Is there an ethical limit to how much wealth one individual should be allowed to accumulate, even if it was earned legally and through innovation?

likefunnysmartuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

No. That is stupid. This whole “eat the rich” socialism campaign is complete lunacy.

likefunnyhelpfulsmart

Yeah let’s eat this guy first

likefunny

Yes. Of course. Legality doesn’t matter. There’s lots of things that are legal that are only legal due to corruption. Billionaires do not earn their wealth. Their employees whom they exploit do.

likefunnysmarthelpful

Nobody was exploited. Everyone got paid for their work. You are not poor just because someone else is rich.

Recent IconRecent

No. If I come up with an idea or product that there is enough demand for to make me a trillionaire, so be it. I wouldn't keep more than I actually need, and children's charities would be really well off, but that would be my choice,

So you essentially would be granting more freedom to those who own less wealth. Wealthy people hold all the power so eventually that would fall apart. They would find a way look at organized crime. That's how a lot of people make money in socialist countries through crime. It's a nice idea but human nature doesn't work that way.

What would that be? How much would that be? who would decide the amount? What else do you want to limit of what people work on? Should you limit how much weight someone gains? How about limit the number of miles someone drives? Or how about limit the size of the house they purchase? Or limit the amount of land they own?

No one should limit what you earn but it wouldn't kill anyone to help others with some of that money. People are dying from lack of healthcare, children do not have food, some can't afford housing. Other countries (not US) give to these needs and the entire country benefits from it. Its rooted in caring and helping other humans. What we are seeing now are oligarchs pushing their initiatives and paying off our government while they pay zero taxes. Its quite disgusting.

Define "legally" -- that criteria has significantly changed since January 20 2025. But even before then, not a single person in the Epstein class has earned their money legitimately. Being subsidized by the government -- although technically legal -- is not ethical or moral.

Not at all. If there was a limit, then people wouldn't strive for more and innovation would slow. Innovation is slowing now due to large corporations buying up all of these small businesses and then killing the product because it was a competitor. Google is very good at doing that.

If you don't like this, wait until he owns Mars

Yes. We aren't that keen on ethics in the US. We are a "might makes right" empire.

What an idiotic question. How would you feel if you earned Mo ey through an invention and production of that invention and someone told you that YOU should not have your wealth or should be forced to share it?

I so not subscribe to the Robin Hood mentality. If you earn it, you keep it.

I believe this post is simply rage bait and hope that you do not truly feel like the rich should be forced to give to the rest of society.

This is America. If you want it, go earn it.

Wealth has nothing to do with “earning off the backs of others”. The United States has laws for fair wages. It’s not like the wealthy are earning their millions by paying people mere pennies.

No.

Well how much of that wealth is actually liquid. Real physical cash. If the Rich paid their fair share in taxes I would be fine with it. But we all know they will not do that.

I don't know if there is a "line" but there is definitely a wealth range beyond which the accumulation of wealth, either by a single person or body, becomes detrimental to society. Take private equity firms buying up real estate, for example. Driving the cost of housing up for everyone is bad for the entire economy. It doesn't liberate the wealthy.
And really, most of the infrastructure of this country was created during a period when the top tax brackets were paying 75% or more of the income in taxes. Shifting that tax burden to the right is only smart. If I'm a struggling family making 40K or less, a $500 dollar tax break is going to be a hell of a lot meaning for me than a guy who made a million last year paying $50,000. Grow up, America, infinite growth is not a thing.

Who should be the person to decide what is that amount. It speaks volumes to the ignorance involved when you realize that the vast majority of Americans are obscenely wealthy compared to the rest of the world. This whole agenda is your typical socialist greed and envy.

The guard rails need to be on how that wealth is spent, rather than having a wealth cap. Huge wealth unrestrained buys off the govt, and becomes an oligarchy.

Give some money to charity or those in need.

Most charities would not exist if not for the incentive of tax credits.

On paper if someone can afford unnecessary luxuries while someone is unable to afford food or needed medical care, that can be argued as un-ethical. In reality there is a lot more noise and fuzz in the system.

At present I firmly believe billionaires should not exist (yes I know worth vs liquid cash), When someone's net worth exceeds $999,999,999,99 they have to return shares to everyone employed at that business or if it is liquid it is taxed.

I'd also have loans taken out against collateral being used for personal things (ie the income tax dodge the wealthy all do) taxed as income, same bands.

Think about the Church of Notre-Dame de Paris in Paris and let me know your thoughts.

Is there a limit to how much land someone should be able to own? Houses? Power? Of course there should be limits, money is no different. Being wealthy or rich isn't bad in isolation, just like owning some houses isn't. Yet if you owned 50,000 houses? That's kind of a problem, even if you did "earn it".

Absolutely not - we live in a democratic country right? I’m all for paying share, don’t get me wrong - but there is a spending problem within our government vs a revenue problem - this explains why spending has gone from 17 to 24% of GDP since 2000.

No. Stop being mad at Elon for elevating 4,400 people to millionaire status.

Related Posts

New offer. What does this mean?: “Policy is that we don’t consider the green card until someone is at 2.5 years prior to the last extended date on their current visa.”

helpful

I’m doing second round interviews with Deloitte but also interviewing with three other companies. If I get an offer from Deloitte, how long can I put off making a decision in order to finish the interview process with the other companies? Is this generally frowned upon?

like

Can someone please tell me about the position Senior Specialist, Business Compliance? In terms of wlb, comp, growth? What all should I keep in mind for the interview?

like

Would going to accounting advisory or finance in industry or Ops at a big bank be a better option for career?

like

Do you always feel tired? How do you have energy for anything with this amount of work.

like

Anyone got premium bagpack?

like

Does anyone have tips/methods for staying on top of all the little things? I’m in litigation and it’s a constant struggle to make sure I have accurate and up to date ‘bring ups’ and that I float anf rename all my emails and get all my time in and update my partner etc. like I can maybe get 1 or 2 but I’m never on top of everything and it’s so hard!

My partner now accepts and understands I am just going to have some organised chaos but also I want to make this little shit work for me!

like

30 m ny/nj. US citizen. Moved as a teenager. INTJ. Single since I figured I’m not fighting the biological clock and have all the time in the world to meet someone and get settled. Things changed after I watched Akshay’s mom (Indian Matchmaking) tell him even 25 is too late and not marrying somehow messes up lives of people around him. While the show was staged, there might be truth to the latter part.
Looking for F in ny/nj. Personality: NOT Aparna. NOT Nadia but def more Nadia than Aparna.🙏

likefunny

Looking for an Amsterdam based Sr. Copywriter with Influencer campaign marketing experience. Script writing and messaging needs. Video game background is good to have. Start date 04/29 for 4 weeks. DM

like

Does anyone have any advice on how to convince yourself life is worth it when you think it’s not. I’m a 28 year guy, just got laid off from my job, have aspergers, have no friends, can’t find a gf, why do I even try anymore at anything

like

Is equity research a possible exit opp from audit?

like

What can a junior associate do about a mid-level that constantly asks questions about things they were cc’d on, sends dozens of piecemeal emails and is generally just super high strung and needs everything right away?? No other mid-levels I’ve worked with act this way and this individual I’m working with is driving me insane and I’ve spent countless hours attaching emails and saying “as explained in the attached email…”

like

Looking for candidates for an Analytics Solution Engineer role at Salesforce. Ideal background: experience working with analytics technology (ie Tableau, Salesforce CRMA (Einstein), Qlik, Power BI), working with or in the government/military, and working in a customer facing role. Please reach out if you have interest or know someone who may be a good fit. Resumes welcome!

like

How long until you felt comfortable in ITS? Is it fair to say with all the changes it would take longer to get comfortable in ITS?

like

And another one bites the dust

like

Hello, I am a junior business administrator working in advisory operations. I have been with the company for 6 months, and was employed along with 2 other colleagues. I have picked the job up really fast and am even doing some “extra curricula’s” I really love my job. However I have recently found out I am being paid the same as an apprentice on my team, I usually do at 3 x the work he does whilst also doing my Cert CII. It has really disheartened me and I feel I should be earning more money

like

This week in homebuying horror stories: offered $60k (10%) over asking on a house. Got beat by a last minute all-cash offer from an out of state buyer who was buying sight-unseen.

This is the worst.

likefunny

Is Argyle, TX good place to buy home and raise family?

like

Hi Folks,

got an call for sap bw hana job. can someone help me with the kind of questions they ask?

like
like

Additional Posts in Tech

Just got my work laptop. I can login with work email. Trying to access my office 365,outlook it’s not working at all I got some error message when trying to login. 3,15- 89 something and I can use my phone an iPad to login just fine. Help

like

My manager micro manages everything I do, and I’m losing my mind. Wanted to see how any of you have handled a manager like this, and get some advice on how to tell them to literally stop.

like

I’m a product designer and have an interview with a lead product engineer for a startup. What type of things do they want to know?

like

Tinder vs Linkedin

Post Photo
likefunny

I've been approached about being an expert consultant. Has anyone done this before? I'm interested to hear people's experience.

like

What inspired you to start on the career you've chosen?

like

Have you been able to spend more time with your kids during the pandemic? How?

like

Considering offer as a Manager in Protiviti technology consulting practice. Considering moving into consulting after over a decade in industry. Can anyone share their perspective on what what it’s like working in protiviti technology consulting as a manager now? (I.e pros and cons). Appreciate any insight!

likehelpful

Anyone have experience taking the GCP Machine Learning exam?

like

When is a 3 page resume acceptable?

likefunny

I have 10 YoE in the Customer Support field, making 68k currently as a lead agent. I applied for a supervisor role, above my current role, and didn't get it.

Any recommendations on how I can leverage my YoE in the future for this role if I've never been in a supervisor role?

like

How easy is it to move from an investment bank firm to a tech company?

like

Best deal sourcing database? Is pitchbook the best? Other comparables? Private companies but could also include public. Range of industries preferred, but definitely inclusive of tech services companies, solutions/products, too.

like

Any favorite go-to online prep resources for an Amazon interview? I have one on Monday and from what the recruiter told me, it’ll be a whirlwind of questions. Thanks in advance!

like

Considering a jump from FTE back to consulting. I have roughly 8 IT YOE, CSPO, CSM, and my MBA. I'm considering a Sr Product Owner role with the mind set of moving to Product Management within the next 1-2 years. With that background and currently being in a candidate's market, roughly what should I target as my salary?

Right now, I'm at 100k with 5% bonus as a BA.

like

Is there a repository of SQL questions asked by Amazon for their Sr. Business Analyst interviews I can refer to? I couldn’t find anything in leetcode. Any help is appreciated! Amazon

like

I feel burnt out by how ruthless the tech industry in US is, but I also know I’m making much more money than people outside of tech or consulting.

How do you adjust your WLB?
I’m so burnt out that I wish I could yell at people who were not kind or supportive to me, but those people often unfortunately were in position of power.
I don’t like unkindness, but my anger is just very bottled up…
What can I do to stay level-headed even when the other side is disrespectful?

like

Wondering if anyone knows anything about a company called Turing.com ? A friend of mine just got a job offer with them and is looking for some insight on the company. Thanks!

like

What things do you do at your company that actually helps improve culture?
Bonus points for remote activities 🤗

like

Best course for GCP professional data engineer? Any suggestions

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal