Related Posts
Anyone at MBB looking to make a referral?
Pro
MBB nyc: kellogg, booth, tuck
More Posts
My one and only
Pro
OMEGA INCREASED THEIR PRICES OH NOOOOOOOOOO
Conversation Starter
Clients are pain in the ass out here
Additional Posts in All Things MBB
Do you always need an MBA to get into MBB?
Anyone with recent experience recruiting for Boston Consulting Group? Got in touch with a recruiter through referral, was directed to submit an application and already finished my pymetrics. Anyone know when I would be able to hear back and what the hiring timeline looks like? Recruiter suggested to get back in a few weeks but isn’t it too slow? McKinsey sent me an invite for 1st interview in a few days after they received my referral.
BCG or McKinsey for consumer goods/retail?
Waiting for BCG R1 results…. 😕
Boston Consulting Group
What will the project dynamics be on a project staffed with 3mdps, a PL, and myself, a summer UG intern? Just got staffed and will be hearing more on Monday from the team, but it came across as an interesting staffing composition.
Have the feeling I'll be making quite a few slides as the only junior. Anyone staffed on a similar case composition?
What do you wish were different about your firm?
Community Builder
Anyone up to case this weekend?
New to Fishbowl?
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
I joined BCG thinking this would be a common occurrence but I find I’m more often impressed by people’s ability to grind
Yup full respect there!
Subject Expert
The brightest come in at the junior level and are gone within 1-2 years
Based on your many years of experience in this game 🤣
There are a few people I've worked with who are clearly next level in terms of intelligence. It's more apparent at the junior levels when they are just crushing complicated analysis. Once you're more senior, communications and relationships matter more
Community Builder
Different take… I’m most impressed by how humble people are. No one is in your face with their Stanford Math PhD or Neurosurgery training or whatever. They’re good at the job.
Yeah, it’s probably hard to be arrogant when you’re surrounded by tons of people with the same or better qualifications than yourself
Top schools just have a much wider variety of intelligence types, as well as variance in talent, than MBB.
You’d be hard pressed to find quantitative savants or literary geniuses at MBB like you would at HYP, but the avg MBB consultant is better with conceptual processing ability, logical reasoning, communication and real world common sense than the avg HYP student.
Subject Expert
Excellent description. The MBB hiring process is a lot more meritocratic than the HYP-type admissions process, so you get a really high minimum and average standard.
Subject Expert
Nah. Everyone is pretty smart but not too many stand out in that sort of way. And frankly, there aren’t too many opportunities in consulting where that next level intelligence could even shine (modelling doesn’t take a math PhD to figure out).
The truly most intelligent in society aren’t doing consulting. If they do accidentally end up at MBB via some tragic misstep, they bounce within the first two years.
Aside: I had a math / CS prof in undergrad went to MBB after his PhD at a top school (think Harvard/MIT/Stanford). He bounced after 1 year and went back to academic life because the work was so menial for him.
I have a PhD in astrophysics, and bounced from MBB after one year 😂 consulting was invaluable, I learned how to be 80/20 and actually get things done besides theoretical research papers. That said, not intellectually stimulating and did not challenge me that way. This is not to say it wasn’t challenging in other ways, I wasn’t better at the job than anyone else. Some things were significantly more difficult for me than my peers (client, slides, being 80/20, knowing when to escalate)
A few people I’ve been impressed by. But what impressed me was that they always knew how to get to an answer. It’s not like they had an answer to everything which is what I though being “smart” was for the longest time.
Not really - I am also not from top school and rather came in as an EH - there’s alot of smart people here but no one’s that’s been like damn but tbh the skills that makes a good manager and a consultant are very different than doing well at school imo - truthfully after a certain point of intelligence it’s rather your EQ that’s gets your further
Not impressed by my peers, but some of the Partners I worked with are extremely smart. Back in school, the people I’m impressed with the most are all doing their PhDs now. It’s a completely different level of intellectual capacity.
Eh, not really
Met a handful who were really sharp and noticeably more so than me or anyone else, but the people who made me go “holy sh*t” were all in college and doing better things
Don’t know about BB but here it’s on a somewhat regular basis I’d say
Subject Expert
English is hard 😂
Def, there are a few BAs/EMs/APs/Partners that have absolutely blown me away. The only common theme, oddly enough, is that every one of them has a collegiate debate background with at least one stem major (and so just seems extremely good at everything - analytics, conceptual problem solving, articulating themselves, rhetoric, etc)
Not really. Also not from a top school in any way shape or form. I’m an experienced hire in EMEA.
People are very good at their job, clearly. But that comes with experience, so that’s what I expect to find. No one is otherwise more insightful than they ought to be or brighter / quicker to make connections / understand things than the standard in this industry.
What surprised me most was indeed the grind and speed. That took me a minute to get used to, and that was impressive to me.
My ability to make 1+1=3 is quite famous
Subject Expert
My supervisor is crazy smart and AP managed teams very well - been impressed so far
Smart as in intelligent? Not really, the smartest people on Earth are probably smart enough to avoid MBB.
Smart as a mix of intelligent + knowledgeable + experienced? Definitely.
Definitely. There are people that I am blown away by all the time.
50% of people I work with are really smart , another 25% are ridiculously smart like ceo material with grind , remaining 25% are average smart like me lol … take heart - you can make it here , just need some luck
I haven’t met any that stood out. What’s most impressive is the abundance of smart people. Also, the people who really stand out are those who did cool sh*t like placed in the Olympics, fighter pilots, etc.
I’m most impressed by people management skills. Eg., partners ability to manage boisterous or difficult clients in a full meeting gracefully