Do you need to ace both cases in Boston Consulting Group final rounds to get an offer? Aced one case but did eh on the second (tripped up on a graph and the partner didn’t run a formal case)

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

That was me and I got the offer so…

like

Same

Here’s the thing. Most interviewees have no idea if they actually killed it or not. They know if they got to a final answer smoothly, but that’s about 10% of what I’m looking for. Did you show an ability to structure the problem, did you communicate your thoughts well, and did you show creativity and a collaborative nature in your thinking? Those are all more important in my book and most people have limited ability to self evaluate how they did on those unless they did really poorly in my experience

like

This.

I keep telling people that the interview is 50% case. The other 50% is your culture fit. Remember that.

I’ve heard that sometimes you never really know what put you forward

like

My example:

I thought about tennis courts like hotels for a revenue case, which seemed sophisticated.

Used to have to do well on both (doesn’t have to be ace) to get an offer. These days there seems to be a lot more leniency—if we expected people to ace both we wouldn’t have bodies. 🤫

like

In today’s climate, you just need to show up to get hired. 😂

Seriously though, in current circumstances you can afford to perform average on one case.

like

This is somewhat true. There have been multiple instances where a person did well in one case and mediocre (at best) on the second case (including making unforced errors) and was still made an offer (because they were otherwise qualified and did well in fit interviews, and were very likable). While this makes sense half the time, I think we need to be better with our standards for case performance.

Totally depends on the interviewer. I screwed up a graph question and still got hired, but I know of people getting denied because the partner didn’t vibe with their PEI answers. Like most business decisions, it seems like it often comes down to a gut feeling.

Hahahhahahahahahahahahha no

Related Posts

Is it ok to apply to multiple positions at the same company when searching for a new job?

like

Does anyone have any recommendations on how to prep for a human capital case study? I’m interviewing for SC role and have deep knowledge in the areas of Org Design, Change Management and Culture Transformation. I worry more about structuring the conversation and my answers in the most effective way

like
like

If you interview for a job but are not offered the position, is it weird to try to connect with some of your interviewers on LinkedIn? I genuinely liked some of my interviewers, but apparently the company identified a candidate whom it believes is a better fit.

like

Do Accenture still do case interview for SM level ?

like

I applied to EY in November through a referral and didn’t get selected. I’m applying again but this time just using the same account as I applied with last time. Will the system move up my app because it’s still within one year of getting a referral?

like

What are the prospects of being hired into a company you failed the first round of interviews (not the HR one)?

like

First American Financial Corporation I have attended two rounds of interview in First American Finan Company last week and have received an email that I have been selected in their interview process. The talent acquisition team did not send me an offer letter instead have sent me a BGC form which I submitted yesterday. I found it very strange as usually first offer letter is rolled out and then BGC check happens if the candidate accepts the offer. Today there was no communication. Can anyone tell me if they faced this situation?TIA

Creative recruiters, how many LinkedIn messages do you get a day?

like

4YOE @Amazon & trying to lateral to a similar role @FAANG. Have my undergrad GPA (3.8/4) on resume from top 15 school but colleague says to take it off (looks silly). If it’s a good school & high GPA, why ever take it off your resume? Even if 10 YOE...can’t hurt?

like

How is everyone getting Fall/ Spring/ summer internships? Are you all applying on the company website/ LinkedIn page. Networking to recruiters? Through college career center. I've been applying and not getting anything? Any tips or advice?

like

Hey all. I have an interview with an investment bank coming up. I am currently a senior associate at big 4 doing financial due diligence. Can anyone give me interviews tips/what to study? I am very new to the diligence (less than 3 months), so am far from understanding a deal start to finish.

like

Anyone know what The Kraft Group & Affiliates tax or finance team interview process is like?

Has anyone ever worked with a recruiter/headhunter? Are there any pr/mar comms focused firms you'd recommend?

like

What questions to expect in ubs UI dev interview for 4 years exp candidate. Can someone share their experience

Are any consulting case books on Amazon worth it, and if so which are they?

like

Hi all,

I interviewed with capgemini for SAP ABAP role and my YOE is 4 years. Just 2 hours after my interview, I got a call from someone at Capgemini saying that I am selected.
They just asked my notice period and current location.I asked them, what is the next round going to be and they said that it is going to be salary discussion. But till now, no one has reached out to me.
Does it mean they got another candidate for same job?
If they get back to me, how much should I ask?
Current - 9.9

Cleared the technical round.I have received an email to submit the docs. But none were called me regarding the salary discussion. Usually how many days it will take to get the feedback

Hey all, having issues with interviewing this year. I’ve been passed over every opportunity I really want and I’m unsure how to regroup and move forward. I’m really trying to break into method development roles and I haven’t had the opportunity to do so with my analytical experience. A lot of my HPLC and LCMS experience is with already established methods. Any tips?

like

Hi those from Amazon - just got an interview for start development manager position in London. Anybody been through the process? My first FAANG/MANGA interview! TIA

like

More Posts

Have an interview with VMYL&R for Creative Director. Any tips on what I should ask or can anyone give their experiences working with the company?

like

Does Controllership at Deloitte have anything to do with FP&A? Thinking in terms of career progression

like

I got an offer in Citi. How will be my growth in Citi. And what can I expect for my future.

like

Is it okay to request to delay the joining date by 2 months?

like

Currently 23 with 1.5 YOE. I have a goal to work abroad in APAC before the age of 30. Would you recommend I do so at ages 24-26, 26-28, 28-29?

like

Or both 😂

Post Photo
likefunny

Is it normal to negotiate for a bigger severance package if it happens within the first year? Because Meta may have something for me but TBH I'm nervous about their hiring freeze news.

like

What kinds of things do you do in commercial healthcare? If that’s a thing?

like
like

Anyone got the skinny on Alix consulting?

Got pinged by a recruiter for an MD role in digital transformation

He claims they compete with MBB and Alvarez.

Thoughts?

like

Negotiation in new offer: I’m moving from fully remote to fully in office (with chance of hybrid later) offer for associate director in quality in pharma for 170k base, 18% bonus and 75k equity. I’ve asked for a sign on bonus as I’m not eligible for annual next year and will be missing my current jobs bonus. I should hear tomorrow (asking for 28k). Thoughts about the offer? Should I ask for more equity or is that standard? They’re public (currently ~$20)should I get the hybrid option in writing?

like

Hearing the sir Martin announcement today, makes you wonder if he is a crazy old guy or a brilliant marketer

like

Sometimes I don't uphold the company mission 😱

like

Hi someone please tell, what is the average Yearly Hike at Nagarro?
if I join now as Associate staff engineer at 20 LPA for 6 YOE.

like

Desi fam, how much did you spend on your wedding ring?

like

I'll switch to a startup as the only data engineer and will closely work with all the Head ofs + the CTO.

Any advice/books/... on stakeholder management at that level? Especially when things fail/discussing budgets/new hires etc.

like

Can one make a transition from salesforce to SAP functional consulting.If yes then how and will it be helpful in long run.

like

What are your tips for publicly responding to negative reviews?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

I am leaving consulting after 7~ years. 2+Y in my current firm.
The goods: Generally young talented people, global though leaders, international collaboration and a brand in my cv.
The bads: Distributed ownership with short-term vision in the business units, we would enage any project in any client as long as it counts for the partner. And we would use the margin as an input, not as a result, so we would be forced to understaff projects so numbers look good. Politics and promises that never came

likehelpful

McKinsey & Company 👀👀👀 McKinsey & Company 😂😂😂

https://bit.ly/3q5OLcW

likefunny

How is BCGs interview process? I have a round 1 interview and was wondering what to expect.

like

How hard/easy is it to break into tech product mgmt. after <3 yrs at MBB?

like

Hi there! I know this is a consulting group but thought I would shoot my shot since the world is small. Does anyone here know any dermatology residents in New York City? I’m trying to help my partner do some networking!

like

New joiner. What should I get with my $250 wfh stipend? I already have standing desk, dual monitor, portable monitor, and good headset, not too sure what else I need, but it’s free money. Thanks.

like

What are the Pracitioner factors that go into your bonus again? Trying to get a guess. Performance, level, promotion year, what else? SC, Not up for promo, $117k, GPS HC

like

Looking for book recommendations; any favorites? Interested in both fiction and educational/self-improvement (for example, investment / finance books, time management, etc). I feel my vocab is...

like

What are some concrete reasons why someone in consulting would be fired, other than the obvious stupid things?

like

Need help evaluating. Current salary: 205k, bonus is 40k, Senior Manager. Offer: $225k, 40k sign on, 40k RSUs, Senior Manager. Market is red hot right now and the incoming offer doesn’t seem compelling enough to jump. Am I mistaken? Opinions welcome. Tia!

like

Best consulting firms to target for Supply Chain & Operations Strategy apart from MBB after graduating from MIT SCM

like

Does anyone have any book recommendations that have helped them become a better consultant ?

likehelpfulfunny

Hey 🐠, what are your recommendations of books, articles, or practice tips to improve communication, both verbal and written? Want to be stronger at running meetings, pitching ideas, writing (cont’d)

like

Trinity EM and AP comp?

like

Best consulting companies with exposure to the blockchain / digital assets space?

like

What grade is a senior associate in KPMG US in Uk ?

like

Hi Deloitte 🐠, What is talent on demand portal? Recruiter wants me to submit another application before interviews.Deloitte

like

I need help, the Google is not helping and feeling lost. National of the country that need visa to visit Mexico (Ukraine), live in the US on H1B. What website do I need to go to apply for Mexican tourist visa? Please help!

like

I think I’m going to be fired tomorrow morning and I am not even sad about it.

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal