Related Posts
Any travel recommendations in December?
Can anyone at Amex share my resume in their team to directly start the rounds of interview? I have tried for referrals through linkedIn and did not recieve any call from the HR.
29th Apr is my last working day in my current organization.
Tech stack: SQL, Tableau, Python, Excel, Powerpoint with more than 4 years of experience. Currently have an offer of 23 LPA fixed. Fixed anything above this or equal to would work. American Express American Express India Campus American Express Global Business Travel
W south beach or Ritz Carlton Fort Lauderdale?
More Posts
Blizzard watch thurs and Friday 👀
Hi how is smartims company for experienced?
I live by this formula. You should, too!

Additional Posts in Creatives
Anybody from Johannes Leonardo here?
GSP San Fran or Leo Chicago?
What questions do you ask at the interview?
New to Fishbowl?
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.







😂
Is it any good is the only question you should ever ask regarding the work in your portfolio.
yes.
Don’t remove it because of AA. There’s not a campaign out there that isn’t similar to something else.
But I’d argue you should remove/replace it because it’s old.
Disallowing work older than 2012 is BS. You’re possibly missing out on some good creatives if you’re that strict. Imagine if we judged musicians, directors and artists in the same way.
Don’t we?
☝️wait...we’re kidding, right? You don’t put “similar” campaign ideas from 2012 in your portfolio. That’s nuts. Uhh, all the Old Spice work is similar to ideas I had in 2009...so it’s like, mine now.
cw1 why in fuck's name would you think that?
I had the exact same thing happen to me with Heinz. But I still think mine is better. Still, I took it out so it didn’t look like I copied them 😭
I’ve seen books where the idea is in there and then you scroll down and they post something similar that was made after they came up with the idea just to show proof of concept. I’m not suggesting you do that, but if any CDs or recruiters see this, offer your two cents
This is crazy talk
Only if yours is better, otherwise you will be judged off the better execution.
2012? unless it's a seminal, ground-breaking piece of work, I think it's probably time to remove it anyway.