Recruiters, is it a red flag if a potential candidate’s previous job experience is as follows:
Job 1: 1.5 years
Job 2: 2.5 years
Job 3: 2.5 years

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

You are fine..chill

like

This is excellent actually. Don't listen to boomers who say 3-5 years in every role. This isn't 1987 anymore.

likefunny

Lmao we don’t believe the grass is greener, it literally is, we get paid to leave. Want us to stick around? Put your money where your mouth is. Otherwise sit down 🪑

Companies aren’t loyal to us, they shouldn’t expect it from us either

likehelpful
Recent IconRecent

Yeah that’s fine, I think the general guidance in this day and age is try to stay at least 2 years most places, but the occasional shorter stint is ok

like

Stay for another year at Job 3 to make it 3.5 years then you can show the trend that you will stay at Job 4 for 4.5 years - lol. You good op, what matters is the confidence with which you can articulate your journey and moves

like

You should be okay as long as you can justify the reason for each of these stints or hear reasonable justifications for them.

like

If a recruiter believes my candidacy for an introductory conversation can be wholly based on years spent in a role without any other context, despite seemingly meeting many qualifications, then I don’t want to work there anyway.

like

Nope, screw this mentality, they left because the employer sucked. They don’t have to put up with bs because it “looks bad.” That’s up to employers, and anyone that pushes this mentality is in the wrong. Now if you’re looking at a string of 6 month stints, then I might have some questions, but there are always reasonable answers for why that is

like

No why would it be?

3 years at a job is a long time for millennials. Fairly common to switch every couple of years.

like

I work with a recruiter for my practice and she would say this is borderline jumpy. Multiple jobs in the 1-2 year range she typically raises a red flag and says this person is job hopping a lot and what's the reason behind it. 2.5 years is better but a bit of a red flag that there's nothing over 3 years and you have 7 years of work experience.

like

I mean - if you have multiple jobs over 2-3 years because you hop to make more money, that is why it’s a mini red flag. Firms budget a dollar amount on a role. They can’t necessarily give you a 30% raise after 9 months just because you’ve finally learned the role and are now performing to standard.

like

Job 1: 1.5 years
Job 2: 3 months, 10% TC increase
Job 3: 2.5 years, 5% TC increase
Job 4: current position, ~100% increase initially and exponentially more earnings potential

A&M still hired me. I was underpaid and there was essentially zero room for growth at my previous jobs. This is why we move. I now feel fairly compensated and have no plans or desire to find a new job.

like

Wow, is this still a thing in 2021?

likehelpful

Instead of complaining about people job hopping, try to implement competitive incentives that will encourage them to stay.

like

I don’t understand why recruiters are qualified to judge… they are too empowered.

likefunny

Depends on the jobs. If you’re bouncing every couple years in the same role/job, just a new company, that’s a red flag.
If you’re advancing, evolving, taking on new challenges, you’d be a decent candidate (assuming the career arch makes sense between each job).
Overall, be prepared to answer why they can expect you to not do that same thing at their firm.

like

Would making it to 3 years at job 3 be better so as to not get labeled a job hopper? Or what would you think is a safe number

None of this matters, this is actually quite decent by today’s standards. We’re incentivized to leave because the market pays more, so blame the companies, not the candidate

like

Can anyone tell me what the red flag is supposed to be?

I won’t hire such mercenaries ever

All depends on how you sell yourself about your experience

Just make sure you have a story

Nothing wrong with that work history. Especially nothing wrong if there's a clear display of career growth/progression in your roles.

How long do you have to stay at a firm for it to not be a red flag

Related Posts

Interested in Data & Analytics practice. Any of the consulting firms hiring right now? Currently working at one of the Big4.

like

Is it worth it to play the long game in public accounting (partner track) or to transition to industry and potentially become CFO, CEO, Controller role?

like

Any Update on Hiring at Novartis? When they will resume Hiring?

like

Any ideas of the expected comp range for a strategy manager role in industry?

like

Considering a change from audit (SM) to an advisory role - looking at a Director position within Strategy, Finance and Accounting M&A. [Insert typical “should I make the jump” question here]. I’m 3+ years to audit partner and weighing options and exhausted by omnipresent inspection risk and how this impacts day to day (and presume it will continue to get worse). Considering the advisory role 1) job security, 2) exit ops, 3) partnership ops. Anyone recently make a similar jump and could share?

like

Thoughts and best practices on sharing examples of strategy work to a hiring manager at an agency under the same holding company as my current agency? How much should I blind the work? What are some rules to remain legally compliant? Or should I avoid altogether?

like

What are your exit strategies out of SALT? If you have them.

like

Yet another town hall where all we hear about is hiring more senior leaders vs promoting talent from within (especially women of color)…

like

Hey all, I’m the founder of Stories Company, a creative agency focused on design for internal/B2B work at Fortune 1000s. Currently hiring a senior designer or AD. 85K-125K. Thanks so much!

like

Bain & Company Hi everyone,

I am currently working as a Software Engineer in Persistent Systems.

I have total exp of 8 months and serving notice period. I have offers from Mckinsey and BCG for their tech roles, but I wish to switch to consulting.

Could anyone please refer me or if you know someone who could refer me at Bain & Company for the Associate Consultant position?

Thank you in advance.

Bain & Company Hi Fishes, Could someone guide on project lead role at BCN (bain capability network)? Whats the day like, the pros and cons, role and responsibilities..Bain & Company

If anyone with 1 YOE or higher (non-internship experience) is looking for a referral to EY's Oracle Services practice, DM me. Referring for Staff 2, Seniors, Managers, Senior Managers and above. They are scrambling to fill many senior roles due to our practice's rapid growth.

like

Do you guys know if these companies hire in Europe remotely?
Riot Games
Activision
Blizzard Entertainment
Rockstar Games
Bungie
I’m trying to make a list of the companies hiring remotely in Europe.If you guys know triple AAA companies don’t hesitate to comment.

like

Received an offer for $120k from AFS for a level 8 position in Hawaii with 5 yoe. Is this a fair offer?

like

Hi All,

I am looking for a switch, a short introduction of mine

1 - I have completed my bachelor in textile currently pursuing Digital Marketing Analytics from NMIMS

2 - 5+ YOE in eCommerce Operation - (Amazon, Flipkart, Myntra, Nykaa, Paytm, Snapdeal, Tata Cliq, Ajioetc)

3 - Currently working with Audientes (Denmark) Company

4 - Achieved certification from Amazon and Flipkart

5 - Current and Preferred Location - Hyderabad

Please refer if you have any references Thanks

#hiring #jobhunt

Can I submit a referral to Accenture if I was a past employee but no longer work there?

Hi everyone,

I am currently a prior authorization pharmacist looking to break into formulary management. I was wondering if anyone had any advice!

Thank you!

like

I am a 25-year-old first year associate fresh out of law school at a small civil litigation firm. I went to a good law school and work hard. I’ve been in this position for about 5 months now and I keep messing up. Losing track of tasks. I have never felt dumber. Any advice? Should I be doing better at this point? I’m a licensed attorney!! Is this normal?

like

More Posts

Hi Fishes,

How are the mulesoft opportunities in salesforce ? What type of work is done in mulesoft role here .
Is it like working for clients and providing them business solutions using mule or solving tickets raised in mulesoft forum related to the product ?

TIA

Production Companies in Mexico City

Anyone have any recommendations for production and/or post companies in Mexico City? Looking to shoot and edit there to try and make the budget work.

Are there any recruiters or head hunters for Video Producers or Content Producers / Executive Producers? I've never heard of any but please enlighten me if you have!

likehelpful

Favorite NYC based experiential production companies?

like

I am in a long distance relationship with someone who is currently in B school. He spends pretty much all his breaks and holidays traveling with his classmates. Most of the time I am fine. But for some important holidays and my birthday, I told him we should spend time together. He just said it’s more important for him to bond with his classmates and ignore my ask. It’s really disappointing and I don’t know what else to tell him. Is that a reasonable ask or am I being dramatic?

like

The Blue Crab Bar was so sure that its bartender was the strongest man around that they offered a standing $1000 bet. The bartender would squeeze a lemon until all the juice ran into a glass, and hand the lemon to a patron. Anyone who could squeeze one more drop of juice out would win the money. Many people had tried over time (weight-lifters, longshoremen, etc.) but nobody could do it.

One day this scrawny little man came into the bar, wearing thick glasses ... continued in comments

funny

Would folks be interested in a NYC singles of fishbowl party? I know a solid venue

like

Has it become common practice for leaders of a team to make less salary than their direct reports?

like

Hey Sharks,
How much should one expect in a top consultancy firm, back end role (reasearch team) ?
Location: Mumbai
YOE: 7

Has anyone has success scheduling all your IEPs for the year in the first month of school? It will be a new requirement for next year.

like

Hi SpEd Teachers, is anyone else facing EXTREME staff shortages as a result of state funding? We are not able to meet my students' IEP requirements (not even close) due to not enough paraprofessionals and the district flat out refusing to hire more. I've lost 70+ hrs/week of para hours over the past few years and my students are really suffering. This leaves our district open to lawsuits, but the real problem is the state's education budget. What can we do?? This isn't going to fix itself.

like

Anyone know the best site for enneagram and MBTI?

like

The fact that our country can send 8 BILLION dollars to Ukraine but can't find funding for the water crisis in Jackson, Mississippi is embarrassing.

like

Anyone know if the wellness subsidy would cover an office chair? Or does D cover office supplies or nah? Looking to upgrade my home office. Thx!

like

Size question. When you buy ovecoats do you buy thinking of wearing over jacket / suits or just shirt? The fit and size will change depending on what you do.

What is fastest way to improve both structured communication and thinking? Any helpful books or drills?
It’s the one consistent feedback I get while casing , “to be more structured” I’m there for math ability , business logic , creativity.

like

Trying to do some initial research on laptops for business school and trying to determine if a new Mac book pro could be used at Wharton (or honestly any school!) for finance (not quant finance major though!)

like

What are some habits that inhibit you from being successful at your job?

like

What is the difference between google and GOC?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting Exit Opportunities

Has anyone interviewed with google for the strategic finance role? If so, would appreciate any guidance/tips on how to best prep for the interviews

like

What’s a good answer to what’s your biggest failure? And to when did you give up on something - what was the outcome?

like

Interested in Data & Analytics practice. Any of the consulting firms hiring right now? Currently working at one of the Big4.

like

What levels can an MBB EM exit to for S&O roles at companies like Google? Rest of FAANG? Thanks! The level schemes confuse me (compared to titles)

like

Received an offer as Engagement Director from Salesforce (CSG, pre sales, L9). Great benefits package, 40% increase in total comp and better WLB.

I do love the people in my practice and current client, but career trajectory has stalled after taking parental leave earlier this year and (yet another) change in leadership.

Realistically, making to Director is 2-3 years away and will require sacrificing time with my family that I am not prepared to give up.

Should I stay or should I go?

like

MBB or FAANG (Ops role)? Similar comp structure

What’s a reasonable base salary for a startup BD associate? Series B, solid funding, and currently sitting at 3 YOE in strategy consulting

like

Sitting on two AWS vs McKinsey offers. Which would you take?

likehelpful

When will FAANG turn into FAANGS to include SalesForce?

likefunny

Big 4 post-MBA consultants - did y’all see a marked improvement in exit opps after you made manager? This is assuming you were in big4 strategy at the senior associate/senior consultant level right out of B-school. Thanks!

like

Anyone have a go-to resume template? Wondering if a summary section is needed or would having one in LinkedIn suffice.
Thanks!
For background: First job out of college - Senior Associate working in tech implementation with various projects under my belt.

like

AWS associate engagement manager salary?

like

Just completed the interactive recorded interview for EY-Parthenon and got positive feedback from recruiter. What are the next steps for a SaT cyber position?

like

Anyone know of orgs with an emphasis/value teaching and learning?

My friend is working for a non-profit, has lots of transferable skills, and is willing to learn…but his job applications haven’t gained much traction. I think it’s because he’s looking to move towards a more corporate org and those recruiters don’t necessarily know what to make of his past experience.

like

What does an L7 package at Google look like? (Base, Bonus, Stock and how much Sign on could I get)?

like

If you relocated from California (LA) to Washington state (Seattle), what will be the compensation adjustment? Will it be significantly lesser as Seattle is a MCOL vs LA an HCOL? Also, will only the base be adjusted or bonus/RSUs as well?

like

I really want to:

1. Do something useful for society
2. Be more than a strategic advisor
3. Get paid a lot ($1M+)

Any options? It seems like these objectives are pretty much incompatible from my search.

likefunny

4YOE @Amazon & trying to lateral to a similar role @FAANG. Have my undergrad GPA (3.8/4) on resume from top 15 school but colleague says to take it off (looks silly). If it’s a good school & high GPA, why ever take it off your resume? Even if 10 YOE...can’t hurt?

like

Should I always have referrals when applying for PE exit? Would cold application work?

like

Company has low base pay but offers "meaningful raise" after few months good performance. Can I ask them to define that?

likefunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal