Offer 1: can live anywhere I want, remote role, love the role and industry. 210k comp

Offer 2: based in NYC (I hate living here), hate the industry, would be very good at the job and it is a senior role with crazy visibility, would work for my mentor who has always been a huge advocate and is a rockstar himself. 300k comp

Which would you choose...

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Sounds like you’d be happier in 1. If you’re happier you will progress faster.

like

I would go for option 2 and reasons why:

1) you are working with your mentor and have a supporter - not many people get that opportunity
2) this role at $300k can turn to $400-500k in 2-3 years or less within the current firm or another firm
3) working remote 100% will impact your career growth
4) I don’t see 100% remote work go beyond the next 12 months. Perhaps some hybrid option, but let’s see. I have heard clients and companies in NYC want people back in the office at least 3 days a week.

End of day is what you want. If you want balance and work remote you go for option 1. If you want to grow and excel in your career then option 2.

likesmarthelpfulfunny

Freakin baby boomers should just retire. Remote work is the future.

like
Recent IconRecent

What company pays 300k for associate consultant

like

EM 7 YOE

like

Heard of the “toss the coin” test? Remember it’s what you wish for when the coin is in the air

like

I would definitely take the remote job. $300k in NYC isnt that good, and you hate the work, the industry, and the city. I disagree with the thought process of not being able to grow your career from 100% remote work. Plenty of people have grown their careers over the last year.

like

Lol $300K anywhere is very good money.

like

A large salary can sometimes blind us or make us see unclearly in a situation like this: lets be clear: making $210k, with the ability to live anywhere, and the benefit of seeing your family everyday WHILE avoiding the intricacies, logistics, and stress of living in NYC (did it, overrated) is a wonderful opportunity and better for your overall mental health.

like

#1 definitely for me. Stay in touch with mentor.

like

Fully remote US or anywhere?

Seems like th NYC role has better long term up side

like

If your goal is to live somewhere with super low cost of living and is aligned with your goals will come out ahead over NYC. You just need some deep soul searching and a pros cons list to help sort out what you really want/prioritize.

Offer #1 and move to Texas

As a Texan, only move here if you don’t mind extended power outages twice a year since that’s apparently now normal for us.

offer 1 easy

The 300K comp factors is a HCOL. It’s not only about what you make, it’s what you’re able to save as well.

Age yoe? Congratulations

Offer 1: work life balance, more time with your family, and industry you love

Offer 2: accelerated growth and comp

Tough decision! Depends on what you value more at the moment

Offer 1. Stay in touch with mentor (leaving doesn’t mean losing the relationships, it means learning to leverage them.)

Option 1 no doubt; at times money isn’t everything. Happiness and enjoyment is muc more worthy especially if you are sitting at 200k you should fine

It would be #1 for me. I think you have to take all information and make the best decision for yourself. Everyone weights these bits different. Some care more about comp, some care more about flexibility, family time, location, you name it. Sounds like you have 2 great choices, but you did have something negative to say about #2

Never leave that amount of money on the table unless you come from generational wealth, or have a safety net. After you’ve been at the 300k job for a few months 1 year start looking for your exit and get on par with the 300k salary.

Offer 1

More specific on each industry?

Offer 1: healthcare/retail

Offer 2: insurance (p&c, life & retirement, etc.)

Offer 1 - choose personal happiness and daily joy. Work to live not live to work.

Take offer 2. Easy to eventually move/be remote once you prove yourself. Not easy to find/get everything else you like about #2. Also easy to find #1, especially if moving from NYC while retaining the job becomes a challenege.

Congrats on two great offers.

Related Posts

Any insights into negotiating a full time salary in tech sales? Do I need competing offers to do so?

like

Emtec I am switching from automation engineer (python) to bigdata. 8 yoe and current ctc 13L. Got an offer from emtec inc for 18L. What kind of clients do they have? Should i accept the offer? Dont have any other offer yet but final round in 2 more service based companies.

like

Hello fishes,
I need referral for a role at @CommonWealth Bank of Australia
Can anyone help me out ?

like
likehelpful

Are MBB furiously hiring in Australia/Singapore like the Big 4?

like

What are you all reading other than maternity help books? Any book recommendations for after baby is born? Mainly around how to keep the baby safe from injuries and incidents.

like

Looking for work from home or remote opportunities from companies based in UK/USA/ Australia/Singapore.
I am based out of India and willing to work at the corresponding work hours of the companies hiring me.
Am from accounts, finance, tax and audit background.
Please help me look up the same!

Thanking you all in anticipation.

like

Can anyone please refer me for below role
Job id 22509019

Is MGMA datadive access worth the cost for salary negotiation info?

like

How much is the shift allowance for US or UK shift????

What is that starting salary of Manager in KPMG INDIA for 11 yoe.

like

Hi All received retain offer from tcs same as PwC India any suggestions what I should do.CTC offered 6.5.TCS HR saying will share breakdown of salary post resignation withdrawal

like

Does Blockchain really have a future? What will be the role of QA Engineers in this technology and how we can be master and get ready if we want to get into this specialization...

Hello Experienced fishes,

Help me with career path.
Wasted 3 years of my life as Sports Analyst with 3 LPA HUDL india.

Currently working as Tester Engineer with 1.3 YOE and 7.5 LPA

I have completed Course Certification for Business Analyst but im unable to land a Job as I have no Experience as a Business Analyst.

Shall I go ahead as a Tester only if yes what skills shall I pursue?
My current company is in Game development and My job isnt that great...

Help and reference is appreciated

like

Hi Fishes

I got offer from 2 companies as QA engg (7.8 years exp). All with same packages with 1 or 2 lakhs difference

Accion Technogies
StoneX

I want to know which company to go for.. And has anyone heard of StoneX company? is it a good company?

like

Recently got laid off in the middle of my search for an exit from consulting. Will this come up in background checks? If so, how do I address if it’s brought up?

likehelpful

Anyone need referral from Deloitte, ping me

likeupliftinghelpful

Hello guys,

How is VOIS as a company in terms of wlb, career growth,hikes, job security , etc ?

Anyone in TCS having qva as 21000??
How much amount u received in latest quater end?

like

More Posts

like

I’m looking to expand my portfolio with some spec work. Any designers out there wanting to collaborate? 👊🏼

How do find a recruiter in the legal field? Have been looking for a job for a year now and trying to transition into another practice area. Applied to more than 20 jobs and still no offers. I feel like I might need some help.
Also, I have no idea how these arrangements work. Do you pay the recruiter to look for the jobs or do you pay them when you get the job? Or does the employer pay them?

like

Anyone got a six figure base as an AE? Hunting around for companies with 6-fig base and similar commission. Seems to be mostly field / enterprise pay.

like

Has anyone gone to HR due to an unprofessional manager? What was the situation and what did HR actually do?

likehelpfulsmartfunny

Dear Fishes,

Could someone let me know which is better to join IBM or deloitte USI both are offering same package?
Experience: 3.10 years
Role: Automation testing with selenium and Java

like

Does anyone feel overwhelmed from all the data they have to format?

like

The lack of honesty in this industry saddens me. Dear CDs and ECDs, if you're gonna put work in your book that you barely touched/had nothing to do with, at least credit those who came up with it.

like

Recommendations for a great L&E big law recruiter in NYC?

like

What do you do for outside the box client appreciation events?

like

I went for 3 interviews with a company met with vp and was given package thinking I aced interview there was another candidate 😞 the other person for the job. The VP calls me to tell me I didn’t get position however he wants me to re apply in new year that something else will be open, and that he wanted to keep a copy of my resume what does this mean ? Should I apply again in new year or don’t bother ?

like

For referal in Amazon, DM your profile

like

Anyone ever had a problem with not being paid for freelance work? And what did you do?
Is it worth it getting a lawyer?

like

Remember The Woo? Yeah, me neither. Well, they cut everyone’s pay (except mgmt of course) by 1/4 to get the small biz gov loan, and used it to hire a $500k/yr mgmt head. Agency still working barebones

like

I have got an offer from Wipro . Designation is tech lead and band is B3 . My joining is on may 26. Am I eligible for upcoming appraisal cycle ? Band b3 is good ?

like

Does anyone know the salary band for clinical program consultant at United Health Group? What is the typical bonus associated with this role?

like

Does anyone know the average salary for an Ultrasound Technologist in Connecticut? Also any specific companies that may pay more than others? I recently moved from NY to CT and bought a house. 2 years of experience. Is it possible to make close to $50/hr? If so how long will this take?

like

How's working for analytics at Gartner ? What all perks do Gartner provide?
Is it good to move from analytics division of Boston Consulting Group (Gamma) to Gartner ?

like

Why would a prior audit firm want to reissue their report if it’s not required? Seems like a lot of unnecessary steps that the prior auditor isn’t getting comped for..?

[Facebook Ads Data VS Google Analytics Data] 🤯

How can I merge FB and GA data? Some clients of mine believe that Facebook doesn't bring us results 'cause GA says so. The difference between the two of them is A LOT. Facebook says we have 100 conversions and GA only reports 2. How can I prove to them that Facebook does its job? What data can I show?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting Exit Opportunities

What would be examples of cushy industry jobs with good wlb with 200-300k pay check in finance industry? My work is mostly FS so it seems to make sense that I exit in that direction, but I keep hearing that finance in general is less chill than normal corporate sector jobs. Or is that just for IB/PE/HF?

I would gladly take a head of local bank branch or something as the culmination of my career but I fear that dream is too 1950s

likehelpful

Has anyone moved from consulting to investor relations? Are you happy with the decision? I have a chance to join a RE Fund in NY for IR, and it is very appealing to me, but I have heard mixed reviews about IR.

like

Would love to hear your best tips for negotiating an offer / what worked for you

like

Thoughts on whether it’s ok to take an Excel assessment being sent to my personal email on my work laptop? personal laptop is a Mac and I know none of the shortcuts

like

I’m in Oracle Utilities functional design/implementation consulting. Anyone have any leads for opportunities in Toronto?
Interested in ACN or D Oracle practice.

like

How are you able to make time for interviews when working in a demanding consulting project?

like

What are the best skills I can teach myself to optimize my odds of a good exit in Corporate Strategy? Thinking about learning SQL and Tableau to start but wondering if there’s a better way to use my time

like

Does a glassdoor review like below means it was written by HR team?

Post Photo
likefunny

Any insights into what job level code ‘M’ at Abbvie might equate to in more standard terminology? Looking at a role there.

like

I've become really jaded about consulting. I find all so often you need to tell the client what they want to hear to keep their business and I feel like so much of the what I recommend doesn't actually get implemented. I'm looking to make a career switch so I can both create and execute on my strategies. A product management path seems very promising for this.

Does anyone who switched from consulting to product management have any recommendations of h helpful PM books, courses, or programs?

like

Got an assignment to be completed as initial screening step. Spent a weekend and provided the best possible solution. Recruiter and hiring manager did not even respond back with any feedback. Height of arrogance.

like

Almost 2 YOE and up for SC promotion. Is it a downgrade to jump to an associate product manager position?

like

Comp check: could anyone share insights on what they think comp would be (base + bonus) for a NYC associate investor role at a family office that operates like a MM PE fund? Cool portcos, small team, role involves sourcing and working with portcos

like

First year (ug level hire) and got email from apple recruiter. Would love to exit to FAANG but not sure I'm ready to leave BCG in my first year but maybe after 2-4. What is best practice?

like

I have my first panel interview, how is it different compared to a 1:1? Would you say questions are harder?

like

Corp dev associate role at F100 with an all in comp of 90k….. I have 3 YOE and am pretty torn here. Work would be interesting, lifestyle would be 10x better. Any thoughts here?

like

Received an offer as Engagement Director from Salesforce (CSG, pre sales, L9). Great benefits package, 40% increase in total comp and better WLB.

I do love the people in my practice and current client, but career trajectory has stalled after taking parental leave earlier this year and (yet another) change in leadership.

Realistically, making to Director is 2-3 years away and will require sacrificing time with my family that I am not prepared to give up.

Should I stay or should I go?

like

Recently got laid off in the middle of my search for an exit from consulting. Will this come up in background checks? If so, how do I address if it’s brought up?

likehelpful

For Series C companies, more normal to get more base or more RSUs? Assume equity is the more attractive form of comp if you believe in the company and vice versa.

like

Have you ever taken a counter offer? How did that go for you? Just turned my notice in and my boss (who is great) instantly said she wants to counter.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal