Currently make $175k as a newly promoted Manager in big city and have an offer for a Project Manager role at a huge retailer for $120k but in very low COL city (where I have a house and want to live long term). I know I want to leave consulting (hate it) but not sure if I should jump at first offer...

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Don't take it. 175 to 120 is massive, and they probably dont increase pay quickly. Keep applying elsewhere. You may need to spruce up your resume and linkedin profile to get more hits.

As long as you don't have a burning platform (e.g. getting counseled out effective 12/31), decline it and keep trying.

likesmart

That’s a tough one, and no one here is going to be able to tell you “the answer”. My $0.02 is - You want to make choices in life that align with your values, which leads to happiness.

Search within yourself and decide if this is worth pursuing. Does the $$ beat everything else? Will you have oppty to grow $$ in the future? You should already be asking yourself these questions to have gotten this far in the job search process.

like

Why is the phrase 2 cents? Really have no idea.. I’ll look it up and report back.

like

If you're going to the HQ of this massive retailer, say Bentonville, make sure you're not getting lowballed. I'd stay a few more years where you are and fight for a better exit. Retail can pay quite a lot.

likefunny

Interesting! Part of the issue is I have NO idea what salaries are at at this place

I'd keep your options open for a remote role or travel occasionally role that allows you to continue earning a similar salary but living from where you want. I'd normally say take the new Opp if money is the same, but $50k is a lot and sounds like you already negotiated the max for the role so you can't expect much salary growth in the near term.

like

The big money in industry is at director level and above where you get into stock and long term incentives in a big way. If you have clear runway to that you can discount the money right now. Consultants are overpaid so it's hard to compare but you can always boomerang if industry isn't what you thought it would be

like

Exactly, I would suggest holding out for a director position from the get go. Sounds like OP has a lot more leverage and will be viewed as more of a "hot shot" / talented candidate from their current position than as a Project Manager making 120k.

like

175 base or TC

like

$125k is just low for a project manager in my view.

What is the growth opportunity like at this firm? What are the profiles of others - if those profiles are ex-consulting, no way are people accepting $125k.

like

I disagree. For Product Manager...you’re probably right.
But every PM job I interviewed for two years ago was around that salary. And I had 12yrs running large programs and had four different certs for project management.

Try taking your big city 175k job to a low COL, see how rich you feel for a year then jump as a Director Instead

like

Even for moving to LCOL, that’s a huge hit and a bit insulting if you told them what you make now. I’d say no personally.

like

So base salary is $172,500. Bonus is like 5-6%. We also get 6% 401k match and employee stock purchase plan discount

like

So you work at Accenture

funnylikesmart

They are not ex-consultants (part of the appeal of working with them!) They are ex-J&J, P&G.

uplifting

Got it. I can see your dilemma.

Only thing I'll add is that think about your financial opportunity cost thoughtfully and reflect if you would have any regret.

The real difference between HCOL and LCOL is largely housing and childcare. Iphones, TVs, cars, furniture, clothes, food tend to be similar costs. So evaluate your opportunity cost looking at it with that lens.

If then you feel you won't have any regrets, go for it! Seems like a good way to get life stability.

likesmart

There might be some comp benchmarks you can use online. H1B database is a good one to give you a sense of if you’re being low balled.

like

First offer meaning this role. I’ve been applying for months at other companies and no bites. I negotiated this offer up already, so it’s final offer

I would take it. You can make 120k feel like 175k in a LCOL.

Related Posts

Hi! I started at a new company 2 months ago and while I’m really enjoying my job so far, I’m having a hard time gauging whether or not I’m doing a “good job.” My role seems to be always evolving, which is fine and I actually enjoy being a support to the greater marketing team, but I feel like I need better defined targets to make sure I’m meeting expectations. Also, when I ask my boss what they’d like to see, I don’t ever get a clear answer. (Cont’d in comments)

like

Hello, I looking for referral in business developpement management with relocation option. Thanks to anyone that can help!

like

Does anyone know how xoogler hiring works? I left a few years ago and am interested in some new roles.

Hi,
Any plans opening Bangalore office from June?

Senior Digital Producers - what is your freelance day rate?
Edited to add: I’m in nyc

like
likehelpful

Is Capgemini Bid Manager for IT and Cloud a good role??

Level C1:C2 What should be an ideal package??

like

Dear Sharks,

What will be my In hand salary per month ?

LTA, Food coupon, upskill allowance , Tele bill-- all these includes In take home salary ?

My CCTC is 7.5 as Fixed, take home monthly 56k. Is this a good deal ?

Please Help
Société Générale

Post Photo
like

Has anyone ever had any issues receiving a response from recruiters at Mastercard? I had an interview about 2 weeks ago and haven’t heard anything back so I will assume I didn’t get the role. I followed up too. Had a similar issue before with a recruiter there. Pretty disappointing 🙁 usually I get a response from a recruiter at other companies even if it’s a no

like

What should be the salary expectations for mechanical engineering graduate with 5 years of experience in inventory, purchasing and as well as product costing?
Preferred city is Bangalore

like

Hello.. I work as a product specialist and have experience of leading projects as well.. I’m looking for a project manager role.. I need advice.. If you’ve applied for an opening in a company, is it okay to apply for another opening that is a similar role or same role - different location.. This is while I’m still waiting to get a status update on the first one..

like

Is senior software engineer a good position offered at persistent system for 3.2 years of experience in Webmethods development?

like

Hello everyone, My name is Varun and i work as a product manager with 4 years of experience mainly in fintech startups. Currently based on of Gurgaon. Kindly let me know if there are any openings in your company where i can be referred. Thanks in advance.

like
like

I had technical and behavioral interview today at Deloitte Canada for visual analytics and information design position.
In technical round there was a case study to create visual data sheet and present it to technical round.

It went good they asked couple of questions and showed that at some point it lacks of continuity and rest thing is good. I have been told we will discuss and send details to HR and you will get update within few days. What are the chances that they can hire me ?

like

Just got staffed on a project in London. Any major differences from American business fashion I should be aware of?

like

My manager continues to ask me to help other teams and do work on other billable projects. I’m sick of it .. and I’m going to explicitly say that no I can’t do it because my hours are taken by the existing project we are doing. Is this appropriate?

like

Please can anyone from Disney assist with a referral

like

Received an offer as Engagement Director from Salesforce (CSG, pre sales, L9). Great benefits package, 40% increase in total comp and better WLB.

I do love the people in my practice and current client, but career trajectory has stalled after taking parental leave earlier this year and (yet another) change in leadership.

Realistically, making to Director is 2-3 years away and will require sacrificing time with my family that I am not prepared to give up.

Should I stay or should I go?

like

Hi Guys,
Need a referral for an opening in Accenture India Accenture. Would appreciate your help. Thanks

like

More Posts

Will get COVID vaccine today. That means party is an option at b school?

likeuplifting
like

Anyone have any suggestions on how to break into this field as a mid-level commercial litigator? I was thinking of taking the CIPP-US test but would that be enough to get some interview traction?

like

What would you suggest as a salary % increase to jump to another firm? I’m being recruited for a Sr Mgr role at EY which looks like a promising opportunity. Any comp sites other than glass door?

like

What was your average YoY salary growth for non-promotional years in big 4 advisory? I got exceeds two years in a row, is 8% annual increase per year too optimistic?

like

Kinda bummed. I’ve been single for 6 years (I’m 31 now). I live in ptown and talk to guys in Boston on tinder. Was talking to a guy for about a week who is my type. I asked if he wanted to FaceTime tonight and he said sure but caveated that he isn’t into long distance (ptown to Boston) and that we would most likely stick to chatting. Idk what’s wrong with me. Everyone tells me I’m a catch but guys I’m attracted to are never into me 😭 just needed to vent

likehelpful

Hi, M - 25 here looking to get into the dating scene. Just moved from Michigan, feel free to reach out!

likefunny

I’m 35, and going on a first date. Thinking about bringing her flowers. Yea on No? And what would be the perception?

like

What’s the point of creative agency CCO’s? Do they touch any of the work? What do they do that ECDs can’t?

smarthelpful

How long due you need to be at an employer to be eligible for the family leave plan that is available for all Massachusetts employees as part of the Paid Family Medical Leave program ? I believe the PFML is applicable 2021 onwards

like

Anyone have tips on first round growth capital/VC case interview? They say there’s gonna be a test on investing acumen.. whatever that means.

like

What will be consequences of renegotiation of accepted offer by showing counter offer?
Will they revoke it without speaking with the candidate once?

like

Hi all
I work as chef and i m looking for job change dm me if any opportunity is there

like

I’ve been in and out of GME puts making money on the rise in price. Yesterday bought contracts for Mar exp at strike price $6 - made over 1k today. Entry price was .22 per contract. There are a lot of different ways to profit from the meme stocks. Trade your plan.

like

Has anyone dealt with a lack of praise from attorneys? I'm not someone who needs to hear "good job" all the time, but we just got a huge deal closed that I worked really hard on and had a lot of overtime. And once it closed, the lead attorney praised the other attorneys, and said nothing about me or my work. I might just be overly sensitive, but it kind of stung. Thoughts?

like

Hello fishes,
I have been recently cleared technical discussion round one for Accolite Digital. And my next round is supposed to be Client interview round. What type of questions can I expect? Will it also be a technical round or managerial?

Yoe 3years
Tech stack- Java, MySQL

like

I am getting third party company mails ,like working for xx client should I apply them?

like

Where are we supposed to submit tax declaration documents after declaring them in the system in EY India?

The system shows the supporting documents need to be submitted by 6th January.

like

New start coming out of undergrad - other than maxing out 401k contribution to 18.5k in the year, what other low hanging fruit should I get? (I.e. I’ve heard of a Roth ira but not sure what it is)

like

Salary bands for senior EA - Does anyone know what they are for the following Canadian companies: KPMG, Amazon, Telus, and Deloitte

like

Additional Posts in Consulting Exit Opportunities

I am a senior analyst with 5+ years of functional experience in health payer, 1.5 years of BA experience. Thinking about exit opportunities and deciding if it's worth pivoting into the pharmaceutical industry, startups, and or straight into a payer company. Thoughts if I should wait or exit?

like

I have an initial recruiter phone interview with Square Thursday. Is it it just a phone call or is it a video call and they didn’t specify. If it’s a video call what’s the dress code like? I’m coming from consulting so all my interviews were in suits. Any tips to get past the recruiter phone screen?

like

Has anyone been able to switch (to industry ) on H1 visa? I am getting a lot of interest from recruiters but am not able to get past the initial screening because of visa.

How long is the notice period at your firm usually?

like

What does an internal facing Strategy director at KPMG do? Kinda sounds nice-ish. Anyone with experience ? Recruiter says great pay and good WLB but any primers?

like

Currently working as a part/time remote contractor (jr role) for a company based in/incorporated in the British Virgin Islands as a side hustle.
The non-compete mentions I cannot work for a “direct” or “indirect” competitor during or for 2 years after working with my current company.
I’m based in the US but may move abroad to Asia at some point this year. Will this noncompete be valid/enforceable? Thx for the feedback 🐠

like

4YOE @Amazon & trying to lateral to a similar role @FAANG. Have my undergrad GPA (3.8/4) on resume from top 15 school but colleague says to take it off (looks silly). If it’s a good school & high GPA, why ever take it off your resume? Even if 10 YOE...can’t hurt?

like

Just completed the interactive recorded interview for EY-Parthenon and got positive feedback from recruiter. What are the next steps for a SaT cyber position?

like

Anyone at Spotify that can speak to their experience, saw a position this morning that aligns very well with my background and future goals.

I’ve applied a handful of times in the past and feels like my resume just goes straight into the void, I’d love any tips on how to get it to a person 😊

like

Is anyone hiring in healthcare/biotech for marketing/strategy roles? Have ~2 YOE at top medical device companies

like

Has anyone interviewed with Pinterest for product mgr roles? I have an upcoming interview and need to prepare to be tested in knowledge of SQL and A/B testing. Even if you’ve prepared for similar assessments your advice would be helpful (please and thx)

like

What’s a good answer to what’s your biggest failure? And to when did you give up on something - what was the outcome?

like

Anyone from Michael's here who could refer me to a position ?

like

If I plan on leaving consulting within the next year to two years, is it worth taking an offer from a small boutique that will give me a 20k bump? Currently at 100k. Or should I stay at ACN for another year in hopes of leveraging a better exit?

like

Any Google fishes who can help me out with a refferal? The profile I'm looking for is based out of India.

likefunny

Has anyone done a lateral move at SM level between big4s and/or ACN, IBM etc? Was it for the compensation or something else like better exit opportunities or partner/director track?

like

What are the chances of Amazon (or FAANG in general) allowing you to apply/interview again for a position that you did not get in the past?

like

Which of these roles best prepares one to run an e-commerce brand? Product manager, brand manager, product marketing manager, growth marketing

like

Sitting on two AWS vs McKinsey offers. Which would you take?

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal