{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Executive folk, how do you decide who gets laid off and who stays?", "post_id": "5ebe2b3e6e12f7001a9cbaa7", "reply_count": 22, "vote_count": 7, "bowl_id": "5565cfca8b2b9a03009acf57", "bowl_name": "Advertising" }

Executive folk, how do you decide who gets laid off and who stays?

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

You start with a talent 9box of everyone on your team. The two axes are performance and potential. High performers kick ass at the job, high potential is likely to move up to the next level. Anyone who is not in the middle or right hand side of that diagram immediately comes under scrutiny. Let’s say everyone on your team is great, you love them and you want to keep them. Then it gets trickier. More on this below. Finance will do an analysis of something like “how many people can we keep employed until the end of the year if we only make this lay-off now.” And say “we need to cut 75 of our 800 people to make it to the end of the year with no more cuts.” The first place people will look is non-billable. Agencies have only one product: the work and the people that make it. So overhead teams like Finance, Facilities, D&I, Culture, Education, etc. tend to get scrutinized first. That may not be enough though (maybe 20 of those 80). From there the COO/CEO will start to make estimates for how each department has to make cuts. From there I’ve had it done two ways: 1) When I managed my teams P&L I’ve gotten a number like “you need to cut 200k of your 1.2M budget” - then I could decide if two juniors at 80k were better to cut than one director or not. In these instances, salary certainly starts to come into play. If you add more expensive, you have a higher risk. 2) Most recently I was just given a number. So of the 60 people we laid off, my department had to contribute 3. In this instance you end up focusing on who is billable/non billable and the junior team members are most likely affected because you are focusing on output. You will go back and forth on this “list” a lot. With HR, with the operations and account leads. You fight for people, for the dollar difference. It’s exhausting. We lay up at night for weeks worried about what it means for this person and that person. It will change last minute - someone may leave to get a new job rebalancing your entire plan. It is never something that we want to do. It is something that we have to do. We’re not responsible for just one team member but the entire team and these layoffs end up happening in an effort to protect as many people as possible longer term.

likehelpfulsmart

@AC OP For the instances in which I get headcount it is because I specifically don’t have optics into finances. This is the first time I haven’t had visibility into a P&L for my department and this is controlled mostly by Operations. To me this tends to be a difference between mid size (100-350 people) to large (300+) people.

like

Well, first the people at the top make a list of all the folks in their department who are not like them. Usually that’s women and POC - so take a good amount of those folks and put ‘em in the lay-off bowl. They then gently stir in anyone over 50 with care to remove any pieces of eggshell from the mix. Then they add a tiiiiiny dash of white guys who they never really vibed with and sprinkle them in for optical flavor. Add condolences and the term “really good people”, then serve from your iPhone.

like

That may be how it is in organizations with a greater mandate to consider optics, but in my agency’s most recent laying off, C-Suite followed that formula to a T: had to let go of 12, 9 of whom were women, 7 of those were WOC, of the remaining 3, 2 were POCs and of the 12, 8 were over 45. But more obviously was a judicious carving out of those who were “not a great culture fit” which meant anyone who filed complaints or harassment charges, or people who were critical of management or processes. Of the survivors, five people failed up. Never let a good crisis go to waste.

likesmart

There’s always a place for talent and loyalty

funnylike

Which industry do you work in? It sounds lovely.

like

In my experience the head of the department will come to the next level down and say “we need to get rid of at least four people, who should it be?” And then we’d negotiate and figure it out. Nowhere near scientific. Much closer to what ECD said though probably less politics and more friendliness. Like if they are talented and people enjoy having them around that’s number one with a bullet to keep your job.

like

I look at the p&l and balance it in the way that hurts the team the least. Output is usually my primary factor, and if I feel I have to be under a bit to keep a better employee and shed some dead weight, I have that flexibility, at least in the short term.

like

Related Posts

Looking to leave my new job (2 months) as the person that hired me was fired for absolutely no reason and realised the company isn’t at all what it seemed. What should I say if I get asked this in interviews?

like

Can you apply to a company you were fired from years ago? Has anyone had this experience?

like

I am an analyst. To be honest, I feel like I am sinking, and everyone knows it. I was not an Econ major in college (poly Sci) , and I am new to excel. However, I feel like I am constantly thrown into the deep end, and no one wants to help me, answer my questions, or help guide me through asks. I was under the impression that this would be a teaching environment. Worst feeling when you feel stupid, and you know that everyone else thinks you are stupid too. Will prob b fired.

likehelpful

Are the EY layoff news true?

like

I’ve seen a dozen CDs try to engineer a turnaround at an agency, all of them failed and got fired. Has anyone been through a successful turnaround with a new CD? Were there any observable changes?

like

Have you ever been fired from a job? What are your strategies for getting back on for feet?

like
like

Being terminated as part of reorg. 13 years of service, consistently exceeded expectations. Officially considered partner. Package is 26 weeks of severance pay, two months "gardening leave", plus payout of long-term incentive. Would have preferred a more cooperative approach to voluntary retirement. Thoughts?

like

I’m about to be a second year and have a core utilization of 75% (adjusted 85%). Is this really low? Is it something I could potentially get fired for? No bad reviews, and the low utilization was due

like

@pwc which verticals being hardest hit by layoffs?

A little over one year out of college- asking older fishes how do I deal with worrying about being laid off and concentrating on doing good work at the same time?

like

For firms where work is assigned through a coordinator, is the fact that you’re still consistently getting work an indicator that you at least won’t be fired soon?

like

How do you roll with the punches? When I make even a small mistake that anyone could make my mind immediately goes to "well that's that, I'm getting fired"

I’ll be honest. I was fired. What can and can’t a prospective employer ask about why I’m not there anymore? (To both me and my old employer.)

like

Caught in round of layoffs. Hard finding fulltime, it was easier when I was younger. I’m 40 but I look 30 (lucky with good genes). Would it be crazy if I cut my resume in half and pretended to be 30?

likefunnysmarthelpful

What is the average time an employee gets before one gets fired after being put in the Performance Improvement Program (PIP)?

like

Is it possible to get laid off 1yr in from an MBB and get hired by another? What’s the story to tell?

like

Has anyone been fired/let go/asked to leave from their company because of their company’s return to work policies? What was your experience?

like

Such low utilization at the firm I'm just over one calendar year now since start date. Is the bench at Deloitte for IM pretty big or am I the only one? About to get fired..

like

Additional Posts

I am 8 weeks pregnant, and recently have been getting really bad headaches, mostly on the right side of my head. Has anyone experienced this during their first trimester? Any advice or tricks on what to do?

So who built the covid test distribution website?

like

Assuming language is no barrier, what would you say is the best country to live in?

like

Any current/future residents of NYC rethinking moving there as of recent? Have always planned on doing a 1-2 year pit stop in NYC but feeling wary due to COVID, rise in [reported] crimes, CoL, etc. Not sure if I’m just overthinking news I’ve read (EG: the recent death of the Deloitte SM) but would love to get others thoughts and opinions.

like

What’s it like working for a DentsuAegis agency? Benefits? Holding Co pressure? Leadership? Seems like they are the only ones not tanking ...

likeuplifting

What are the current timelines for H1B transfers? Transferring to FAANG and assuming premium processing. Anyone going through this?

like

Trichologist is NYC ? Are they covered by insurance ?

like

Trump tests COVID-19 positive! First reactions?🤔

likefunny

How are you making your upcoming vacations COVID-conscious (re logistics not public health? Specifically, which hotels and airlines have the best reschedule/cancel policies in case something happens? Anything else to check? Hacks or tips?

like

Special shoutout to JetBlue for the Dunkin coffee and foaming hand soap. To the firm that does its next cost cutting, pls keep.

likefunny

Is a 10% raise pretty good when you get promoted?

Is it unprofessional to smoke on Zoom calls if I'm in my own home?

like

KPMG lawyer filed both I-140 and I-485 back in February, but I did not see any medical form in the package. I-140 has been approved, but I’m still pending I-485. Should I be concerned if the medical form wasn’t included?

like

Daycare has been closed this week due to snow and a positive case for one of the teachers. My sister was able to help for a few hours yesterday with babysitting but otherwise, it’s mainly just me taking care of the baby even though my husband is also working from home. We both work demanding jobs but I feel like my job has always taken a backseat against his. I’m truly thinking of finding another job that brings more work/life balance because he doesn’t seem like he’s going to back down.

like

Have you felt the need to come out to show advocacy and diversity in your classroom? Even if you’re totally comfortable in your personal life, do you feel this need to be out and be an ally?

like

I keep getting ads for the Avocademy UX Course. I'd like to hear about anyones experience taking it or Google's UX Cert. I'm working towards expanding my skillset. TIA!

like

What's the salary bracket for Senior consultant, lateral hire in Oracle Consulting.

like

Ratings on three projects - 3,2,2. Utilization - 90%... Proposal hours - 15... Firm activities - 43 hrs... I then get a YE rating of 4 😕 ... How worried I should be regarding the layoffs???

like

Clever ways to meet credit card spending requirements?

like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal