Currently make $175k as a newly promoted Manager in big city and have an offer for a Project Manager role at a huge retailer for $120k but in very low COL city (where I have a house and want to live long term). I know I want to leave consulting (hate it) but not sure if I should jump at first offer...

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Don't take it. 175 to 120 is massive, and they probably dont increase pay quickly. Keep applying elsewhere. You may need to spruce up your resume and linkedin profile to get more hits.

As long as you don't have a burning platform (e.g. getting counseled out effective 12/31), decline it and keep trying.

likesmart

That’s a tough one, and no one here is going to be able to tell you “the answer”. My $0.02 is - You want to make choices in life that align with your values, which leads to happiness.

Search within yourself and decide if this is worth pursuing. Does the $$ beat everything else? Will you have oppty to grow $$ in the future? You should already be asking yourself these questions to have gotten this far in the job search process.

like

Why is the phrase 2 cents? Really have no idea.. I’ll look it up and report back.

like

If you're going to the HQ of this massive retailer, say Bentonville, make sure you're not getting lowballed. I'd stay a few more years where you are and fight for a better exit. Retail can pay quite a lot.

likefunny

Interesting! Part of the issue is I have NO idea what salaries are at at this place

I'd keep your options open for a remote role or travel occasionally role that allows you to continue earning a similar salary but living from where you want. I'd normally say take the new Opp if money is the same, but $50k is a lot and sounds like you already negotiated the max for the role so you can't expect much salary growth in the near term.

like

The big money in industry is at director level and above where you get into stock and long term incentives in a big way. If you have clear runway to that you can discount the money right now. Consultants are overpaid so it's hard to compare but you can always boomerang if industry isn't what you thought it would be

like

Exactly, I would suggest holding out for a director position from the get go. Sounds like OP has a lot more leverage and will be viewed as more of a "hot shot" / talented candidate from their current position than as a Project Manager making 120k.

like

175 base or TC

like

$125k is just low for a project manager in my view.

What is the growth opportunity like at this firm? What are the profiles of others - if those profiles are ex-consulting, no way are people accepting $125k.

like

I disagree. For Product Manager...you’re probably right.
But every PM job I interviewed for two years ago was around that salary. And I had 12yrs running large programs and had four different certs for project management.

Try taking your big city 175k job to a low COL, see how rich you feel for a year then jump as a Director Instead

like

Even for moving to LCOL, that’s a huge hit and a bit insulting if you told them what you make now. I’d say no personally.

like

So base salary is $172,500. Bonus is like 5-6%. We also get 6% 401k match and employee stock purchase plan discount

like

So you work at Accenture

funnylikesmart

They are not ex-consultants (part of the appeal of working with them!) They are ex-J&J, P&G.

uplifting

Got it. I can see your dilemma.

Only thing I'll add is that think about your financial opportunity cost thoughtfully and reflect if you would have any regret.

The real difference between HCOL and LCOL is largely housing and childcare. Iphones, TVs, cars, furniture, clothes, food tend to be similar costs. So evaluate your opportunity cost looking at it with that lens.

If then you feel you won't have any regrets, go for it! Seems like a good way to get life stability.

likesmart

There might be some comp benchmarks you can use online. H1B database is a good one to give you a sense of if you’re being low balled.

like

First offer meaning this role. I’ve been applying for months at other companies and no bites. I negotiated this offer up already, so it’s final offer

I would take it. You can make 120k feel like 175k in a LCOL.

Related Posts

I’ve been a club performing rep for years at a SaaS company…but as an enterprise account exec… my average deal size is around $75k in annual recurring, quota of $1M. This is inline for my company but low when I speak with others for Enterprise rep openings. Any thoughts on recommendations for steps to bridge that gap?

like

Salary for centra care manager FL

like

Anyone hiring a senior team?

like

Looking for talented HCP Copywriters at various levels (senior, copy supervisor, group copy supervisor) for full-time hybrid role with top Pharma agency in New York. Must have 5+ years of pharma experience, have recent digital/print HCP work samples, be knowledgable about legal/regulatory review process. DM me for details. Onward Search

like

Does anyone currently work for Jefferies? How do you like the culture, pay, benefits, work life balance etc. what are some pros and cons?

like

Is the pay more for software engineers as compared to folks in analytics??

like

I heard from my head that there is a lot of slowdown in VW Germany... There is Hiring freeze, level freeze and all ... And soon that will spillover to india. So be prepared for very less hikes in coming cycle :( Also automotive sector in general is struggling with tesla laying off 10% workforce recently. Maybe time to make a move? What do you say fishes?

like
like

Hello Fishes, Can someone please help me with a referral with EY
Work experience -2.5 years experience
CFA level 2 candidate and MBA in finance
Help with a referral please

like

Hello All,

Is there anyone working in TCS for Boeing Client ? Kindly DM me.

Thanks in Advance

like

Hey there Data folks. Happy new year to all!
Wanted to know what would be average salary for 3 YOE for Data Analyst role at Gartner Mumbai??

And how is Gartner in terms of growth, culture, work.. your inputs are valuable

like

Do hiring managers even care about PMP Certification? That whole org seems like a cash grab pay to play scam.

like

What would be the salary for an integration manager in the post merger integration team? Kindly suggest. How are the yearly hikes in TechM ?

like

Does phone screen performance have any relevance in the hiring committee stage? Or do they only check onsites?

like

What is a fair salary for a 3rd year PI attorney at a boutique law firm? I went to a T-14, 1 year PI experience, 1 year clerkship, 1 year other.

like

Is anyone else finding it difficult to get a raise this year because of market conditions? I moved from a business analyst role to a management role and didn't get a raise even though I'm taking on significantly more work. The terrible market conditions are what my boss pointed to. Is this happening at other companies also?

likehelpful
like

Salaries are getting credited today ?

Brand Name Vs Higher Salary Offer

Company A: Salary = $150k for senior manager position. Company isn’t well known and raised a $60mill series B.

Company B: Salary = $115k for mid manager position. Company is brand name, on the stock exchange and valued at $20 billion.

Both jobs will be doing the same exact thing. Which one do I choose?

like

How much does usually a supervisor in coding makes?

like

More Posts

In need of a job. Available to join immediately. Ready to relocate.
Exp - 2.5yrs
MBA & Bcom(H)
Last employer - EY Global
Any referrals?

like

What’s the cuisine that Seattle’s known for?

like

Please share your experience with Sopra Steria management? What kind of projects are there?

like

Is world war 3 goin on right now? Wtf is happening? All coins are tanking and BTC is leading the way.
On the other hand, BUY sounds great right now 🤔

like

I’m currently drafting up a Roles & Responsibilities doc for a new position I am creating for myself (with the CEO on board). I’m nervous about overpromising and/or opening the door to be taken for a ride if I suggest every task/responsibility up front. Any suggestions for creating your own role in a company you’ve been working in for 3 years?

like

I submitted my Canada visitor visa on 13th oct and my biometric is on 28th October from USA!
When can I expect approval? I have an international travel from 27th Nov after that I will be 2 Months outside of USA!
Can someone please share their recent experience with Canada Visitor visa

TIA

like

Hi team . How is fiserv company. . How about appraisals

like

This bowl is a place for teachers to share positive or negative experiences they have had with professional development opportunities.

like

Hi All, I am currently a Data Analyst with 1 year of experience and pursuing a masters in Computer Science (expected to graduate 5/2023). I am looking to transition into an entry Data Scientist role (preferably remote or Philadelphia, PA). Can someone refer me or let me know who is hiring?

I can provide my resume if needed.

Hey,
Need refferal for Machine learning engineer position at oracle.
I'm currently working at Danaher, fortune 500 Healthcare company.
Thanks for the help

like

Hi Guys! I am looking to pivot into customer success. I am looking at the customer success representative position at Veeam in Alpharetta. Would anyone be able to refer me?
Thanks!

like

Does anyone have any suggestions on small side gigs or other ways to make some quick cash for the holidays?

like

How do you pivot into FP&A if you didn’t start FP&A or audit? Anyone who was in tax and pivoted to FP&A?

likefunny

Hello Everyone

My current salary is 12 LPA
I have an offer of 17LPA
I am looking for a Remote Opportunity with an E.CTC of 25LPA

Am a Business Analyst & Product Analyst

like

Should I drop everything and go to Coachella?? Got an offer for a 3 day GA pass for $100 (not sure if that’s good or not though, need my Coachella specialists to give me a diligence memo)

like

My dates think I'm crazy when I tell them I have to work 8 - 8 then study for the CPA 9 - midnight lol. Anyone else have a hard dating with the hours? I can only even see people on Sunday

likefunny

Can someone please explain this phenomenon I notice. Idk if it's an internal observation issue or really externally things change.

As a happy career-oriented single man. When I'm just focused on improving my career, thinking about work, just doing my thing. I notice women find me attractive, they're nice to me, want me to talk a little bit, and get annoyed or sad when I'm short with them. So I generally feel attractive.

But when I'm dtf, that attraction immediately dissappears. Is it me?

like

Hi Guys,

Please Advice, TIA.

Post Photo
like

What does it mean having a sponsor in public accounting firm?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting Exit Opportunities

I have 5 yrs post MBA experience with Deloitte Strategy and Operations (overall 8 yrs exp.) working primarily in supply chain/operations consulting. Currently a M and looking to exit to PE/VC. Dont have a ton of relevant experience though in valuation etc. Any guidance on how I should go about it (job search/prep etc) or do you think it's difficult to get a shot? Any advice will be highly appreciated!

funnylike

Anyone go back to a firm they left? What’s the process like? Did you have to re-interview?

like

Help me value RSU potential: Offer from series D unicorn with 300 shares that will vest over 4 years. Based on the current valuation and the number of outstanding shares, they estimated a current...

like

Searching for healthcare consulting opportunities to get me back to the LA area. Anyone know of any leads / have any recommendations?! TIA

helpful

Just rolled off a project and about to take a week of PTO. The twist is I have an offer that I plan to accept beginning in June. How should I play this so that I’m not doing more than I absolutely need to but am also not burning the bridge?

like

Future of a software engineering career? I hear such disparate advice from “you’d have to study all the time, it’s over flooding and outsourceable” but also hear “it’s highly paid, irreplaceable and great WLB”

like

Thoughts on product ops in big tech? Based on career advancement ops and maybe switching to pm?

like

Anyone else seeing all the visa/gc sponsorship opportunities dry up? seems like 2 out of every 3 businesses have just noped completely out of the game. Looking at opps to jump but it's looking bleak

like