I think i already know what people will say, but would you take a McKinsey EM offer for $180k and $60k bonus, or MasterCard director level role for $235k with 25% bonus? Currently at $165k base with 5-15% bonus. Hopefully more in a few weeks.

Obviously the immediate comp and WLB are better at option 2, but option 1 might have more prestige/exit opps and higher comp after 5 to 10 years if i stayed and made partner? WLB isn’t that important to me rn, but it may be in coming years.

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

2

To leave as a partner with stellar exits, you’ll need to be a deep expert and have some luck - so that’s like 10+ years in as partner usually for C level exits

In that same time, you can develop operating track record in industry and have other opportunities that are great too. Much harder to switch from Consulting to industry at higher levels without operating experience

likesmart

Ditto

Kind of surprised that McK EM getting $180k base…but 2 nonetheless! Congrats!

likefunny

Yeah it’s like big4 money for 50% more hours I know they pay their people a lot as they get more senior so maybe you just gotta pay your dues.

Recent IconRecent

2 — congratulations 🎉🍾

like

MasterCard

like

Congrats 🎉 2 seems to sound good. The only challenge will be is whether Mastercard is going to grow or going to be eaten up by the upcoming Fintech companies

like

Congratulations!!

How many YOE do you have? Thank you

like

10, though not all at Accenture

like

Surprised McK is only offering $180k - I'm getting that at D, though much lower expectations for bonus and I'm sure benefits aren't as strong.

Personally, I'd only choose 1 if you *love* consulting and don't want to leave

like

Not sure about the function at 2 (e.g., is it something more siloed / dead end like strategy or a more core role to the P&L). Did you tell McK that you have a counter offer? They may bump the base... The TC looks like an EM with WP track record vs. VS or D track record..

like

McKinsey EM is only 180k base? I’m sure they have great career ops but seems a bit low. Managers in Consulting (especially new hires) make 190-200k+ base at my firm.

Option 2 looks good, big increase. You can always go back to Consulting if you don’t like it.

Option 3- Apply for Senior Manager in Deloitte Consulting! Shoot for 240-250 base plus 30% bonus. :)

like

Thats a pretty nice band there big D

Um Mastercard - no doubt

like

What function of MasterCard is this?

like

Pricelessness Strategy Manager

likefunny

What kinda wizardry…. OP, how are you going from, I’m assuming, an ASCDP senior consultant to a D level role at an F250?

M2 going on m3 actually, with an exec mba and 10+ years of experience. So, not sure where you got ASCDP senior consultant from except that i know those folks are getting high starting comps these days.

like

As per other comments, likely option go 2. But only unless you are looking for a major pivot elsewhere into a diff domain or industry, you might be better served hanging on in McK.

What level is the director at MasterCard?

That seems low for a mck em. Could you tell them you need them to match the $235. If you are still interested in learning and are not set on the payments space I would take mck. If payments is your chosen path, go for that. I just think you might limit your career growth and potential at mc

McK 7, what type of candidates negotiated? Is it when joining or internal promotions/designation?

like

Aren’t MBB post-MBA salaries now like 175k with recent raises? Do they just not bump too much going to EM?

You can negotiate with McK

Does MC pay more than Amex?

OP - I would really reflect on your priorities and do a self-assessment again, and then decide.
MC can be exciting (if payments is your thing) but may be longer journey to the top. Although you never know - from MC many doors can open in banking, fintech...great company, I’ve heard.
McK can be equally or even more exciting (if consulting is your thing and if you’re keen to learn new things) and journey to P can be reasonably fast (4-7yr max; if you make it...). But as pointed out before, it’s a way far from guaranteed that as a P at McK you’ll have ton of exciting C-suite opportunities. Likely not...
World has changed, it’s not the same as even 10 years ago.
So in short, I’d go to McK only if you want to be career consultant (perfect place), or if you just want to do 2-3yrs (making AP or not) to get that badge on your cv and move on (will likely be considered for the same positions as now, perhaps a bit better / more choices).
2 cents from someone with similar background, currently an SEM and looking out...

Related Posts

Hi Folks,

Am currently working in EY as Tax Analyst. But i would like to change my job profile. Am interested in Investment Banking. I don't know whether investment banks hire people without any previous experience from IB. So, is there any courses to enter into IB? Kindly give suggestions on this.

like

Hello fishes, does anyone know about 60 decibels and the work culture is ? An insight would be very helpful. Thanks in advance :)

Privacy fish - Anyone taken the CIPM and can share what the exam is like?

Content outline seems like application of standard consulting approach, so how do they test it on an exam?

like

What inspired you to pursue a career in your particular field?

like

I have received offer from Wipro which is little above than the offer that I am holding but fixed pay is less. Thinking of rejecting Wipro offer. Is it better to reject or accept and then not join. Also if I reject, will there be any issue like they won't consider me in future?Tata Consultancy Wipro Cognizant Infosys

like

Looks like some bonus numbers are coming out for bankers, would appreciate any insights!

like

Is it really unrealistic to expect a raise in this current economic climate? Review period is coming up in July, and I don’t want to shoot myself in the foot by not asking for a raise.

like

Hi

For some reason TCS HR did not responded on quoted compensation and was lowballing. The call was not fruitful. As i have already resigned not sure even if they release the offer letter no.

Can you please help me on finding jobs for Devops 10 YOE.

like

Any Accenture and slalom fish know what I can expect coming into either with 4 yrs of experience into the salesforce practice?

like

Which one is ideal in terms of WLB and job security?

Altimetric
Epam
Encora

like

I got the salary breakup from HCl Technologies what will be next procedure I yet to recieve the offer letter can someone guide me

like

Hello Everyone!!

I've been working in the sales industry from past 1.5 years, but i wanted to change my field.
After some research i decided to get into Cloud Computing. I've done Microsoft Azure course and cleared AZ 104 Certification for Azure Administrator.
But because of my Sales Experience my profile is not getting shortlisted.
Please suggest me what can i do ? And if anyone can help me with the job.
Thanks!

like

IBM - 19.7L fixed + 2L JB

FIS Global - 19.8L fixed + 1.90L variable + 1L JB

YOE - 7 years
Tech - .Net

Which one in terms of Job security(main concern) , WLB , yearly average hike , better projects ?

like

Looking to make a career change from tax to maybe tech.. does anyone have any experience or advice on what other field I could transition to?

like

Accenture is hiring Microsoft stack.

Post Photo
like

Hi Fishes, I am looking for a new role in SAP security and GRC
Total exp: 2.8 yrs
CCTC: 4.3 lacs
Skills: SAP SECURITY/GRC AC/ Abap and MM
LWD : 27/07/2022
It will be really helpful if you can help or refer.

like

Currently got selected for Manager II, Program Management role at Amazon. Any amazon folks can help me understand what the package and WL are and career growth?

like

Hi Fishes,

Pls provide me your referrals for operation - non technical - Team lead role. I have got 11 yrs of experience. Thanks for your support

like

More Posts

fishbowl has invited me for there ambassador program, anyone else gets this as well?👶🏻

like

Deloitte US just announced layoffs. Any other B4 started layoffs too ?

like

How we all dealing with Rona times??? Hope you all ok 👍

like

So. I plan to invest $100k new money and I want to know what stocks are looking the best. Esp considering future results from the vaccine...

like

Will most of us (big 4 employees) be in at least the 200k+ salary range once we hit our late 40s and early 50s? I know that MOST of us won't stay with our firms, but does that mean we stagnate?

like

Which one of you wrote this? The feels...

Post Photo
likefunnyhelpful

Hi Fishes,

Could someone help answer this.
I have a offer from CTS and I'm considering joining here but I've heard a lot of bad remarks regarding bench policy.

Now I'm worried whether i will get a project once I join here or will I get kicked out in 30 days if not.

Tech stack: Mulesoft

This is the first time I'm switching companies so I'm really worried about how life will be if I take the risk and join here.

like

Any advice with anxiety before calls/door pulling? Never happened before but it’s crippling now.

likehelpful

Hi,

My brother had just graduated from bba in Manipal. Any suggestions on what he can do next? How yo get a job?

like

Anyone is a tech role in healthcare ? If so what is your title so you enjoy it?

like

For the one year of work experience requirement to get CPA license in CO, when did you qualify? Do they just do 1 year from DOH or do you need to have charged 1,800 hours of client work?

Hello! Would anyone at Deloitte be willing to look over my CV and possibly refer me for a role in Dublin? (I’m currently based in London)

like

Hi!

I recently did a job interview and I made it clear to the HR my expectation salary is 60k a year, non negotiable.
Today I got the job offer and they are offering me 54k. My current company is making me 50k with tons of benefits which is why I am asking for 60k.

Should I accept the offer or renegotiate?

like

How is job security, annual hike and onsite opportunity in Publicis Sapient?

Role: Product Manager

Please let me know your views.

like

Houston downtown JW vs Westin.. Thoughts?

like

Looking for some book recommendations :)

like

What made you want to go on to become a nurse practitioner?

like

Not including the canned stuff from wirehouses, does anyone send out a newsletter regularly to their clients?

like

Cognizant Will cognizant give a Diwali bonus?

funnylike

Additional Posts in Consulting Exit Opportunities

Fellow 🐟 any thoughts? Received an offer from Deloitte -> Role Manager, Base 180K HCOL, YOE 8, Current Base -> 150K and may get close to 160K in 3 Months. Is it worth the jump? Pros in current role -> High Visibility due to small practice, 45 to 50 Hr work week. Will be SM in next 2 to 3 Years, Cons - TC, Brand Value, Mid Tier Clients. Any opinions?

like

What is realistic comp and career progression at a PE firm exit?

like

Thoughts on Facebook / Amazon Corp Dev (L7) vs. M&A team at Big4 (e.g. senior manager at Deloitte or EY Parthenon) with 10 YOE and similar TC

like

All the jobs in my city are business analyst or FP&A..... The wait continues

like

For anyone that left consulting to work in product management. How is it? How is the work? Wlb - people - culture .. etc

like

Anyone have benchmarks for equity offer from Series A startups in a Senior Strategic Finance Manager role? Base salary is market if that helps.

like

I’ve been a management consultant for 3.5 yrs. I’ve done 18 months of internal sustainability work such as building our sustainability practice, initiatives to get B CORP, SBTI, tracked carbon emissions, company campaigns for sustainability awareness, sustainability strategy. I want to move into a sustainability consulting role. Which area of sustainability consulting should I look at? Are there any courses or certifications I should do?

like

Apple UK cover letter - Yea or Nay?

like

Anyone know if any Tech/FAANG companies hiring in Sourcing and Supply Chain management roles?

like

People who pivoted/trying to pivot to PM - what resources did you use/do you recommend? There are some online courses or boot camps that have $1-2k tuition fees - worth it? Which ones are worth it?

like

Need some advice. Had final interview with practice lead on Wednesday but haven’t heard back from HR. Is it bad taste to send him a thank you note and wishing him a good weekend?

like

Do you have to give two weeks notice that you're leaving? Don't want to burn bridges, but I'm ready to go now haha.

like

AbbVie just posted Director of Innovation role. Does anyone know about this team? Seems like a good exit opportunity but would like some inside scoop.

like

Currently at Deloitte and considering leaving. Is it worth jumping from one Big4 to another? Seems like getting into Industry is not working out.

like

Looking from some insight on exit opportunities to tech firms - Amazon, Google, smaller tech firms. I have an engineering background but have mostly worked in finance for close to 10 years. I feel I am lagging in technology to get into these firms. Any recommendations on skills to develop?

like

What are the pros and cons for working at your consulting firm? (salary, benefits, culture, growth opportunities, international projects , etc). Trying to figure out where I might want to go next.

likefunny

4YOE @Amazon & trying to lateral to a similar role @FAANG. Have my undergrad GPA (3.8/4) on resume from top 15 school but colleague says to take it off (looks silly). If it’s a good school & high GPA, why ever take it off your resume? Even if 10 YOE...can’t hurt?

like

How difficult is it to move from the UK to US without having studied there and just applying to a big tech directly (not a transfer)? NB: have previously worked in a big tech as a PM in the UK as well as time at McK

like

Anybody having post consulting syndrome?

like

Advanced doctorate degree and MBA, starting FT at MBB soon. Thinking about spending a year or so at MBB and then considering startups or VC investing in the healthcare space. I’ve seen post MBA PE exists from MBB, but what are the VC exit ops like? Does MBB help? How easy/hard to get partner track without operating or startup experience? What about for later stage stuff like growth equity? (Not interested in PE).

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal