Can references tip the balance in an MBA application (e.g., 2 very strong Partner references, both HBS alum), when having a sub-optimal gmat score (e.g., 680-700). Context: 4 years work experience at MBB

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Sure it will help, but applications are looked at holistically

like

If the references are really outstanding then that makes a big difference. Only data point they have that isn’t straight from you. Especially from MBB where they’re well calibrated
But are they really that outstanding? Bear in mind that the vast majority of people who apply to HBS have bosses who like them. Are yours willing to say you’re the best they’ve ever worked with?

like

I’d also argue if you’re a 680 gmat, you won’t be in the “balance”. You’ll most likely have to knock everything out of the park, including recs and interviews to get in, especially if you’re applying from MBB where gmat average is at or higher than school average.

It’ll really depend on what they say not who writes it. Particularly for HBS. Focus on who can write the best one, not the title.

FYI - applied as MBB 4YOE this round and both my recs were non alums and only 1 was a Partner.

Nowhere yet but had interviews with H and W.

Sounds like you don't even have a GMAT score yet if you are offering a range. There is no shame in taking the test more than once.

Since the evaluation is holistic, your test score won't get you in or keep you out. With a score below the 80% range you need to be outstanding on all other areas of evaluation.

Thank you. Does 680 fall in the 80% range?

Related Posts

Anyone at MBB looking to make a referral?

funnylike

Does anyone know of somebody that was able to transfer to a US school as an undergrad?

like

Going to Wharton in the fall. Is it worth going MBB over returning to big 4 (sponsored)? Is this a common path?

like

Need to recertify my AWS-SAA cert. any recommendations on best resources given the new test format (SAA-CO2)?

like

I’m feeling stagnant in my career and looking for ways to grow. I was considering obtaining a PMP certification and wondering how impactful this is. Is this certification well recognized?

like

Phr vs waiting for sphr?
Taking the credential and want to prep.

Looking for advice on tips and tricks for landing PE MBA internship, coming from consulting. What were the game changers for you?

like

Are PE investing role WLB and Stress that much worse than MBB?

like

On MBA resumes, how should I describe my company? Work for a company that the ad comm probably won’t know. What details should I include?

like

Does PHR certification help in India, as this is globally recognised how much valuable is this currently in indian job market.

Do we got some good offers or its another certificate just to add to CV after so much of investment & time I don't want to get this wasted !!

Need suggestions ??

Any recommendations on schools that offer PhD studies as part time while one still works full-time? What's the tuition fee and years of study?

like

Leadership role in my state university’s alumni group vs leadership role at my firm’s early career group? Want to develop ways to show leadership for MBA applications in a few years. Thoughts?

likehelpful

Hi Guys,

I have 11YOE overall. I am doing a CSM & PM(PMP) role for past 4Y

CCTC - 11LPA
Already got an offer of 15LPA

Atteending further more interview
How much should I quote as my ECTC ?
Pls hlp

Thanks!

like

Hello Fishes.

I am having 2 years experience in SAP MM, SAP MII and Supply Chain Management with a popular certification. I am understanding what kind of opportunities I can get in McKinsey. Can anyone be kind enough to throw a light?

Smart Connected Products team within Industry-X of Accenture Capability Network is looking for folks with relevant work experience (Consulting, Connected Products and Platforms, Product Management, Innovation, Urban Mobility, Smart Cities etc.) of 8+ years (including pre-MBA experience) for executive positions - Level 7 & above.

Please reach out to me if you have a relevant profile.
You can DM me and I can share the JD.

Thanks

Accenture

like

Career pivot into consulting? I've always been in a non client serving role and I just want that opportunity? Even completed an MBA and no luck. Too much experience in one area that am no longer interested on.

like

Anyone here have experience / know anyone who did the Luxury & Fashion Retail MBA @ NYU Stern?

like

I have recently joined EY SaT group as senior consultant recently in Netherlands. I’m tripple masters in MS economics, MBA and MS business analytics. Have 4 YOE in different industries but no M&A experience specifically. Any ideas what company should be offering me? I’ll be working as expert on commercial due diligence, FDD and valuation teams and doing automation alongside. is it wise to demand higher salary or promotion soon after I have proven that I can work and do it better than most?EY

likefunny
like

I have a return offer from a big 4! Thoroughly enjoyed the experience as an intern and have no complaints. Would love to go back.

However, a bit confused if I should try and recruit with MBB’s or if I should accept the big 4 offer already and take the sign on bonus?

Would it be a blunder to NOT try recruiting with MBB’s ? Besides the monetary aspect, what are the other things I’d have to think about?

like

More Posts

Just to get things started around here… what are your go-to restaurants to entertain or just take the family?

like
like

How much would orange theory cost if you went 2-3x each week?

like

I feel that way too bud

Post Photo
like

Given all the recent buzz about expected large raises around the big 4, I’d like to level set on the average salary for a 4th/5th year female senior manager in federal tax ( credits & methods group) in the Midwest - Chicago/Minneapolis/Detroit market. Anyone willing to share a range if they work in a similar area of tax / similar level? I recognize all groups vary greatly in salary expectations, so looking for input specific to my area. Current expectations set at 140-160k. Reasonable?

likefunny

Anyone else frustrated with the lack of follow through from potential employers? I have had two companies undercut my ability to have an equal chance to compete for a role. One company kept telling me a second interview would happen in a few weeks. Nothing for 3 months even with my check ins. To just find out the role was filled. Another company flat out said they couldn’t find my application (in their system where it was attached to job req number) and filled the role.

like

Wells - curious. Where are you and are you buyer/seller? I'm guessing buyer and all the stats I read are completely in our favor, yet I feel like books of business should be going for sale every day and I struggle to find any good sellers?

Hi, Can someone guide me which product based companies are good for a linux administrator with 4+ years experience. It will be helpful to move forward with clarity.

like

is mba necessary for landing job as HR, how to establish into L&D roles ? are certification helpful, can you let me know some.

like

considering betting a ton of money on tomorrow’s elections via “predict it”, as an emotional hedge. is this a stupid idea or a genius idea

like

Looking to invest money with a Schwab brokerage to save for a down payment on a home. What ETFs should I invest in?

like

I’m a 40-year-old agent and it feels like it’s now or never for following my passion. Does a newbie to film at my age have any chance of breaking into the industry?

like

What are good margins for PI associate attorneys; i.e., what should they make for the firm compared to what the firm would/ should pay them?

like

I’ve been told my company is changing my title from Associate Director of BD to Sales Executive. I’m concerned it reads like a title demotion. Is it just semantics? How will this look for my career development? Curious about the standard perception of Sales Executive from a seniority perspective. Where does this land on the sales roles hierarchy? For context, it’s a professional services firm, I’ve been there 3+years, and they gave a Sales Executive title to someone who just started 5mo ago.

like

Need a morning workout buddy

like

Girlfriend has very obvious high functioning anxiety and body image issues that she admits but thinks she doesn’t need therapy or medication and that reading self-help books will help her. It’s not changing in the last several years and it’s impacting our relationship. Anyone have experience with their SO dealing with untreated anxiety? I know I can’t control her but would like to express my feelings without sending her into a spiral. For context, I’ve been in therapy for 12 months and medicated

like

My office will be Marisoft Wing C, Kalyani Nagar. How is that? In which area can I find flats for rent?

like

Hi,
Need a referral for a data science/analytics position in Pune/Remote.
Total yoe - 4 yrs (All into analytics)
Tech Stack - Python, Tableau, SQL, Advance Excel, Github, Data Science, AI, ML, etc.
TIA!!!

Hello, I'm looking at a position within Paypal. My question, what is the work life balance, expectation for office (hybrid/remote/other) and is the pay comparable to other companies? Reviewing Director and Senior Director roles on the business side. I have over 15 years experience with multiple degrees. TIA!

like

Additional Posts in MBA Applicants

Any advice on where to find the best “profile guides” for the top MBA programs? I find that the school descriptions on poets and quants are a bit outdated.

like

Anyone felt their Wharton TBD went poorly (or average)? Hope I am not the only one who felt that way.

like

Chin up to all my fellow HBS dings out there. It was a tough year. Congrats to all who were invited! 🍻

likeuplifting

Is R3 even worth the bother? I have a T15 option but thinking about throwing in another M7 app. Thoughts?

like

Has anyone here gotten the Consortium Fellowship with the help of a consultant?

like

Got another reject 😔
Advice on applying in Round 3 for Darden ?

like

What does the order of Stanford interview invitations mean? If you get one sooner (closer to 10/14), does that mean you’re higher priority?

like

Trying to get my GRE Quant score from a 160 to a 165. Feel like it’s a harder jump than when starting from a lower base - will appreciate any strategy tips or suggested Quant resources!

like

Hello, has anyone filled in the Forte Fellows Kira video questions?

Are they any different from usual Kira interview questions?

like

Sponsored folks, where do you plan to intern during bschool?

like

In one month is my mid term review.. Should I let my mentor know I'm applying for mba this year now or should I wait till after the review session? I'm afraid mentioning going to b school would hurt my "fast promotion". What's your guy's experience? :)

like

Are sponsored applicants less likely to get scholarship $ since the school knows that $ is likely not a barrier to attending?

like

Why is it that those in IB can’t get an MBA and return to IB the way people from other industries have returned post-MBA?

like

what gmat score do I need to get to aim for m7? I’m asian, F, 2+ years in accenture strategy, & studied at top public school (think UC Berkeley, UMich) with a 3.4 GPA with engineering degree

likefunny

Do schools ever admit applicants without interviewing? I didn’t get invited to interview at SOM/Darden — does that mean it’ll 100% be a rejection?...

like

I regret not applying to Harvard. I never thought I’d get into a top school and then got into wharton with a 100k fellowship - which changed my entire perspective. It sucks thinking “what if…”. I just didn’t have the confidence and thought wharton was a reach so why bother with H/S 🙃 hope this inspires someone to just shoot their shot - you never know

like

Enrolled in an executive MBA program at a top uni, and I have to say I’m very happy I did that vs FT/PT.

likeupliftingfunny

Need advice—torn btwn Booth and Sloan.

Already work in mgmt. consulting but looking to do either consulting or ibanking post-MBA (have only been at company for 1 year so not sponsored and may or may not return to my company).

Have $60K scholarship at Booth, nothing at Sloan. However, I already went to UChicago undergrad and live in Boston so have an established network here. However, concerned about lack of soft skills/leadership development, focus on academics, nerdy culture at Sloan.

like

anyone here apply to MBA programs in Europe? from the states but am interested in pursuing my MBA in Europe and would love to learn more about the process!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal