Looking for advice. Closing on a new primary in Charlotte NC area. Current HHI $350K, with $250K savings. New home purchase price of $860K. We will spend $100K down payment and planned renovations of $150K which will drain my savings. Our current primary, im debating whether to rent or sell. If we sell, we would likely get $200K in equity. If we rent, we could likely cash flow +$1000 per month. House was built in 1996, with likely big repair such as HVAC replacement needed. Should I rent or sell

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Yeah basically a $5.5K mortgage with a $7K biweekly paycheck since I’m putting 10% down. Potentially our HHI could double in a couple years, and hoping rates come down. But two big If’s there.

funny

are the renovations necessary, just nice to haves, or a mix of both?

If nice to have you could hold off on the reno for a year or two and build a bigger cushion while renting the other property.

like

So essentially a $1M home with $350k HHI at current mortgage rates? Might be a stretch. Would sell the primary and move the equity into the new home

If your renovations can add value, this isn’t a terrible idea as I think most people expect interest rates to drop in the next 6 to 24 months, and you may be able to refi to not only a lower rate but also no PMI.

If you think the renovations will run $150k, I’d set $180k aside for it because renovations always seem to run over. In that situation, you seem stretched a little thin on your budget. If you can pay for some materials on a CC that has a 12 to 18 month 0% intro interest rate, that might help stretch it a bit. If you have other assets you could potentially tap into if you need to (brokerage assets, RSU’s, etc), that would make me feel a bit more comfortable.

$1k per month in cashflow on the other house sounds nice, but knowing you have some big expenses that might be coming around soon, and being stretched thin across 2 properties, I would lean towards selling and moving on.

Renovating two original bathrooms that’s outdated would run $35K, replacing laminate flooring with hardwoods would be another $15k, and replacing deck and building screen in porch is $75K. The last one is the one that probably isn’t “necessary” right now that I’m considering saving for next year after bonuses roll in

Without knowing anything else, I would agree with the bathrooms and the flooring. Bathrooms are a necessity for your family and guests, and hardwood floors are good not only cosmetically but tend to increase property value (apparently a lot of buyers like seeing hardwood).

I think holding off on the deck for a year or 2 would be financially smarter, just so you don’t deplete your savings.

Rent that thing! That kind of cash flow is amazing.

$2100 rent + 10% vacancy reserves + 10% maintenance reserves + 5% property management (aka paying yourself, real property management is likely 8% to 10%) = $375 “actual cashflow”. We already know the HVAC will be needed soon, so you probably should be saving 20% to 25% towards capex alone (HVAC could be $15k - $20k fairly easily… that eats away 2 or 3 years of your “best case cashflow” alone!)

You can’t assume that nothing will ever go wrong, or that you’ll never have vacancy, or that managing a property is effortless. Those are the exceptions, not the norm.

OP - what did you end up doing? I’m in a very similar situation. Including towards renting out current primary but feel like we will be really stretched thin.

Related Posts

How much are you contributing to your 401k?

What’s a good, practical tax book to read for someone who knows nothing about taxes? I feel like I should familiarize myself with them but don’t know where to start/find the topic very overwhelming and dense even as a finance attorney. Welcome to other beginning finance book suggestions too! (Already read Kiyosaki and Ramsey)

like

Morgan Stanley or Schwab? Which brokerage should i choose?

like

Make $80k a year, pay $1,440 for rent, haven’t grown my savings in 2 years. Is it me, or Sf?

What would you do?: trying to maximize points. Have CSR, Amex Gold, Chase freedom unlimited. Will be receiving CORP Amex from new firm. Background:

Thoughts on investing long term in BA at current price?

like

Anyone here willing to explain their thesis on bitcoin? Thanks!

like

When does HSA contributions show up in BOA account? I’m seeing HSA contribution deducted from my paycheck but nothing on BOA account.. had three paychecks so far. Also, does Deloitte deposit a one time firm contribution to HSA account?

like

If you living currently in a home and looking to buy another home but plan to put only 10% on the new home, can I pay the remaining 10% after selling my existing home in 1-2 months .. and get the PMI

like

Tough investing market out there!! What are some investment strategies to consider during these times?

like

I will be moving to Australia from the US in a couple of months. I was wondering what would be the best way for me to transfer the money in the US bank account to Australia? Also what are some of the good banks that allow opening of accounts when the individual is not in Australia? Thank you for the help!

like

I am sure this is a question with an obvious answer, but does anyone else just feel absolutely trapped in a job they hate because of their student loans? I’m three years out of law school and I still have $160K in student debt despite making aggressive payments. I work in a larger firm (not big law per se, but 250+ attorneys and big for the market). I am pretty unhappy with my job the vast majority of the time, but I feel like I have no options. $160k at 6% and 7% interest cannot be ignored.

like

1099 or w-2 ? I have been given the option though the company prefers w-2. It’s a day rate booking couple of months or more (no end date). I already have 1099 from similar company this year and am leaning towards 1099, but I don’t want to be difficult. I do take home office deduction and they are not supplying any equipment. Suggestions?

like

Does anyone have any book recommendations for information on buying a house?

like

I consolidated grad loans in ‘15, kept federal separate from private (w SoFi @6.75%). Can I refinance w SoFi or w Earnest? Should I combine the federal and lose the protections for better %?

Noogler question: are approved Amex expenses from concur directly paid by google to Amex? Or I gotta to pay? My expense was approved but has not yet been fully received in my account..

like

Anyone willing to share what assets they're investing in with the extra money from being overemployed?

like

Not related to consulting but anyone has experience with ratehub / canwise financial as lender for the house mortgage? They seem to offer better discount on Prime rate compared to the big 5 banks.

helpful

In GMS is it mandatory to declare loans, insurance etc. ? EY Is there any issue if somebody forgot to declare and signed?

like

Any San Francisco peeps have a good accountant who specializes in taxes for freelancers/contractors?

More Posts

Hey fishes,
Need help with a query. I had a joining bonus of 2LPA subjected to tax deductions. Now, since I am leaving within an year of joining, the company is asking me to pay back the complete 2LPA. In this case, what happens to the tax I have already beared close to 45,000. Will I get it when I file ITR?

like

Want to warn stakeholders that their hostile, posturing emails with our main client CC'd is only going to backfire (main client ❤️ us). emails will no joke prob get some of them fired. #restructuring

like

So, at what point is it considered “ghosting”?😐

like

Hi there. Anyone willing to refer for Ops M&A roles at KPMG? Thanks!

like

When is busy season over for the SOX side of stuff? Please tell it doesn’t go past 12/31.

funny

Just checked my bags and my nw is down 35% in the last 24 hours. I’m numb to it. To the mf moon. Send it

likefunny

A real gem from Henry Ford: "stopping advertising to save money is like stopping your watch to save time."

likeuplifting

New to trading and investing in equity. Have $200k in equity and $20k in MUNI bonds. How do you plan to diversify?

Target Date Fund or Index Fund investing for 23 y/o analyst? Which should I prioritize?

likehelpful
like
like

Any thoughts on Meta? I'm scheduling a first interview for a communications manager role.

like

Hello all

Does Airbus revise offer on sharing a counter offer?

TIA🙂

like

I know it’s a Glassdoor estimate but $120k as an EP?????? I was making that as just a P…. For a company like ABinBev I hope this is Glassdoor just predicting wrong.

Post Photo
like

Lets type in the Companies we work for with YOE!

like

Hi Guys,

I will be moving to Hyderabad soon. Can someone please tell me some good areas to live and party/hangouts?

like

How long does it take in tcs to complete the bgv? When can i know whether it is completed successfully or not?

like

Hi all. I’m looking into potentially transitioning to PE with a background in Finance Transformation consulting @KPMG of 4yrs. Do I stand a chance? Any advice on how to best approach this would be super helpful, thanks.

like

Anyone use Adobe Captivate Prime as LMS? Thought on it?

Additional Posts in The Real Estate Bowl

Has anyone used Loan Cabin to refinance? They seem to have the best rates.

like

If I’m a Real Estate Agent buying my own property, can I negotiate the Buyers Agent commission to be 0% instead of being paid the buyers commission? Essentially converting what would be Income into Cost Savings for tax purposes?

like

Hi all - any advice for a first time real estate investor looking to make their first purchase at the end of 2021.

I plan on saving $50K, for a $350-400K property in the Long Island, NY area for my first property. Does this sound reasonable? And does anyone have any experience & advice investing in the LI area?

Id like to rent it out for some positive cash flow that I can then start using to save for my 2nd property (sounds easy when I type it).

Thanks all for your input - stay safe!

like

Anyone punched out of state 4-10 unit apt building? How did you find the listing?

like

How did you get started with your personal investing in stocks? I am 26, F, have some money in savings, 401k, stocks and just started my own business albeit small. I’m extremely interested in real estate investing have been reading and listening to podcasts. Any advice?

like

Question for folks with second homes: Considering buying a vacation home but would be primarily for family use. We currently have a primary residence with a mortgage balance of ~640K, so my understanding is I could only deduct the mortgage interest on 110K of the second mortgage to stay under the 750K cap. If I were to buy the second home through an LLC, would that allow me to exceed that 750K since the expenses of the second home would be pass through expenses/income?

like

Is it okay to buy a home worth 660K for a couple earning 325K TC together? The HOA and taxes for this home bring the monthly payment up to ~4.8K which is ~32% of our monthly take home after tax…we’re first time home buyers, any advise is appreciated!

like

28 year old with ~125k in cash/brokerage. Have been wanting to begin purchasing rentals but anxious to use a good bit of my liquid savings. Thoughts on biting the bullet vs. investing in stocks. In Houston if that is a factor

like

If anyone has problems with leaks or anything facade related I work in facade restoration, preservation, rehabilitation, retrofitting in NYC. I’d be happy to discuss potential solutions.

like

Looking to move out of California, and considering buying a townhome in Atlanta for ~$650k. Any thoughts on the Atlanta real estate market?

like

Any Property Management recs in Seattle area? :(

like

I am wanting to start investing in real estate in the new year… I’m using this month to read up on it and familiarize myself with it. I am a true beginner and wanted to ask for any tips, tricks, advice, books, videos, magazines, podcasts, etc to start? Please let me know!

like

Our appraisal came through exactly as the offer price we put. Apparently by lenders 3rd party. Isnt that a bit fishy? If it came in lower our contract has the option to negotiate a bit with seller. Is lender just trying to push this along faster? I'm pretty sure in this crazy market the home is not valued at what we offered. Why would seller put a much lower asking price then? Make no sense. Please advise!

likehelpful

I'm early in my career, managed to save $30K to invest, and want to get my hands dirty with a rental property without too much risk (e.g. no HML/flipping). It sounds like that's a tall order in the NY/CT area given the prices, not to mention whether I'd be able to get a mortgage on anything below $100K, but I figure I'll give it a shot anyway. Any advice on what you might do in my position? Am I being crazy with this idea?

like

My assumption is that one makes money in RE with leverage. So, would you never let your equity in any given property get above certain% (I.e re-leverage and invest elsewhere) or would one eventually want to own a property outright?

like

From a financial standpoint in this market, which would be a better approach in Austin -

1. Buy a ~8-850k house that meets most of our ideal criteria (size, schools, interiors etc) to stay long term

2. Buy a ~5-550k house that’s not ideal with the plan of moving into an ideal home in 4-5 years when kid is ready for school.

How easy is it to get a mortgage for the second home?

Household income - 300k

Happy to add more details as needed

Thanks

My clients wish to write a testimonial/review for my RE broker services. What is the best site/medium for this? Yelp? Google Review? Zillow? Facebook?

like

Is it common for HOA to ask you to prove your car registration is up to date?

like

How long did it take you to buy your first million dollar home? What were the steps you took to get there?

My dream neighborhood is 10 min down the road but entry point is 1.2m. Currently my house is worth around $550k

like

At what income level should one be comfortable to spend 2400/mo on rent in HCOL? Assuming single, no kids, no debt or major expenses.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal