Currently have offers from the 3 firms L.E.K. Consulting, Roland Berger and Strategy& cloud and digital services. Need insights on which firm would be better to join as a consultant post MBA. I have a decade of experience in the automotive sector which I think will help at Roland Berger and I have heard great things about the culture, brand recognition and future career prospects at LEK. Any thoughts and perspectives would be helpful.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

In the US then S&, anywhere else RB, PE then LEK. Want a global career=rb. At my place, RB’s size=S&+Monitor+LEK+OW, so you have many international opportunities. (I am in Asia, LEK is a boutique and S& is very small)

like

Please feel free to DM me. I had offers from both RB and LEK out of Booth.

What you are seeing in the comments here is the general fact that LEK is much bigger in the US than RB, but situation is more nuanced. LEK’s primary focus is on DD work. Just do a search for automotive partners on LEK’s website and you’ll find that they have maybe 4 people, and the auto work they do is a few specific topics outside of DD. Look at RB’s auto practice and you’ll find 100+ people on the website and a ton of content and studies on cutting edge topics in the industry. Yes, marketing isn’t always reflective of the situation, but the difference in practice size and emphasis is apparent. So if you’re focused on the auto industry this should be a no-brainer.

If you want to do tech consulting, then the Strategy& sounds great.

like
Recent IconRecent

I would do S& then LEK then RB

like

Lek for sure

like

For US Consulting, I’d go S&, then LEK. For Europe/Asia, RB. For PE, LEK.

like

LEK will give you the broadest exit opps that youve listed within the US (including PE) and pays far better than the other two once you get to the manager level.

Internationally I agree with what other fish have posted about RB - have heard great things in europe. S& cloud/digital does not seem like the move to make for what you want to do

like

LEK manager would be a director anywhere else. No longer doing much case slide work. Mostly sell and only help out when shit hits the fan

like

I’d go with LEK if I were you, no brainer

like

Thank you everyone. The offers are for Chicago offices in the US. Based on the comments so far LEK appears to be a better firm based on reputation and future career prospects. Curious to hear from consultants at RB on their growth trajectory in the US and how they rate their compensation scaling compared to the industry.

like

If you want to stay in the automotive space, given your experience and the firms growth in the USA, you are in the drivers seat for career growth.

smart

RB is more known in Europe. If the offer from their US offices, that may be a minus. Strategy& is part of the PWC and that may be a negative as well. I would say go with LEK especially given that you consider PE route seriously.

like

If US or Middle East then S&. Europe then RB.

LEK is also great, and world be a good choice in the US if you want to focus on DD.

like

I agree with this. The Middle East is our strongest group.

helpful

I would generally say LEK and S& is a toss up, but your offer is for the cloud line at S& I’d ask whether that is a passion of yours, or if you’d like to do more growth strat and DD which would be better at LEK. FWIW pay at LEK will be significantly higher if you make M

like

If interested in auto and industrials in Chicago then I think RB is a clear first choice. Interesting mix across OEM , suppliers and aftermarket. Leading the change in the overall industry pertaining to electrification and new business models. And we’re growing tremendously which creates great upside.

like

Keeping my options open. Option1 would be to continue in consulting, option 2 explore PE opportunities, option 3 Switch into PM/Corp. Strat roles at tech firms.

like

I think LEK gives you the most leeway here. No bad options but all things equal LEK is probably more synonymous with PE.

like

Think all 3 are the same for op 1 and 3 but Lek wins option 2. Curious on other thoughts, not too familiar with RB

like

Ops? RB.
PE? LEK
Don’t know? Strategy&

helpful

RB owns auto practice globally

like

Unable to DM anyone since I'm new to Fishbowl. RB2 could you send a DM ? Eager to hear your thought

like

Fishbowl is telling me ‘this user is not available to chat’. Not sure if it’s an issue on my end, your end, or fishbowl’s.

What is your long term professional aspirations?

Directly recruit into the RB digital service?

We have an automotive practice (although don’t know much about it), so if that’s something you’re interested in you can always mention it to staffing or reach out to the partner.

Related Posts

What’s the best career for a students who wants to work before going into strategy consulting? Let’s assume that working in external advisory and consulting is off the table.

likesmart
like

Hi fishes I am fresher from Computer Science. I am allotted salesforce developer profile in my organization. I want to know how good is salesforce developer for career. And how will be it's demand with respect to future. Please guide me I am in a lot of confusions.

like

I left my last job because I didn't appreciate the culture (B4). However, it was probably because I was a terrible employee. However, I do find that my clients love me 10x more than my consulting colleagues. I joined a smaller firm to cover up the problem.

I drink during the day. I know it's the main reason for my ability to be a productive employee. Anyone else deal with this? I'm trying to control it through moderation management, Dharma meetings, therapy, and white knuckling.

like

Need to recertify my AWS-SAA cert. any recommendations on best resources given the new test format (SAA-CO2)?

like

I have a possible opportunity at Protiviti. Coming from big4 and wondering if Protiviti has fairly similar perks. I’ve read the 2022 benefits guide and it gave a oddly low PTO count of 16 days. Is this true and what about a holiday disconnect in the December time period? Are there any other hidden perks that are awesome? Already heard WLB is better and the culture, but I feel like I’ve gotta find that out first hand. Protiviti

likehelpful

How many days will it take for Wells Fargo to release the offer letter ?
I attended my interview and got shortlisted as well, I just got an email stating congratulations and send us list of documents !! After which When I try contacting the HR, he's not responding !! What do I do in such case !!
Kindly Advise...

like

Hello all, Mphasis reviews please. How are spotfire or other BI tools like tableau and Power BI projects there? How easy or difficult is it to switch technology and project there? How is the job security considering the current recession?

like

Is buddy and counsellor same in EY Gds?

like

Thinking of switching over to a non-creative role but not sure how my soul will react. Anyone here done it? What was the outcome?

like

What advisory positions in big four best translates from audit? I am interested in advisory but want to make sure I am capable of doing the position. Any advice on position that best translates from audit experience?

like

Anyone from GSK who can help with some questions?

Hi,
I had call with the HR for he position based out of Mumbai everything in interview and they are ready to share the offer. however, I quoted for 10 lakhs and they said for fixed pay of 8.75.
Although, i checked on Google as well average pay they are giving is 9.7 lakh
So should I accept the offer as per their negotiation or shall positively tell them why 10 lakh is justified?

I had a very positive experience interviewing with Amazon for an L5 Technical Writer role. I originally applied for a lower level writing role, ending up acing my Loop, and was passed on to speak to the hiring manager for the L5 role.

Given the positive tone of our conversation, I expect to receive an offer this week.

Can somebody tell me what kind of base salary/bonus/RSU ranges I should aim for? I'm transitioning to tech and have 10+ years of professional writing experience. PNW based.

like

Are Analysts expected to travel while working for the consulting practise at Deloitte India? How often is one staffed on/rotated across projects?

like

What is the Protiviti senior consultant 1 salary? Also thoughts on Protiviti vs West Monroe?

like

How is life at IBM ISDL Koramangala Bengaluru office? IBM IBM iX

like
like

Are skills in MDM on the rise? What technical skills should be learned in addition to create a transferable skill set?

like

More Posts

I submitted the documents with HR more than a month ago. Since then I haven't received an offer letter or Update from them. I tried contacting but no response.

Now suddenly I got this mail. Still no offer letter.
I am really confused.
Please share your thoughts?
Cognizant

Post Photo
like

Has anyone lost a job opportunity because your counter offer was too high?

like

Dear Sharks

Has anyone got Bonus payment, Usually 30% bonus split into 7.5% will paid on the last month of each quarter right
Like March, June, September, December

I have joined August month
I have not got any variable pay bonus
Is my understanding correct
Pls guide

How hard are the Series 7, 65, or 82 exams? Interested in those because I don’t see myself reaching accredited status via capital alone any time soon.

like

Clearing out the entire schedule for champions league >>>

like

When do I begin adjusting? It’s been 4 months. I joined as an associate and I feel like sometimes my work is sloppy or I’m overwhelmed. I’ve gotten feedback that I’m making progress but that sounds fake. I’ve also gotten feedback that my work is sometimes sloppy. The last report I helped write had a ton of write ups on it. Feels like I’m about to get fired.

like

Got my first juror summons that I couldn’t claim an exemption for yesterday 😭. Anybody here actually made it onto a jury as an attorney?

likesmart

Any good ideas for mouse macros? So far i have ctrl shift L, paste values, and format painter....

I’m 25 living in Chicago, decent paying jobs, no bills/loans. Is it best to rent or own?

Anyone up for a date this weekend in Pune. M29 here.

Kya pata maa ko bahu mil jae.. 🙊🙈

Cringe. Finding an excuse to pose a pic of herself. Also, Jean skirt: faux pas.

Post Photo
likefunny

How does everyone manage SAD during the winters. Feeling so down and not sure what are the best ways to cope.

like

SM on my project stepped away on paternity leave. SM was the one who led partner discussions and most of the client meetings. We're a week from a client deadline.

As a manager, I'm stepping but incredibly stress with the amount of moving parts. I don't have a strong rapport with the partner (Neither did the SM) to be open and transparent on how stressful I'm feeling without downgrading myself.

I'm sick to the stomach and very anxious, stressed at the suddenness of the thrust.

Help!

like

What’s the thought that keeps you from giving up?

like

I have been at my job for 6 years. I’m upset about how our pay raise went and I’m thinking about looking for a new job. The anxiety is overwhelming when it comes to this. Different routine, different people, the thought of messing up, what if I hate it. I am comfortable where I’m at, but feel as though they did us aides wrong when it comes to pay. I’m very overwhelmed right now.

like

Hertz or Avis, and why? Hertz for me because everyone I know that uses Avis says it takes forever to earn free days.

like

What are some good books that helped you with consulting? Looking for some good reads.

like

Sometimes, I feel so proud when I look at my old codes and think, "How can I think something so beautiful like this?" 🤩

like

Anyone have a lake? Has Sonar AS (floridone) worked for your pond weed problem?

1 week sober! Over the last 12 years (I’m early 30s) I’ve reached this point just a handful of times. Alcohol is deeply intertwined into my social life much like everyone’s is I imagine. Feeling clear minded and energized. Want to stay clean for my own mental and physical health and for the benefit of my wife and children. Just starting this journey so thank you in advance to this community as I’m ready to learn from you all and be a part. Let’s go!

likeuplifting

Additional Posts in Career Advice for Students

Anyone know why Capital One is ramping up hiring ? Capital One

like
like

recently asked a question about going to law school with an accounting degree. follow up on that- if i work 1-2 years at my current firm (offered 72,500 full time after graduating undergrad) and acquire my cpa (courses and exam fees paid for by the firm), then apply to law school, would that be more beneficial? ive been reading a lot that work experience helps with the application, alongside having a high gpa and LSAT score

As someone who gets an offer to work in PwC, can I relocate internationally within PwC to other countries ? PwC

like

Anyone know how long it takes to get an offer or rejection from Accenture after the final interview? Interviewed for a consulting role.

like

Any advice for somebody graduating with a Masters in Technology Management in December (2022) and looking for a job in Product Management?

Have been looking on LinkedIn for a few months and other company sites but no luck.

like

What are the best consulting firms for digital marketing?

like

Do not be distracted 🤝

Post Photo
likehelpful

Anyone here pivot from politics/campaigns to consulting? Worked at one of the national committees for a few years and decided to get my MBA as a working professional to try and transition. Any advice appreciated!

What’s the best career for a students who wants to work before going into strategy consulting? Let’s assume that working in external advisory and consulting is off the table.

likesmart

I just got an offer at McKinsey and I was wondering if the base pay is the same across all first year BAs or if there is typically room for negotiation this early in the career. What other questions do I need to be asking?

I had requested a super brutal resume review a couple of days back here and got some excellent feedback. Added indents and cut down content (there was a lot more text earlier) according to suggestions.

Will be extremely grateful for an additional review with the changes. I am looking for business intelligence and business analyst roles.

I am also looking for a referral in Deloitte +kpmg for a systems/bi analyst role, will be super grateful for some help there too.

Post Photo
like

Applied to McKinsey Business Analyst Internship 2023 @ NYC office, did the Imbellus 10 days ago. Have not heard anything from recruiting yet. Meanwhile my friend who applied to the same position, same school here at Dartmouth got invited to McKinsey Philadelphia Office interview. Is NYC office slow or does that mean I am out…?

like

How to start automation testing?

likeuplifting

As an ADC applying this summer for 2022 start, I haven’t gotten a chance to connect with any L.E.K. Consulting members and I really want to get to know the company better before moving on with my application. Any L.E.K. Consulting fish out there willing to spare a few minutes to chat about their work, the company, the culture etc? Thanks!

like

What are exits for tech transfer? Have an opportunity, but idk if I want to work for university commercialization offices for the rest of my life

like

I have been looking at the curriculums for Harvard Business School's Master of Business Administration and Harvard Extension School's Master's in Management. They both have the same requirements, generally speaking, including a field immersion course that serves as a capstone in the Master's in Management, which is fairly new. If I am not able to gain admission to Harvard Business School, but wanted a similar educational experience to become a consultant, should I attend Harvard Extension?

like

Hi guys,
Can you tell me which way should I display my profile and skills?
The first section or second? Both contain almost the same keywords.

Post Photo
like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal