

like

My boyfriend has been playing duets with a neighbor of ours for the past ~8 months. His wife is due to have a baby girl in a week. What might be a nice gift? We don’t know her that well so want to play it safe!

like

More Posts

Alvarez & Marsal Alvarez & Marsal fishes - comp wise for new hires, are base salaries pretty much fixed at AM or could be negotiated? Looking for base range at Senior Director level for PEPI MAS.

Knicks & Giants won today, what a great Sunday

like

Product Manager offer is 120k salary, sign on bonus of 15k. 4 YOE total. Undergrad degree in computer science. Am I underpaid? This is a legit question lol. I’ve only done federal contracting/consulting work.

like

What is avg. salary paid to a lead (manager level- 7+YOE) at Bain? Also how’s the WLB?

like

I recently was let go (in lieu of accepting my two weeks) and I should have received my March expense check by the end of April per the employment agreement (submitted the report April 1, let go before mid April). I have emailed HR but haven't heard anything. I've got a feeling someone at the top is putting a hold on it.

How do I get my money from them? It's a few hundred dollars

Sorry if this isn't the right bowl for this question - I've checked a few.

like

I heard from my head that there is a lot of slowdown in VW Germany... There is Hiring freeze, level freeze and all ... And soon that will spillover to india. So be prepared for very less hikes in coming cycle :( Also automotive sector in general is struggling with tesla laying off 10% workforce recently. Maybe time to make a move? What do you say fishes?

like

Analyst doing the same tasks each week only needing to put in 60%. does it get less repetitive? I want to put in 110% with new challenges. any advice?

Is canada goose just an NYC thing? And moreover is it just a show off thing (cause i haven’t been cold in my 200$-300$ down jacket lol)

like

Cool Halloween party ideas for a late 20/early 30 group?

like

Anyone at EY willing to talk about their experience and potentially refer for a salesforce senior dev position ?

Recruiter said IFS comp is basically an inflation-level raise annually and bonus of 0-15%. Is that your experience? Afraid if I leave client side I’ll get 0% bonus and 1-2% raise

Do you believe getting paid more would alleviate your burnout?

like

Anyone know any places hiring designers in PDX? 🙂

like

Hearing the low raises of senior managers and up as a senior, it makes me worry a little bit about long term trajectory.

like

I am an Oncology Clinical Research Coordinator with 15+ years of experience. I have program management and pharmaceutical manufacturing experience that gives me additional unique experience. I am wanting to get into the Clinical Trial Management/ Research Management role and am having no luck. Currently working for UW in Seattle. Pay is stagnant, grossly understaffed, commute is terrible, but the benefits are great. Any suggestions on CTO that offers great benefits and competitive salary?

likesmart

What do you guys think if away carry on? How do they compare to tumi or rimowa?

like

I have a wee crush on one of the partners in my firm and I thought he liked me too, but neither of us did anything about it (which is entirely appropriate). That was all pre-Rona. Now I’m leaving the firm and pursuing another opportunity and staying in the same city. Since he’ll no longer be my boss, is there a way to find out if my feeling was correct? How should I go about this? (Especially given Rona?)

like

Have people gotten their bonus’ prorated in a year they were on parental leave? Any hunches to tell if it was more less than a straight prorate?

like

Dear legal recruiters who used to work as attorneys: are you glad you made the switch? I think recruiting could be fun but I know how much I ignore recruiter emails daily so it makes me think it’s touch to place people and make a consistent income. Thoughts?

like

I joined in mid February in FIS Global and my PF is deducting since Feb but not crediting in PF account as it is not showing in PF portal. Only 9 days of Feb of Employer contribution in PF and EPS is showing only.

Kindly to whom or how to approach for this ??

like

Additional Posts in New York City

My boyfriend has been playing duets with a neighbor of ours for the past ~8 months. His wife is due to have a baby girl in a week. What might be a nice gift? We don’t know her that well so want to play it safe!

like

Anyone at Deloitte ny in M&A or due diligence willing to chat?

like

I’m looking for a 1BR / Studio apartment in NJ area - Hoboken, Grove St., Exchange Place, etc. - anyone looking to sublease their apartment for a period of 6-8 months starting January?

like

Anyone have experience with rentopia for Brooklyn listings? They seem to control most listings in the area I’m looking and are very unresponsive

like

anyone willing to help me out and send throw this post some likes, need to access DM's, please and thankyou!

likesmart

Does anyone know of a place to get something notarized in the area of Grand Central? Tried Chase bank but they won’t notarize a deed.

like

Need some opinions with a situation I’m dealing with my roommate. So, she’ll have people stay over and 95% of the time she won’t tell me about it. And they’ll stay anywhere from a few days to a month. I’m more annoyed when they stay longer than a week or so. She has someone over now and didn’t tell me. It’s been about a week now. If she stays longer, am I a bad person if I ask for her to pitch in with the utility bill or something.

like

Looking to buy my first condo in Long Island city area. How many properties you typically visit (open houses) before making a decision?
Thanks!

like

Anyone can recommend good Meetup groups/events in nyc? I feel like a lot of events I find there show the author books +20 ppl coming and I can’t even see who are those coming. Not sure if it’s a scam

like

Thinking of getting a peloton. Anyone actually experience weight loss and overall health improvement from having one?

I make excuses for not going to the gym and the number 1 being convenience so I figure if it’s in my actual home then I have no excuses!

Be nice, thanks! 😊

like

Has anyone used kaiyo for selling furniture? Have a west elm couch i want to get rid off

like

Best places to shop for dresses to wear to summer weddings?

like

Does anyone have Harry styles tickets for sale?

like
like

Anyone had any luck recently landing a place under $3k?

like

Recommendations for an Indian restaurant (preferably halal) in Manhattan that can accommodate a party of 30-40 folks? TIA

like

Rental car third party liability insurance: My credit card covers car insurance, but not third party liability insurance, so I generally get that from the car rental company at about $20 a day. Is there a cheaper way to do it? Recommendations?

like

Has anyone had roommates who got sick with Covid and they managed to not catch it from them? If so, what precautions did you take? We have a good relationship and so far he’s been staying in his room and using a mask whenever he needs to use the restroom or grab water from the kitchen. I am the only one who touches the fridge and takes his food out so he can eat. What else can we really do?

like

Anybody here visit Gunnison, either once or regularly? Curious how much of the professional NYC crowd is present there.

like

Can someone explain to me what the big whoop is about working in IB? Hours seem nuts from what I read in the bowls. What am I missing? Is it the pay?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal