If two employees at the same level currently have two different salaries (due to number of yrs experience) both get promoted at the same time, would they in theory both jump to the same salary? Because they are both entering the same pay band?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

No. It depends on a lot of things, but mostly on how well they can negotiate.

like

The salary band is a range though - not a fixed number. And within that range, one could be higher paid than the other.

like

^ CD 1 nailed it. Agencies want to pay the least amount possible so it comes down to negotiation skills

like

No. And depending where you are, you may receive a certain % boost when you’re promoted, like 15%.

like

Agree with this! They would get % increases and the %could also vary. So they wouldn’t necessarily come to the same level at all

like

All of these answers from people who have not ever set anyones salary speculating on how it’s determined… here’s some insight from someone who actually does this:

1. It’s possible for two people to be promoted into the same level and get different salaries. Current salary, experience, performance, skills, retention priority all go into this.

2. It’s also possible for two people currently at different salaries to be promoted and get the same salary. This is something I will do if I want to rectify what I see as an undue pay disparity that existed before; especially if that pay gap is correlated with race/gender/etc. I’ll use the simultaneous promotion as a chance to level the playing field.

3. Negotiation skills almost always have fuck all to do with this! When you are first receiving a job offer you have a lot of negotiating power, but when you receive a promotion you have low negotiating power because you’re already doing the job (probably not going to quit the day they promote you) AND because your new salary has already gone through multiple levels of approval before you see it. Very, very occasionally I am able to go back and get someone a bigger raise than we initially gave them - but only really in cases where I can prove what we’re offering is way off what we’re paying comparable employees. Even in the best cases the additional increase will usually be pretty small. This scenario people are describing where you deploy your ~smooth negotiation skills~ to reject your salary and magically get a much higher one, is not something that happens unless you have a competitive counteroffer in hand (and even then, maybe not).

The best way to ensure you are offered the most competitive salary with a promotion is to be indispensable before you’re promoted… and to work at a company that’s consistently hitting its financial targets, which is honestly the biggest factor in any of this.

like

THANK YOU this was so helpful!

like

It is possible that the two employees would jump to the same salary, but it is also possible that their new salaries would be different. The salary within a pay band is typically determined by factors such as years of experience, skills, and education.

Probably not. The new salary for employees in a pay band is typically based on various factors, including the employee's current salary and years of experience.

This is so sad! Mostly because I’m the one with less experience

Do not try and bend the spoon, that’s impossible. Instead, only try to realize the truth… there is no spoon. Then you’ll see that it is not the spoon that bends, it is only yourself.

Related Posts

Hourly pay rate

like

Hi everyone

My current CTC is 4.1L

My skills: Manual, API, Performance testing

Yoe: 3

Thinking of joining another company, How much should I expect in my next package jump?

Kindly help me with your suggestions!

like

Hello fishes,
i have an offer of X amount from jp morgan and x+ 3.5L from Mphasis, my joining is within a week, I asked counter offer from HR, she said we will look if there is any backup candidate to fill that position then we will not do counter and it will impact my DOJ also since offer approval process takes around 2 weeks. should i wait or should i join on my current doj. and also if i will wait will they give me another doj on my current compenstion or they will revoke the offer past doj?

like

Hello Fishes,

I currently hold offers from below:
IBM - 15.5 LPA
CTS - 18.5 LPA
PWC India - 16 LPA
Oracle Financial Services Software(OFSS) - 21 LPA

Planning to join OFSS as I will work in product development team and can work in any shift timings with WFH.

Today I had my 2nd round interview with EY GDS and got rejected.
Do I need to worry about this and feel low?
Could EY GDS would have been better instead of OFSS?

Please provide your valuable inputs.

like

Hi fishes,
YOE-14
Tech stack-AEM

Looking for good wlb and job security. Please help me choose from below offers.

1.
Infosys-JL6A Designation:Senior Technical Architect CTC-38LPA incl 20% VP JB-1.25l
2. Capgemini-D1 Designation: Senior Manager CTC-39lpa incl 15% VP
Infosys Capgemini

like

Hi All!
Hope everyone's doing well and good!
I just have one query! It'll be really helpful if anyone can help me out!
I recently got selected in Pwc India as an Tech. Consultant!
I'm being offered 5.5Lpa, can anyone let me know the salary breakup/in-hand salary?

like

What is typical signing bonus offered by MBB if you are recruited as an experienced hire into their Manager or Senior Manager level (coming from Big 4)? For core strategy practice, not niche areas.

like
like

Hello Fishes,

Can someone please let me know the salary range for an Automation engineer/SDET role in
Pure Storage Bangalore with a total experience of 4.6 years @Pure storage

Thanks in advance

like

What is UBS Associate Director salary in Non IT Pune role with 15 yrs of experience.

Interviewing for a Senior Specialist role in Product Management (Commercial, Smart Data). Could someone please provide insight on what I can expect in the interview process as well as the role and overall culture/wlb? Expected comp? It’s onsite at the Arlington office but curious about hybrid accommodations. Thanks!

Anyone exit for in house counsel jobs? How much does general counsel pay v tax counsel, say 5 YOE?

like

can anyone let me know about Hashmap. The company has been acquired by NTT data and they are offering ntt data offer.

YOE is 6. Profile is senior cloud engineer-ETL

like

Would you leave consulting to go from 200k to 300k if you love the travel and are single? They may give me a raise so what about 225k to 300k or 250k to 300k?

like
like

Currently interviewing for a role at Amazon that is listed as a CW position, but I have direct experience in the product and capabilities this role is seeking, and the hiring manager is moving me forward. What is the likelihood that if I tried to negotiate from a CW to FTE, I would get the position?

Hey guys joined new in Tavisca but was eligible for year end review, I got On track. The evaluation window was narrow so no complaints. What can I expect in compensation changes ??
Cloud Engineer , 28LPA , 9 YOE

I'm in monaqo since 5yrs, I just got promoted with 52% hike from 12.5LPA to 19LPA(18Fix,1V) and increased NP to 90D from 45D. Every year I get hike betwn 20-25%.
Now got offer from freshmenu(product based) giving only 25% hike(24Fix,0V) but ready to wait 90D NP. They are saying - I already got good hike, no budget, your NP is high and we are considering only fixed part.
So in dilemma to stay for yearly hike or to leave because of 90D NP which will make difficult to get another job
E:7Y
Tech:PHP

Pay for teachers in Arizona is so awful 😭. I always wanted to teach in my local community but frankly I can't afford it. I want to move to another state where comp is better but I'm not positive where. What do you make & where are you located? For context I'm a 3rd year 2nd grade teacher.

like

More Posts

Seriously need to up the study game rn

like

Change my mind: A motion to “clarify” one of the court’s orders is actually just a cute, roundabout way of asking for reconsideration.

like

Having a son (first) next year and looking for a birth year watch to hand down. Obvious thought would be a sub but open to other ideas - ideally want something that is classic and will keep its value. Would wear myself. Would rather have my name (or his) on the registration if possible. Any tips/ideas? Is it impossible to get a new sub in a year’s time?

like

Director at DI Deloitte or Digital strategy principal at Adobe Which is better and why? Please help/DM.
All views welcome Adobe Deloitte

like
uplifting

What is the salary range for L7 in consulting?
Location: India

like

Signed an offer letter today after being laid off for 2 months and not gonna lie, it feels pretty damn good.

likeupliftinghelpful

Should I max out my HSA contribution?
I am maxing my 401k though.

Also, if I max my HSA, can I invest say 50% and keep the other 50% for expenses?

likeuplifting

What if airbnb gives you a similar suite than the one in the picture but it is still not the same suite? And you tell airbnb but the host says its not accurate and says you are a disrespectful host?

like

What is average cost of living near jp morgan office in bangalore? (PG/ Flat/ Apartment)

like

Sigh. Whats the point of having a bowl if no one uses it....leaving.

funnylike

Interviewing with Activision Blizzard. I have a one hour interview for Lead SDET. Anyone have any insight or tips for the interview?

like

Time to DIVE into a deck.

Post Photo
like

When is a 3 page resume acceptable?

likefunny

In the parking lot, found this truck with two interesting statements. "Congrats on the baby" and "I 💓 crack whores". Hmmm...head scratch...

Post Photo
likefunny

I just got a new credit card. It came with a Priority Pass membership. I always travel economy, I hardly ever get lounge access. I got excited, until I remembered I can’t travel and lounges are closed anyways. :(

like

I’m relocating in two weeks, which requires flying with my cat. I’ve never flown with a pet in-cabin before. (U.S. domestic flight) I already have a vet appointment booked for the vet certificate. Anything else I should make sure to do before my trip? Any tips from those who have flown with a pet before ?

likehelpful

I am joining Deloitte India next week and I have received a mail from the recruitment team that I have assigned with a "Buddy" from Deloitte to help me guide through the beginning.

Is this a normal thing in Deloitte/Big4? What is the significance?

like

Do you think Google's CEO will be able to get them through the anti-trust lawsuit effectively?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

like

Can we stop calling brands “brave” for putting out certain work? Looking at you, BK Andy spot. We’re not running into burning buildings to save people. It’s a f’in TV commercial.

likefunny

With so many layoffs and the strange uncertainty of this industry right now—is anyone scared to death?

likehelpful

New to IT B2B marketing. Any advice on how to educate myself with IT? Any classes, books, etc. that you recommend?

like

The Goggle pixel + childish gambino spot is 🔥

like

I saw earlier today someone else posted the BOP copy from some Trader Joe’s arugula, which kept using the fantasy word [its’] in place of [its]. Now my wife brought this home (also Trader Joe’s).

Post Photo
like

Any junior/student Art Directors in Portland Metro area looking for a Copywriter partner?!

like

Does anyone regret having a second kid? Did it make working in advertising completely untenable?

like

Creatives shouldn’t be sharing their screens…I will die on this hill.

likefunny

What’s the latest on BSSP in SF? The only clients I’m really interested in are 2K and ESPN (judging by their website), but dunno what the status of those are. Also, am I going to have to trek up to Sausalito, or will I be able to wfh given the new post-pandemic normal?

like

If a client no longer wants to work with someone because they don’t like them and/or think the ads they create are all terrible. Why would the agency continue to keep this person leading the account?

like

Mad Men came out 10 yrs ago when I first started in this industry as a wide eyed acct coordinator. Planning on rewatching from the start for a new perspective. Where were you in your career back then?

like

Quick poll: how many of these posts are made sober vs not? Asking for a friend

like
like

Thoughts on Ketchum CEO /agency culture.

like

Anyone have a recommendation for books or resources on upping my sales game? Open to in person class, online class, books, etc!

like

Books or websites to learn more about social media strategy, community management, and smart decision making for social?

like

Is it hard to switch from Designer to Art Director? I just got offered a Junior Designer role and don’t know if this will mess up my chances of being an Art Director down the line

like

"Hi. Reaching out because I really like your book. It made me laugh a lot. I have a great opportunity that won't allow you to use humor or smart thinking. Let me know what you think. Best, Recruiter."

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal