I’ve seen a lot of recruiters recently trying to hire for advisory consulting firms that claim they do the work that Big 4 can’t because of independence issues. Does anyone think these types of firms are sustainable or will big 4 find a way around the independence restrictions and take this work back?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I don’t understand how these even exist currently. 4 competing firms means that 1 firm does the audit, 1 firm does design consulting, 1 firm does implementation consulting, 1 firm is left to give competitive bids for any of the 3 other services.

likefunny

I think it’s a stretch to say they do the work that the big 4 can’t do for independence issues. I can understand why 1 firm won’t be able to do to independence but why wouldn’t the other 3 be able to? Seems like a marketing ploy to be honest. If you want to go to reputable consulting shops vault gives you a good idea.

like

There are many niche firms that do similar work to advisory big 4 work. Many reputable and sustainable. If anything government bodies are increasing independence restrictions worldwide. UK as an example. I began my career at Alvarez and Marsal and can say the lack of independence barriers were a huge plus

like

Related Posts

Thinking of exiting from B4 M&A Advisory to Corp Dev to gain industry experience before b school with long term goal of PE. How much does company size, brand name and location matter for 1) b school apps 2) PE recruiters in the future ?

like

Need a referral to Deloitte, over 10+ yrs experience, 7 of those in big 4, MBA, PMP, SAFe, CSPO, left big 4 to work as a head of pmo and delivery for a small boutique, i don't like it. Cont'

like

Honestly working at Big 4 has made me feel worthless. Seems like nothing I do is good enough. I graduated with honors from a large competitive public university. I came in with a positive attitude,I am a very talkative person who had many leadership roles in college, I always stay organize, and I put in the time and continue to look for ways to improve. But constantly feeling like I’m not “type A” enough or that I need to communicate more and prove my worth. Is it like this at other jobs too? :/

likeuplifting

Curious what the current Employee Referral Bonuses look like in B4 firms? As a smaller firm, our people are being inundated by recruiters, but also staff/seniors from B4 firms looking to poach, I assume because there is significant financial incentive. How good are the referral bonuses at your firm?

like

Currently working in a Management Consulting role in Big 4 (not front office). Got an offer from Product Based company that is more of value consulting and business development role. and Its a new team catering to Partner ecosystem of the company. I am doing good in my current role.

Any insights or suggestions would be greatly appreciated

like

In first year at Big 4 advisory firm and assignments are scarce; killing my utilization. Should I look for another job or are newbies given slack? Anyone laid off in first year or been through it?

like

How is the growth and exit opportunities for Finance and Shared Services Outsourcing advisory teams in Big 4? My current profile is more towards secondary research and benchmarking (some exposure to outsourcing advisory)? Does it make sense to leave my current role for Finance and SSC team in another big 4?

My Profile:

MBA (tier 2) Senior Analyst KPMG

like

Dear Big 4's

In EY...How much pay is expected for 8 yrs exp. BI lead role? Including variable..pls comment

like

Looks like B4 partners makes the most $$ in the long run, even tech/FAANG or industry level senior roles doesn’t pay more then $600-700k, except a few roles like ceo/IB/PE/other financial roles/startup rsu (of u r lucky). Came to the conclusion after reading all the posts in this and other bowls. May be MBB, but if u add pensions, I think B4 is better. Thoughts?

like

Considering making a switch from Big 4. Comments to share on bonus this year and in a normal year? Culture?

Curious...for big 4 and national firms: for travel expenses (food hotel flight), do you have to use a firm card or can you use your own card? Also, do you have to book with a certain travel agent

Big 4 M1 tax salary in the Minneapolis office? Am I underpaid at 110k currently? Not able to leverage big4 transparency data. Appreciate if anyone could share their thoughts.

like
like

At the Big 4, what's the highest salary for a Senior Associate that you've seen? I'm trying to negotiate.

like

From a big 4 Management consulting. Have been invited to apply for Accenture strategy, same level. What is the reputation of the strategy group of Accenture?

like

Hi Fishes,
I hold 8 years experience in Wealth management, financial advisory in Banking. My current salary is fixed 9 lpa and variable 10 lap. Currently I am negotiating salary with one of the Big 4 firms. Can anyone tell me how much hike should I quote as fixed and variable ??

like

Leaving Big 4 for industry, and I’ll have a two-month gap before my benefits and health insurance kicks in with the new company. Should I do COBRA or a short-term health insurance plan? I’m healthy and do not have any pre-existing conditions.

like

Would it be a lot harder to move back to MBB/T2 firms if i exit to Big 4 (not Strategy&, monitor etc.) or relatively unknown industry positions?

like

What is the salary base for Internal IT Audit Manager within 8 YOE in NYC? Looking for both Big 4 & industry for comparison. TIA

like

Anyone got experience with McKinsey Digital? Couple questions below:

- Where do most applicants come from for associate roles? (5YoE requested) what's the average background - still oxbridge and top MBA?
- Associate renumeration structure?
- is it more people/strategy focused like Accenture or more tech development
- Where does the majority of their client base sit?
- is travel frequent?

What are other MBB tech alternatives to B4?

like

More Posts

I am 32. Once divorced, just left a bad relationship. Is it too late for me? Feeling like I have no chance of a family at this point. Sad, hopeless, and looking for some encouragement from the wonderful ladies in this bowl.

like

Hi sharks,

Nagarro vs Amdocs vs Netcrackers

Looking for job security, wlb and Tech stack. Which one is best to join if CTC offered is same in all of the above.
Tech stack:- Java Springboot Microservices. YOE :- 4

Thanks in Advance.

Amdocs Nagarro Netcracker

like

Hi everyone HELP! I was lucky enough to receive two job offers, one in SNF/LTC one in oncology outpatient setting. Looking for any tips from people that have worked in either setting or both??
Some background I am coming from a inpatient hospital setting. Thank you!

like

Hey MC fish!

Can you name the Management Consulting firms which are next best to MBBs and Big4s?

like

Is it ok to wear a white sleeveless blouse and white shoes to a wedding with a (pink) saree? Is that too much white?

Bride will be in a white dress.

like

Hello fishes just want to know does anybody uses AMD processors and if yes how is your experience in terms of programming, do anyone face any challenges while using an AmD for coding? On a software abstraction level they should be same but there are various problems in the past with AMD not able to run android studio and not supporting NUMPy, there are workaround but If I am thinking of buying a gaming+coding lapto Intel ones are quite expensive.

like

Can anyone refer me for EY noida for java profile
Yoe: 9+ yrs

EY

Hi Ladies!

I am a current IB analyst at a BB in an industry coverage group. Have been thinking of recruiting to PE but don’t know where and how to start. Any advice? Also, is there a way we could share our prep resources and materials here?

Thank you in advance!

like

Sara cashback le lia wapas😤

Post Photo
like

Me and my husband are both associates and are busy (like everyone else). No kids and have our house cleaned every Friday, order all our groceries via delivery, but I’m looking to outsource more. I wish I had an “assistant” one day a week to do miscellaneous tasks like take things to the post office, go get the car washed, run random errands, put laundry away… has anyone found a good solution for this? If so what are you paying?

like

With so many layoffs and the strange uncertainty of this industry right now—is anyone scared to death?

likehelpful

Jr AD’s- I’m looking to pay someone to help polish one of my projects. Need to work on it a bit more and then mock it up. Just got fired so I gotta revamp. $50 sound alright?

like

Seeing a couple of rumours on the new Deloitte consulting bandings, can anyone shed any light on what the news is? PwCs coming in at the end of June…

like

Hello, can we use this thread to share job openings? I thought this might be a great way to help each other out!

likehelpful
like

Has anyone been to the Martinique or St.Lucia? If so, any Rec?

like

Just bought an iwatch, what’s your favorite health / fitness app and why?

like

What is the process for resigning from JP Morgan or other investment banks? Is there an intranet link or it's just telling your staffer?

Any one exited Capgemini recently ?
How long it takes to get Full and Final Settlement amount?
Anyone also withdraw PF along with F&F ?

like

Additional Posts in Accounting

Anyone here ever switch from audit to forensics? What was the switch like, biggest differences and similarities? Did you regret the switch?

likesmart

Guys - what brand of dress shoes do you wear, how much did they cost, and how well are they holding up?

like

If i am filling out a background check for my employer and they are asking for EY contact information, who’s name and number should i give them?

like

Dreaming of the day when yoga pants become acceptable office attire. #lifegoals

like

Does deloitte reimburse you the cpa fees for taking the cpa?

like

Has anyone seen someone successfully exit IT audit to an industry role that is NOT IT audit?

like

How much writing is required in audit ? Lastly,Is it acceptable to copy last year work papers ?

like

What was that moment like when you just suddenly realized you needed to get out of public? I do like my coworkers but not the work. Have been having dreams about work lately… not good ones. and it’s not even busy season right now. Also felt like I haven’t learned much technical stuff. Been wanting to look what’s out there lately. Not a clue what I want to do though. 😭

likehelpful

First year manager salary in risk advisory in MCOL (Philly or similar)

like

What CPA study software does your firm offer if any? We use becker.

like

Anybody have to pay back a signing bonus? My bonus at EY doesn't "vest" for two years, but I'm wondering if they'll actually pull it back if I leave at about 18 months, or will they just let it go?

like

My name is short and spelled out in my email, yet people repeatedly misspell it when responding to my emails. How can you misspell it when it’s literally spelled out for you in both my email and signature.

like

I’ve been seeing this a lot more recently and just had to make a thread about it. I refuse to believe that anyone on here has actually been asked to work a 100hr week. People come onto this thread with legitimate questions and concerns and I just see people trying to scare them out of public which inevitably makes it worse for everyone else who sticks around. Even an 80 hour week is debatable and that is the absolute top. Stop trying to be an attention getter. We work, but not 24/7.

likefunnyhelpful

Woke up to 15,000 extra SPG points this morning. Good morning all

like

Lost a ton of friends, gained 20 pounds, developed drug addiction all for $$$ was it worth it? Kinda. I mean it's very easy to find a well paying job, they just suck. Not even licensed yet but testing

like

Last weekend I brought 2k to Vegas for a getaway with friends and ended up finding a magic machine that paid me $1500 every hour. I ended up with 15 hand pays all at or above $1500. Like a true drunken Vegas partier, I kept putting my winners back in, paying for my friends games, dinner, drinks, shows.... I was showing off. Ended up coming home with 6k. Still happy. But not the 21k my tax records show I won. What do I need to worry about come tax time?

likefunny

Which firms pay out bonuses and what is the typical amount? Any of the mid-size pay bonuses like the big 4?

like

I’m up for early promotion, and I’m curious about the raise %. By getting promoted early I’ll be missing out on one year of 5-8% at my current position compared to most of my peers in the new one. Do early promo raises ever account for this or are they the usual annual + promotion %? If they don’t account for it I feel like it leaves me under compensated compared to my peers. Even with one less year of experience I would still be doing the same job and expect the same compensation.

like

Can anyone recommend a good office chair for less than $100?

like

Any podcast recommendations for commuting?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.