For people who have been involved in hiring: how often does the final decision come down to something subtle that candidates might not realize? Not skills, but things like communication style, energy, or how someone thinks through problems out loud.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

TBH - it think no one really cares about that, they want someone who will be happy doing the work, is qualified enough not to need hand holding, and can easily blend into the culture and not piss people off.

Not that often, to be honest. Usually it's something pretty easy to identify and quantify. One recent example of a more subtle distinction was a position that came down to three highly qualified candidates. They each had a final interview with the whole team and it ultimately came down to "vibes" (the manager's words). But this is pretty rare.

I usually dont look at small things as the tipping point. This is a big decision for both parties, so the decision is serious so I have to look at the entire package from interviews to salary to career aspirations. Hope that helps.

Very rarely does it come down to something subtle. It almost always comes down to experience and whether or not a candidate is a cultural fit. Its rare thta something small is why we go with one candidate over another.

Very often. Soft signals like clarity, curiosity, and how someone approaches problems out loud can tip the balance between two equally skilled candidates.

Related Posts

Hi All, I am exploring a contract position and they are offering the below. As I am new to contracting, Please suggest which one is better Option 1: $70/hr on W2
Option 2: $80/hr on 1099
I live in the Bay Area, CA if it matters.

Thank you so much !

like

I’m struggling at the moment to gauge how much I should be getting paid in my position as i feel I’m heavily underpaid for the work I do, which includes managing digital marketing operations across 12+ countries, manage the studio/creatives plus lead on any campaigns and strategies, etc. I’m also remote UK-based although my company is international. So what do you feel a fair UK wage would be for the role? I love my job/team but the stress isn’t worth it for me atm. Thanks in advance!

like

Any agencies hiring? (Planning on staying away from Rogers and pharma)

like

Anyone have advice for advancing in your current role? My co-worker was hired in at manager level but somehow “proved” he was actually doing director level work and got a title promotion and salary increase in less than a year. I also went above and beyond my job as well (covering for him for a month while he was away on paternity leave) while taking on other projects outside of my job title and got zip—no raise or recognition. Any advice would be appreciated!

like

How much should be expected in Barclays with 11 yoe

Position open is for AVP

like

What kind of companies pay more than $200k base and what practice areas? Remote or Texas. I’m a new attorney between M&A and L&E, but I’m willing to switch practice areas for the best exit options in the future (4-5 yoe).

Anyone from Amazon's finance division. Require an employee referral for a role.

like

Microsoft is hiring an account executive and I’m really interested in the role. I have B2B sales experience in a different industry, but my skills include lead generation, prospecting, account management, negotiating, etc (all within the C Suite and other decision makers).

Would appreciate knowing if this is something I have a shot at with no tech sales experience and what I could expect for promotional opportunities and compensation.

Thanks for the help!

I feel like I can’t redeem my career. I’ve been out of paying work since I graduated. My bar was delayed due to a medical problem and since then I’ve only been able to find volunteering. I’ve been working for free for 2 years now. My network is tapped, my mentors are confused why I can’t find anything, my law school’s career services actually gave up on me, I don’t have the money to move to a new place, I have no other support and I can’t even go back to retail because nobody’s hiring out here.

like

Hello, i am working as an android developer with 6.5 years of experience. I have cleared all the rounds of interview at paypal India. I am being hired for the core team. Could you suggest How much can I ask for SDE 3 role at paypal ? Any suggestions are welcome.

Thanks

like

Can someone refer me in Wipro for AWS Devops role Yoe- 3.9Wipro

like

Anyone have any idea when the hiring freeze might end within AWS ProServ? I’m currently at Amazon and have a TS clearance, PMP & CSM. I come from a Big4 consulting firm with a background in Enterprise Performance. I’ll be honest and say I’m not feeling very safe in my current role with the ongoing layoffs. Instead of leaving, I’d love to go back to my “consulting roots” and join the ProServ team. I’m taking my AWS Certified Cloud Practitioner exam next weekend. Hoping this freeze is lifted soon.

like

Question on switching from provider side to brand/client side…
I’ve been on the “solution provider side” to brands CPG/retail insights and innovation teams, largely in account management (sales) for B2B syndicated database/SaaS providers.
I’m looking to break into an insights/innovation-type role on the client side.
Any suggestions on addressing perceived experience gap because I’ve always been on the pricier side? Are industry certifications helpful on a CV?
Lots of questions, TIA!

Hello Fishes,

I got an offer from Airbnb for the L7 role. I would like to know about the working culture of this company?

Thanks in advance!

like

What’s the best approach to negotiate a higher base salary? Should I mention competing offers, what my earning potential is in the next ~2 months in my current role - or both?

like

For every Logistics Manager:
What are the top 3 red flags when evaluating hiring a new provider?

like

Any 🐠 here who have left ClearView? How is life? would you have done anything differently at ClearView to set yourself up for a great exit?

like

Hi fishes,
I am working as a QA from past 6 years now and I want to switch my career to business analyst role. Can someone please help me what should I genuinely prepare for this role and if any course you would like to suggest.

like

More Posts

Hired as SA1. if my utilization is low for round table but I’ve gotten good Snapshots will I go up to SA2 or SA1B, which I don’t want of course.

like

Any good books or recommendations on sales? Sales tactics trips and tricks?

like

“The shaft is not always welcome, but but hole always is.”

likefunny

Is there any advantage to telling a company you are interested in working for in the future where you decided to accept an offer from? Or does it not matter? I accepted an offer a week ago with a great company (Company A) that for this season in my life seems like a great fit and only strengthens what I have to offer company B down the road. Company B just sent me a request for interview and I want to keep the door open with Company B but they were just very late in extending an interview.

likehelpful
like

NielsenIQ Is it write time to join nielsenIQ in software developer field? Actually seeing a lot of negetive vibes against nielsenIQ. That's why asking. Please help me on this🙏NielsenIQ Nielsen

like

Hi,
Can someone refer me at NielsenIQ for Data analytics positions?

What is average Hike % in Nielsen? and in which Quarter they will be rolling it out?

like

Where my DC peeps at??

like

What’s the reputation of the JPM CCB Corporate Strategy team? Any insights into pay/hours/culture?

like

Have been interviewing at cvs health. Any ideas how the marketing and analytics teams are?

like

Need 11 likes to start DM

like

Interested in becoming a Google cloud product manager. Here are my observations on the experience you will need to be considered.

Here are my observations about the skills and experiences that PMs have and how people are joining that group.

They are all technical. All of them could easily be very technical cloud consultants or cloud engineers.
Tl/Dr. If you couldn't get hired as a cloud engineer or cloud consultant - you probably can't become a PM

like
like

What is the salary range of b3 band in VMware for a operational role

What excuses have you used to leave for an interview that is not a “doc appointment”?

like

Did it happen with someone in the last quarter that although you got nominated by L1 for band progression but the promotion did not happen?

like

Hi All,
I am joining EY GDS next month. I have heard a lot about hectic work hours in EY and no work life balance. Is it true? If yes, how many hrs working should we expect in a day to be mentally prepared.

like

I am feeling so low. Not sure if I like what I do, but I like staying in this country. Am I ruining my life chasing this impossible American dream? I need to talk to somebody, not sure who can help 😣

like

Additional Posts in Ask A Recruiter - Tech

Every time I try to work with a recruiter, the initial conversation goes great and then I never hear another peep from them. Am I doing something wrong? What can I do to make working with a recruiter worth my time?

like

Why do so many people need sponsorship? Most people I speak to in tech (data) require some sort of sponsorship. Just curious why this is.

like

Does anyone have a go-to "odd" or unconventional question you like to ask candidates to keep them on their toes or see how they react when put on the spot?

likesmart

Hi anyone willing to provide Atlassian referral for US/Canada based jobs?

like

what was the most impressive question a candidate has asked during an interview?

like

Do cover letters matter at all anymore?

like

How do referrals work?
If I get a referral from someone and I apply, then can I still reach out to a recruiter on LinkedIn expressing interest in the role? And do I let them know that I already applied? I’m sure they get tons of messages so what should I say so that it won’t be overlooked?Im currently unemployed and very eager to get an entry level position in either HR, Marketing, or Project/Program Coordinator in the tech field, so any advice is greatly appreciated.

like

Looking to pivot into managerial. Can someone take a look at my resume? Tips would be appreciated as well!

likehelpful

I’ve worked at the same well known tech company since I graduated school 8 years ago. I’ve been promoted 3 times so I’ve held a few different jobs within my org.

BUT .. I’ve applied to a few companies and getting no responses. Is it a deterrent for hiring managers/recruiters that my experience is based primarily at one company?

like

Hello recruiters, happy Monday!

I want to know why recruiters ask me in an interview if I am looking at other opportunities, or if I am interviewing at other companies. If I say yes they will ask at what stage I am.

I just want to know the reason behind it and if there is a right answer to this question!

like

How much should Software Engineers make in year if you have 4-5 years of experience in the Bay Area?

like

What is the base salary that one should negotiate for a senior tech recruiter in Illinois in a large manufacturing company? Looking for some insights; I have 8+ years of experience; thank you!

I'm looking to make the jump into tech but I've got an Advertising background. Is it possible? Looking for a referral.

like

What do you like about working in tech ?

like

Bring interviewed for a data center role at a FAANG in an engineering capacity. Is this considered a tech or non-tech title within most companies?

like

How can I get my foot in the door with Microsoft?

like

Just realized excel has a new feature to analyze data in excel. Do you think this will impact the need/want for data analysts? Will the compensation go down or do you think it’ll have no impact?

like

Why are engineers so difficult to recruit? Sometimes they make me feel stupid lol.

Next week I have two skill interviews w/ Accenture & Bioventus (both Workday positions) . Any advice / recommendations on preparation for the questions (and answers) they may ask?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal