Recently received offer for trader position at a small prop trading firm (think flow trader, wolverines and Belvedere), and an entry level position at MBB.
Which one would you choose and why? (The trader position make 60k more than MBB for the first year)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

If you’re good at math and trading you’d be closer to 7 figures than anyone commenting here lol

You can join MBB anytime in the next decade, I don’t think trading shop opportunities come around that often. As McK said, do what you are interested in. I assume you wouldn’t have got that trading job unless you wanted it, so sounds like that’s what you should consider

like

Decide based on the work you want to do.

Run a business? Or trading?

Wildly different

like

Traders don't get to move into anything outside of trading easily.
MBB opens doors to nearly every industry.

I would suggest doing MBB first and then trying trading.

I have done both and can tell you that optionality and strong branding are worth a lot.

Mbb. The name alone can open doors. Def will feel the weight of the 60k not being in your pockets but you’ll most likely put pace that w/n ~3 years if that

like

Thank you PWC1

Trading 100%

I'd try trading first, as those roles seem harder to come by. If you don't like it, you can always hit the MBA reset button to try something else (including mbb) if the narrow exits are not palatable.

If you want to be rich, go for the prop shop. You'll be making more than all the consultants at MBB on here in 5 years.

Related Posts

What will be the hike percentage in Infosys for JL5 meet expectations.

like

BAs that started in 2014...what did you make as a 2nd year BA if you got a 3 your first year?

SAP Mega Drive on 12th Nov in LTI- Larsen and Toubro Infotech.
DM your Emailid along with Jobcode to Apply!!
All LTI Locations!!
#SAP #HIRING #Opportunity #Opening

Post Photo

Is hiring going strong these days in MBB? I will be interviewing soon with Boston Consulting Group, McKinsey & Company, Bain & Company

Any ME fish willing to share insights?

like
like

I’m curious. What would you say is the best industry / sector for…1. WLB, 2. Great people / team, 3. Exit opp’s., and 4. Overall (mix of the above). Goes without saying the obvious “it depends on office, team, project, client, etc.” So this is an ask for general observations.

like

Rate my offer for a business valuations associate role at a boutique firm in Toronto:
- $90k + ~7.5% annual performance bonus
- $5k in clawback reimbursement
- will pay all professional fees throughout term of employment (CPA & CBV)

My background:
- SA1 in assurance
- Master of Accounting
- passed CFE, qualify in about half a year
- enrolled in CBV program of studies
- 24 yrs old

like

Does anyone know when QE (or other firms ending their fiscal year in October) pay out bonuses? Need to know how long I have to do this until I can quit.

likefunny
like

Is anyone hiring in healthcare/biotech for marketing/strategy roles? Have ~2 YOE at top medical device companies

like

Are the recent economic troubles translating to slower hiring or lower salaries in life sciences industry? I want to transition to industry this year but am worried it may not be the best time to.

like

Hi,
Looking to find out realistic salary of VP's in technical roles at Barcalys in London area. I've been working at Barcalys for 7 years in Infrastructure engineering roles , I feel like I am getting underpaid, I have no realistic reference since this is my first fulltime job.

Anyone have a full-time Big 4 offer (JD/LLM) with a signing bonus in Dallas or similar COL? My recruiter says it’s not negotiable but if I know of someone from a competitor with a higher bonus then she can see what she can do.

like

What is your opinion on online assessments as part of the hiring process?

like

What do you all think is the upper limit range for someone in an account manager role at a tech firm? What’s the career path? Was there anything you’ve done in terms of upskilling that resulted in increased pay? Or should I just pick something else if I want to be making more than what I make atm ~150k TC with 6 years exp.

like

Hi fishes,

Could you please let me know how much expected salary I can ask for as I have 4.6 years of experience in manual testing?
Please enlist expected salary details as per market standards:
1)If I show as 4.5 years exp in manual testing -how much I can expect?
2)2 years manual and 2 years automation.
3)3 years manual and 1.6 years in automation.

My current package is 5.2lpa.
This will be my first switch.

Thanks for all your kind suggestions in advance.

like

Current CTC - 6L. Accenture has offered 10.4 with 60k joining bonus. Designation - Sr Analyst. Is this too low? I have 4 yoe

like

If we’re not likely to break even with our base this year, independent of BU, does it make sense to leave now for +30-50% total comp vs biting the bullet and waiting for next year? Been here for a little less than a year and failed to negotiate a first full year assured bonus, just had a partial year bonus in 11/21
Some people are saying that’s just the way it is and to wait it out 1-2 years and network more, others are saying otherwise. Would appreciate some perspectives… US Director level

like

Hi Fishes,
Anyone needs referral in Infosys please DM me.
We have openings for Java Developer, .NET developer, DevoOps consultant, React JS developer, AWS developer, Azure developer. Feel free to contact.

like

I have cleared all the round of Amazon DE How much I should ask ? My YOE is 3 year and I am holding offers around 23 lpa (22 Base) Amazon

like

More Posts

Friend of mine are looking to move to the city in March around LES & East Village areas. Anyone think prices will continue to drop as we search in early Jan-Feb? Any tips for our 1st hunt in NYC?

like

any suggestions on where to rent? preferably manhattan downtown or midtown. budget is ~2.1k or so. priorities are having a doorman, elevator, laundry in building at the very least

like

For the NJ folks who work in NYC - my potential new employer has offices in both NJ and NYC. The NJ office is a 1.5 hour drive vs. NYC ~40 min commute via train. Still very much hybrid work arrangement. Given the option, which office would you prefer to be based out of and why? Mostly asking from a tax perspective. While I believe it’ll even out when filing, I’d be paying state tax in both states throughout the year, right?

like

Hi guys,

I have my joining in
Capgemini tomorrow but I still haven't received my Resignation Acceptance Letter from my previous organization will receive the same on Monday. Will there be an issue while bgv tomorrow?

like

Hey Fishes

I have asked for location transfer recently, can anyone help me approx when it'll be completed? How much time?

like

For the past few months of interviewing have made it to the final round with a few firms, and the feedback is similar, ‘I’m a great candidate, but it’s not the right time’ Is this code for something? Am I missing something?

like

Got 6 lakh jump in HCL with technical specialist role ? wanted to know how HCL is doing with regards to SAP projects? I heard it has more Support Projects, is it true? I see variable pay is 4.4 lacs how this works? I heard they use some application to monitor resources hours in front of laptop? is this seriously monitored? Once resources completes all his deliverables being 9 hours infront of laptop is still mandatory?

like

Looking for a REMOTE Paralegal Position in the Colorado Springs, CO area - preferably in Family or Criminal Law - If anyone knows of anything. If someone knows of a recruiter in that area as well, please let me know!
TIA!

like

Have a great weekend Paralegals ✌️

Post Photo
like

Can folks share their experiences of working during 2nd and 3rd trimesters? How hard was it? What accommodations or adjustments did you make? I’m only in my 1st trimester now but will be starting a new job in October (4 months before my due date) and am nervous about not being able to be at my best

Orally accepted a job offer that I’m excited about, but have another interview this week for a different job. I didn’t realize the first offer would come so quickly! Should I cancel the interview this week or go through with it? Small legal community- people talk.

like

At what stage were you guys able to buy a house? How much did you have down and how much was the house overall?

like
like

How many days E&Y takes in general to release offer? My last discussion with the HR was on 06th Oct, no further communication or discussion initiated for negotiation.

like

What’s the salary for experienced analyst in the Deloitte digital group in Chicago?

like

Good mornings! Does anyone have any Insight on Latham & Watkins culture in NYC?

like

Hi Fishes,

Does anyone know about TCS Digitate? Can you share some reviews about it?

Thanks!

like

How is the annual hike percentage in Natwest group RBS for B7 designation?

like

If anyone knows of any good fully remote LMS prospects, please let me know since I'm looking now. Thanks in advance. I have 13 years experience.

like

I feel like I was straight up lied to during the interview process. “lots of opportunities to hit quota”. I’m sitting here with only one demo two months after joining the company. it looks like our team has only two people doing demos, and demos are only happening once every two weeks. At this rate, I don’t think I’ll be even close to hitting OTE. Are there any other companies hiring right now? I’ll have a discussion about my concerns with my manager soon, but there’s too many red flags here.

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

These people speaking at RNC either truly believe that DT could be a good president or they are attention/power whores. Both despicable.

like

Do any strategy arms of Big 4 or MBB do pre-MBA internships?

like

Any Freemasons lurking around here!? Thinking about making a Bowl for my Traveling Brothers. Maybe to talk about how we view this unique Labor (consulting) in a Masonic context, post some inspirational messages, recommend good books, idk stuff like that...

like

Any book recommendations for the summer vacation season? What's your favorite book over the last year?

like

Do you guys think that post pandemic consulting travel will return to how it was (Monday-Thursday)?

likefunny

Entering my 15th week unstaffed for the year. Does Deloitte do layoffs for low utilization? Mine is around 60%

like

Can we go back to desperate hookup posts now?

like

Planning on a weekend road trip/get-away on Nov 18th weekend starting from DC with my SO. Planning on driving south and seeing shit. Any suggestions?

like

What is the tuition reimbursement benefit like at your company? I’m in Accenture Operation and there’s no such benefits. (Only strategy and CDO have it). Is it typical?

like
like

Death in the fam Mon., car oil pan broke yest., rock cracks windshield today. All I had to look forward to today was some chocolate and it just melted IN MY POCKET. Bring it Karma, you motherfucker...

like

If I just chill on the bench for long will I still only get fired at the end of the year?

like

Know this may be a long shot in terms of actual responses but:
@PPMDs, what are your thoughts on the current/impending COVID specific layoffs at your firm?

E.G. Glad for the opportunity to reduce the headcount of mid performing SMs with little/no chance of making PPMD? Sad to see a firm you’re a part of undergo such unforeseen circumstances?

like

Got the Go decision today. Makes working over thanksgiving worth it! 🎉🙏🏻🙌🏻

like

Best consulting firms for PE work (CDD,Value Creation)? Looking for the best firm for exit ops to PE ops eventually. Thanks!

like

Has anyone here been offered a job in consulting without applying for it? What do you believe led to you receiving the offer?

like

CFA or CAIA?

Has anyone heard of the Practice Area Project Manager at BCG (kinda internal role)? Pros & Cons? In terms of career projection, posibility to jumping to consulting, WLB, exit opportunities...

like

I got an email from a Cybersecurity Advisory Partner with the subject "Catch-up". Last week we all rolled-off from project abruptly b/c the client terminated the contract. Am I getting laid off?

like

Do you have to return the sign on bonus if you get laid off, sign on period (2 years) has not yet passed. I would also like to know the firm's severance policy.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal