Got two offers: one from a V100 firm that is essentially the best in the practice area that I’m in. The other is a mid-sized that is offering approximately 33% more in base comp, but don’t have much of a rep in my practice area. Which should I take? What else should I consider?

likesmarthelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Also factor in work life balance and people you’ll work with. That’s super important and more important than money (I know it sounds ridiculous but it’s true)

likesmart

Not ridiculous at all. People vastly underestimate the importance of the people they will have to work with and culture of the firm etc. After years of professional experience in the legal industry and outside of it, I’d put that over money any day.

like

Which one are you better positioned to make partner at or would allow you to lateral to the kind of firm you'd like to be partner at? Think longer term here. The big pay increase now could be far outweighed by the possibility of a more lucrative partnership opportunity elsewhere. Or maybe the partnership prospects at mid-sized are really good and you could be better off than gambling on biglaw partnership.

likesmart

33% more base comp sounds like a lot. Don’t get underpaid for doing the same work. What about raises, what are they like at each firm? What is your current year level? Maybe the midsize firm isn’t as developed in this area but they want to build out and you’d have a great shot at partner there if you’re senior and bringing experience they don’t have?

What are your long term goals? Partner? In-house?

like

Ask them to match (or close to it)

smart

There are midsize firms paying that much more than market? Or is this one of the V100 firms that pays significantly below market (Littler)?

like

Exactly

I had a similar issue. But my mid size firm only paid 10% more, not 33% more. I still went with the midsize firm bc it was a full service firm, meaning I’d have better opportunities for origination credits, V100 firm practice exclusively L&E. The commute was far better with the regional firm. And I would gain more diverse experience at the regional firm, since Id be working on several different types of assignments. Lastly, it was more money, albeit, not that much more.

like

I think it depends on your class year. If you’re still junior/ low midlevel (ie you feel like you need to be taught), I’d go with the firm who is strongest. It will open doors in the practice area. However? If you are senior enough and feel like at this point, you can hold your own, then I’d take the higher comp.

like

Is it just me or is this same dilemma posted every week?

It’s a common theme and issue and different people are going through it at different times

like

Related Posts

Wondering if anyone can give insight as to what salary range is for an insurance compliance role as an IC3 or similar?

like

Currently looking to hire over 15 Product Managers to join our Federal team here at VMware . The product is Tanzu - our newest platform offering and the heart of the company’s application modernization strategy.

No active clearance necessary, but an active/current clearance is a bonus.

DM me if interested. I’ll try and answer any questions as well.

like

Hello,
I've recieved an offer from Morgan Stanley, my previous salary was around 6 Lpa and last offered was around 15 Lpa (WFH), I quoted 40 to 45% on top of that around 22 Lpa considering Mumbai location, WFO and Glassdoor pay range.
Did I just do a mistake by quoting too high a number? Please let me know your opinions.
YOE: 3.5
Tech Stack: Java Full stack devMorgan Stanley JPMorgan Chase

like

Mckinsey fish, how is implementation practice? How does it compare to general consulting? How is the growth trajectory? Got an opportunity to join as implementation consultant but I am worried it will be a step down (will be taking a paycut as well).

like
like

Recently moved into Tech Sales. Frustrated with my Salary (32K base/year, negligible bonus potential of a few K). Was making ~3K/week on average in my previous role which was commission only, no base. Feel like I am completely wasting my time and potential. Saw the cut as necessary evil initially in order to move into tech sales and make multi six figure commissions later on with potential to reach 7 figures in total comp. At least my current role is with enterprise accounts which. Thought?

likesmarthelpful

🔥How much Annual hike(%) & bonus (%) bny Mellon technology employee getting every year? BNY Mellon BNY Mellon Corporation BNY Mellon | Pershing

like

How is BNY (Pune ) in terms of work culture , YOY growth and Bonuses.
Are there additional rewards or incentives for employees?

like

Hi A&M fishes. For PEPI whats the median or a good guess for base salary and annual bonus for a Senior Director. Do they get any equity too? Looking for realistic numbers, trying to make a decision.

like

Hi fishes, Need your help. How much can i expect from Morgan Stanley for a senior associate role in technology with 2 years of experience. My current ctc is 11lpa and i have a counter offer of 17lpa. Morgan Stanley

like

Odds T2/Big 4 will follow MBB pay bumps?

likefunny

Hi sharks,

18LPA CTC in India equivalent to how much in US considering all factors??

What’s a fair salary increase after a year of inflation?

like

Senior associate, 3.5 YOE, M&A tax in southeast US. What’s a reasonable salary expectation?

like

When do we get salary ?
Last day of month?

like

Hello Fishes,

What is the maximum package VOIS can offer for Assistant Manager position ?

YOE 3.7

like

Amazon I joined Walmart 7 months back. I have 7 years of experience. Current CTC is 30 LPA (22 fixed). From Tier 3 college. If I plan to switch to Amazon, how much package I can expect?

like

Hi! Recently discussed an associate graphic designer role with a recruiter. Is it reasonable to expect an 85k base in NYC? Am I underselling myself? They started with it being a 75-80k budgeted position. What are typical base salaries for someone with 4.5 ttl YOE? Does it matter that 3 YOE was in an adjacent industry?

What will be in hand salary per month for fixed pay 20 LPA in EY GDS after tax deduction?

like

Got offered a pharma/healthcare role (currently work consumer side). 15% more than current role, lateral move, remote for now of course. Not sure if I should take the offer or not, given I have no experience in pharma & health. I said I would sleep on it. Advice?

like

More Posts

What do I do if HR is pushing a role onto me? I said I will think and get back to you but she set up an interview with MD... do I just be honest and say that HR didn’t accurately relay my message?

like

Any MNCs hire me If I performed well in every phases of the interview and I have 2 backpapers in my B.Tech degree course??

like

Hi Fishes,

Which one should I choose as a Software Engineer with 8 YOE:

Mckinsey Knowledge Centre-31 LPA Fixed + 2 LPA Variable + 1L JB
Smart Energy Water- 36 LPA Fixed
Coforge- 35 LPA
DMI- 34.5 LPA Fixed+ 3.85 LPA Variable
Connectwise- 38 LPA

like

What is the best appraisal you have ever recieved?

like

What goes though you mind when thinking about quitting consulting ? Considering a move to industry

like

Is the international BA diploma worthwhile? My company offers but wonder if other qualifications such as AWS would be more worth while?

like

BCG🐠 how long is the cool off period for a fresh application if I didn't get to the interview stage?

like

I know this is a broad question but how much should a 3 year PI attorney going into their 4th year make approx. I’m in Chicago, a range is fine too.

like

Anyone has idea about Capgemini g gurgaon location ? Which is the nearest metro ?

like

Workday I’m a QA Automation Analyst with 2 yoe. I gave my tech interview for Workday and cleared it on Tuesday. I’m currently holding an offer of 15.1 from a bank. How much can I ask from workday?
Tech stack. - Selenium,Java,Jenkins,Salesforce automation.

like
like

So this all seems like mental illness pretending to be investing. Good luck on the gambling. I’m blown away by the people screaming “HODL” with no rationale. I’m 100% out

like

Hello fishes,

Accenture has offered me level 11 for 3.8 years of experience. Can I get level 10 at 3.8 years of experience?

Please suggest.

Thanks.

like

Hey! I’m from Spain, and I’m thinking about find a job overseas, maybe in central america or southeast asia… I have experience in finance consulting… do you have any recommendation, contact or tip that could help me?

I don’t know if try to find a job first and move then, or move out first and find a job from there.

Thanks!

like

What are bonuses like for a first year IB Analyst in London? (Think US banks like GS, MS, Citi etc.)

like

What’s the going rate for an implementation manager with 4 years of service. Primarily in the PBM world

like

H i Guys need your suggestion,
I am earning 32LPA in India , planning to take PR for Canada through consultancy or selfia it worth moving to Canada ? What are the pros and cons ?

YOE -8.5
Tech -- Cybersecurity Tata Consultancy Accenture Infosys Cognizant Amazon Deloitte EY

like

Does Google value FAANG experience over consulting? Say if a person is trying to get into Google from Apple, will it be considered easier?

like

Hi Fishes,

Can anyone working as data engineer or ETL engineer in Harman message me.
Have a query in interview process.

Thanks your time is really appreciated.

Hi Fishes, do you see any recruitment in Software Testing Roles in Goldman Sachs ?

Additional Posts in Law

Why do we put up with the dysfunctional BS from our peers and superiors? Are we well-compensated chumps?

like

Why are read only documents called “riders?”

like

Gripe in here about Legal Assistants (more in comments)

likehelpful

Market research - can anyone in Philly share their firm name, salary, and year?

like

So the feeling that you’re forgetting something important because you have so much on your plate…that never goes away right?

like

2020 grad M&A/PE Associate in LCOL area thinking about moving to a ECVC/M&A boutique. I generally like the work I do and the people I work with, but I really don’t like the hours and the constant late nights and weekends. Currently on pace for 2250. Boutique I have been eyeing has billable hour requirement of 1500-1600 and comes with a 20-25% paycut. Is this a stupid idea and should I grind it out until I can move in house? Will this ruin my opportunities down the road?

like

Tech question - for those that do document prep - what monitor size do you prefer?
I’m updating from twin 23” in portrait and considering twin 32 or one ultra wide 38”.

like

What’s the most unethical thing you’ve seen OC get away with?

like

Does anyone have any experience or insight as being an attorney for tech start ups?

like

First time interviewing multiple potential hires at a job fair tomorrow. Any tips or suggested questions?

like

Fifth year labor and employment associate at Big4 L&E firm (think Littler) and am considering making a move into big law (think Jones Day, Goodwin, etc.) Any thoughts on if it’s worth it this late in my associate career? Also, do those big firms take 6-8 year L&E laterals?

like

How do you spend your precious unwinding time after work? I love binge watching tv shows but realize it’s probably not the healthiest way to wind after a stressful day. Anything fun / low stress yall do?

Note; working out is not a relaxing activity for me so don’t even start with that. Also I am single and have no kids so ..

like

What would you say is the difference between a billable hour target vs. minimum? I feel like some firms boast about not having a “minimum” but the expectation is that you to exceed this target which just makes it a minimum.

like

Beisdes CiIPPS and CIPP/US, what certifications would make you more likely to hire an attorney for a data privacy/IT law role?

like

Has anyone else noticed that a hugely disproportionate number of latinx big law attorneys seem to be white / white-passing?

like

I just gave notice. I’ll need to take some of my work products with me because I’m flying solo. What is the best way of leaving the firm with some of your work products besides taking photos of them? 🥲

like

Curious to know what other firm's bonus structures are, particularly those with billable requirements of 1900 and below. Trying to understand what the norm is and figure out if associates at my firm are getting screwed. thanks

like

HIPAA special enrollment extension: does this apply to major medical, dental, vision, health FSA? Thanks!

like

Does anyone know the starting salary for Jackson Lewis in the firm's Connecticut office, as well as the billable hours requirement?

like

I'm a long time prosecutor getting into the ID game and billable hours. Are there any resources out there that can help me get more effective/efficient without spending months/years learning the hard way? Some days I'm at the office 10 hours, took virtually no breaks and yet only bill 7. 🤬

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal