My state is moving towards removing the 150 credit hour requirement for CPA licensure. Personally, I think removing the education requirement is ridiculous and will not resolve the pipeline issue. There are more substantial and serious issues that keep people from becoming and staying a CPA. #1 Pay as a tax accountant, I see what people make - yes, there are jobs that pay less, but there are so many other jobs that pay much more for much less work which ties into #2 Work-Life Balance.

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

You have to understand the AICPA first of all. They are a lobbying group for the partners of the firms not the staff-SMs. Secondly they’ve been diminishing the value of our credential by allowing non US people, talking about Philippines and soon probably India, to receive the US designation. Why, because they want continue to have cheap labor. They don’t want to fix the salary issue that accounting no longer competes with other career paths. If accountants stopped bidding their work to the bottom just to win the work rather than putting an actual value in it then maybe everyone could eat. The low level would make more and so could the partners. But people won’t do that unfortunately.

likehelpful

The problem that I'm not sure can be remedied is that you'll always have people who can ace an exam, but lack the understanding of the issue. I had a classmate who was also a former co-worker who graduated with top honors in accounting. However, when a group of us would get together and 'talk shop' she wasn't able to add to the conversation, she was puzzled and would ask questions. I've seen that more times than I could mention. I agree, lowering the the 150 won't help.

like

Removing the extra credits it’s a great idea. I got my extra credits on online community basket weaving classes. Absolutely nothing to do with accounting.

likefunny

Exactly! No one was going to sell me a masters in accounting that I would never use.

Recent IconRecent

I have 34 years experience as a tax accountant and CPA. The 150 hour requirement for CPA licensure is a waste of time. I guarantee you I have much more experience and knowledge than most CPAs and only took 120 hours of credits in college. Knowledge is gained on the job, not in the classroom.

likesmarthelpful

The biggest barrier to entry is the $390 exam fee. 4x is almost $1,600 they should lower the fee

likefunny

A1, that’s awesome I wish my firms did that! My first firm only paid for passing exams! My 2nd firm would pay for 1 pass OR 1 fail, not both :/

Sure it’ll help with pipeline. By lowering the bar and barriers to entry, the bookkeepers and AP clerks of today will be the new CPA’s of tomorrow!

like

You think your masters in accounting is valuable or sets the bar high for a CPA? I took the minimum number of classes needed to sit for the exams and took a bunch of bs classes at community college to get to 150. Not having a masters or taking less than 150 credits doesn’t make you less smart.

like

The state requested feedback on their public forum board -- Haha, like I'd want to publicly state that public accounting (ie. my firm) sucks and we need better pay and better work-life balance in a place that everyone above me will not only see, but get an email notification

likesmart

Great input, bud

like

Removing the 150 doesn’t lower the bar. A masters degree doesn’t make someone more qualified and someone without a masters. I work with partners who don’t have masters degrees, and I don’t have one, so I don’t think it hurts to remove it, but like you’ve said, there are broader issues than barriers to entry.

like

@OP I've trained new hires with and without master's degrees and there is very rarely any difference in how little they know. I always ask them things like if they can tell me what a withholding is to gauge their knowledge before I train them, and so far only one intern was able to answer correctly, if at all.

like

I have never given much credence to the things you are considering important. Thankfully, I hope this country is headed back towards common sense.

I did my internship under a CPA who didn't go to college. He was self educated and passed the exam before credits were a requirement. I'm thankful for that. He was one of my three greatest mentors. You couldn't get anything past him.

My first real job in business I worked for a self-made millionaire. He started building model homes with a couple of buddies right out of high school. By the time I went to work for him, he was a real estate mogul, owner of an amusement park, Sat on the board at a large bank and was friends with the Governor. The second of my great mentors.

The third was less "formally educated" than the first two. He was my father. A man who, in 1929, dropped out of 8th grade to raise his younger siblings after losing his parents to yellow fever. He will always remain the smartest man I have ever known.

CCollege credits will never replace intelligence or common sense. I have been appalled at some of the CPAs I have encountered over the past few years.

As far as the AICPA goes, they don't care about you or this industry. They hhave been selling you out to businesses like Intuit for years.



like

I didn’t know about the designation of Filipinos to US CPAs. I am for removing the 150 hours requirement. It was in place to make the accounting profession more “exclusive” to those that could afford an extra year of school. It’s not the solution but one step. The good thing about tax though is that you can start your own practice much easier than other accounting professions.

like

Why would they need to increase the amount of classes? I took the minimum classes needed to sit for the exams and then took a bunch of bs classes at community college to get to 150. The masters in accounting and/or additional accounting classes isn’t needed.

like

I think the hours reductions is a good thing. And I agree with you in that I think the impact will be minor on imporveing the pipeline.

I took so many filler classes to get to the hours requirement. Stuff like nutrition, geology and bowling. All interesting and fun classes. But they are doing me almost zero benefits with my tax specialty.

My nephew is getting an accounting degree. I told him to go into finance. He was split between the two and I honestly believe it is the better career track right now.

like

Pay needs to increase for starting salaries but what people always leave out is the stability of the profession. If you are decent at your job, there are always positions available. That’s not the case in tech, marketing, etc. There’s value in having a stable job regardless of market ebbs and flows

like

Well go get one of those so many other jobs that pay much more (both in the short term and long term) for much less work.

like

I'm in a LCOL area. Albeit, in a specialty tax area but, new associates make at least $65k, high-performing senior associates can make approximately 100k. That to me is fantastic pay for the area and no CPA, 4 yrs of experience. As a senior manager in the LCOL with 9yrs experience I'm pushing 200k. The compensation in our industry doesnt seem to be a problem. The wage growth is fast in our industry if you're a high-performer.

like

Removing the credential waters down the cert and puts downward pressure on comp. It accomplishes the exact opposite of solving the shortage of CPAs and addressing the root cause.

like

Yes, doing anything to make a credential easier to get devalues it.

like

I wonder how that will affect reciprocity with other states?

like

IF the candidate can pass ALL the CPA sections so what. How many of the candidates come with 150 + hours and Masters degrees and retake the sections over and over? I dare say that so many newly minted CPA’s can’t do any fundamental bookkeeping, audit or tax.

Personally IF someone has learned on the job, studied their a$$e$ off to pass, I’d hire them in a hot minute without the 150 hours.

like

Work is life that’s the balance. Plus, money is just enough not to starve.

Removing the requirement is absolutely not ridiculous. It was ridiculous when they began implementing it many years ago. They didn’t require that you fulfill those extra credits by taking accounting or business level classes. Those extra credits could all be fluff electives. All it did was put people more in unnecessary college debt. If people did go the masters route it would be for something like MACC or MBA which really don’t mean much in our profession. At least on the tax side it doesn’t, they’d rather see a masters in tax which isn’t want people were going for.

I can’t wait for the requirements to change. Saves me a masters degree cost or random community college classes that would eat up time/money.

Personally, I think that the 150 credit hour requirement for CPA licensure should be lowered to 120. But I don't think that it should be totally removed. While the education requirement seems to be an initial barrier, I agree that pay and work-life balance are also major issues.

I agree that it won't help the problem. They act like the extra 30 credits is a huge barrier to entry but you could literally take a couple more community college classes to get them. The talent issue deals with pay, image, and work life balance for sure.

Thirty credits is an additional year of college. That is not insignificant In time or cost. I retired after 28 years in the profession and only had to have 120 credits to be a CPA. The people after me that had the extra 30 credits were no more successful than me. Im all for reducing the requirement to 120.

like

Related Posts

Are we allowed to trade crypto on TD Ameritrade?

like

What is the positional hierarchy in Risk CCB - fraud risk strategy at JPMC.
What should be the YOE for senior associate?

I have cleared CTS interview and have asked for 21lpa with 6 yoe in automation testing. Do they give that much with the yoe I have ?

like

What do u prefer

Post Photo
helpfullike

The “Pour one out for the L train” ads by Kombucha are part of the problem... cont

like

Gyms - anyone back at them? I’m going to upgrade from my COVID-time small gym near house to big one back downtown. So excited to be back at lifting fully.

like

When it comes to therapy do I look up a place online and make an appointment or do I need some sort of referral? Not sure if I need to see a therapist or physiatrist really.

like

Did you/would you get booster during pregnancy?

like

Hey you guys! can somebody please help me answer these questions!

1. WonderWorks wants to increase hospitality sales by 25% in the next year. What are some sales and marketing strategies you would use to increase sales with our corporate partners? Outline a variety of paid and organic tactics you would use, indicating any potential costs that may accrue in your plan.

like

Partner told me that they will give me an offer with Deloitte ARA. Does anyone have any experience with the group. Hours, type of assignments, travel, pay etc?

like

What does a 30% travel requirement mean in a job description? How often do they expect the candidate to travel ?

like
like

Hi, I did interview with amazon.

Round 1: HR round. cleared.

Round 2: Hiring manager round. Went well.

After 2 weeks they said Role no longer available. It was L5 supply chain role. This happened in April. Can I apply again in Amazon? I joined a company 3 months ago, does it look bad in CV to leave again in 3 months? I hv a 6 month gap in career in 2019 due to lay off (covid). total exp 9 yrs. SCM exp 6 yrs.

like

Hello Everyone,
I am a fresher with over 9+ months of experience as a Data Engineer at
Tata Consultancy .

I just needed some suggestions from you experienced folks.🙏

In my current project my colleagues have over 6+ years of experience and are not very supportive and scold me for unnecessary reasons, which is effecting my mental health.😔
Also I am not getting to learn anything.

Continued 👇

like

Looking for job change.
Preferably profile related to Consumer insights

like

Hi Fishes, It will be highly appreciated if anyone reffer me at Capgemini for Informatica IDQ role. YOE- 5. I'm Serving Notice period 40 days to go. I'm looking to grab that opportunity if I complete all the process. Thank you!Capgemini Hexaware Technologies Publicis Sapient Persistent Systems Limited Virtusa

Any suggestions on SPG/Marriott hotels in Barcelona for personal travel?

like
like

Additional Posts in Accounting

About to put in my 2 weeks next Monday, what should I be aware of?

like

Looking for a good personal finance or similar book to read. Any suggestions?

like

Just wondering what percentage of associates don't get promoted to senior? Anyone has the stats?

like

Does insurance cover vision and dental?

like

Accounting manager 5-6 years out of school salary+bonus range in NYC? Is 140k all in a good salary?

like

If my recon doesn't add up, can I blame Russia?

like

I’m looking to exit B4 audit to transfer to B4 FDD/TAS. Has anyone made this move? Advice for interviews? I am not a CPA, however would consider pursuing my CFA. Is there a license requirement to make manager at the B4?

like

Me: Hi, can I please get a report of (insert report name here)?
Individual: *sends screenshot*
Me: This is great! Can you please send to me the report?
Individual: *sends screenshot of another report*
Me: You know what, never mind! *copies and pastes screenshots into word document and adds to the audit file* Done!

like

What are your thoughts of getting CIA instead of CPA? Does it look bad/looked down upon?

like

Has anyone worked for an accounting advisory (technical accounting) practice and FDD? Which did you like better and why?

I'm in an AAS practice but wonder if I'd like FDD more.

like

So would you say Andy from Shawshank redemption was a Banker? Seems to me that the service he provided was more of a CPA.

likefunny

Y'all leaving upper deckers in the toilet stalls need re-examine your life. How can it be so tricky to hit a12inch hole while sitting down? Bathroom is out of commission thanks to a serial squatter.

like

Is $170k as M3 FSO Advisory NYC EY at par with other Big 4 firms?

like

Anyone ever quit big four and apply to the same one successfully to expedite the transfer process?

like

Hi everyone, I’m looking for some clarification. This may be obvious and I might not need to ask, but what is the difference between senior managers and managers? Apart from seniority. I’m trying to understand the dynamic of how senior managers are in closer contact with staff than managers. Or maybe I have the wrong idea...

like

Has anybody performed a walkthrough for entity level controls? How can I prepare for this? What do I expect?

like

For auditors with 4-6 YOE leaving PA to industry for entry level accounting manager role, what questions would be asked for interview? And how would you respond to questions like you have no accounting but just auditing experience before

like

Hi everyone! Please DM me if anyone is interested in joining BDO. Thank you in advance! :)

funnylike

Best tips to manage another person that's on the same level as you, but knows everything about the client and you don't - since you are the new guy.

like

Are finger tattoos acceptable at work? Really want to get some before return to office

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal