Why would anyone under the age of 25 want to work for a holding company advertising agency? Inbred corruption. History of not hiring people of color. Or hiring them and making them ‘write White’. The history of abusing defrauding and demeaning women. Currently in the middle of a huge ageism epidemic. Human resources that reports right back to managers. Under paying staff while overcharging clients. These agencies will die from lack of clients but even quicker from lack of new talent.

likesmartfunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Agree with you on all points. Unfortunately the way it is for us young creatives is that often in order to get a good pedigree of agencies and build up a solid book, we often have to go to those networks before going indie and taking a more senior position.

In our time there, let's work on changing it so that it's at least better for the next generation (assuming these networks will be around or appealing to the next generation of creative talent lol)

likefunny

Agreed. When I was an intern and entry level employee many moons ago, I sought out big name agencies (often associated with holding companies) for resources, talent, and prestige. It’s very much a symbiotic relationship because WPP, IPG, OMC need cheap talent and we need their big clients for experience. I once interviewed at a small indie shop and their clients were an organic graham cracker company and Altria.... see the difference?

like

Looks better on a resume than “who’s that?”

likesmartfunny

@acd1, well done.

Recent IconRecent

Honestly I think most people under 25 just want a job

likesmart

Yep. Those student loans won't pay themselves off!

like

...but they'll cover my Invisalign...

likefunnysmart

I think these are all thing things that take a few years to sink in...us youngins still have a few more years of bright eyed optimism 🥴

like

Where do you work? At an independent? That’s a dream for most of us, we know we have to cut our teeth at these bigger shops to get into the smaller ones...

like

Yeah I’m 28 but got into the game when I was older. Your points are all really valid but reek of the privilege of actually being able to get a job.

Most under 25s just need a foot in the door, and this industry is built so that they will trade their souls to do so.

like

Worked at an Indy that didn't have job security, diversity, and had a problem with sexual harassment. It's baked into the industry unfortunately.

like

Especially if the agency owner has a big ego (duh) and uses nepotism/cronyism

Exodus is brewing. Once pandemic is over, expect the run to the doors. Agencies have rarely treated employees well and they well know it.

like

@SAD3 I know of a couple people that went to ad tech Chicago offices, e.g. Google, FB. For Amazon, Netflix, Walmart, Target, you would likely need to relocate.

As a 25 year old - I’ve been at a WPP agency since I was an intern. Did not have any connections, just applied through the website. I think the holding companies are a great place to start: name for your resume, big clients, smart people to learn from, connections for later in career. Only thing is it’s not meant to last. 3 years later of working my butt off I’m paid 30% less than industry average, which is greedy, gross and clearly signals time to leave.

like

because most of advertising is owned by holding companies who have the big clients and they hire.

no problem with working at a smaller shop. most independents are, and they’re devoid of a lot of the problems and also some of the stability benefits of holding co agencies.

like

Because I want to get my damn career started. Speaking of, if anyone in NY is looking for a junior creative, let me know so I can DM you my book.

like

I guess I should clarify: advertising is already losing incredible young first-job talent to technology companies and in-house agencies. Agency leaders are always quoted in the trades as being confounded by that. ‘Why wouldn’t they want to work with us?’ I think talented people interested in marketing, with the Creatives or strategists, will just go right to in-house at brands, and keep going to Facebook and Spotify and Apple, and we will continue to see the best and brightest Avoid traditional advertising agencies because of the pay, the hours, and because of the culture.

like

Agencies are quite behind the curve in most matters. Take WFH. They were not that into it and in fact somewhat opposed for new talent. Now, it is becoming more evident that 2-3 days a week in the office would suffice. I enjoy working with young talent and harnessing their energy and coaching them. And those who left for better pastures is what I am proud of.

like

$$$$

like

I would presume anyone under the age of 25 working at a holding company is related to the shareholders, Board of Directors, legal team or client and/or is one of the above’s kids, neighbors, babysitters, tutors or former au pairs.

like

Some of these comments are so off base it’s not funny and you obviously have never worked at one. As a 50 something woman who didn’t even really realize what the difference was in a holding company agency and an independent agency when I very first started in advertising back in 1988 I nor the majority (or even 10%) of the employees have ever fallen into those categories And I can tell you the problems of nepotism, racism, and ageism all exist just as much in smaller independent agencies. I’ve worked in both and it may have even been worse in the independent agencies.

Why they would work there is better benefits, larger agency which is a huge difference in work environment, and opportunities to work on large global brands and do good work. I wouldn’t hesitate to work for one again

likesmarthelpful

It is sad but expected as a norm that agencies have 30-40% turn over. The business model is like a production line without raising talent for the future.

like

This is the inherent flaw in the business model where agencies do not have standardized offerings and wilt to every client demand. Since the agency product is constantly being customized, its output is adhoc and risk to talent drain is lower. It is also a corollary to the quality of the product and the demand for agency leadership. We do not mind if Starbucks has a lot churn, because all we want is simple custom iterations of the same coffee.
Unless agencies up their game and make themselves indispensable like tech, this will be the norm.

like

Agencies are a good training ground, so I would not discount the value for new starters. If you have a good manager that shows the ropes, you can significantly increase your value in 3 years.

like

Look at which agencies get into Cannes and the other big shows. Overwhelmingly the holding company shops. Those types of awards can open a lot of doors.

like

You’re questioning why junior staff want to work there, and then saying those agencies will die from lack of new talent.. which one is it?

funny

Resume building

like

Related Posts

Have any of you transitioned from a software consulting role to a product owner role? What was that transition like?

like

Typical exit ops for M&A operational due diligence?

like

I am currently working as a delivery manager for a data science project where I manage both ML and DE teams. I am not sure what career path should I follow.

Should I move into either a core technical data science/data engineering role or move into a techno-managerial role like a program or project manager? What role would be best in terms of money, growth, and job security?

like

Is 80k cash + 20k company share a good deal for a junior dev role in the bay area?🙏

like

Hello Everyone, please find the current opening for Mitratech

List if quite Long will be posting one by one
If someone wish to be referred just drop me a dm or connect over LinkedIn for more information

Post Photo
like
like

Any insight on working as a staff attorney at Sidley as far as pay, growth, hours, etc.? I had someone reach out to me about a staff attorney role there and just want to hear opinions.

like

I’m interviewing for a marketing manager role at a company based in SF. I’m genuinely excited about the role and the company but we’ve yet to discuss salary. I expect to be asked at some point, but my research has given me a VERY broad range. So I’m here to do a bit more research. I’ve got 5 very relevant years of experience and will have an associate manager directly reporting to me. Are there any marketers out there who can share their salaries in similar regions and experience levels?

like

How feasible to change role at Visa inc

like

What will be the exit opportunities/job for those who do project management work? Feeling extremely burned out and depressed these past few months

like

Thinking of going on a sabbatical and using the time to dust off resume, get certs and find a new position.Anyone else recommend this? Currently being distracted by billable work that adds 0 to resume

like

Anyone interviewing with Frontdoor for a Strategy role?

Accepted a role with 80k of equity at a late stage start up with 4 year vest. If they IPO, do I wait for 4 years to get all?

like

Can someone refer me, I'm a project lead with 9 years of experience, looking for a lead role.

Skills : Splunk, basic of tailwind css, html...

Notice period 3 months

like

Looking for a salesforce referral, highly qualified, passionate product manager seeking something new! Will DM the role(s)!

like

Openings for SDET less than 5 years experience at Informatica. DM me if interested, thanks !

like

Anyone here have experience with Uber? Have been made an offer with them for an Operations Manager role (not SF) but unsure how I feel about the current and future state of the company.

like

Job opportunity (mgr title, 4-6 yr exp needed) in Internal Audit (w/ data analytics exposure) at one of the largest private companies in Chicago. I interviewed with them (director and vp) till last round and decided to pursue a different opportunity. Great and caring people who seems to support what you wanna do at this position. Since it’s private there is a lot of room to create and build from the best practice. lmk if you are interested or know someone needs help. Thanks!

like
like

More Posts

Is the Austin side of Chicago really that unsafe ?

like

Anyone in printers row know of good gyms around ~$50? Looking to avoid LA Fitness at SouthGate or XSport (reviews seem to agree - they are a mess). FFC is just not in the cards rn.

KMPG 🐠 Senior Associate, NYC

likefunny

What kind of compensation/titles have former financial consultants/restructuring/TAS folks got when they go to industry?

like

My offer letter says I will be eligible for 60k RSUs annual award with a 3 year vesting period. Does this mean I will get 60k award each year and my vesting each period would look like this. Year 1: 20k, Year 2: 40k, Year 3: 60k, Year 4: 60k …

like

White & Case About to lateral into the project finance team of White & Case. Thoughts on the culture / dos and don’ts?

like

If I need Friday 4-5pm to go to a doctor's appointment, do I need to set a meeting invite to my manager in order not to be fired?

funny

CD in Detroit ? Any idea?

Hi fishes, I am new joiner in Accenture While accessing my laptop I am constantly getting this bitlocker message as attached. Can you please suggest anything or provide me with Accenture internal IT support number. Thanking you in advance for all your valuable help.

#Accenture internal IT support number required.

Post Photo
like

What’s everyone doing today

like

Random question, has the govt shutdown affected anyone’s work/business?

like

Left a career in banking for consulting. Ended up working on M&A post merger/Documentation as I’ve experience in the field. Life is funny.

like

I’ve noticed vaccine resistance among pet owners is growing and I’m starting to lose the will to educate people who are worried about “canine autism.” How hard do you try to inform the misinformed?

like

Anyone interested in going to club cafe this evening? DM me

In my third year of real estate practice. Run the gamut between leasing, acquisitions and sales, financing and everything in between. Enjoy where I'm working but (continued in replies...

Do you think logistics and supply chain management is an industry that can function effectively 100% remotely?

like
likehelpfuluplifting
likeuplifting

What is expected salary of experienced Data Analyst ?

like

why cts blacklist any company any idea?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

The people behind Diet Madison Ave IG account are heroes

likeupliftinghelpful

Given the outbreak, are places actually going to be hiring right now? Recently laid off from 9-5 and my freelance is starting to fizzle.

like

My browser history is failing me and hope y’all can help! I recently stumbled upon a website where some ad folks had compiled a bunch of idea/conceptual thinking approaches and if you clicked through there were past spots that had utilized that idea / way of thinking. I wanted to share it with a mentee and can’t track it down. It was a simple layout: grid of images w/headline naming the idea … Sound familiar?

like

Thoughts on GREY NY these days?

funnylikehelpful

Is it okay to call a sick day as freelancers?

like

Wieden guys, what's your opinion on the non american/non european W+K offices. How offices like tokyo, shangai and sao paulo are perceived within the network?

like

When do new roles in NY start opening up for the new year? Feel like I'm still seeing the same positions on Linkedin that I saw last year.

like

Today my boss told me I need to work on showing my frustration directly to people. She mentioned a meeting THREE weeks ago where, during a meeting, I said one single thing that showed I was unhappy with not being included in a particular meeting (for a project I was leading), and my tone made it clear I was unhappy about it. She said the person I “called out” didn’t even bring it up to her; it was what she “noticed.” Cont’d...

like

Without asking or confirming, account lead booked an in-person client meeting that requires travel. Who books ~any~ major client meeting without first checking with the team ?

like

Traits of your favorite account people?

likesmart

How many months in is it normal to hate a new job vs you've given it a long enough chance to know it's a wrong fit?

like

I have an internal interview for a potential promotion soon. Any tips on how I should treat it vs. a regular interview?

like

Any agencies that have a good reputation, but suck when you actually work there? Wonder why that happens?

like

Do you feel it’s appropriate for a non-Latinx/Hispanic Producer to ideate or create a Spanish US/Domestic ad for the Latinx audience?
(ie Spanish spot running on Univison for Walmart) **Not referring to LATAM ads**

like

A little humor sprinkled in a resume. Yay? Nay?

like

I’m currently in the US but starting to miss the family and friends in Europe... The agency I’m at have offices there. How common are transfers? Who do I talk to in the agency? Don’t want to come off as I want to leave but more so that I want to be closer to my family.

likehelpful

Dear Creative Directors who’s only talent is showing up to meeting with a full repertoire of buzzwords, die slow. Thanks, everyone.

likefunnyuplifting

First holiday since the the divorce. Let’s see how this goes.

like

What odd questions about your job did you get at the xmas / Hanukkah table?

likefunny

Today is Women's Day and 'A Day Without a Woman,' -- are you skipping work and wearing red?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal