I had an interviewer say, “You’re overqualified — why would you want this job?” It threw me, because I didn’t know how to answer without sounding desperate. How would you flip that into a positive without losing credibility?

likehelpfulsmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

It might appear that way based on past experiences, but this opportunity excites me.

likehelpful

Yes looking at the number of years I have worked in the mining industry,the skill and the experience I have gained in operating wheel Loader for 9 years I can be over qualified.

like

When preparing for every interview I write a little career story for myself that has the company and the role as a main character. Sometimes it's fiction and sometimes there are elements of non-fiction, you know? So you're looking to gain x skill for y reason, and this job description appealed to you because of its emphasis on that skill. At this point in your life you are looking for a z company that does blah blah blah just like Thiscompany. The story is multi-purpose, and I can tell it a bit differently in response to any flavour of 'why would you want this job'.

I would avoid saying that you're looking for something less stressful. That sounds like you're hoping to coast and not put forth much effort. I'd keep it focused on why the job or the company are attractive to the personal/career growth you envision for yourself.

likesmarthelpfuluplifting

I really love that idea omg thank you

like
Recent IconRecent

I see my experience as an asset here. I’m looking for a role where I can make an impact quickly, mentor others, and continue growing in a collaborative environment. This position aligns with my strengths and career goals, and I’m committed to bringing that expertise to your team.

like

I had a manager adk me wouldn't you be bored with this position? Well I know I'm not going to be where I was at 24 years?

like

This would be my same concern if I were hiring for a junior role and got a senior candidate.

like

This has been my experience with that question, and I have had it many times in my job searches.

I usually give one of three answers:
"Well this is an industry im very interested in, and thought I should start at the entry level position and work my way up."

"This is a company I have always admired for its (insert reasons here), and when this position popped up, I immediately knew I could excel and become a great asset to the team with the company i have always wanted to work for."

"With already having the skills, I can do the job with ease, quickly and efficiently. This can easily have me be able to tackle any extra tasks that I could take off of your plate."

All 3 answers I get just an "OK."

Every time I got that question in an interview, I have never gotten the job. They usually have already made up their mind by the time that question is asked.

like

For me it depends, if it's a job that I personally enjoyed doing in the past then I'd dig into that and express how much you enjoyed the work. If it's a job just to get a job then maybe start talking about what you hope to gain in that position. If it's to get your foot into a specific company then move up, then you may say something like: "I am hoping to become an employee within 'this company' and I wanted to try building my way up from 'here' to be better informed about the different roles of the positions within so I could get a better idea of where I'd like to be in the future."
I see that as letting the employer know 1) that you are actually interested with staying in that company, 2) that you do have some kind of career goals. 3) that you do intend to LEARN something from the position.
I personally went from a job where I was able to do little to nothing most of the night to a position that has me doing more work for the same amount of pay. I know for most that sounds crazy and dumb, but personally I am not the kind of person that likes getting a paycheck just for sitting in a chair. I like to keep busy and love learning new things for different jobs. All my references and especially past managers would tell anyone that. So in a way, I did do something like this. I explained to my current employer, "I took that job to see if it would be something I was interested in doing as a career. I learned quite a bit from that job, but I personally don't think I would have it for my perminate career choice. I had a similar job to the position I am applying for now, and held it for 'X amount of years' because I personally enjoyed the work I was doing."
Putting personality into an interview isn't necessarily a bad thing. It just depends on how you use say something and the EXACT words you use. You don't want those words biting you in the tail later on during that interview.

like

I HAVE SAID,....I love the job,that's why people need and want over qualified so they know they are getting the best service this side of the mason dixon.I worked for that company for 27 years.till I got cancer and then they sued me

like

OMG 😲
I am so sorry you had to deal with their shit on top of cancer 🤗

like

I was laid off recently and was interviewing for a SM role, with 2 decades of DM roles on my resume. The interviewer brought it up in a rather snide way. I wish interviewers would keep their value judgements to themselves and focus on the job description, and whether you can do the role. I did tell them "each position and organization is different, and I look forward to proving that I deserve this role, with the benefit to the company being that I can step up if the opportunity for promotions present themselves in the future. I am not expecting or relying on that promotion however. My focus will be on getting this store and it's team to perform above standards".

like

I was once asked this question VERY early in my career. I was very clear: Perhaps I am overqualified, but I was excited about and passionate for the role I was applying for and I felt it was the best place for me to continue to grow and learn.

like

Hello

like

Registered Psychiatric Nurse

like

I have over three years’ experience in care, supporting individuals with autism, Alzheimer’s, dementia, schizophrenia, and other complex needs. I am committed to person-centred care and available to start immediately.

like

Hi! This isn't the right thread, nor the right bowl to request work. Try to look for a healthcare one.

like

"I'm at a point in my career where I'm looking to specialize and go deeper into a specific area, and this role offers exactly that. I’m excited about this opportunity because..."

like

Note: It's a good sign they're asking, still. They'd like to have you, but want to ensure that you won't drop the job in six months because you can fast-track to another role, dislike the pay grade, won't learn anything useful, etc.

I got this feedback in my current company when I first applied, and I was at the recruiter stage (it reflects bad, though on their side if you get this feedback wit the hiring manager). We agreed I was passionate about the company and too senior. I leveraged that to get a callback n months after for the senior role, same function, and got it!

like

At present I am in search of a new opportunity. This seems like a great place to join and contribute to your companies goals.
I heard this many times since April of 2025. When you interview, answer directly and simply and use positive words as your tools to land a job.

like

It's got great benefits and I would be a good candidate for the job. I make myself a little speech before I to the interview and practice it before I went in. Ask myself questions about the the job that I'm applying for as what matters most when it comes to job related concerns.

like

Absolutely loved this response!!! The funny thing is sometimes people don’t realize things happen in life and you have to downsize, but it doesn’t mean that you can’t do the job and actually they would or should welcome the opportunity to have someone on board then overqualified because they know that you’re gonna be able to do the job and put an extra effort and energy and getting things done While putting yourself in position for a growth opportunity with the organization.

like

My qualifications may support our customers in feeling like we sent our best and most knowledgeable individual to assist and increase our business, and potentially move up the ladder in the decision making process.

like

i do not see overqualified i see years of experience that can help others

like

When someone says a candidate is overqualified, it often says more about the person hiring than the person applying. In many cases, what they really mean is: ‘I feel uncomfortable managing someone with more experience than me.’

Ironically, it’s usually not about the candidate being too skilled — it’s about the hiring manager being unsure how to lead, motivate, or retain someone with that level of experience. I’ve seen this pattern often, especially in large organizations where management roles are filled by tenure or politics, not necessarily leadership ability.

A confident and capable leader would see overqualification as an opportunity — not a threat.

like

I enjoy walking and sitting by lake Grapevine reading a book.

like

I have seeing that in my path looking for a Job where paid rate are very low like in the 90's but they ask you for Bachelor Degreed Bilingual and a lot experience

like

I. Bbn bnnb.bb!

like

Related Posts

I have been going on interviews and noticed 2 department heads already assume I was laid off or fired due to a 4 months gap. I explained I left my last role due to short term health issues that have been resolved. Not even sure how to respond when they assume. Any advise? Thanks!

like

Question for everyone; what are some of the better job boards for underrepresented groups in tech? Non-traditional job boards that promote inclusivity and diversity hiring?

like

I know agencies across the board did some layoffs right before the holidays, but when do we think hiring will pick up again? Getting to a point where I feel like I need to start thinking about a change.

like

How do you folks describe your deals in resume/ interviews/ LinkedIn while stopping short of naming client/target? If you describe the acquirer and target, it’s pretty easily traced to the exact deal.

like

I left my old job the end of January (due to compensation) and hate my new job. I don’t sleep and am constantly stressed. I have been interviewing since May, but I can’t seem to find a good fit that has an insurance Plan that fits my needs. I am thinking about reaching out to my old job (very small and tight knit) to see if there’s a position available for me still. They told me there would be when I left…what is the best way to go about this?

like

How does contract to hire work? If I’m offered $37/hr on w2 for 3 months and then possibly a permanent position, how much can I expect to get annually as a full time company employee as a BI data analyst II? I have a M.S. and certificates in DA but this will be my first job as DA.
I prefer working for what is offered on contract without negotiating, and then negotiate when I transition into the company itself so I have a better chance of getting the contract position and show my skills.

like

HIRING: MM private equity firm based in NY focused on healthcare; Strategy Lead role (similar to Chief of Staff). Looking for investment bankers / consultants with 4-6 YOE, that's looking to transition into a strategic role. DM me to chat!

Johnson & Johnson Hi Sharks, I have overall 2 years of experience in pharmacovigilance as well as Quality. I am looking for a job opportunity in Pharmacovigilance. I can start at a short notice. Please let me know relevant openings for the same. Any help/initiative from your end will be Accenture" class="linkified" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" >appreciated.Accenture Cognizant Novartis Dr. reddy’s laboratories ltd Johnson & Johnson Medtronic Merck

like

Hi Friends, is there any opening for checkpoint firewall

like

I just started training with United HealthGroup for Medicare. I have previous experience in Medicaid-- quite a different role, but similar. I'm so nervous about how complex Medicare can be. Any suggestions or advice? I'm not exactly a dumb-dumb but nor am I the sharpest knife in the tool box.

like

Hi 👋 I’m a Bank Manager with 12+ years of banking experience looking to transition in fintech sales. I don’t have software exp but banking sales and business development exp. I’m looking for midmarket or enterprise sales executive roles? Ive been applying with no call backs. Any referrals or suggestions please.

like

(1/2) Hi all, based in the UK 🇬🇧, would appreciate your advice on how I could break into product management.

Context: Graduated in 2019 (Finance), 2 years at EY as a business consultant on mix of pmo projects and tech projects where I was developer (data vis, power platform, sql, vba, data analysis etc.). Joined Google on a 6 month contract as a data analyst.

Should I be applying for product analyst roles? Should I apply for strategy consulting? Could I go straight for prod mgmt roles?

like

Hi everyone, I have a question about job transition. I want to transition into sales training. I have 9 YOE in sales account mgt and created some really effective trainings my office used and loved. After that I got 2 yrs in curriculum development elsewhere. 

I want to move into a sales training role that will take into consideration my sales experience? Don't want to start from scratch. What job titles should I be looking for?

Hi fishes,
I have 4.5 years of experience in .net and angular in cognizant I'm working I got call from
Genpact but In Genpact they are asking me join as lead consultant is it normal software engineer position or what any idea ..for only 4.5exp is it sufficient for lead consultant position.. firstly what is the responsibilities for lead consultant in GenpactGenpact

like

Hello friends
We are hiring.....

Post Photo
like

Which is the right move for a young creative: free ride to portfolio school, or take a full time junior position where you’ve been interning?

Hello fishes,

I have cleared the interview round and the documents submission step is also completed on May 25th.
Can anyone please tell me how much time it will take to get the offer letter?

Post Photo
like

Hi Fishes,
It's over a month I had applied for a job post at career portal of accenture and still it is showing your application is under evaluation. My job CID no is C7183481. And now I am unable apply for other job openings too. Can anyone help me to apply for job post also and to know about the status of this applied position.

So I’m engaged in an interview process for a top FinTech company. It started the 1st week of August and just now I’ve gotten word from my recruiter that they didn’t update on any decisions made. I had my 3rd & final interview last Friday. My recruiter doesn’t communicate well nor does she let me communicate with the company direct. May I being led on? Am I still in the race for this role in your opinion with the details stated. Please message me if you would like to know more in detail.

What should I be considering when evaluating a business analyst role? Are these more accounting than finance, FP&A, or does it change by company?

like

More Posts

Hey can anyone refer me for Agoda careers? I’m very much interested in working with them any leads would be highly appreciated :)

like

Hi All,

I have 2 offer please suggest which 1 to go with.
1. CTS 9 ( 8.55 Fixed 45k Variable)- Tech Lead
2. Vodafone 9 same as CTS they matched plus JB-50K - Band I
Exp 3.9
Skills: Oracle DBA
Your inputs will be highly appreciated to choose best comparing WLB and Job Security.

likeuplifting

Bhai log kaisa hai Accenture? Got level 10, security family group hai. Bata do jara doston thoda ghana jo bhi pata hai, dua dunga.

like

Hello Guys ,
Please someone explain / guide how to become cloud engineer ?
I am beginner,don't know much about cloud
!!

I got an offer for senior Salesforce associate for support project. The skill set mentioned was LWC, apex and configuration. Wanted to understand how the work will be for Salesforce support in PWC.

like

I have got an offer from S&P Global I want to know about following things

How much of Variable Pay is Paid ?? I got 15% of Base salary but how much will be paid like the usual norm i want to know

And what are the deductions from Base salary apart from PF ?
There are lot of allowances like internet reimbursement etc etc
Are they mandatorily credited or you need to claim ?

Will be recruiting with Deloitte and Google — tough decision because I like both, any thoughts on how to compare/choose between the two? Thanks!

like

Hi! Is there anyone from Deel who would be willing to connect? :)

like

Hi everyone
I recently got offer from TCS for 10 LPA and my current CTC is 7LPA with 2.5 years of experience. Am I being underpaid here?

like
like

Any insights into the Kroll or CFGI FDD/TAS Manager interview process? Any comp expectations for NYC/HCOL M1?

like

Can anyone provide a referral for a remote opportunity in Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion? I am near completion of my certification in DE&I, and have over 10 years of experience in recruiting from various industries.

Nothing on here for the Forestry industry. This app caters to do nothing managers it seems. :(

like

Interning this summer in TC. Any suggestions on best pants to wear? Heard good things about lulu commission but want other opinions. Thanks in advance!

like

Hi everyone!
Does anyone know how much is the start-up salary range out of college for forensics/criminalist in California? And where to apply?

like

Having a discussion with someone about seo. They were adamant that seo works differently on a mac book for some reason. Am I missing something?

funnylike

Additional Posts in Interview Tips

What are some questions you always ask during your interview? I feel like I need to be asking more.

like

Hey y’all. I went through an exceptionally traumatizing experience a few years ago that has totally & utterly shattered my confidence, self worth, self esteem etc. I have a hard time portraying my work experience + deserving of a new role.

For context, I did well in uni, got into law school but due to finances + the experience in question I didn’t end up going. Kept working in the public sector as a coordinator & now got my scrum master certificate to transfer to SM role in finance/ tech. Help

like
like

Do recruiters typically reply to the “Thank you email” after the initial interview?

like

Could someone take a look at my about me section for my LinkedIn pls. Would appreciate some feedback. Trying to transition from reception job to selenium or lean six sigma. Please dm me!

like

How do you explain to a interviewer that you are leaving your job because your new boss doesn't treat you well/fairly?

like

Hello 👋🏾 I have a Senior CRA interview with Emmes next week and they informed me that it would be in 2 parts : with the hiring managers and then an assessment of my writing skills with multiple choice CRA questions? Does anyone have any tips, please, or referrals to learning resources? I really want this job! Thank you!

like

Hi, I am interviewing for a senior sap consultant role (MM / Procurement) at ACN and two firms of the Big4. What kind of technical questions should I expect? Thanks for your efforts!

like

Hi all, I’m trying to transition to the insurance industry and begin as a claim adjuster. I have a virtual interview for progressive and a phone call interview with AAA coming up soon. Do you have any tips for me?

like

in live hirevue interviews, can they tell if you switched tabs? I have a few notes on my computer id like to refer to if possible

like

Was scheduled for an interview today for a Director pos. early morning I get a Reschedule request to next Wednesday but I cannot make it due to personal commitment .
Called recuit
mgr.to let him know and he tells me the director is very busy as she’s the IT. Dir for the whole org.politely asked him to send her availability other than next Haven’t received anything since then . Wondering if such co. Is worth pursuing that doesn’t value others time and that too a replacement pos for the same busy role 🥹

like

For people with Non-technical backgrounds who are now Product managers in the Tech industry, what kind of resources did you use to prep for your interviews? I've had people recommend brushing up on cracking the PM code but there's SO MUCH information out there and it's hard to figure out if I'm looking at the right thing or not. Please share resources that helped you get into PM roles (bonus points if you work at companies like Amazon and Google).

like

So I just received a job offer through a recruiter & tried negotiating the pto and vacation.

I asked just for a few more days 2-4 but im terrified they might reject the offer all together. I’m definitely over thinking 😭 but I’m hoping they get back to the recruiter before leaving the office for the weekend.

like

Hi! Does anyone know anything about the company Rently? Remote? Great environment? I can’t find anything on here, Indeed, or Glassdoor. Thank you!

like

Hi what questions do they ask for data analyst role? I have a test for the role with two questions. Thanks

like

I have an interview for my first product designer role out of Bootcamp. What are your favorite questions to ask during an interview as a job seeker and why?

like

Citi Bank I would like to know how much % hike one can get in internal mobility within citi ,Dublin.jump from AVP to VP Citi" class="linkified" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" >position.Citi Bank Citi

like

If a hiring manager wants to talk to you again that’s a good sign right? I’m just bracing myself for this offer😅

like

I was just informed after the third round of interviews they’d like at least 5 references, two must be supervisors. My last job was a temporary remote job where I didn’t really interact with my supervisor and the jobs before that were at my family’s business (I do not speak to any of them for serious personal reasons.) Anything before that was grad school and I haven’t kept in contact with any professors from over five years ago. What should I do? 😕

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal